字号·· | 护眼
纽约时报

中国对孙悟空和林黛玉的粉丝制作人工智能视频感到不满China Is Not Happy About Fan-made A.I. Videos of Sun Wukong and Lin Daiyu

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

孙悟空和林黛玉谈起了恋爱。对中国监管机构来说,这越界了。中国经典作品中深受喜爱的角色被混搭制作的视频——其中一些是用人工智能生成的——引起了当局的注意。

A Monkey King and a Maiden Fell in Love. For China’s Regulator, It Crossed a Line. Mash-up videos of beloved characters from Chinese classics — some made with A.I. — have caught the attention of the authorities.

最近几周,一些温馨的视频让中国互联网用户津津乐道:身穿黄色武打装的孙悟空和身披刺绣丝绸的林黛玉手牵手。他们在沙滩和郁郁葱葱的林间小径上嬉戏。他们在灯笼点亮的夜市里坐过山车、品尝冰淇淋。

In wholesome videos that have delighted the Chinese internet in recent weeks, the Monkey King in a yellow martial arts outfit and a maiden swathed in embroidered silks walk hand in hand. They frolic on sandy beaches and lush forest trails. They ride roller coasters and sample ice cream in a lantern-lit night market.

这对看似不可能的情侣是孙悟空和林黛玉,他们分别出自中国古典小说《西游记》和《红楼梦》,这两部小说在20世纪80年代被改编成电视剧。

The unlikely couple are Sun Wukong and Lin Daiyu, who hail from “Journey to the West” and “Dream of the Red Chamber,” classic Chinese novels that were turned into television shows in the 1980s.

在此之前,这两个角色在文学作品中——或在屏幕上——从未相遇。他们的爱情故事是粉丝们编造出来的,有些人使用了人工智能,有些人则把旧的电视片段拼接在一起。

The pair had never met in literature — or onscreen — until now. Their love story has been concocted by fans, some using artificial intelligence and some splicing old TV footage together.

虽然这些视频在中国观众中很受欢迎,但它们引起了当局的注意,当局认为这些视频把来自截然不同世界的角色凑在一起,创作自由度过大。

While they are popular with audiences in China, the videos have attracted the attention of the authorities, who believe they take too much creative license by bringing characters from disparate worlds together.

共产党的机关报《人民日报》本月发表的一篇评论文章承认,改写角色命运的创意有其吸引力,但表示这可能侵蚀原著的意义,这些原著被视为中国四大古典名著。《人民日报》的评论文章呼吁,对描绘“恶意篡改、调侃英雄”的视频划定红线。平台在10月表示,根据政府一项要求删除“严重违背”古典文学原作精神及其角色的人工智能动画的指令,它们已经下架了数千个将孙悟空和林黛玉塑造成情侣的视频,其中一个平台称两人之间存在“不当恋爱关联”。

An editorial this month in People’s Daily, a Communist Party mouthpiece, acknowledged the appeal of rewriting the destiny of the characters, but said it risked eroding the meaning of the original stories, which are considered among the four most important Chinese classical novels. The editorial called for red lines to be drawn over videos depicting “malicious alterations that ridicule heroes.”Citing a government directive to remove A.I. animations that “seriously violate” the spirit of original works of classical literature and their characters, platforms said in October that they had taken down thousands of videos featuring the Monkey King and Lin Daiyu as a couple, one citing “improper romantic associations” between them.

上世纪80年代的两部电视剧改编作品是一代中国千禧一代的童年记忆,剧中人物因不受世俗束缚的格格不入而深受喜爱。这些小说也被重新诠释为电影和歌剧。

The two 1980s televised adaptations were the childhood staples of a generation of Chinese millennials, and the characters are beloved for being misfits unbound by convention. The novels have also been reinterpreted into films and operas.

《西游记》中的孙悟空是一位天真无邪、追求涅槃的僧人不屈不挠的伙伴。他经常发现自己与神仙发生冲突。

Sun Wukong, the Monkey King from “Journey of the West,” was the irrepressible companion of a guileless monk seeking nirvana. He often found himself in trouble with the gods.

林黛玉是《红楼梦》中一个被富裕亲戚收养的孤女。她多愁善感、体弱多病,动辄赌气回嘴。最终,在爱人另娶他人后,她心碎而死。

Lin Daiyu was an orphaned girl who had been taken in by wealthy relations in “Dream of the Red Chamber.”Sentimental and sickly, she was prone to sulky ripostes. Ultimately, she died of a broken heart after her lover was married off to another woman.

英国曼彻斯特大学社会学讲师梁歌表示,中国政府要求对经典作品进行恭敬的解读,虽然这些小说一直被改写,但这些重述似乎越过了那条线。

Liang Ge, a lecturer in sociology at the University of Manchester in Britain, said that the Chinese government demanded a reverential interpretation of the classics and, while the novels had always been rewritten, these retellings seemed to have crossed that line.

