字号 ·· | 护眼
南华早报

日本博物馆回避在海外广受赞誉的战争暴行视频艺术作品Japanese museums shun video artwork on wartime atrocities acclaimed abroad

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

一件以一名前日本士兵的证言为核心的影像装置作品,涉及其在战时中国杀害平民和实施性侵的往事,将于10月在伦敦。与此同时,其创作者正努力寻找愿意在日本展出这部获奖作品的博物馆。

A video installation built around the testimony of a former Japanese soldier on the killing of civilians and sexual assault in wartime China will go on display in London in October, even as its creator struggles to find a museum willing to exhibit the award-winning work in Japan.

这部由当代艺术家小泉米罗创作的《证言之天使》在海外广受赞誉,但日本各家博物馆一直不愿展出该作品,因为它直面了日本军队在抗日战争期间实施暴行的历史记忆。

Created by contemporary artist Meiro Koizumi, “The Angels of Testimony”, has won acclaim overseas, but Japanese museums have been reluctant to exhibit the work, which confronts memories of violence committed by Japanese troops during the Sino-Japanese war. “The work will only truly be complete when people can see it in Japan,” said Koizumi, 50, who hopes it will eventually be exhibited in his home country.

50岁的小泉米罗说:“只有当人们能在日本看到这部作品时,它才算真正完成。”他希望该作品最终能在自己的祖国展出。

Three screens emerge from the darkness of the exhibition space. At the centre is the late Hajime Kondo, a former Imperial Japanese Army soldier who was 99 when the work was filmed. Kondo entered military service in 1940 and was sent to China, where he fought in areas including Shanxi province.

三块屏幕从展览空间的黑暗中显现出来。中央屏幕上是已故的近藤初男小泉对电影和小说中将二战期间日军战至最后一刻及神风特攻队行动浪漫化的现象深感不安,开始通过自己的作品直面战争的现实。

A book published in 2005 compiling his testimony recounts an episode in which another soldier showed him the brain of a Chinese person, saying it could cure illness. “Do you remember?” Kondo is asked in the video. Apparently unable to recall the episode, he breaks down in tears. On the other two screens, young people recite Kondo’s testimony on the streets of Tokyo.

以近藤所犯暴行记忆为核心的作品《证词天使》于2021年获得了英国重要当代艺术奖项“艺术世界奖”(Artes Mundi Prize)。

They recount how Kondo, after being told it was part of his training as a soldier, bayoneted a Chinese person to death and how he joined other Japanese soldiers in sexually assaulting a woman they had captured. Koizumi believed such testimony needed to be passed on and chose to give it expression through his art. He began studying video art at a university in London in 1999 and later worked in the Netherlands before returning to Japan in 2007.

此后,该作品在英国、阿拉伯联合酋长国和荷兰等国展出。然而,小泉表示,在日本,博物馆曾要求他替换其他作品,或展览计划彻底告吹。

Troubled by what he saw as the romanticisation in films and novels of Japanese soldiers fighting to the death and kamikaze attacks during second world war, Koizumi began confronting the realities of war through his work.

在2019年爱知三年展上,一件象征“慰安妇”的雕像被纳入展览,这些女性曾被强迫在日军战时妓院工作。该展览在经历一系列抗议和威胁后被临时关闭。

“The Angels of Testimony”, centred on Kondo’s memories of violence he committed, received the Artes Mundi Prize, a major British contemporary art award, in 2021. The work has since been exhibited in countries including Britain, the United Arab Emirates and the Netherlands. In Japan, however, Koizumi said museums have asked him to substitute another work or exhibition plans have fallen through altogether.

小泉在该艺术节上展出了画作,他表示这一事件可能使博物馆变得更加谨慎。他说:“博物馆工作人员可能会想,‘万一出事了怎么办?’”伦敦展览将于10月1日至11月20日举行,由致力于促进日英交流的伦敦组织大和英日基金会主办。

At the 2019 Aichi Triennale, an exhibition that included a statue symbolising “comfort women”, who were forced to work in the Japanese military’s wartime brothels, was temporarily closed after a series of protests and threats. Koizumi, who exhibited paintings at the festival, said the episode may have made museums more cautious. “Museum staff probably think, ‘What if something happens?’” he said.

负责该展览的41岁的小田奈奈表示,小泉决心直面许多人宁愿回避的暴力历史,并将这些记忆传递给后代,这令她深受感动。她说:“即使有抗议,我们也不会取消展览。”

The London exhibition will run from October 1 to November 20 and is organised by the Daiwa Anglo-Japanese Foundation, a London-based organisation promoting exchanges between Japan and Britain. Nana Ota, 41, who is overseeing the exhibition, said she was moved by Koizumi’s determination to confront a history of violence that many would rather look away from and to pass those memories on to future generations.

“我希望人们观看作品后,思考战时暴力如何深刻地烙印在亲历者的心中,同时也反思当今正在发生的战争。”

“Even if there are protests, we won’t call off the exhibition,” she said. “I hope people will see the work and think about how deeply wartime violence can become etched in the hearts of those who experienced it, while also reflecting on the wars taking place today.”