字号·· | 护眼
亚洲新闻台

缅甸政府拒绝在CNA节目中使用“罗兴亚”一词,称罗兴亚作为一个民族身份“从未存在过”Myanmar government rejects use of term ‘Rohingya’ in CNA programme, says Rohingya ‘never existed’ as an ethnic identity

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

《亚洲新闻台》纪录片《洞察2026/2027——马来西亚的罗兴亚难题》的一张截图。A screenshot from the CNA documentary Insight 2026/2027 – Malaysia’s Rohingya Riddle.

新加坡讯:缅甸军政府对亚洲新闻台(CNA)近期的一档时事节目提出异议,该节目探讨了罗兴亚人在马来西亚的困境。缅方指称,其中一些信息“缺乏历史证据支持”,并称节目包含可能损害缅甸形象的指控。

SINGAPORE: The Myanmar military government has taken issue with a recent CNA current affairs programme which examined the plight of the Rohingya community in Malaysia - alleging that some information was “unsubstantiated by historical evidence” and allegations that could undermine Myanmar’s image.

缅甸驻新加坡大使馆在日期为10月22日、发布在缅甸外交部网站上的一份声明中表示:“缅甸断然拒绝‘罗兴亚人’这一称谓,该称谓错误地将所谓的‘罗兴亚人’称为一个从未在缅甸存在过的族群。‘孟加拉人’一词在缅甸早已存在,英国殖民统治时期的人口普查等历史官方记录均可证明。因此,使用此类术语的言论是不可接受的。”对此,CNA执行制片人丹尼尔·亨指出,使用“罗兴亚人”一词符合既定的国际惯例,也是被广泛接受的新闻实践。

In a statement dated Oct 22, which was put up on the website of Myanmar’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Myanmar embassy in Singapore said: “Myanmar categorically rejects the nomenclature that falsely claims the so-called ‘Rohingya’ as an ethnic identity which has never existed in Myanmar. The term ‘Bengali’ has existed in Myanmar as proven by historical official records, including the censuses during the British colonial administration. Therefore, the remarks using such terminology are unacceptable.”In response, CNA executive producer Daniel Heng pointed out that the use of the term “Rohingya” is consistent with established international usage and widely accepted journalistic practice.

“罗兴亚人”一词被多个主要国际组织使用,包括联合国、联合国儿童基金会、联合国难民署、国际法院、无国界医生组织和乐施会,以及英国广播公司(BBC)、美国有线电视新闻网(CNN)、美联社、路透社和法新社等国际新闻机构。

The term Rohingya is used by major international organisations, including the United Nations, the United Nations Children's Fund, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, the International Court of Justice, Doctors Without Borders and Oxfam, as well as international news organisations such as the BBC, CNN, Associated Press, Reuters and Agence France-Presse.

“鉴于这部纪录片探讨的是罗兴亚人群体在马来西亚的处境,同样值得注意的是,马来西亚政府在议会程序和公共讨论中使用了‘罗兴亚人’一词,《新海峡时报》(NST)等马来西亚媒体也使用了这一术语,”亨先生说。

“Given that the documentary examines the situation of the Rohingya community in Malaysia, it is also pertinent that the term Rohingya is used by the Malaysian government in parliamentary proceedings and public discourse and by Malaysian media such as the New Straits Times (NST),” said Mr Heng.

CNA每周时事节目《洞察:马来西亚的罗兴亚人之谜》于10月15日播出,并于次日上传至CNA Insider的YouTube页面。

The CNA weekly current affairs programme, Insight: Malaysia’s Rohingya Riddle, aired on Oct 15 and was uploaded the next day on CNA Insider's YouTube page.

《洞察》是CNA一档屡获国际奖项的一小时时事节目,旨在让观众了解当今社会所面临的政治、社会和经济现实。本期节目探讨了马来西亚在人道主义关切与国家利益之间的平衡,此前曾获庇护的罗兴亚人如今面临日益高涨的敌意和政治压力。缅甸军方发动政变夺取政权、推翻民选政府至今已五年多。

Insight is CNA’s international award-winning one-hour current affairs programme that aims to expose viewers to the political, social and economic realities facing today's societies. This episode explored Malaysia’s balance between humanitarian concerns and national interests, as Rohingya who had been offered refuge now face rising hostility and political pressure. It has been more than five years since Myanmar’s military seized power in a coup, ousting the elected government.

