字号·· | 护眼
卫报

李尔王剧评——大卫·思雷尔福尔演绎动人的李尔,但为何他还要扮演弄臣?King Lear review – David Threlfall makes a moving Lear, but why is he playing the Fool too?

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

经典李尔……大卫·思雷尔福尔饰演国王。摄影:海伦·默里Classic Lear … David Threlfall as the king. Photograph: Helen Murray

电视剧《继承之战》的创作灵感部分源自《李尔王》,剧中罗伊这一姓氏则取自法语中的君主称谓“roi”。作为回应,马修·邓斯特执导的这部作品将焦点放在年轻一代身上,刻画他们在家族权力纷争中的种种算计与博弈。

The TV series Succession was partly modelled on King Lear, the family name Roy derived from the monarchic French roi. Returning the compliment, Matthew Dunster’s production centralises dynastic dynamics among the young as they plot around a splintering figurehead.

舞台布景采用了现代元素——牛仔裤、车钥匙以及手枪取代了原作中的麻布、马匹与刀剑。安娜·弗莱施勒设计的舞台上布满了闪闪发光的绳索,它们将舞台划分为夜总会、英格兰与法国的场景,还有地牢;在暴风雨场景里,这些绳索又充当了挡雨帘,保护观众不被淋湿。

The reading is supported by a modern setting – jeans, car keys and handguns for hessian, horses and swords – on an Anna Fleischle set of spangly strings variously dividing the stage into a nightclub, England and France, dungeons and, in the storm scene, serving as shower curtains to keep theatregoers dry.

这部剧的一大特色便是重复出现的台词,而不同版本的“李尔”形象则通过文字的斜体化处理得以呈现。此前在谢菲尔德上演的版本由伊恩·麦克迪阿梅德主演,着重表现了虚无主义情绪以及李尔与整个社会的末路景象。邓斯特的版本则着重刻画了父母与兄弟姐妹的关系——乔纳森·斯林格饰演的格洛斯特性格极其恶劣,显然是按照李尔的育儿方式将埃德蒙与埃德加养大的;此外,剧中还较为常规地展现了衰老主题,大卫·瑟雷福尔饰演的李尔在表演中精准地呈现出神经退化的种种迹象。

In a play notable for repeated words, versions of Lear are revealed through verbal italicisation. Titas Halder’s recent Sheffield staging with Ian McDiarmid stressed nothing and other nihilisms, emphasising the end days of a man and society. Dunster underlines references to parenting and siblings – Jonathan Slinger’s unusually unpleasant Gloucester seems to have brought up Edmund and Edgar using Lear’s childcare manual – and, more conventionally, to senility, David Threlfall’s King feeling neurologically forensic. Otherwise, Dunster is notably disruptive.

除此之外,邓斯特的改编极具颠覆性:开场时仅由瑟雷福尔独自登台,念出第三幕的台词;随后又安排年轻一代表演带有情色意味的哑剧。曾获水星音乐奖提名的音乐家纳丁·沙赫在剧中饰演贡纳莉,她也是《李尔王》演出史上首位随着自己创作的动感音乐表演性爱动作的演员。这种将诱惑视为权力手段的处理方式,以及将繁衍与继承权挂钩的设定,与最后一幕中残酷的权力三角关系相契合——帕迪·斯塔福德饰演的埃德蒙一边把玩着李尔的两个女儿,一边贪婪地品尝两杯葡萄酒。不过这样的设计有时也会让人觉得《李尔王》仿佛变成了《权力的游戏》。

Starting with Threlfall alone on stage delivering a speech from act III, he gives the younger generation introductory erotic dumb shows. The Mercury prize-nominated musician Nadine Shah becomes surely the first Goneril or composer for a staging of King Lear to mime sex to her own pulsing compositions. This accentuation of seduction as a power tactic and the implied significance of procreation to inheritance fits the brutal triangle of the final act – Paddy Stafford’s Edmund lasciviously tasting two glasses of wine as he juggles Lear’s daughters – but can feel like Succession becoming Game of Thrones.

王朝动态……左起:杰森·多恩(肯特)、乔纳森·斯林格(格洛斯特)、汤姆·瓦雷(埃德加)和大卫·思雷尔福尔(李尔王)。摄影:海伦·默里Dynastic dynamics … l-r Jason Done (Kent), Jonathan Slinger (Gloucester), Tom Varey (Edgar) and David Threlfall (King Lear). Photograph: Helen Murray

最具颠覆性的改编在于移除了一位伟大的莎士比亚式人物。特雷尔福一人分饰君主与其弄臣,像个嘴巴会动的腹语术演员,独自完成他们二人的对唱。当乔纳森·普赖斯饰演的哈姆雷特同时也扮演老哈姆雷特的鬼魂、近乎呕吐般吐出台词时,有一种恶魔附身的感觉。而在本剧中,对着空气说话可能是痴呆症的症状,但这一改动意味着我们失去了李尔身边唯一敢说真话的人。

The most seismic rewrite removes a great Shakespearean character. Threlfall doubles as monarch and his Fool, doing both halves of their duologues like a ventriloquist whose mouth moves. When Jonathan Pryce’s Hamlet also played King Hamlet’s ghost, almost vomiting the lines, there was a sense of demonic possession. In this case, speaking to the unseen can be a dementia symptom but the change means we lose the one candid truth-teller to Lear.

这或许是一个编辑层面的隐喻,意指那种毁灭权势者的绝对封闭性,但弄臣的被抛弃,给本已因主角在第四幕长时间缺席而留有空白、且审判场面本就显得古怪的剧作,又增添了一个漏洞。

This could be an editorial point about the absolute insularity that destroys the powerful, but the casting-off adds another hole to a play that already bears one in the title character’s long act IV absence and makes the wonky trial scene even odder.

“可能继承了她父亲的任性愤怒”……伊索贝尔·阿库乌迪克饰演科迪莉亚。摄影:海伦·默里‘May have inherited her dad’s wilful anger’ … Isobel Akuwudike as Cordelia. Photograph: Helen Murray

在这花哨的噱头之中,特雷尔福呈现了一个相当经典的李尔王,在临终场景中深深动人;但他既确立了角色的民族主义倾向,又在通常毫无波澜的台词“我是在法国吗?”处博得了满堂大笑。伊索贝尔·阿库乌迪克引人入胜地暗示,考狄利娅可能继承了父亲那倔强的愤怒。

Within this gimmickry, Threlfall delivers a fairly classic Lear, deeply affecting in the deathbed scenes but, having established the character’s nationalism, winning a big laugh with the usually nothing line, “Am I in France?”Isobel Akuwudike intriguingly suggests Cordelia may have inherited her dad’s wilful anger.

《李尔王》的语词回响中包含四十多次“信件”或“纸条”,邓斯特将这点处理得异常具体:一些原本只在口中提及的书信被实际递送并拆开;这位李尔王的王国拥有一个令人印象深刻的皇家邮政系统。人们怀疑,导演将会收到大量关于幽灵弄臣的来信。没有弄臣的《李尔王》,在两层意义上都“不好笑”了。在曼彻斯特皇家交易所剧院演出,至11月15日止

King Lear’s word reverberations include more than 40 uses of “letters” or “note”, and Dunster makes this unusually tangible: some correspondence generally only spoken of is delivered and opened; the kingdom of this Lear boasts an impressive Royal Mail. The director, you suspect, will get a lot of missives about the spectre jester. Lear without Fool is, in two senses, not funny. At Royal Exchange theatre, Manchester, until 15 November