
Meta 表示,它会删除可能导致迫在眉睫的身体伤害的内容——但近 50 万成员加入了一个经常宣扬错误信息的群组。随着麻疹疫情在 8 月蔓延至宾夕法尼亚州兰开斯特县,一位家长向一个名为“Crunchy Moms”(直译为“自然派妈妈”,下同)的大型公开群组寻求建议。他们正考虑给三岁的孩子接种疫苗,部分原因是为了保护他们六个月大的婴儿。“我为我的宝宝感到紧张,”这位家长写道。
Meta says it removes content that could cause imminent physical harm – but nearly half a million members have joined a group that regularly promotes misinformation s a measles outbreak spread through Lancaster county, Pennsylvania, in August, a parent turned to a massive public group, Crunchy Moms, for advice. They were considering getting their three-year-old vaccinated, in part to protect their six-month-old. “I’m nervous for my baby,” the parent wrote.
“首先,你的孩子不会死于麻疹。这简直是不可能的,”一名成员回复道。“别打,”另一位建议道。其他人则说疫苗会传播麻疹,或者打疫苗就像“注射毒药”。
“First of all your children cannot die of measles. It is literally impossible,” one member responded. “Do not do it,” advised another. Others said the vaccine would spread measles or that it would be like “injecting poison”.
在该帖子末尾,Facebook 的 AI 系统——由其母公司 Meta 运营——总结了 589 条回复,其中部分写道,评论者“声称疫苗没有必要,甚至有害”。
At the end of the post, Facebook’s AI system – run by its parent company Meta– summarized the 589 responses, writing in part that commenters “claim the vaccine is unnecessary or even harmful”.
这些说法没有一条是真的。宾夕法尼亚州今年已报告 6 例麻疹相关死亡病例,其中包括兰开斯特县的两名婴儿。麻疹、腮腺炎和风疹(MMR)疫苗安全有效。卫生官员表示,这是防止麻疹传播、伤害或致死的最佳手段。
None of those claims are true. Pennsylvania has reported six measles-associated deaths this year, including two babies in Lancaster county. The measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine is safe and effective. Health officials say it is the best defense against measles spreading and injuring or killing people.
科学家、医生以及健康和儿童安全倡导者告诉《卫报》,他们在“Crunchy Moms”和类似群组中看到的情况令人担忧。他们担心孩子可能正在受到伤害,母亲们正被卷入一个拒斥科学和循证医学的在线社区。一位利用业余时间监控该平台以揭露有害健康错误信息的科学家称“Crunchy Moms”为“Facebook 上最危险的群组”。Meta 未对该表述发表评论。
Scientists, doctors and advocates for health and children’s safety told the Guardian that what they see in Crunchy Moms and similar groups is alarming. They worry children could be getting hurt and that mothers are getting pulled into an online community that rejects science and fact-based medicine. One scientist who spends her free time monitoring the platform to highlight harmful health misinformation calls Crunchy Moms “the most dangerous group on Facebook”. Meta did not comment on that characterization.
Facebook 上虚假信息的传播已是多年顽疾,但过去该公司曾采取措施加以遏制。例如在新冠疫情期间,Facebook 承认自身存在问题,并调整政策,以“优先将人们与准确的健康信息联系起来”。但去年,在唐纳德·特朗普就职典礼前不久,Facebook 亿万富翁创始人马克·扎克伯格表示,Meta 平台上存在“过度审查”。
The spread of misinformation on Facebook has been a problem for years, but in the past, the company took steps to curb it. During the Covid-19 pandemic, for example, Facebook recognized it had a problem and changed its policies to “prioritize connecting people with accurate health information But last year, shortly before the inauguration of Donald Trump, Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook’s billionaire founder, said there was “too much censorship” on Meta’s platforms.
Meta 随后改变方针;它在美国取消了事实核查员,并降低了除最严重或违法内容以外的主动审核力度。公司仍保留一项禁止有害健康虚假信息的政策,但不清楚 Meta 如何执行该政策,也不清楚其新的宽容做法在麻疹等传染病卷土重来之际如何影响用户。
Meta changed course; it eliminated factcheckers in the US and dialed down active moderation of anything but the most severe or illegal content. The company still maintains a policy that prohibits harmful health misinformation, but it is not known how Meta enforces it, and how its new permissive approach affects users at a time when measles and other infectious diseases are making a comeback.
针对《卫报》的提问,Meta 声称自 2023 年以来,政策及其执行方式均未发生变化。
In response to questions from the Guardian, Meta claimed nothing has changed in the policy or how it is enforced since 2023.
《卫报》调查发现,危险的医疗虚假信息在 Facebook 群组中自由流淌,例如“Crunchy Moms”(天然育儿妈妈)群组,成员现已超过 49 万。更有甚者,公司似乎还通过将“Crunchy Moms”推送进用户的动态消息中,帮助传播此类观点,即使用户并未主动搜寻。
Guardian investigation has found that dangerous medical misinformation is flowing freely on Facebook in groups like Crunchy Moms – now more than 490,000 members strong. What’s more, the company appears to have helped spread such ideas by promoting Crunchy Moms into users’ feeds, even when they do not seek it out.
扎克伯格此前曾建议,等待用户举报“坏东西”——而非依靠自动化系统捕捉——能在其所谓的“审查”与言论自由之间取得更好的平衡。但《卫报》发现,遵循扎克伯格建议的做法,似乎对“Crunchy Moms”群组中流传的虚假信息几乎没有任何可辨别的抑制作用。
Zuckerberg previously suggested that waiting for users to report “bad stuff” – rather than having automated systems catch them – would strike a better balance between what he termed censorship and free expression But the Guardian found that following Zuckerberg’s suggested approach appears to have little to no discernible effect on false information that circulates on Crunchy Moms.
