坎迪斯·欧文斯声称,在过去18个月里,她一直遭受“精神病态的谎言”攻击。 布丽吉特·马克龙不能要求坎迪斯·欧文斯个人为有关法国第一夫人是男性的言论承担责任。
Candace Owens claimed that she had been subjected to ‘psychotic lies’ over the past 18 months Credit Getty Images/Joe Raedle Alexandra Snow 3:14pm GMT Emmanuel and Brigitte Macron cannot hold Candace Owens personally liable for her claims that the French first lady is a man a judge has ruled.
马克龙夫妇此前在特拉华州起诉了这位右翼播客主持人,因为她散布了布丽吉特·马克龙是跨性别者的虚假说法。
The Macrons had sued the Right-wing podcaster in Delaware after she spread the false claim that Brigitte Macron was transgender.
欧文斯在其播客中用了数十期节目来传播针对法国第一夫人的这一阴谋论,她从2024年3月开始推动这一说法。
Ms Owens devoted dozens of episodes of her podcast to the conspiracy theory against the French first lady which she began pushing in March 2024.
周二,特拉华州高等法院法官谢尔顿·K·伦尼裁定,法院对欧文斯没有管辖权,因为她居住在田纳西州。
On Tuesday, Judge Sheldon K Rennie, of Delaware superior court, ruled that the court did not have jurisdiction over Ms Owens as she lives in Tennessee.
这一裁定意味着,即使马克龙夫妇在案件中胜诉,任何判决也无法对欧文斯执行,她的个人资产很可能受到保护。
That ruling means that if the Macrons were to prevail in the case, any judgment could not be assigned to Ms Owens, and it is likely that her personal assets would be shielded.
她的两家公司——坎迪斯·欧文斯有限责任公司和乔治汤姆公司——仍是被告。
Her two companies, Candace Owens LLC and GeorgeTom Inc, remain defendants.
伦尼法官周二还裁定,应适用法国的诉讼时效,而非美国的诉讼时效,因为马克龙夫妇居住在巴黎。
Judge Rennie also ruled on Tuesday that the statute of limitations in France should apply, rather than the United States, since the Macrons live in Paris.
欧文斯的法律团队曾力推这一变更,并辩称这对夫妇“故意挑选法院,因为若适用法国三个月的时效,他们的诉讼请求本会自然失效”。
Ms Owens’s legal team lobbied for this change and argued the couple was “intentionally forum shopping because being held to France’s three months would have naturally expired their claims”.
法国法律规定,从发表诽谤性言论到提起诉讼的期限为三个月。如果某人因种族、宗教、性别、性取向或残疾而成为攻击目标,这一期限延长至一年。
French law gives a deadline of three months from the time the defamatory statements were made to when a lawsuit is brought. This is extended to one year in cases where someone is targeted for their race, religion, sex, sexual orientation or disability.
法院已要求双方就哪个时限更为适当提交论据。如果法官裁定适用三个月的规则,此案可能会被完全驳回,因为马克龙夫妇确实在该期限内提起了诉讼。
The court has asked both sides to submit arguments for which time period would be more appropriate. If the judge decides that the three-month rule applies, the case could be dismissed altogether because the Macrons did file their action within that period.
一个在网上流传的阴谋论声称,布丽吉特·马克龙原本是名叫让-米歇尔·特罗尼厄的男性。阿纳多卢通讯社 via Getty Images/穆斯塔法·亚尔钦 欧文斯女士表示,对于这一部分法律上的胜利,她“心情绝对好极了”。
An internet-spread conspiracy theory claims Brigitte Macron was previously a man called Jean-Michel Trogneux Anadolu via Getty Images/Mustafa Yalcin Ms Owens said she was “in the absolute best mood” over the partial legal win.
“感觉就像一年半以来,我的家人不得不应对关于即将破产、秘密账户和逃离该国计划的疯狂谎言,”她在一篇长篇X帖子中写道。
“Feels like a year and a half of my family having to deal with psychotic lies regarding pending bankruptcies, secret accounts and plans to flee the country,” she wrote in a long X post.
在帖子中,欧文斯女士声称这对夫妇“并没有(起诉),也从未因涉及性、性取向或性别的事项起诉过任何人”,反而称诉讼是针对她关于“MK Ultra(战后中央情报局的人体实验项目)和盗窃”的言论。
In the post, Ms Owens claimed the couple “is NOT [suing] and has never sued anyone for matters pertaining to sex, sexual orientation, or gender”, instead saying the suit was in relation to her statements about “MK Ultra [a post-war CIA human experimentation programme ] and theft”.
据《每日电讯报》了解,该诉讼涉及的是关于马克龙女士性别的虚假言论。
The Telegraph understands the lawsuit is in regard to false comments about Ms Macron’s gender.
代表马克龙夫妇的律师事务所Clare Locke赞扬法院保留了对欧文斯女士公司的索赔,并表示将探索其他方式追究其个人责任。
Clare Locke, the law firm representing the Macrons, praised the court for keeping the claims against Ms Owens’s companies alive and said it would explore other ways to hold her personally accountable.
在过去七个月里,欧文斯女士因对“美国转折点”联合创始人查理·柯克被杀事件的评论而两次被控诽谤。这两起案件分别在田纳西州和犹他州提起,目前均在审理中。
Ms Owens has been sued twice for defamation in the past seven months over her commentary on the killing of Charlie Kirk the Turning Point USA co-founder. Those cases were filed in Tennessee and Utah, and are both pending.