字号·· | 护眼
经济学人

塞内加尔尝试用更多儿童的母语开展教学Senegal tries to teach more children in their first language

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

当塞内加尔政府想要弄清该用哪些语言教学时,它派官员深入学校,听孩子们玩耍时的交谈。在全国各地的校园里,调查员发现孩子们用沃洛夫语和普拉尔语交谈,用萨菲语开玩笑,偶尔夹杂几个法语单词。

When Senegal’s government wanted to find out in which languages to teach children, it sent officials into schools to listen to them playing. In school playgrounds across the country, the surveyors found children speaking in Wolof and Pulaar, joking in Safi, and throwing in the occasional French word.

这项语言摸底工作是2021年启动的一项倡议的一部分,旨在推动用塞内加尔本土语言教学。塞内加尔大多数学校用法语授课,法语是该国唯一的官方语言。但大多数儿童并不理解或不善说这种语言。塞内加尔希望,通过先用本土语言教低龄儿童,随后再过渡到其他语言,能让他们学得更好。

The mapping exercise is part of an initiative to foster teaching in Senegalese languages that began in 2021. Most schools in Senegal teach in French, the country’s only official language. But most children do not understand or speak it well. By starting to teach young children in local languages before transitioning to others, Senegal hopes that they will learn more.

目前,许多就读法语授课学校的儿童几乎听不懂课程内容。在首都达喀尔,据估计有55%的儿童不会说法语。在该国南部法蒂克等农村地区,这一比例上升至87%。这一状况反映了整个非洲大陆的现状。大多数非洲学校用国际语言授课,但据认为只有10%-15%的非洲人精通一种国际语言。

At the moment, many children who attend French-speaking schools can barely understand their lessons. In Dakar, the capital, an estimated 55% of children do not speak French. In rural areas such as Fatick, in the south of the country, that share rises to 87%. The situation mirrors the rest of the continent. Most African schools teach in international languages, but only 10-15% of Africans are thought to be fluent in one.

他们通常说几种非洲1500至3000种土著语言中的一种或几种。但由于大多数儿童没有接受过母语的正规教学,母语往往发展不足,无法成为在学校学习新语言的基础。结果,许多人在任何语言中都难以正常学习。澳大利亚圣母大学的研究人员恩兰拉·姆波富表示,她研究的一个南非班级中,约80%的9至10岁儿童能完美朗读句子,却不理解其含义。

They usually speak several of Africa’s 1,500-3,000 indigenous languages. But because most children receive no formal instruction in their first language, it often ends up insufficiently developed to form the basis for learning a new one required at school. As a result, many struggle to study properly in any language at all. Nhlanhla Mpofu, a researcher at the University of Notre Dame Australia, says that around 80% of nine- and ten-year-old children in a South African class she studied could read a sentence perfectly, but did not understand what it meant.

本地语言教学似乎有效。2024年南非的一项研究发现,专注于用母语学习阅读的儿童,在国际语言方面的表现也更好;而专注于国际语言的较弱学生,其母语阅读能力反而较差。在塞内加尔,最新的努力似乎也提高了阅读成绩。然而,世界银行和美国国际开发署(USAID)此前资助的本地语言教学项目在那里遭遇挫折,部分原因是家长不满教科书制作粗糙,不如法语授课班级使用的教科书。

Local-language instruction seems to help. One study in South Africa in 2024 found that children who focused on learning to read in their home language also did better in an international one, whereas weaker students who focused on the international language read less well in their home language. In Senegal, the latest effort also appears to have improved reading scores. Yet previous local-language teaching programmes funded by the World Bank and USAID faltered there, in part because parents were unhappy that textbooks were poorly made, compared with those for classes taught in French.

一个重要决定是用哪种本地语言授课,考虑到非洲各地使用的语言众多。例如,塞内加尔除官方语言法语外,还有六种宪法承认的语言,但实际上至少有30种语言。佛罗里达大学的Fiona McLaughlin表示,语言统计数据陈旧且不完整,偏向某一种语言可能在政治上很棘手。她估计,沃洛夫语是约40%塞内加尔人的第一语言,90%的人会说这种语言。

One important decision is which local language to teach in, given how many different ones are spoken across Africa. Senegal, for example, has six constitutionally recognised languages in addition to the official French, but there are at least 30 in total. Language statistics are old and incomplete, says Fiona McLaughlin of the University of Florida, and preferring one language to others can be politically tricky. She estimates that Wolof is the first language for around 40% of Senegalese and that 90% speak it.

但其在达喀尔的普及程度及作为通用语的地位,引发了“沃洛夫化”的担忧,尤其是在基督教徒较多的南部地区,许多人将该语言与伊斯兰教联系在一起。

But its spread and status as a lingua franca in Dakar have raised fears of “Wolofisation”, especially in the Christian south, where many associate the language with Islam.

为缓解此类担忧,塞内加尔官员按学校决定推荐使用哪种语言。负责协助实施该项目的组织“发展研究与教育合作伙伴”的负责人Mamadou Ly表示,学校具有灵活性。例如,在以普拉尔语为主的地区,以索宁克语为主的村庄里的儿童将用索宁克语学习。在一个案例中,一所学校最初用沃洛夫语教学,但两年后一些家长希望孩子学习普拉尔语。该校便将班级拆分,以便两种语言都能教授。

To assuage such concerns, officials in Senegal make decisions about which language to recommend on a school-by-school basis. Schools are flexible, says Mamadou Ly, who runs Associates in Research and Education for Development, one of the organisations helping to implement the programme. For example, children in villages that predominantly speak Soninke in a majority-Pulaar region will learn in Soninke. In one case, a school started out teaching Wolof, but after two years some parents wanted their children to speak Pulaar. The school split the class so that both could be taught.

也许最大的挑战在于让家长放心,用本地语言教学不会挤占英语、法语或葡萄牙语的教学时间。前殖民宗主国的语言在法律、政治和商业领域仍占主导地位,掌握这些语言对成功至关重要。塞内加尔采用循序渐进的过渡方式。孩子们起初用自己选择的国家语言学习的时间占80%,用法语学习的时间占20%。到12岁时,这一比例会反过来。“孩子们应当扎根于自己的文化,同时也应当面向世界,”利先生说。

Perhaps the biggest challenge is reassuring parents that local-language instruction will not crowd out teaching in English, French or Portuguese. The languages of former colonial powers still dominate law, politics and business, making them essential for success. Senegal uses a gradual transition. Children start out learning in their chosen national language 80% of the time and in French 20% of the time. By age 12, the ratio reverses. “Children should be anchored in their culture, but should also be open to the world,” says Mr Ly.

阅读媒体原文 ↗