字号 ·· | 护眼
亚洲新闻台

曼城上诉在即,足球界应对有罪裁决的余波Man City appeal looms as game grapples with fallout from guilty verdict

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

英国曼彻斯特,10月1日电:曼城面临周五的上诉截止日期,以针对其违反英超联赛财务规则的相关认定提出申诉,这开启了该案件的新篇章,而该案件对俱乐部及英格兰足球的最终影响仍充满高度不确定性。

MANCHESTER, England, Oct 1 : Manchester City face a Friday deadline to appeal against findings that they breached Premier League financial rules, opening the next chapter in a case whose ultimate consequences for the club and English football remain deeply uncertain.

在英格兰足坛最严重的纪律裁决之一作出两天后,尚未对俱乐部施加任何竞技层面的处罚。否认有任何不当行为的曼城目前仍位居英超积分榜榜首。

Two days after one of the most serious disciplinary verdicts in the English game, no sporting sanction has been imposed and City, who have denied any wrongdoing, remain top of the Premier League.

恩佐·马雷萨执教的球队开局五战全胜,将于10月11日在利物浦继续其争冠征程。尽管相关认定悬而未决,但球场上的业务基本照常进行。

Enzo Maresca’s side have opened the season with five wins from five and will resume their title challenge at Liverpool on October 11, with business on the pitch continuing largely as usual despite the findings hanging over the club.

然而,在场外,所有人的目光都紧紧锁定在周五,关注曼城是否会就委员会关于其近十年间系统性财务违规的认定提出挑战。此举可能会延长这场已酝酿多年的风波,并可能推迟对任何处罚措施的明确界定。

Off the field, however, attention is firmly on Friday and whether City challenge the commission’s findings over systematic financial breaches spanning nearly a decade — a move that could extend a saga already years in the making and potentially delay clarity over any punishment.

“这绝非理想状况,”品牌史密斯律师事务所(Brandsmiths)合伙人、体育律师汤姆·基恩表示。

"It's not ideal at all," said sports lawyer Tom Keane, a partner at Brandsmiths.

“这些法律程序及其规模本身就具有不幸的性质,需要耗费时间。如今,这种不确定性笼罩着正在进行的赛事,这对所有俱乐部的球迷和球员来说都是糟糕透顶的,包括曼城在内。

"It's just the unfortunate nature of these legal proceedings, the size of them, that it's going to take time, and there's this doubt now hanging over the competition that's currently in play, which is awful for fans, players of all clubs, including Man City.

“你难道不渴望一个结果吗?但显然,这可能会拖延到赛季结束之后,这同样令人沮丧,因为如果曼城再度过一个出色的赛季,这将围绕某些成就引发更多疑问。”疑问犹存裁决或许回答了一个问题,但却引发了数十个新问题。上诉需要多长时间?处罚何时决定?结果是否可能改变联赛积分榜、奖金分配或欧洲赛事资格席位?如果其他俱乐部开始寻求赔偿,又将发生什么?

"You just want an outcome, don't you? But it clearly could drag on beyond the end of the season, which again is terrible because it puts more questions around certain achievements if City go on to have another good season." QUESTIONS REMAIN The verdict may have answered one question but it has opened dozens more. How long will the appeal take? When will sanctions be decided? Could the outcome alter league tables, prize money distributions or European qualification places? And what happens if other clubs begin seeking compensation?

根据英超联赛的规则,上诉听证会应在上诉提交后12周内举行,裁决则须在听证会结束后的30天内做出。

Under Premier League rules, an appeal hearing should be held within 12 weeks of an appeal being lodged, with a decision due within 30 days of the hearing concluding.

由于该案规模庞大——仅独立委员会文件索引就达750页——对于截止日期是否存在一定的灵活性,英超联盟并未回应置评请求。

The league did not respond to a request for comment on whether there is any flexibility on deadlines due to the sheer scale of the case - the index to the independent commission's document bundle alone was 750 pages.

“鉴于案件的复杂性和指控的数量,这真的能在那个时间框架内完成吗?是六个月?还是十二个月?”基恩说道。他并补充称,法律费用已经达到数千万英镑。

"With the complexity of the case and the number of charges, is this really something that can be done in that timeframe? Is it six months? Is it 12 months?" said Keane, who added that legal fees will already be in the tens of millions of pounds.