缅甸政府在声明中附上了缅甸1881年、1921年和1931年的人口普查报告副本。声明还称,缅甸“优先向在海外面临困难的缅甸公民提供必要援助”。

In its statement, the Myanmar government included copies of Myanmar’s census reports from 1881, 1921 and 1931. It also said that it “prioritises provision of necessary assistance to Myanmar citizens facing difficulties abroad”.

声明说:“近期,经核实程序后,每周有8041名缅甸国民乘飞机被遣返回缅甸。此外,1476名经核实、无力承担机票费用的缅甸国民由缅甸海军舰艇遣返回国。”

“Recently, following the verification process, 8,041 Myanmar nationals were repatriated to Myanmar by air on a weekly basis. Moreover, 1,476 verified Myanmar nationals who could not afford airfare were repatriated by Myanmar Navy vessels,” the statement said.

“缅甸坚决拒绝带有政治动机、意图对该国施加国际压力的广播节目。此类节目不得将缅甸国民从马来西亚被遣返一事,与非法进入马来西亚的孟加拉人这一独立问题相关联。这些言论构成捏造的宣传,旨在煽动对缅甸及其人民的仇恨。缅甸是一个多民族、多宗教的国家,不同信仰的人们一直和睦共处。”缅甸大使馆临时代办佐敏昂还向CNA总编辑发出抗议信,表示“强烈反对这部纪录片中未经核实的信息,这些信息未能准确反映当地实际情况”。

“Myanmar firmly rejects politically motivated broadcasts intended to exert international pressure on the country. Such broadcasts must not link the repatriation of Myanmar nationals from Malaysia with the separate issue of Bengalis who have illegally entered Malaysia. These statements constitute fabricated propaganda aimed at inciting hatred against Myanmar and its people. Myanmar is a multi-ethnic and multi-religious country where people of different faiths have lived side by side in harmony.”The embassy’s Chargé d'Affaires Zaw Minn Aung also sent a letter of protest addressed to CNA’s editor-in-chief to express its “strong objection to the unverified information contained in the documentary that fails to accurately reflect the situation on the ground”.

黄先生指出,CNA的节目并未忽视或歪曲缅甸政府的立场。节目明确提到了这一立场,称“缅甸当局和民族主义团体经常拒绝使用‘罗兴亚’一词,而是将该群体称为‘孟加拉人’,暗示他们主要是来自孟加拉国的较近期移民”。关于据报道缅甸同意接收来自马来西亚的5000名罗兴亚难民一事,该纪录片引用了马来西亚总理安瓦尔·易卜拉欣在一次演讲中的言论,这些言论由《新海峡时报》于2026年7月报道。

Mr Heng noted that the CNA programme did not overlook or misrepresent the Myanmar government’s position. It explicitly acknowledged this position, stating that “Myanmar authorities and nationalist groups have frequently rejected the term ‘Rohingya’ and instead described the community as ‘Bengali’, implying that they consist of relatively recent migrants from Bangladesh.”Regarding the reported agreement for Myanmar to accept 5,000 Rohingya refugees from Malaysia, the documentary drew on remarks made by Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim during a speech, as reported by the NST in July 2026.

《新海峡时报》援引安瓦尔的话说:“现在,由于我们与缅甸的良好关系,他们已同意从马来西亚接收5000人。”

"Now, because of our good relations with Myanmar, they have agreed to take back 5,000 from Malaysia," Mr Anwar was quoted by NST saying.

《新海峡时报》还报道称,安瓦尔表示他的政府将继续坚决打击扰乱公共空间和交通的罗兴亚难民,并且他已“指示警方和边境当局,我不希望罗兴亚人扰乱道路或公共场所”。

NST also reported Mr Anwar saying his government would continue to act firmly against Rohingya refugees who disrupted public spaces and traffic, and that he has “instructed the police and border authorities that I do not want Rohingya disrupting roads or public places”.

CNA的节目还明确澄清,最近从马来西亚遣返的约1500名缅甸国民中不包括罗兴亚人。

The CNA programme also expressly clarified that the approximately 1,500 Myanmar nationals recently repatriated from Malaysia did not include Rohingya.

黄先生说:“CNA坚持其报道,该报道基于可追溯来源,并在适当背景下呈现,包括缅甸政府的立场。我们仍然致力于准确、平衡和具有背景的新闻报道。”

“CNA stands by its reporting, which was based on attributable sources and presented with appropriate context, including the Myanmar government’s position. We remain committed to accurate, balanced, and contextual journalism,” said Mr Heng.

阅读媒体原文 ↗