欧盟担心中国大量出口廉价电动汽车。10月12日,欧盟表示,将在12月对来自中国的混合动力电动汽车进口实施每年35万辆的配额。这预计将使其市场份额减半。但欧盟也担心中国在制造这些车辆所需的关键矿物供应方面的主导地位。
The European Union worries about China’s vast exports of cheap electric vehicles. On October 12th it said that in December a quota of 350,000-a-year would be imposed on hybrid EV imports from China. This is expected to halve their market share. But the bloc also frets about China’s dominance over the supply of critical minerals used to make these vehicles.
随着电动汽车数量快速增长,大量电动汽车即将被报废并更换。粉碎其电池可产生“黑粉”,这是一种粉末,从中可以回收和再利用锂、钴、镍等贵重金属。从下个月起,欧盟将使该废料的出口更加困难。其目的是鼓励在本地(目前大部分黑粉被运往亚洲)进行更多的黑粉处理。8月份,美国——尽管禁止中国电动汽车但仍大量进口中国电池——阻止了所有黑粉出口。
A fast-growing number of EVs will soon be scrapped and replaced. Shredding their batteries yields “black mass”, a powder from which valuable metals such as lithium, cobalt and nickel can be recovered and reused. From next month the EU will make it harder to export this waste. The aim is to encourage more processing of black mass close to home (at the moment most is shipped to Asia). In August America, which has banned Chinese EVs but still imports lots of Chinese batteries, blocked all black-mass exports.
然而,中国不太可能受到影响。国际能源署(一家预测机构)表示,到2050年,黑粉可能占全球电池金属需求的20-30%。因此,中国正在加速发展其回收产业:不仅为了保障电池金属供应,还包括稀土及其他许多资源。其目标是使经济从“线性”(即原材料制成产品后被丢弃)转向“循环”(即闭环,使再生废料替代原材料)。
China, however, is unlikely to suffer. Black mass might make up 20-30% of global demand for battery metals by 2050, says the International Energy Agency, a forecaster. So China is supercharging its recycling industries: not just to shore up supplies of battery metals, but also rare-earths and much else. The goal is to make its economy less “linear” (where raw materials are made into products which are then thrown away) and more “circular” (closing the loop so recycled waste replaces raw materials).
曾经,回收工作主要受污染担忧驱动。如今,在全球为建设高科技经济所需材料展开的竞争中,安全已成为主要动因。
Once recycling efforts were driven by concerns about pollution. Now, amid a global scramble for the materials needed to build a high-tech economy, security has become a primary motive.
中国在垃圾管理方面积累了艰辛的经验。其产生的垃圾量全球最高:约占世界城市废弃物(从家庭垃圾桶内容到街道清扫物)的15%,以及超过四分之一的工业废弃物(如拆除废料、工厂废水、废金属、炉渣和灰烬)。
The country has hard-earned experience in managing rubbish. It produces more than anywhere else: about 15% of the world’s municipal detritus (everything from the contents of household bins to street sweepings) and more than one-quarter of its industrial waste (such as demolition debris, factory effluent, scrap metal, slag and ash).
20世纪80年代,中国开始进口废弃物,接收富裕国家不再需要的硬件、纸张和塑料。一个庞大的非正式回收行业随之兴起,由拾荒者在垃圾堆中拣选废弃物为主导。大量废弃物最终进入填埋场或在露天焚烧,渗出有毒化学物质并产生毒害性雾霾。2011年一部中国纪录片发现,北京周边垃圾场的有机废弃物正被转化为油并卖给餐馆。
In the 1980s China started to import waste, taking the hardware, paper and plastic that richer countries did not want. A sprawling informal recycling-sector emerged, led by scavengers picking through rubbish piles. Much ended up in landfills or burnt in the open air, leaching toxic chemicals and creating poisonous smog. A Chinese documentary in 2011 found that organic waste from dumps around Beijing was being turned into oil and sold to restaurants.
2013年,鉴于公众愤怒日益加剧,中国宣布开展“战争”以应对污染,并发布了首个全面的国家循环经济计划。电子产品被引导至新设立的“城市矿区”进行安全拆解;家庭垃圾被送往专门设施进行焚烧发电;填埋场倾倒的废弃物比例开始下降。2017年,中国启动“国家剑行动”以禁止大多数塑料进口(2021年,所有固体废弃物进口被禁止)。官方媒体宣称中国“不再是垃圾场”。过去五年,大多数城市已推行家庭垃圾强制分类。
In 2013, cautious of mounting public anger, China declared a “war on pollution” and released its first comprehensive national plan to create a circular economy. Electronics were directed to new “urban mining” zones to be scrapped safely; household rubbish was sent to specialised plants to be burned for power; the proportion of waste dumped in landfills started to fall. In 2017 China launched “Operation National Sword” to stop most imports of plastics (in 2021 all imports of solid waste were banned). China was “no longer a dumping ground,” trumpeted state-run media. Over the past five years most cities have rolled out mandatory sorting of household rubbish.