一名《卫报》记者从自己的 Facebook 账号向平台举报了 50 多条帖子和评论,Facebook 未对任何一条采取行动。
Facebook took no action on more than 50 posts and comments a Guardian journalist reported to the platform from her own Facebook account.
这些帖子似乎违反了 Meta 自身的标准,包括宣称疫苗导致自闭症、麻疹并非致命,或者“神奇疗法”如腐蚀性药物黑药膏(会破坏皮肤组织)能治疗癌症。对于《卫报》在 5 月、7 月和 9 月提出的报告,Facebook 未对任何一份予以确认或回应。
The posts appeared to violate Meta’s own standards including that vaccines caused autism, that measles is not deadly, or that “miracle cures” like the caustic agent black salve that destroys skin tissue can treat cancer. Facebook did not acknowledge or respond to a single one of the Guardian’s reports, made in May, July and September.
2026 年 9 月 29 日,马克·扎克伯格出席了唐纳德·特朗普在白宫外举行的、与 AI 高管们举行的新闻发布会。
Mark Zuckerberg attends a press briefing held by Donald Trump with AI executives, outside the White House, on 29 September 2026.

在一份回复中,Meta 表示,其错误信息政策允许人们讨论个人经历和科学研究。该公司称,只有当错误信息有可能直接导致迫在眉睫的身体伤害风险时,才会将其移除。但 Meta 未就“Crunchy Moms”群组或专家关于此类错误信息在该群组普遍存在的评估,回答详细问题。Meta 去年的收入超过 2000 亿美元。
In a response, Meta said its misinformation policies allow people to discuss personal experiences and scientific research. It said it removes misinformation when it is likely to directly contribute to the risk of imminent physical harm. But Meta did not respond to detailed questions about Crunchy Moms or experts’ assessment that such misinformation is commonplace in the group. Meta’s revenue last year exceeded $200bn.
医生、研究人员、前员工和公共卫生倡导者表示,《卫报》的调查结果表明,Meta 的态度已摆回到对虚假健康信息极少进行内容审核的时期。
Doctors, researchers, former employees and public health advocates said the Guardian’s findings show that the pendulum at Meta has swung back to a time when there was little moderation of false health information.
“近十年前我们就在记录 Facebook 向家长推荐反疫苗群组的情况,”研究在线操纵的乔治城大学教授蕾妮·迪雷斯塔说。
“We were documenting Facebook recommending anti-vaccine groups to parents almost a decade ago,” said Renée DiResta a professor at Georgetown University who studies online manipulation.
她和其他人已证实,这种做法危害了儿童。当时,有孩子因父母求助 Facebook 群组获取健康建议而受伤甚至死亡的报道。
She and others have shown how that approach harmed children. Back then, there were stories of children being hurt dying after their parents turned to Facebook groups for health advice.
“我担心我们将再次看到同样的动态。” Facebook 推荐引发《卫报》调查 一名《卫报》记者 3 月时正在手机上浏览,某条推荐引起了她的注意。她的 Facebook 信息流推荐她加入一个名为“Crunchy Moms: Natural Living & Clean Products”(酷妈们:自然生活与纯净产品)的群组。
“I’m afraid that we’re going to see that same kind of dynamic all over again.”A Facebook recommendation sparks a Guardian investigation A Guardian journalist was scrolling on her phone in March when something caught her eye. Her Facebook feed recommended she join a group called Crunchy Moms: Natural Living & Clean Products.
该群组创建于 2025 年 3 月,比扎克伯格宣布 Meta 新的“不干预”方针晚不到三个月。
The group was created in March 2025, less than three months after Zuckerberg announced Meta’s new hands-off approach.
“Crunchy Moms”的管理员将其描述为“一个支持性的空间,供想要使用无毒产品、低毒替代品和纯净成分解决方案来抚养家庭的妈妈们使用。”但快速浏览该群组即可发现,专家也证实,这里是可能伤害人们——尤其是儿童及其母亲——的虚假医疗信息的温床,而这些母亲正是为了寻求社群、建议和认同而加入该群组。
Crunchy Moms’ administrators describe it as “a supportive space for moms who want to raise their families using toxin-free products, low-tox alternatives, and clean ingredient solutions.”But a quick check of the group revealed, and experts confirmed, it was a hotbed of false medical information that could hurt people – especially children and their mothers, who turn to the group for community, advice and affirmation.
该群组主要关注健康话题,尽管一些发帖者也会来寻求育儿建议、产品推荐和其他非医疗问题。许多发帖者似乎默认群成员反对——或应该反对——给孩子接种疫苗。他们经常将疫苗及其成分描述为致命、有毒或有毒害。截图已模糊处理以隐藏评论者身份。照片:“我们这个群不打疫苗。这是成为‘Crunchy Mom’的基础,”一位匿名成员上个月在回复一条关于呼吸道合胞病毒(RSV)疫苗的提问时解释道。
The group focuses largely on health, though some posters also come to seek parenting tips, product recommendations and other non-medical questions. Many posters appear to take it as a given that group members are – or should be – against vaccinating their children. They frequently describe vaccines and their ingredients as deadly, toxic or poisonous. Screenshot has been blurred to obscure identity of commenter. Photograph: “We don’t vaccinate in this group. It’s the foundation of becoming a crunchy mom,” one anonymous member explained last month, in response to a question about the vaccine for RSV, a respiratory virus.