这位学者补充说,视频平台快手使用“不当亲密关联”这一说法很能说明问题,当局似乎对“大规模未经授权的亲密关系创作”感到担忧。一些经典改编作品得到了共产党的鼓励。中国领导人习近平敦促复兴传统文化,称经典文学与革命英雄一样,是现代中国身份认同的基础之一。大热电子游戏《黑神话:悟空》也取材于《西游记》,以超写实手法呈现,被誉为软实力的胜利,以至于山西省旅游部门发布了一段宣传视频,展示了游戏中出现的名胜古迹。

The use of the phrase “improper romantic association” by the video platform Kuaishou was telling, the academic added, saying that the authorities seemed concerned by “unauthorized authorship of intimacy at scale.”Some adaptations of the classics have been encouraged by the Communist Party. China’s leader, Xi Jinping, has urged a revival of traditional culture, saying that classic literature is part of the foundation of modern Chinese identity, along with revolutionary heroes. The blockbuster video game, “Black Myth: Wukong,” with hyper-realistic depictions also drawn from “Journey of the West,” was hailed as such a soft power triumph that the tourism authorities in Shanxi Province released a promotional video featuring landmarks that appeared in the game.

范德堡大学亚洲研究助理教授郝宇聪在一封电子邮件中表示,重新诠释中国历史、神话和经典的自由仍然受到“意识形态正确性”的约束。她补充说:“讲好中国故事与以可能被视为颠覆性的方式讲述中国故事之间的界限往往很模糊。”

Yucong Hao, an assistant professor of Asian studies at Vanderbilt University, said in an email that the freedom to reinterpret Chinese history, mythology and classics remained bounded by “ideological correctness.”“The boundary between telling China’s stories well and telling them in ways that may be deemed subversive is often ambiguous,” she added.

今年1月,国家广播电视总局发起了一项行动,清理其所称的诋毁革命英雄、呈现反事实历史以及歪曲经典文学人物精神的AI动画。

In January, the National Radio and Television Administration launched a campaign to remove A.I. animations that it said maligned revolutionary heroes, presented counterfactual history and misrepresented the spirit of characters from classic literature.

包括微信和抖音在内的社交媒体和视频流媒体应用在10月表示,它们已删除违反规定的、涉及古典文学的AI生成视频。

Social media and video streaming apps, including WeChat and Douyin, said in October that they had deleted A.I.-generated videos referencing classical literature that violate the rules.

来自中国的科技作家和文化评论人王阿芙拉表示,林黛玉和孙悟空的配对之所以如此受欢迎,“是因为这两个角色如此不同,同时这两个角色又深深植根于这一代人的心理之中”。王女士说,观众似乎喜欢看到这两个角色一起找到幸福,看到林黛玉终于心满意足。《人民日报》那篇评论下点赞最多的评论是:“愿所有伟大的人都有伟大的人生。但现实往往如此残酷。”就连广州铁路也发布了一则广告,将其与顾客的关系比作这对组合之间的化学反应。

Afra Wang, a technology writer and cultural critic from China, said that the Lin Daiyu and Monkey King pairing was so popular “because of how different those two characters are, and at the same time, how deeply those two character are baked in the psyche of the generation.”Viewers seemed to enjoy the characters finding happiness together and seeing Lin Daiyu finally content, Ms. Wang said. The most liked comment under the People’s Daily editorial was: “May all great people have great lives. But reality is often so cruel.”Even the Guangzhou Railway posted a commercial comparing its relationship with customers to the chemistry between the pair.

网民大多对视频被下架一事加以嘲讽。有人开玩笑说,所有让女性感到幸福的关系都会被贴上“不当恋爱关系”的标签。杜克大学汉学家周成荫表示,由于毛泽东在1961年将自己比作一位搅得天翻地覆的孙悟空,重新诠释经典是一种政治行为,其历史可追溯到中华人民共和国成立初期。

Internet users have largely mocked the removal of the videos. One joked that all relationships that make women happy are labeled “inappropriate romantic associations.”Eileen Chengyin Chow, a Sinologist at Duke University, said that with Mao Zedong identifying himself as a havoc-wreaking Monkey King in 1961, reinterpreting the canon was a political exercise dating back to the early days of the People’s Republic of China.

她在电子邮件中写道:“粉丝们觉得——而且理直气壮地觉得——改编经典完全是他们应有的权利。毕竟,‘谁不希望黛玉幸福呢?’似乎是最普遍的心声!”赵思怡(音)在北京参与研究。

“Fans feel — rightly so — that it is very much in their rights to reinvent the classics,” she wrote in an email. “After all, ‘who doesn’t want Daiyu to be happy?’ seems to be the most popular sentiment!”Siyi Zhao contributed research in Beijing.

阅读媒体原文 ↗