在废弃物管理方面,中国仍远落后于欧洲一些干净整洁的国家(尽管难以具体说落后多少,因为中国未公布详细的全国回收数据)。其较贫困的农村地区仍常见乱堆乱放的垃圾。但官员们至少已让中国的大城市变得更干净、更宜居。如今,他们的重点正转向利用回收以保障安全。2023年7月,中国发布了截至2030年的循环经济发展计划。该计划指出:“资源安全的重要性日益凸显,而地缘政治动态……变得日益复杂和严峻。”
China is still well behind squeaky-clean European countries when it comes to waste management (though it is hard to say how far, as it does not publish detailed national data for recycling). Its poorer rural areas are still often strewn with rubbish. But officials have made China’s big cities, at least, cleaner and more pleasant to live in. Now their focus is shifting to the use of recycling for the sake of security. In July China released a plan for the development of the circular economy until 2030. “The importance of resource security has become increasingly prominent, while geopolitical dynamics…have grown complex and severe,” the plan noted.
该判断基于两个考虑。首先,中国希望在从机器人到风力涡轮机的所有领域主导高科技制造业。其次,为了实现这一目标,它必须确保原材料供应,连接更多电力线路并建设更多数据中心。需要大量的铝、铜、电池金属和稀土。虽然中国控制着这些材料全球炼制能力的大部分,但它依赖进口来获取大部分矿石。与此同时,许多西方国家希望减少对中国工厂的依赖。
That judgment rests on two considerations. First, China wants to dominate high-tech manufacturing in everything from robotics to wind turbines. And second, to achieve this, it must secure supplies of raw materials, connect more power lines and build more data-centres. Massive amounts of aluminium, copper, battery metals and rare earths are needed. While China controls the bulk of the global refining capacity for these materials, it relies on imports for most of the ores. Meanwhile many Western countries want to reduce reliance on China’s factories.
官员们担心他们可能会试图限制中国的供应。去年,一家国有研究机构的一名研究员表示,如果不进行回收,中国将“在未来继续面临被掐住脖子的局面”。
Officials worry they might try to squeeze its supplies. Last year a researcher at a state-owned research facility said that without recycling China would “keep facing strangleholds in the future”.
中国希望通过回收在2030年每年提供5.1亿吨工业材料,比目前水平高出约三分之一。较为容易的部分将是扩大钢铁、铜和铝的回收:这种工作已经是一个成熟的产业。回收更多塑料稍微棘手一些,但值得这样做,以帮助中国减少石油进口。最困难的部分将是管理日益增长的电子垃圾洪流。到2030年,中国预计每年将产生来自风力涡轮机的0.5万吨废弃物、来自电动汽车电池的1万吨废弃物以及来自太阳能电池板的150万至200万吨废弃物——占全球总量的大比例。
China wants to use recycling to supply 510m tonnes of industrial materials annually by 2030, about one-third more than the current level. The easier part will be scaling up the recycling of steel, copper and aluminium: this kind of work is already a mature industry. Recycling more plastic is a little trickier, but worth it to help China reduce imports of oil. The hardest bit will be managing a growing tsunami of electronic garbage. By 2030 China expects to generate 0.5m tonnes of waste from wind turbines, 1m tonnes from EV batteries and 1.5-2m tonnes from solar panels every year—big shares of the global total.
鉴于中国已经大规模生产这些产品,回收应该会更容易实施。工厂可以调整设计,使产品以后更易于拆解。而且许多电池生产技术(例如使用酸和热来分离贵金属)也用于回收它们。以宁德时代为例,它是全球最大的电池制造商。该中国公司的大部分销售是国内的,最终将由其子公司宁德时代磷酸铁锂(Brunp)处理,而Brunp是全球最大的电池回收商。这种安排帮助中国建成了全球85%的电池回收能力。
That China already makes vast quantities of these goods should make recycling simpler to do. Factories can tweak designs so that products are easier to dismantle later. And many battery-producing techniques (such as using acids and heat to isolate valuable metals) are also used in recycling them. Take CATL, for example, the world’s largest battery-maker. Most of the Chinese firm’s sales are domestic, and will end up being processed by a CATL subsidiary called Brunp, which is the world’s biggest battery-recycler. Such arrangements have helped China build 85% of global battery-recycling capacity.