一位群管理员在回复另一条帖子时表示:“作为一个‘Crunchy’社群,我们通常反对v@cs”——这是“疫苗”的隐语。
A group administrator responded to a different post that “As a crunchy community we are generally against v@cs” – a code for vaccines.
自1月以来,“Crunchy Moms”的规模已翻倍多,每天收到数百条帖子,以及数千条评论和回复。
Crunchy Moms has more than doubled in size since January, and receives hundreds of posts a day, and thousands of comments and replies.
Sara Rupe于2025年3月创建了该群组。这距离扎克伯格宣布Meta采取新的放手政策不足三个月。这位康涅狄格州的妈妈在接受采访时表示,她创建该群组的初衷是分享个人护理产品、化妆品等方面的产品推荐,但它后来发展成了更大的东西。
Sara Rupe launched the group in March 2025. It was less than three months after Zuckerberg announced Meta’s new hands-off approach. The Connecticut mom said in an interview that her intention in creating the group was to share product recommendations for things like personal care products and makeup, but it turned into something bigger.
她说,“Crunchy Moms”至少部分成功的原因在于它不屏蔽“言论自由”。
At least part of Crunchy Moms’ success, she said, was because it does not block “free speech”.
“每个人都有权说他们想说的话,只要符合Facebook的社区准则,”Rupe说。“我不审查内容。
“Everybody has a right to say what they want to say as long as it’s within community standards of Facebook,” Rupe said. “I don’t censor things.
鲁普补充道:“如果有人想说什么,我通常会让他们说。但我的意思是,在合理范围内,如果我真的认为那会伤害到某人,我就不会让。但我也认为让一些信息传播出去可能是好事。”Crunchy Moms是一个群组网络中最大的群组,这些群组合计有超过100万名成员。鲁普在几位管理员和版主的帮助下运营这些群组,其中包括她的丈夫——他是注册护士,还有纽约州北部的一对牧师夫妇,以及一位女性,她的Meta认证账号将她描述为整体健康博士。
Rupe added: “If somebody wants to say something, then I usually let them. But I mean, within reason, if I really think it’s going to hurt somebody, I don’t. But I also think letting some information get out there could be good.”Crunchy Moms is the largest group in a network of groups that collectively has over 1 million members. Rupe runs them with the help of several administrators and moderators, including her husband, who is a registered nurse, a pastor and wife couple in upstate New York, and a woman whose Meta-verified account describes her as a doctor of holistic health.
他们经常发帖,附上亚马逊商店出售的补充剂和其他产品的链接,附上另一位管理员的护肤系列链接,或者附上联盟营销链接,为分享者提供销售分成。
They post often with links to supplements and other products for sale on an Amazon store, with links to another administrator’s skincare line, or with affiliate links to products that provide a cut of sales to the person sharing it.
鲁普说,她和另一位管理员使用多个账号来运营该群组,这样如果Facebook限制她的账号,他们仍能保持对该群组的访问权。去年,她的女儿读七年级时,鲁普用女儿的账号发布了一份包含三十多种产品的清单,其中包括售价超过100美元的草药疗法套装、无氟牙膏、25美元的牛脂膏,以及售价200美元或以上的红光治疗仪。
Rupe said she and another administrator use multiple accounts to run the group, which lets them maintain access to it if Facebook restricts her account. Her daughter was in seventh grade last year when Rupe used her account to post a listing of over three dozen products, including herbal remedy bundles that run over $100, non-fluoride toothpaste, $25 tallow balm and red light therapy panels that cost $200 or more.
第二位管理员道恩·曼尼恩表示,她没有从这个群组中赚钱,不过其他人能获得少量佣金,“甚至不到最低工资”。她说,她经常建议成员向整体健康或其他合格医疗专业人员寻求医疗帮助。她还说:“我们不阻止人们寻求医疗护理。我们鼓励这样做。”《卫报》联系的其他管理员和版主没有回复寻求置评的Facebook消息和短信。
A second administrator, Dawn Mannion, said she doesn’t make any money from the group, though others make a small commission that’s “not even minimum wage”. She said she frequently recommends that members seek medical attention from holistic or other qualified healthcare professionals. She added: “We do not discourage people from seeking medical care. We encourage it.”Other administrators and moderators contacted by the Guardian did not respond to Facebook messages and texts seeking comment.
鲁普说,许多Crunchy Moms成员在加入该群组时就已经热衷于“自然生活”并对疫苗持怀疑态度,群组领导者并不试图改变任何人的想法。
Many Crunchy Moms members were already into “natural living” and questioning vaccines when they come to the group, and group leaders don’t try to sway anyone’s mind, Rupe said.
鲁佩有一个患有自闭症的孩子,她现在认为这与疫苗接种有关,并表示该团体中的许多人认为他们的孩子因疫苗而受伤。
Rupe has a child with autism that she now believes is connected to vaccination, and said many others in the group believe their children were injured by vaccines.
“我们根本不希望任何人受到伤害,”她说。“我们希望每个人都尽可能快乐健康。”虽然“Crunchy Mom”的帖子经常强烈反对疫苗和现代医学,但鲁佩表示,她认为该团体并没有伤害任何人。相反,她说它正在帮助人们做出自己的决定。
“We don’t want anybody to be hurt at all,” she said. “We want everybody to be as happy and healthy as possible.”While Crunchy Mom posters often vehemently counsel against vaccines and modern medicine, Rupe said she does not think the group is harming anyone. Instead, she said it is helping people make their own decisions.