他认为上诉应该在任何处罚决定作出之前进行,“如果随后要进行可能会根本改变结果的上诉,那么把时间和费用浪费在处罚听证会上,显然是没有道理的。”基恩表示,负责处理该案进展的人员应制定一个切实可行且严格的时间表,“这对所有人都有利。”

He believes the appeal should come before any sanctions, saying: "It would surely make sense not to waste time and expense on a sanctions hearing when you're going to have an appeal which could fundamentally change the outcome." Keane said those managing the operation of the case should set a practical and rigid timeline "for the benefit of everyone.

“从外部来看,曼城对这起案件的处理方式似乎就是为了制造拖延,”他补充道。

"From the outside, it appears that the approach taken to this case by City has been to create delay," he added.

“他们已经把事情拖到了这一步,你也会预料到,再次进行上诉时,考虑到证据的数量——我们还没看到证据,只看到了裁决结果——曼城将能够把最终结果进一步拖延下去。”索赔这种不确定性已经在足球界之外蔓延开来。

"They have kicked it down the road this far, and you would expect again with an appeal, the amount of evidence - we've not seen it, we've just seen the decision - that City will be able to kick the final result further down the road again." COMPENSATION CLAIMS The uncertainty is already spreading beyond football.

自2009年以来一直是曼城主要赞助商的阿提哈德航空本周表示,在拒绝接受与该案中提及的商业安排相关的调查结果后,该公司正在寻求法律咨询。

Etihad Airways, City's principal sponsor since 2009, said this week it was seeking legal advice after rejecting findings linked to commercial arrangements referenced in the case.

与此同时据了解,竞争对手俱乐部正在探讨因奖金、欧冠收入及其他财务机会损失而提起潜在索赔的可能性。

Rival clubs, meanwhile, are understood to be exploring potential compensation claims over lost prize money, Champions League income and other financial opportunities.

在球迷中,情绪从愤怒到难以置信不等。在本场老特拉福德球场附近,本周出现了一块写着“欢迎来到假曼彻斯特”(Shamchester)的巨型广告牌。

Among supporters, emotions range from anger to disbelief. Near Old Trafford, a giant billboard declaring "Welcome to Shamchester" appeared this week.

根据联赛方面的声明,曼城通过使用“虚假”的商业合同来虚增收入、同时隐瞒实际成本(金额超过9亿英镑/12亿美元)。

It played on the league's statement that City used "sham" commercial contracts as part of schemes to inflate revenue and understate costs by more than £900 million ($1.2 billion).

原本应该围绕战术和转会话题展开的球迷讨论,现在都被转移到了酒吧里,人们一边喝啤酒一边讨论相关的处罚措施和上诉程序。

Fan discussions that would normally revolve around tactics and transfers have also given way to talks over beers in pubs about sanctions and appeal procedures.

对于基恩来说,这场风波的影响最终可能会远远超出英超联赛和曼城本身的范围。

For Keane, the ramifications may ultimately stretch far beyond the Premier League and Manchester City.

“处理曼城的案件其实还算比较简单,”他说,“真正复杂的情况在于那些认为自己错失了奖金、商业收入或欧冠参赛机会的俱乐部——他们可能会采取法律行动。”他提到了球员和经纪人可能发起的法律诉讼。

"Dealing with the City case is almost now the easy part," he said. "What happens next, with clubs who believe they missed out on prize money, commercial revenue or Champions League football, is where things could become really complicated." He mentioned the potential for legal action from players and agents.

在所有上诉程序结束、处罚措施确定以及任何后续的法律纠纷得到解决之前,英格兰足球界正处于一个前所未有的困境中:一家被认定严重违反财务规定的俱乐部,却依然位居英超联赛榜首,同时还在等待这一裁决带来的真正后果。

Until appeals are exhausted, sanctions determined and any subsequent legal claims resolved, English football finds itself in an unprecedented state of limbo: a club found guilty of serious financial rule breaches, yet still leading the Premier League and waiting to discover the true cost of the verdict.