字号 ·· | 护眼
卫报

法耶德的幸存者表示,GMC拒绝调查医生,导致虐待行为得以继续Fayed survivors say GMC let abuse continue by refusing to investigate doctors

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

有人指责医疗监管机构未能对相关指控进行调查,从而任由性虐待行为持续发生;这些指控指出部分医生参与了法耶德的犯罪行为。

have accused the medical regulator of allowing his sexual abuse to continue unchecked by refusing to investigate allegations that doctors were complicit in his crimes.

法耶德性虐待行为的受害者呼吁对英国医学总会(General Medical Council, GMC)展开调查——该机构曾在2017年驳回了要求对一名医生的调查请求。这名医生被指控对一名女性进行了侵犯性的性健康检查,并将检查结果告知了法耶德。

Survivors of Fayed’s abuse have called for the General Medical Council (GMC) to be investigated after it dismissed a request in 2017 to scrutinise a doctor accused of subjecting a woman to intrusive sexual health examinations and sharing the results with Fayed.

在首次向英国医学总会投诉温迪·斯内尔(Wendy Snell)近十年后(斯内尔于2022年去世),该医疗监管机构终于对另外两名医生采取了行动;这两名医生也被指控将女性的性健康信息传递给了法耶德,而法耶德后来对这些女性实施了性虐待。

Almost a decade after complaints were first made to the GMC about Dr Wendy Snell, who died in 2022, the doctors’ regulator has now taken action against two other surviving doctors who are also accused of passing sexual health information to Fayed about women who he later abused.

法耶德曾是哈罗德百货公司的老板,他于2023年去世。就在这一年之前,数百名女性公开了自己在过去的几十年里遭受法耶德性侵犯的指控。

Fayed, the former owner of Harrods died in 2023 a year before hundreds of women went public with accusations of sexual assault by Fayed over the previous decades.

佩勒姆·斯庞(Pelham Spong)在2017年向英国医学总会投诉了斯内尔——斯内尔曾是法耶德的雇员,她在2008年接受求职面试时被要求接受性健康检查。斯庞称,当天法耶德抓住她的脸并强行吻了她;她还表示,法耶德还询问了她关于某种性传播疾病的状况,而斯内尔曾保证所有相关信息(包括她的体检结果)都会被保密。

Pelham Spong complained to the GMC in 2017 about Snell, a doctor employed by Fayed who subjected her to sexual health tests in 2008 as part of an interview process for a job with the former Harrods owner. The same day Fayed grabbed her face and forcibly kissed her, Spong alleged. Fayed also quizzed Spong about a sexually transmitted disease that Snell had assured her would be kept confidential along with all her results, she claimed.

她的投诉信中写道:“我知道还有其他女性也有类似的遭遇——她们都与法耶德(Fayed)以及哈罗德百货(Harrods)的医生们有关,这些医生在健康检查过程中存在不当行为。事实上,安排我参加这次面试的招聘人员之前还曾安排过另一位候选人参加面试。”

Her complaint, seen by the Guardian, said: “I know that there are other women who have similar stories involving both Fayed, and doctors and improper health screenings at Harrods. In fact, the recruiter who sent me on this interview had previously sent another candidate.”

信中还提到:“让我感到屈辱、羞愧和尴尬的是,这家潜在的雇主竟然了解我身体上最私密的细节。”

It added: “I felt humiliated, ashamed, and embarrassed that this potential employer knew the most intimate details of my body.”

英国妇科医学院(GMC)告诉斯庞(Spong),调查她的事件并不符合“公众利益”;他们表示:“我们没有权力去调查、处理或评论是否应该在招聘过程中进行妇科检查。”

The GMC told Spong it was not in the “greater public interest” to investigate Snell. It added: “We have no powers to investigate, resolve or comment on whether a gynaecological examination should have formed part of your recruitment process.”

斯庞在遭受虐待时年仅23岁,她对《卫报》表示:“令人震惊的是,英国妇科医学院在2017年就收到了我的举报,却什么都没做。他们对此事置之不理近10年,导致施虐者逍遥法外。英国妇科医学院的冷漠态度实在令人质疑——我当时可是正在举报人口贩卖行为啊!”2017年10月,斯庞还向伦敦警察厅(Metropolitan Police)报案,伦敦警察厅在初步调查过程中获取了她的投诉信,但之后并未采取任何进一步行动。

Spong, who was 23 at the time of the abuse, told the Guardian: “It’s shocking that the GMC received intelligence like mine in 2017 and did nothing. They have been sitting on this for almost 10 years and let my abusers escape. There was an alarming lack of curiosity by the GMC which begs all sorts of questions. I was reporting trafficking.”In October 2017 Spong also reported her ordeal to the Metropolitan police, which obtained a copy of her complaint to the GMC as part of its initial inquiries, before taking no further action.

她补充道:“法耶德一直虐待女性,直到他去世。因此,伦敦警察厅和英国妇科医学院在2017年没有履行职责,这意味着更多女性受到了伤害。这完全是他们的责任,他们绝对应该受到调查。”

She said: “Fayed continued abusing women until he died. So the fact that the Met and the GMC didn’t do their job in 2017 means more women were harmed. That’s on them, so absolutely they should be investigated.”Spong is backing calls for a public inquiry into Fayed’s crimes that would include failures by the Met and the GMC.