2026年10月28日,美国卫生与公众服务部部长小罗伯特·F·肯尼迪在爱荷华州克莱夫举行的一场“让爱荷华州再次健康”集会上。
Robert F Kennedy Jr, the US Health and Human Services secretary, at a make Iowa healthy again rally, in Clive, Iowa, on 28 October 2026.
一些成员表示,疫苗非常危险,以至于感染一种致命的或改变人生的疫苗可预防疾病比接种疫苗更安全。他们告诉其他成员,像麻疹或水痘这样的疾病“自然”感染可能比接种疫苗更健康。另一些人则重复美国卫生与公众服务部部长小罗伯特·F·肯尼迪未经证实的说法,即泰诺与自闭症有关。最近的一条评论称,感染麻疹可以使身体更强壮,锻炼免疫系统,并降低患心血管疾病和癌症的风险。
Some members say vaccines are so dangerous that it is safer to get a deadly or life-altering vaccine-preventable disease than it is to get immunized. They tell other members that catching a disease like measles or chicken pox “naturally” can be more healthy than getting vaccinated. Others repeat US Health and Human Services secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr’s unproven claims that Tylenol is linked to autism. One recent comment said that catching measles makes your body stronger, trains your immune system and results in a lower risk of cardiovascular disease and cancer.
许多帖子传播了疫苗会导致自闭症和婴儿猝死综合征(Sids)的虚假说法——尽管Meta在其自身政策中明确规定,发表此类言论的帖子违反了其条款。
Many posts spread the false assertion that vaccines cause autism and sudden infant death syndrome (Sids) – even though Meta specifies in its own policies that posts saying so violate its terms.
寻求帮助和建议的新妈妈或准妈妈是常驻发帖者,也是大量评论的攻击目标,这些评论告诉她们不要遵循有科学依据的儿童健康建议,例如给新生儿注射维生素K以预防脑出血。一名女子询问疫苗接种与婴儿猝死综合征(SIDS)之间的联系,暗示她担心如果遵循建议的疫苗接种时间表,就会让宝宝面临死亡风险。她说她正考虑推迟婴儿的疫苗接种以降低风险。她在帖子结尾写道:“我吓坏了。”
New or soon-to-be mothers looking for help and advice are frequent posters, and targets for swarms of comments telling them not to follow science-backed health recommendations for their children, like giving their newborns a Vitamin K shot that can prevent brain bleeds One woman asked about a link between vaccination and Sids, suggesting she feared she was putting her baby at risk of death if she followed the recommended vaccine schedule. She said she was considering spacing out her infant’s vaccines to lessen the risk. She ended her post: “I’m terrified.”
“推迟注射毒药不会有任何好处。注射毒药只会增加婴儿猝死综合征的可能性,”一名女子回复道。另一名被Facebook标记为“全明星贡献者”的用户插话道:“婴儿猝死综合征就是疫苗致死。发明婴儿猝死综合征是为了掩盖疫苗杀死婴儿的事实。”
“Delaying poison won’t do anything beneficial. Injecting poison WILL increase the likelihood of SIDS,” one woman replied. Another, labeled an “All-Star contributor” by Facebook, weighed in: “SIDS is vaccine death. SIDS was invented to cover up the fact that vaccines kill infants.”
浏览一篇询问疫苗是否导致自闭症的帖子,读者会发现评论接连不断地声称疫苗会导致自闭症。在一条帖子中,一名常驻评论者提供了一个虚假统计数据,称79%的自闭症是由疫苗引起的。她回复一位自称神经多样性人士的人:“是你父母的疫苗导致了这点。我很抱歉。”
Scroll through a post asking whether vaccines cause autism, readers will find comment after comment saying that they do. In one post, a frequent commenter offered a false statistic that 79% of autism is caused by vaccines. She replied to a person who said they were neurodiverse: “Your parents caused this with their vaccines. I am sorry.”
同一名评论者后来劝告一位担心社区麻疹疫情的兰开斯特县家长:“为了一种充其量只能无效预防麻疹的疫苗,去冒死亡或致残性终身神经退行性疾病(如自闭症)的风险,不值得。”该群组包含各种观点。一些评论者会鼓励寻求医疗护理并给孩子接种疫苗。《卫报》采访了成为“Crunchy Moms”成员、试图为那里分享的虚假信息提供制衡力量的人们。曼尼恩表示,他们不认可个别成员发表的每一条言论。
The same commenter later counseled the Lancaster county parent who was worried about their community’s measles outbreak that “It is not worth risking death or a disabling lifelong neurodegenerative condition, such as autism, for a vaccine that is ineffective, at best, at preventing measles.”The group includes a mix of views. Some commenters will offer encouragement to seek medical care and to vaccinate their children. The Guardian spoke to people who became members of Crunchy Moms to try to provide a counterweight to the false information shared there. Mannion said they do not endorse every statement made by individual members.
“Crunchy Mom”群组的规则之一规定,群内分享的信息不构成医疗建议,成员在做出任何健康或医疗决定前应咨询医疗服务提供者。但在许多家长寻求建议或分享医生意见的帖子下,评论者常劝说他们不要遵循医生的建议,甚至称根本无需咨询医生。
One of the Crunchy Mom rules that is supposed to govern the group is that the information shared is not medical advice, and that members should consult a healthcare provider before making any health or medical decisions. But in the many posts from parents asking for advice or sharing what their doctors told them, commenters often urge them not to follow what the doctor suggests, or say there is no need to speak to a doctor at all.
