字号 ·· | 护眼
卫报

比例代表制投票制度可能给工党带来灾难A proportional representation voting system could spell disaster for Labour

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

读到安迪·伯纳姆想要推动选举改革、让英国走向比例代表制(《报告》,9月29日),我忍不住对着屏幕大喊。我来自意大利,在那里我见识过比例代表制的运作。它们在议员与选民之间制造隔阂。它们助长部落主义(是的,甚至比这里更甚)。

Reading that Andy Burnham wants to push electoral reform forward and move the UK towards proportional representation (Report, 29 September), I found myself shouting at the screen. I come from Italy, where I have seen proportional systems at work. They drive a wedge between MPs and their constituents. They reward tribalism (yes, even more than here).

它们让大批选民沦为小党任性的俘虏,并迫使政党组建拼凑的联合政府,导致政府不稳定、低效。尽管如此,人们似乎并不觉得自己得到更好的代表。

They leave large parts of the electorate hostage to the whims of tiny parties, and force parties into ragtag coalitions that produce unstable, ineffective governments. And for all that, people do not seem to feel any better represented.

自2014年起生活在英国、以外部视角观察其政党后,我仍认为简单多数制是两害相权取其轻。

Having lived in the UK since 2014 and watched its parties with an outsider’s eyes, I still see first past the post as the lesser of two evils.

脱欧暴露了戴维·卡梅伦保守党彻底的领导力缺失,这是一次前所未有的自残行为,我们至今仍在为此付出代价,字面意义上的代价。

Brexit exposed a complete lack of leadership in David Cameron’s Conservative party, and it was an act of unprecedented self-harm that we are all still paying for, quite literally.

但它也表明,两大党之外的政党能施加足够压力,迫使执政党调整,甚至(遗憾的是)倾听选民声音。

But it also showed that parties outside the big two can exert enough pressure to force the party in power to adapt and, alas, to listen to voters.

与此同时,工党显著地自我重塑:从埃德·米利班德的温和左翼到杰里米·科尔宾的更激进纲领,再在证明无效后回归。

Labour, meanwhile, has reinvented itself remarkably: from Ed Miliband’s soft left to Jeremy Corbyn’s more radical programme, and back again when that proved ineffective.

若无简单多数制的激励,一个大党会让自己经历如此多的自我审视吗?

Would a major party put itself through so much self-scrutiny without the incentives of first past the post?

还是说它会分裂成几股势力,或许更具代表性却效率低得多,像意大利左翼诸多政党那样挥霍其历史?

Or would it have split into several streams, perhaps more representative but far less effective, squandering its history as so many parties of the Italian left have done?

作为一名定居身份居民,预计今年入籍,并希望在下届大选投工党一票,我只能说:请别这么做。Gian Lorenzo Spisso Bristol

As a settled-status resident who expects to become a citizen this year, and is hoping to vote for Labour at the next general election, I can only say: please don’t do this. Gian Lorenzo Spisso Bristol