琼(Joan*)指控自己在20世纪90年代被法耶德的弟弟萨拉赫·法耶德(Salah Fayed)强奸;据她所述,在那次性健康检查之后,萨拉赫·法耶德在她的面前拨通了安·考克森(Dr. Ann Coxon)的电话,并将电话转接到了扬声器上,考克森在通话中向萨拉赫·法耶德透露了她的性健康检查结果。

Joan* alleges she was raped in the 1990s by Fayed’s brother Salah Fayed after a sexual health examination by Dr Ann Coxon. She alleges that before she was raped, Salah Fayed, who died in 2010, phoned Coxon in her presence and put her on speaker. She alleges Coxon then told him the results of her sexual health tests over the call.

琼说:“我是亲耳听到这些事情的,当时我就把这些情况写进了书面证词中。我还保留了她所提到的相关证据。”

Joan said: “I heard it first-hand and I’ve got it all written up in an affidavit that I made at the time. I have also got the test that she refers to.”

琼继续说道:“如果英国医学总会(GMC)在2017年首次收到投诉时就采取行动,法耶德本可以被制止并追究责任。如果他们收到了关于医疗不当行为的报告,就应该立即将情况上报给警方。然而,由于巨大的政治压力,英国医学总会才迟迟不肯采取行动,直到现在才终于开始采取一些措施。这种处理方式完全错误——英国医学总会存在的意义究竟是什么?”

Joan said: “If the GMC had acted when the first complaints were made in 2017, Fayed could have been stopped and held to account. If they were hearing reports about malpractice they should have escalated it to the police. But instead the GMC, very begrudgingly, very slowly, after massive political pressure, are only now finally starting to take action. This is just the wrong way around. What is the GMC for?”

第三位受害者朱迪思表示,她在接受斯内尔(Snell)进行的性健康检查后遭到了穆罕默德·法耶德(Mohamed Al Fayed)的骚扰。那次性健康检查是法耶德家族招聘员工过程中的一个环节。

A third victim Judith*, says she was groped by Mohamed Al Fayed after a humiliating sexual health examination by Snell as part of a recruitment process for a job working for the family. She said the examination occurred after Fayed sold Harrods in 2010.

朱迪思回忆道:“那次检查发生在法耶德出售哈罗德百货公司(Harrods)之后。我接受了全面的妇科检查以及性传播疾病的检测。我非常震惊和痛苦,因为觉得这种检查完全没有必要,也感到无比羞愧。因此,从那以后我一直很难接受任何妇科检查。整个事件真的让我的生活陷入了危险之中。”

Judith said: “I had a full gynaecological test with sexually transmitted disease testing as well. I was really shocked and traumatised that this was needed and I felt so much shame. As a result, I have really struggled with having smear tests since. So the whole episode has really put my life at risk.”

她强调:“我并不希望英国医学总会仅仅道歉或承诺类似事件不会再发生;必须制定明确的法律法规来监督私人医生的行为。目前看来,根本没有任何监管机制存在。”

She said: “I don’t want an apology from the GMC and a promise that this will never happen again. Instead there has to be clear legislation in place to ensure private doctors are monitored. At the moment there seems to be no oversight at all.

考克森(Coxon)对《卫报》表示无法对此事发表评论,但她此前曾否认自己对哈罗德百货公司的员工进行过性健康检查。英国医学总会已经暂时限制了她和另一位医生的执业资格,等待进一步的调查结果。

“A public inquiry needs to be started as soon as possible and that the GMC should be part of that.”Coxon told the Guardian she could not comment but has previously denied carrying out sexual health tests on Harrods staff.

艾玛·琼斯(Emma Jones)是利·戴律师事务所(Leigh Day)的律师,她代表了几名法耶德(Fayed)的受害者。她说:“英国医学总会(GMC)终于开始认真对待这个问题了,因为他们对这些医生实施了临时限制措施;不过这种做法在这些调查中并不总是常规做法。不过,这仍然远远不够,而且为时已晚。”

The GMC has imposed restrictions on her ability to practise, and that of another doctor, pending a full investigation. Emma Jones, a solicitor at Leigh Day who is representing several of Fayed’s victims, said: “The GMC is finally taking things seriously, because they’ve imposed interim conditions on these doctors which isn’t always a standard step in these investigations. This is far too little, far too late.

“当这些投诉首次被提交给英国医学总会时,他们本应立即将情况报告给警方。实在难以理解为什么这些投诉没有得到更早的调查——这些指控非常严重:这些医生在未经患者同意的情况下对患者进行了性健康检查,并将相关报告直接上报给了法耶德。”

“When the complaints were first made to the GMC it should have reported them to the police. It beggars belief why they were not investigated earlier – they were such serious allegations they were conducting sexual health examinations and reporting back to Fayed without permission of the patient.

“英国医学总会的失职行为是必须被调查的关键问题之一,而唯一能够彻底调查这一问题的方式就是通过公开调查。”英国医学总会的一位发言人表示:“关于穆罕默德·阿尔·法耶德(Mohamed Al Fayed)涉嫌性虐待的指控令人震惊和恐惧。”

“The failings of the GMC is one of the crucial areas that needs to be investigated, and the only way to do that properly is through a public inquiry.”A GMC spokesperson said: “The reports of sexual abuse carried out by Mohamed Al Fayed are horrifying and shocking.

“我们正在调查那些受雇于法耶德的医生,并已向相关方发送函件,以向他们通报我们的调查进展。我们非常重视这些指控,并一直与包括伦敦警察厅在内的相关部门保持联系。”

“We are investigating doctors employed by Mr Al Fayed, and have written to the parties involved to provide an update on our investigations. We are taking these concerns very seriously and remain in contact with relevant authorities, including the Metropolitan police.

“如果发现某些医生存在不适合继续执业的问题,我们将采取相应的措施;不过,我们无法透露具体的调查细节。”

“We will take the appropriate action if we identify any potential fitness to practise concerns about individual doctors, but cannot provide information about individual investigations.”