Rupe表示,她认为许多此类评论来自意在“捣乱”让群组陷入麻烦的“网络喷子”,大家只是在发表个人观点。
Rupe said she believes many of the comments are from “trolls” trying to get the group in trouble, and that people are simply posting their opinions.
应《卫报》要求审查该群组的儿科医生Alok Patel指出,这类评论尤为令人担忧。母亲们向同为母亲的人寻求建议是由来已久的传统,Patel认为人们利用社交媒体寻找连接很重要。
Dr Alok Patel, a pediatrician who reviewed the group at the Guardian’s request, pointed to those kinds of comments as particularly concerning. It is a time-honored tradition for mothers to turn to fellow mothers for advice, and Patel believes it is important for people to use social media to find connection.
“但当人们彻底摒弃现代医学、态度强硬地说‘别打疫苗、别打维生素K针、别看医生’,转而推销某种产品时,这就是彻头彻尾的错误信息,且潜在危害巨大,”他说。
“But when people are outright dismissing modern medicine and putting their foot down and saying don’t get vaccines, don’t get the vitamin K shot, don’t see a doctor, and instead promoting a product, that is outright misinformation and potentially dangerous,” he said.
Patel在Meta旗下的Instagram平台上积累了自己的粉丝群体,致力于向大众传递基于科学的医疗信息。他表示,社交媒体公司应当证明,提供高质量信息比让用户留在自家应用上更重要。
Patel has built up his own following on Meta’s Instagram platform to deliver science-based medical information to people. Social media companies, he said, should show it is more important to provide quality information than it is to keep people on their apps.
“向我们证明,你们重视公共健康,正如你们重视投资者的利润一样,”Patel说。
“Prove to us that you are prioritizing public health as much as you prioritize profits for your investors,” Patel said.
2026年4月25日,Alok Patel医生在华盛顿特区的华盛顿希尔顿酒店出席2026年白宫记者协会晚宴。
Dr Alok Patel attends the 2026 White House Correspondents’ Dinner at Washington Hilton on 25 April 2026 in Washington DC.

现实决策产生实际影响。
Photograph: Taylor Hill/WireImage Research has shown that health misinformation shared on Facebook can have a real-world impact on people’s decisions. Jennifer Allen, a professor at NYU Stern who worked at Facebook from 2016 to 2018, has researched the effect of misinformation and vaccine-skeptical content on Facebook.
詹妮弗·艾伦是纽约大学斯特恩商学院的教授,2016年至2018年曾在Facebook工作,她研究了虚假信息以及质疑疫苗的内容在Facebook上造成的影响。她和同事估算,新冠疫情期间,人们在平台上接触到质疑疫苗的内容,降低了他们接种疫苗的意愿。他们估计,如果没有这类接触,将多出500万美国人接种疫苗,大约可挽救2.1万人的生命。
She and her colleagues have estimated that exposure to vaccine skeptical content on the platform during the Covid-19 pandemic reduced people’s intention to get vaccinated Without that exposure, they estimated 5 million more Americans would have been vaccinated, saving approximately 21,000 lives.
艾伦说,虽然人们应当能够表达自己的观点,但有证据表明,她在“Crunchy Moms”中看到的那类表达可能具有危险性。
While people should be able to express themselves, Allen said, there is evidence that the kinds of expression she saw in Crunchy Moms can be dangerous.
艾伦说:“这个群组似乎确实存在,还被推荐给人们,而且里面有这么多明显的虚假信息,在我看来,这说明Facebook在某个环节上出现了失职。”
“The fact that this group seems to exist and is being recommended to people, and there is so much clear misinformation in it, it seems to me that that means that there’s a failure along the way of Facebook,” Allen said.
她说,疫情期间,Facebook在识别和删除极其错误的信息、以及不向人们推荐这类信息方面做得相当不错。她说,如今看到如此露骨的虚假信息在一个公开群组中传播,而且Facebook还把它推荐给用户,她感到惊讶。
During the pandemic, she said Facebook got pretty good at identifying and taking down egregiously false information and also not recommending it to people. She said she was surprised to now see such explicit misinformation being shared in a public group, and Facebook recommending it to users.
一位科学家利用业余时间在Facebook上搜寻,以曝光她在那里看到的有害信息。她因遭到骚扰和威胁,要求匿名接受《卫报》采访。她说,“Crunchy Moms”属于最糟糕的一类,但绝非唯一存在这些问题的群组。
One scientist who spends her free time trawling Facebook to highlight the harmful information she sees there spoke to the Guardian on condition of anonymity because she has received harassment and threats. She said Crunchy Moms stands out among the worst, but is far from the only group where these problems are happening.
她说:“Meta,尤其是Facebook,在纵容这些事情继续下去。”她举例说,她看到有帖子劝母亲不要给新生儿接种维生素K针,还有帖子在销售不受监管的补充剂。她说,她认为这个群组比她监测的任何其他群组都更危险。
“Meta, and specifically Facebook, is allowing for these things to continue,” she said. She cited posts she has seen that counsel mothers not to get the Vitamin K shot for their newborns and others that sell unregulated supplements. She said she believes it is more dangerous than any other groups she monitors.
在被给予机会回应这一批评时,鲁普说:“每个人都应当有自由谈论自己想谈的话题。”
“Everybody should have the freedom to talk about what they want to talk about,” Rupe said when given the opportunity to respond to that criticism.