然而,巨大的挑战仍然存在。由于太多电池最终落入非正式废品收购商手中(他们浪费了电池内部许多有价值的部件),或被直接丢弃,中国大部分的回收能力仍未被利用。近年来,多个犯罪团伙因经营电池收集网络而被查获。太阳能电池板和风力涡轮机常用于该国偏远地区,这使得它们的回收问题更为棘手。它们所含的贵重材料(太阳能电池板中的银;风力涡轮机中的钕,一种稀土元素)仅以微量存在,导致提取过程更加复杂。
Still, big challenges remain. Much of China’s recycling capacity is unused because too many batteries end up with informal scrap dealers (who waste much of the good stuff inside them) or are just dumped. In recent years several criminal gangs have been bust for running battery-collection rings. Solar panels and wind turbines, which are often used in remote parts of the country, present an even bigger collection problem. Valuable materials they contain (silver, for solar panels; and neodymium, a rare earth, for wind turbines) are only present in small quantities, making extraction trickier.
一如既往,中国希望其技术赋能的国家能够解决这些问题。2024年,中国成立了一家名为中国资源再生集团的新国有企业,旨在协调和简化回收工作,重点放在清洁技术产品上。回收厂已开始使用人工智能来更高效地进行分类。4月,电池和电动汽车制造商被要求为其产品赋予数字身份证,以便在国家运营的平台上追踪其全生命周期。他们还被法律要求对其生产的电池进行回收。
As ever, China hopes its tech-enabled state can solve such problems. In 2024 it set up a new state-owned company called China Resources Recycling Group to co-ordinate and streamline recycling efforts, with a focus on cleantech products. Recycling plants have started using artificial intelligence to sort more efficiently. In April battery and EV makers were required to give their products digital IDs to track them through their life cycle on a state-run platform. They have also been made legally responsible for recycling the batteries they make.
中国正试图提高稀土回收的效率(其声称目前供应全球稀土的10%)。目前,从废旧产品中提取稀土的成本远高于从原材料中提取。尽管如此,科罗拉多矿业学院的科比·安德森指出,中国的稀土企业——几乎全部为国有企业——“在所有情况下都不依赖经济可行性”。
China is trying to make the recycling of rare earths (which it claims now supplies 10% of them) more efficient. At present it is far more costly than extracting them from raw materials. Still, Chinese rare-earth companies, which are almost all state-owned, “do not rely on economic viability in all cases”, notes Corby Anderson of the Colorado School of Mines.
为了确保其回收厂有原料供应,中国也在悄悄地恢复其在废弃物贸易中的旧角色。它正在选择性地放宽对部分外国废弃物的进口限制。2024年,它放宽了对部分废铜和废铝进口的限制。去年,它开始允许进口黑色物质。今年1月,它将该物质的进口关税从6.5%降至3%。官员们承诺,在未来五年内将继续增加“高质量”再生材料的进口。
And to make sure its recycling plants are fed, China is also quietly reassuming its old role in the waste trade. It is selectively rolling back import restrictions on some foreign waste. In 2024 it eased curbs on imports of some scrap copper and aluminium. Last year it started allowing imports of black mass. In January it slashed import tariffs on the stuff from 6.5% to 3%. Officials have pledged to continue to increase imports of “high-quality” recycled materials over the next five years.
然而,如今美国和欧洲希望保留其有价值的废弃物,它们是否会侵蚀中国在回收领域的主导地位?深圳上市公司GEM(格林美)的副总经理张宇平认为不会。“从国家安全的角度来看,他们可能有一些理由,”他说。但中国境外的回收成本将很高,且难以扩大规模。张宇平认为,欧洲至少“无法消化”如此巨大的挑战。“他们将付出沉重的代价。”■
Still, now that America and Europe want to keep their valuable waste, could they eat into China’s recycling dominance? Zhang Yuping, the deputy general manager of GEM, a big Shenzhen-listed battery-recycler, thinks not. “From the perspective of national security, they might have some justification,” he says. But the cost of recycling outside China would be high and scaling up difficult. Europe, at least, “can’t digest” such a challenge, reckons Mr Zhang. “They would pay a heavy cost.” ■