
铁丝网围栏后是一道巨大的、张着的大地伤口。就在几个月前谷歌进驻之前,位于芬兰北部乡村小镇穆霍斯附近、面积达330公顷(815英亩)的森林里,估计生长着四分之一百万棵树。如今,它们全都不见了。
Behind a wire fence lies a vast gaping wound of earth. Before Google's arrival a few months ago, an estimated quarter of a million trees occupied the 330 hectares (815 acres) of forest near the town of Muhos in rural northern Finland Now they are all gone.
在科技公司为建设数据中心而非法剥离了整片区域——连表层土壤也一并带走——之后,剩下的只有一大片泥地,上面留有机械履带痕迹、水坑,以及堆积的泥土、树根和树枝。居民表示,从工地流出的褐色污水正汇入一条支流,而该支流注入奥卢约基河。
After the tech company illegally stripped the entire area to build a datacentre – taking even the top soil with it – all that remains is a vast expanse of mud indented with the trail marks of machinery, puddles and mounds of earth, roots and branches. Residents say that brown water flowing off the site is going into a stream that feeds the Oulujoki River.
“这没完没了,一直延伸下去,”芬兰自然保护协会(SLL)的生态学家玛丽·安纳拉看着无人机拍摄的原森林航拍画面说道,她站在围栏边缘。
"It doesn't end. It goes on and on," says Mari Annala, an ecologist from the Finnish Association for Nature Conservation (SLL), looking at drone footage of the former forest from the perimeter.
随着145座新数据中心处于不同规划阶段,芬兰发现自己处于科技公司最新扩张浪潮的最前沿。除了相对稳定的地缘政治和地质环境、充足的土地资源外,凉爽的气候使其在节约能源成本方面极具吸引力。
With 145 new datacentres at various stages of planning, Finland has found itself at the forefront of the tech companies' latest push. As well as its relative geopolitical and geological stability and abundance of land, the cool climate makes it especially attractive for saving on energy costs.

本月初,芬兰许可与监管局(LVV)下令谷歌暂停穆霍斯工地及东南约100公里处奥坦麦基村另一工地的施工,原因是该公司在皆伐土地前未完成必要的环境影响评估。这一消息引发了广泛愤慨,并引发全国范围的反思:在全球为跟上人工智能快速发展而竞相建设数据中心的浪潮中,芬兰究竟应扮演何种角色,抑或根本不应参与。
Earlier this month, Google was ordered by the Finnish Licensing and Supervision Authority (LVV) to temporarily stop work on Muhos and another site about 100km south-east in the village of Otanmäki after it failed to complete the necessary environmental impact assessments before clearcutting the land. The news has prompted widespread outcry and a national reckoning over what role, if any, the country should play in the global rush to build datacentres to keep up with rapid AI development.
上周,谷歌芬兰分公司经理安蒂·耶尔维宁为森林皆伐道歉,但声称公司当时是“基于我们对当时立法的最佳理解”行事。
Last week, Google's Finland country manager, Antti Järvinen, apologised for the forest clearings but claimed the company had acted "on the best understanding we had of the legislation at the time".
穆霍斯和奥坦麦基是谷歌一项价值130亿欧元的人工智能基础设施项目的一部分,该项目招致了唐纳德·特朗普的批评,他宁愿这些中心建在美国,并公开呼吁该公司重新考虑。这是北欧国家同类项目中规模最大的一次。
Muhos and Otanmäki are part of a €13bn AI infrastructure project by Google that has attracted criticism from Donald Trump, who would rather the centres were built in the US and has publicly called for the company to reconsider. It is the biggest ever project of its kind in the Nordic country.

芬兰政府在主导大幅削减开支的背景下,一直鼓励这项投资。上个月,当谷歌的计划公布时,该国总理佩特里·奥尔波表示,吸引投资是“首要任务”,“数据经济的价值远远超出直接投资”。他说,这项谷歌交易将“为双方带来持久利益”。
The Finnish government, which has presided over deep spending cuts, has encouraged the investment. Last month, when the Google plans were announced, the country's prime minister, Petteri Orpo, said attracting investment was a "top priority" and "the value of the data economy extends far beyond direct investment". He said the Google deal would "deliver lasting benefits for both parties".
但关于谷歌不当行为的披露引发了公众担忧,这些交易对附近社区、芬兰家庭的能源价格以及芬兰的自然环境——这一国家骄傲的来源——意味着什么。数据中心建设热潮很可能成为芬兰人在4月去投票时的一个关键选举议题。
But the revelations over Google's misconduct have prompted public concern over what these deals mean for nearby communities, energy prices for Finnish households and Finland's natural environment, a national source of pride. The datacentre push is likely to become a key election issue when Finns go to the polls in April.
除了穆霍斯砍伐的25万棵树,安纳拉估计奥坦麦基还额外砍伐了15万棵树。她说,因为这些树是非法砍伐的,这两个地点的木材无法出售给木材加工厂。
In addition to the 250,000 trees felled at Muhos, Annala estimates that an additional 150,000 trees were felled at Otanmäki. Because the trees have been felled illegally, she says wood from the two sites cannot be sold to wood-processing plants.