鉴于帖子的数量庞大,鲁佩表示她和其他管理员无法审查每一条帖子。
Given the volume of the posts, Rupe said she and other administrators can’t vet every single post.
“我假设如果Meta认为(帖子)不符合规定,它就会将其删除。所以我不怎么担心那部分,”她说。
“I’m assuming that if Meta sees that it doesn’t agree that it will just take it down. So I don’t really worry about that part,” she said.
Meta的规则及其执行方式 2019年,Facebook宣布将停止推荐传播疫苗接种错误信息的群组,并表示“完全致力于我们社区的安全”。迪雷斯塔说,随着反疫苗活动人士利用Facebook破坏公共健康(例如2019年萨摩亚爆发麻疹疫情,导致83人死亡,其中大部分是五岁以下的儿童)的情况变得清晰,该公司对公众压力做出了回应。当时Facebook的区域政策主管表示,其团队“正在主动扫描任何与健康相关的错误信息,并采取行动防止其在我们的平台上蔓延”。
Meta’s rules and how they are enforced In 2019, Facebook announced it would stop recommending groups that spread misinformation about vaccinations, saying it was “fully committed to the safety of our community”. DiResta said the company responded to public pressure as it became clear anti-vaccine activists were using Facebook to undermine public health places like Samoa where a 2019 measles outbreak killed 83 people, mostly children under age five. Facebook’s regional policy director said at the time that its teams were “proactively scanning for any health-related misinformation and are taking action to prevent its spread on our platforms”.
同年晚些时候,一位共和党国会议员就此事向扎克伯格施压,抱怨Facebook审查用户关于疫苗风险和伤害的言论。扎克伯格,他的妻子普莉希拉·陈是一名儿科医生,并且他向旧金山一家主要医院捐赠了7500万美元,该医院现以他们的名字命名,他承认了这一担忧。但他表示,“我们也持续听到社区的声音,人们希望我们阻止错误信息的传播”,并且他理解“科学共识是,人们接种疫苗很重要”。
Later that year, Zuckerberg was pressed on the issue by a Republican congressman who complained Facebook was censoring users’ speech about vaccine risks and injuries. Zuckerberg, whose wife Priscilla Chan is a pediatrician and who donated $75m to a major San Francisco hospital which now bears their name, acknowledged the concern. But he said “we also hear consistently from our community that people want us to stop the spread of misinformation” and that he understood “scientific consensus is that it is important that people get their vaccines”.
扎克伯格说,虽然用户可以发布反疫苗内容或加入此类群组,但Facebook不会“推荐或主动向人们展示鼓励人们加入这些群组的内容”。
While users would be allowed to post anti-vaccine content or join such groups, Zuckerberg said Facebook would not “recommend or go out of our way to show people content that would encourage people to join those groups”.

2019年12月6日,政府雇员和志愿者被分派到小组,在萨摩亚阿皮亚,在麻疹疫情期间提供援助。
Government employees and volunteers are assigned into teams on 6 December 2019 to provide assistance in Apia, Samoa, during a measles outbreak.
2020年新冠疫情暴发后,(脸书)完全停止推荐健康类群组,并解释称“人们必须从权威渠道获取健康信息,这一点至关重要”。反疫苗活动人士抱怨遭到审查,并与共和党政客以及其他对脸书处理选举等公共事务虚假信息方式持异议的人士联手。随后,特朗普当选,赢得第二个任期。他选定领导国家卫生部门的人选是肯尼迪——反疫苗运动的长期领袖,他曾指责脸书审查他本人和他曾经领导的团体,并为此提起诉讼,但案件被驳回。
After Covid hit in 2020, stopped recommending health groups altogether explaining that “it’s crucial that people get their health information from authoritative sources.”Anti-vaccine activists complained of censorship and joined with Republican politicians and others who took issue with Facebook’s response to false information about elections and other civic matters. Then Trump was elected to a second term. His pick to lead the nation’s health department was Kennedy, a longtime leader in the anti-vaccine movement who has accused Facebook of censoring him and the group he used to run, and sued over it The case was dismissed.
在特朗普宣誓就职前不久,扎克伯格和Meta宣布在美国终止第三方事实核查,并回退内容审核措施。几周后,扎克伯格与多位科技公司CEO出席了特朗普的就职典礼。
Shortly before Trump was sworn into office, Zuckerberg and Meta announced the end to third-party factchecking in the US as well as rollbacks to moderation. A few weeks later, Zuckerberg and tech CEOs attended Trump’s inauguration.
尽管如此,Meta仍保留了错误信息政策。现行政策称,它会删除其所谓的有害健康错误信息,即“可能直接导致对公共卫生和安全迫在眉睫的伤害”的内容。政策列举了若干不被允许的具体例子——其中大部分与疫苗有关。其中包括:声称疫苗导致自闭症或婴儿猝死综合征;声称疫苗成分致命、有毒、有毒性、有害或危险;声称疫苗无效;以及声称麻疹不致命。
Still, Meta retained a misinformation policy The current policy says it removes what it calls harmful health misinformation that is “likely to directly contribute to imminent harm to public health and safety”. It lists several specific examples of what it does not allow – much of it about vaccines. Among those are claims that vaccines cause autism or Sids; that vaccine ingredients are deadly, toxic, poisonous, harmful or dangerous; that vaccines are not effective; and that measles is not deadly.