这一举动还引发了质疑,为什么芬兰的可再生能源被用来为国际公司供电。
The move has also prompted questions over why Finland's renewable energy sources are being used to power international corporations.
超过9.3万人签署请愿书,要求加强数据中心监管,并征收费用以补偿当地社区的环境损失。丑闻曝光后,奥尔波将穆霍斯发生的事情形容为“冷水浇头”。
More than 93,000 people have signed a petition demanding more datacentre regulation and a fee to compensate local communities for environmental damage. Since the scandal broke, Orpo has described what happened in Muhos as a "cold shower".
芬兰版权组织 SLL 董事会主席汉娜·哈尔梅恩帕(Hanna Halmeenpää)表示,当她发现谷歌违法时感到难以置信。“起初我简直不敢相信,”她说,“我从未听说过在芬兰有任何公司做过这种事。”她表示,该体系很大程度上依赖信任,而她认为谷歌利用了这一点。“他们买下了大片土地,然后就这样开始砍伐,”她说,“这是纯粹的傲慢,令人震惊。”
Hanna Halmeenpää, chair of SLL's board, said she had been incredulous when she discovered Google's law breaking. "At first I couldn't believe it," she said. "I have never heard that any company has done anything like this in Finland." She said the system depended a lot on trust, which she believes Google took advantage of. "They bought the vast land area and they just started to cut it, just like that," she said. "It's pure arrogance and it's amazing."
她说,事态发展的速度让全国感到震惊。“许多人只是看着新闻,互相询问:‘现在发生什么了?我们能做什么?我们非得在芬兰接受所有这些数据中心项目吗?’” 赫尔辛基大学计算机科学系主任于西·坎加沙尤(Jussi Kangasharju)表示,虽然数据中心带来了有限的就业岗位,可能提振当地经济,但在国家层面收益微乎其微。
The speed of developments had shocked the country, she said. "Many people are just watching the news and asking each other: 'What's happening now? What can we do about it? And do we have to take all these datacentre projects in Finland?'" Jussi Kangasharju, head of computer science at the University of Helsinki, said that while datacentres brought a limited number of jobs, potentially boosting the local economy, the benefits on a national level were minimal.

“实际上,对芬兰来说,没有任何好处,”他说,“它们是服务于国际客户的国际公司,极少企业税流向芬兰。数据中心最终除了数据中心运营商外,对其他人几乎没有任何好处。”随着立法仍在追赶进度,各方纷纷争取尽快启动项目。
"Really, for Finland, there are no benefits," he said. "They are international companies serving international customers. Very little corporate taxes go to Finland.
有人呼吁设立一个中央协调机构来统筹数据中心项目,而不是将如此多的决策权留给市镇,因为市镇很可能会优先考虑当地的即时需求。
Datacentres ultimately have very little benefit for others except the datacentre operator." With legislation still playing catchup, there is a rush to get projects under way as fast as possible.

在穆霍斯和奥坦麦基,有人支持这些项目,以及它们将为当地带来的就业岗位和土地税收。但许多人认为,市镇亏待了他们。
Some are calling for a centralised body to coordinate datacentre projects, rather than leaving so much of the decision-making down to municipalities that are likely to prioritise the immediate needs of the local area.
Antti Jakonen住在芬兰米莫斯,他说,虽然砍伐的树木仅占芬兰森林总面积的一小部分,但他反对这种处理方式。“那是错误的方式。美国式。毫无意义。完全没有意义,”他说。这位前企业家兼渔民希望谷歌通过帮助恢复当地被水电工程毁掉的鲇鱼种群来赔偿。
In Muhos and Otanmäki, there are people who support the projects, along with the jobs and land taxes they will bring into the local area. But many believe they have been sold short by municipalities.
在奥塔马基,自然扰动和居民日常生活受到真切感受。当树木被砍伐时,曾在那里生活的狼群来到了村庄,53岁的Anni Ranta说,她的家族世代居住于此。
Antti Jakonen, who lives in Muhos, said that, although the trees felled represented a small fraction of Finland's overall forests, he objected to the manner in which it had been carried out. "It has been done in the wrong way. American style. No sense. No sense at all," he said. The former entrepreneur and fisher wants Google to compensate by helping to restore the local salmon population destroyed decades ago by hydropower.