Meta的政策还表示,禁止宣传或鼓吹有害的“灵丹妙药”,包括在网上被兜售为皮肤癌疗法的黑药膏——没有证据表明它有效,且已导致一些人毁容,或任由其癌症发展。尽管该公司今年发布了一份关于其如何执行社区标准的报告,但并未讨论它如何或是否执行了规范健康错误信息的相关标准。
Meta’s policy also says it bars promoting or advocating for harmful miracle cures, including black salve which is peddled online as a skin cancer treatment without evidence that it works, and it has disfigured people or left their cancer to grow Though issued a report on how it has enforced its community standards this year, it did not discuss how or whether it has enforced its standards that govern misinformation on health.
《卫报》采访了多名曾向 Facebook 举报 Crunchy Moms(脆脆妈妈)群组帖子、或试图举报群外类似含有危险健康错误信息帖子的人。他们表示收效甚微。
The Guardian spoke to several people who had reported Crunchy Moms posts to Facebook or who had tried to report posts outside the group that similarly contained dangerous health misinformation. They said they had little success.
“我个人的帖子举报普遍被 Facebook 忽视,”康涅狄格州儿科心脏病专家 Frank Han 博士说。
“My own personal post reports have universally been ignored by Facebook,” said Dr Frank Han, a pediatric cardiologist in Connecticut.
Han 说:“尽管 Facebook 声称会进行内容审核,但实际效果是医疗错误信息的传播速度远快于医学正确信息。”
“While Facebook claims that they moderate, the practical effect is that medical misinformation propagates much faster than medically correct information,” Han said.
另一位 Crunchy Moms 成员 Emily Loving-Rodriguez 表示,自今年早些时候加入以来,她已向 Facebook 提交了几十次、甚至可能上百次举报。这位爱达荷州居民出于对儿童福利和错误信息的个人关注,提到最近在 Crunchy Moms 看到一条帖子,称疱疹可以用膳食补充剂沸石治愈。她说她的举报很少产生效果。
Another Crunchy Moms member, Emily Loving-Rodriguez, said she had made dozens of reports to Facebook, and possibly hundreds, since she joined earlier this year. The Idaho resident has a personal interest in child welfare and misinformation, and noted a post she had seen recently in Crunchy Moms where someone said herpes could be cured with the dietary supplement zeolite She said her reports rarely had any effect.
另一位成员 Kasey Kramps 称,她过去曾因医疗错误信息向 Facebook 举报,但表示现在已找不到举报渠道。
Kasey Kramps, another member, said she had made reports to Facebook in the past for medical misinformation but said she could no longer find a way to report it.
“他们的健康错误信息规则非常明确,规则依然摆在那里,”应《卫报》请求审查该群组的 DiResta 说。“他们有政策,但主动选择——至少目前看来——似乎并不执行。” 为测试 Facebook 如何执行其有害医疗错误信息政策,《卫报》向 Facebook 举报了 55 条疑似违规的 Crunchy Moms 帖子、评论、回复及一条短视频。
“Their health misinformation rules are very explicit. They’re still up there,” said DiResta, who reviewed the group at the Guardian’s request. “They have a policy and they actively choose – at this point – it does not seem that they are enforcing it.”To test how Facebook enforces its harmful medical misinformation policy, the Guardian reported 55 Crunchy Mom posts, comments and replies and one video reel to Facebook that appeared to violate the policy.
这是扎克伯格在 2025 年 1 月宣布 Meta 变革时所背书的做法。
It is the approach that Zuckerberg endorsed when he announced Meta’s changes in January 2025.
“我们过去有过滤器,会扫描任何违反政策的内容,”扎克伯格当时说。“现在我们将把这些过滤器的重点放在打击违法和高严重程度的违规行为上。对于低严重程度的违规行为,我们将依赖有人举报问题后再采取行动。”
“We used to have filters that scanned for any policy violation,” Zuckerberg said then. “Now we’re going to focus those filters on tackling illegal and high severity violations. And for lower severity violations, we’re going to rely on someone reporting an issue before we take action.”
《卫报》的举报涵盖一系列内容。一条帖子部分声称科学研究表明“疫苗导致自闭症”。一条评论说:“疫苗导致麻疹。”另一条:“疫苗极其有毒且没必要,也并不安全或有效。它们全是毒药。”截图已模糊处理以隐去作者身份。
The Guardian’s reports spanned a range of content. One post stated in part that scientific research shows “vaccines cause autism”. A comment said: “The vaccine CAUSES measles.”Another: “Vaccines are extremely toxic and unnecessary as well as NOT safe or effective. They all poison.”Screenshot has been blurred to obscure identities of authors.

在群组内分享的一个视频中,该视频淡化破伤风的危险并劝阻接种疫苗,字幕中包含这样一句:“高剂量维生素C使破伤风感染儿童实现100%存活,并降低了成人的死亡率。”Meta的政策禁止声称维生素C与疫苗同样有效。
In a video shared in the group that downplayed the dangers of tetanus and urged against vaccines, a caption included the line “High-dose vitamin C led to 100% survival in tetanus-infected children and reduced death rates in adults.”Meta’s policy prohibits saying Vitamin C is as effective as a vaccine.
在一条询问“我们用什么来消除皮肤癌?”的帖子下,《卫报》报道了多条回复建议使用黑膏药。它还报道了一条询问用于“可疑痣/印记”的黑膏药品牌的帖子,以及一位群组管理员提供的回复,其中包含购买黑膏药产品的联盟链接,以及另一位管理员的亚马逊店铺链接。
On a post asking: “What are we using to get rid of skin cancer?” the Guardian reported several replies suggesting black salve. It also reported a post asking for a brand of black salve to use on a “questionable mole/mark”, as well as the reply from a group administrator providing an affiliate link to purchase a black salve product, as well as to another administrator’s Amazon store.