从前是一个采矿村,该地区以稀土元素闻名。Ranta的家族住在村庄中心,旁边是一座三角形的教堂尖塔和一个已空置多年的旧酒吧。曾经绵延数英里的宁静森林如今已被谷歌砍伐地段的施工噪音所包围。
In Otanmäki, the disruption to nature and to residents' daily lives is being vividly felt. When the trees were felled, the wolves who had lived there came to the village, said Anni Ranta, 53, whose family has lived there for generations.
“因为所有野生动物都离开了森林,所以狼群会来到村庄,”Ranta说。“它们逃走了。让我担心数据中心的问题,还有噪音,因为这里的土是硬岩土壤。即使我们站在那里说话的时候,”她补充道,跫着脚,“就像打鼓一样。”
A former mining village, the area is known for its rare earth elements. Ranta's family live at the centre of the village next to a triangular church spire and a former bar that has been empty for years. The peaceful forest used to extend for miles from the village. Now the sound of building work next to the clearcut Google site reverberates.

她对谷歌的到来如此强烈反对,以至于她考虑搬离。她还担心数据中心会使村庄成为俄罗斯的目标,而芬兰与俄罗斯有着漫长的边境线。“我不希望他们在这里,”她说起谷歌。“我不希望他们在芬兰。我不喜欢整个人工智能的想法,以及世界正在改变的方式。变化太快了,太快了。”她的父亲Pentti Korhonen,一位退休的荒野向导说,自从森林被毁掉以来,溪流里的水已经变褐。“芬兰根本不需要数据中心。根本不需要数据中心,”他说。
"We had wolves coming into the village because all the wild animals moved out of the forest," said Ranta. "They fled. What worries me about the datacentres is also the noise because this is hardrock soil. Even when we are standing here talking," she added, stamping her feet, "it's like a drum."
Vesa Hyyryläinen,地方SLL地区主席表示,森林中筑巢的三趾啄木鸟已被驱逐。“我们所有的自然保护者都对芬兰的政治局势和政治非常担忧,”这位生物学家兼鹗类专家说。“我想不通,为什么我们必须牺牲如此多的自然。他们太轻易地把一切让渡了。”
Such is her strength of feeling against the arrival of Google that she is thinking of moving out. She also fears the datacentre could make the village a target for Russia, with whom Finland shares a long border. "I don't want them here," she said of Google. "I don't want them in Finland at all. I don't like the whole idea of AI and the world changing and the way it's changing. It's going too fast, too soon." Her father, Pentti Korhonen, a retired wilderness guide, said that since the forest was destroyed, the water in the stream has turned brown. "There is no need at all for datacentres in Finland. No need for datacentres at all," he said.

他 however 表示,鉴于该地区人口老龄化,他理解当局为何要引入新的投资和就业来源。“年轻人去赫尔辛基、柏林和巴黎,”他说。“人口实在太少了。我们必须作出牺牲。”
Vesa Hyyryläinen, chair of the local SLL district, said three-toed woodpeckers nesting in the forest had been pushed out. "All of us nature conservationists are very worried about our Finnish political situation and politics," said the biologist and osprey expert. "I wonder why we have to sacrifice so much of our nature. They give everything away too easily."
环境部部长助理 Veli‑Matti Uski 说,政府正在“监测[数据中心]行业的总体发展、其立法的适用情况,并准备在必要时提出立法修正”。
He said, however, that he understood why authorities were trying to bring in new sources of investment and jobs, given the region's ageing population. "Young people go to Helsinki and Berlin and Paris," he said. "There are so few people. We have to sacrifice." Veli-Matti Uski, director general of the ministry of environment, said the government was "monitoring the general development of the [datacentre] sector, [and the] application of its legislation, and is prepared to propose legislative amendments as necessary".

Google 表示正致力于保护穆霍斯(Muhos)地点的水质,并计划在该地种植 130 公顷的树木。保护主义者称,这一数字相较于砍伐造成的破坏而言,太低,难以产生实质影响。
Google said it was working to protect water quality at the Muhos site, and that it planned to plant trees across 130 hectares there. Conservationists say that figure is too low to have any real impact in comparison to the damage done by the tree felling.
一位发言人说:“我们在芬兰已运营 15 年,一直致力于满足或超越分区、环境、健康和安全要求。
A spokesperson said: "We have operated in Finland for 15 years and have always worked to meet or exceed zoning, environmental, health and safety requirements.
‘在收到 LVV 于 10 月 6 日的函件后,我们停止了穆霍斯和卡亚尼(Otanmäki 站所在地点)的前期工作,并已向 LVV 提交了正式回复,确认此事。
"After receiving the LVV letters on 6 October, we stopped preparatory works at Muhos and Kajaani [where the Otanmäki site is located] and have submitted a formal response to LVV confirming this.
‘我们将全面遵守 LVV 在此事上的要求。我们期待与所有当局保持积极、开放的对话,以加强我们与芬兰及当地组织的合作伙伴关系。”
"We will fully comply with LVV's requests in this matter. We look forward to maintaining an active, open dialogue with all authorities to strengthen our partnership with Finland and local organisations."