鉴于类似内容在该群组中司空见惯,《卫报》还于10月1日举报了整个“Crunchy Moms”群组。
The Guardian also reported the entire Crunchy Moms group on 1 October, given that similar content is commonplace within it.
无法专门将内容举报为有害健康错误信息。相反,举报用户必须先选择一个大类:“诈骗、欺诈或虚假信息”。然后,可在“分享虚假信息”标题下举报内容。
There is no way to report content specifically as harmful health misinformation. Instead, the user making a report must first select a broad category: “scam, fraud or false information”. Then, content can be reported under the heading “Sharing false information”.
《卫报》并未收到 Facebook 对其任何举报的确认回复,尽管该公司声称会向用户通报举报结果。Loving-Rodriguez 表示,当她在其他 Facebook 社区举报仇恨或纳粹内容的评论时,会收到 Facebook 的确认消息。但在她标记“Crunchy Moms”群组中似乎违反 Facebook 规定的内容时,却没有收到任何确认。
The Guardian did not receive a single confirmation from Facebook to any of its reports, even though the company says it alerts users to the outcomes of their reports. Loving-Rodriguez said when she reports comments for hate or Nazi content in other Facebook communities, she gets a message from Facebook confirming her report. But not when she flags content that seems to violate Facebook’s rules in Crunchy Moms.
当 Meta 被请求置评时,《卫报》举报的几乎所有内容仍然在线。
Nearly all of the content the Guardian reported to Facebook was still up when Meta was approached for comment.
尽管《卫报》多次举报违规行为却未收到任何回复,Facebook 却邀请该记者加入平台的“社区笔记”计划。该计划在 2025 年政策回调后取代了美国的第三方事实核查员。Meta 表示,该计划已在多个国家进行测试,并计划在确信其运行良好后推广并取消事实核查员。
While the repeated reports of policy violations by the Guardian didn’t receive any responses, Facebook invited the journalist to join the platform’s community notes program. The program replaced third-party factcheckers in the United States after the 2025 rollbacks. Meta has said it was already testing the program in several countries and plans to roll it out and eliminate factcheckers once it was confident it was working well.
本周,《卫报》向 Meta 提供了在该群组发现的违规内容示例。Meta 表示正在审查这些链接,并将对违反其政策的帖子采取行动。“我并非主动寻找”根据公司最新报告,推荐内容已成为 Facebook 的重要内容来源,现在占用户在新闻动态中所见内容的 。这些内容来自用户未关注的来源,但 Facebook 判断可能引起他们的兴趣。相比之下,来自好友的内容仅占用户动态的约 20%。
The Guardian this week provided Meta with examples of content found on the group. Meta said it was reviewing those links and would take action on posts that violate its policies. ‘I did not seek it out’Recommendations have become an important source of content on Facebook, now representing of what users see in their news feed, according to the company’s most recent reports. That content comes from sources they are not connected to but which Facebook determines might interest them. By contrast, content from friends makes up only about 20% of users’ feeds.
Facebook 称,此类个性化推荐旨在帮助人们“发现新社区和内容”。
Facebook says it makes such personalized recommendations to help people “discover new communities and content”.
DiResta 指出,当 Facebook 选择推广某个群组时,它是在行使编辑自由裁量权,行使其言论自由并作出价值判断。她说,过去 Facebook 曾承认,推荐机制带来的责任程度,与单纯允许人们发言是不同的。
When Facebook chooses to promote a group, DiResta claimed, it is using its editorial discretion, exercising its speech and making a value judgment. In the past, she said, Facebook had acknowledged that recommendations create a different level of responsibility from simply allowing people to speak.
《卫报》发现了几位因 Facebook 的推荐机制而在信息流中接触到“Crunchy Moms”(意指崇尚自然育儿的妈妈群体)的人。
The Guardian found several people who encountered Crunchy Moms in their feed as a result of Facebook’s curation choices.
“它出现在我的信息流里,我就参与了进去,”大约六个月前加入该群组的 Kramps 说,“我并没有主动去找它。”
“It came across my feed, and I engaged,” said Kramps, who joined the group about six months ago. “I did not seek it out.”
“它以自然的方式被推荐到了我的信息流里,”南达科他州苏瀑市的麻醉科医生 Casey Husser 博士说,“我没有找过‘Crunchy Moms’。”一位来自明尼阿波利斯、育有两个孩子(分别两岁和五岁)的母亲告诉《卫报》,即使她不是该群组成员,也没有主动寻找,“Crunchy Moms”还是在她的信息流里出现了几个月。
“It was offered to me organically in my feed,” said Dr Casey Husser, an anesthesiologist in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. “I didn’t look for Crunchy Moms.”A Minneapolis mother of two children, ages two and five, told the Guardian Crunchy Moms showed up in her feed for months, even though she was not part of the group and did not seek it out.
Meta 告诉《卫报》,其应对错误信息的方法是创造一个减少错误信息传播的环境。对于为何向用户信息流推荐“Crunchy Moms”这一具体问题,Meta 未予回应。
Meta told the Guardian its approach to misinformation is to create an environment that reduces its distribution. It did not address specific questions about why it was recommending Crunchy Moms to users’ feeds.
Facebook 还采取了给部分帖子添加标题或评论摘要的措施。这些内容由 Meta 的 AI 工具生成,旨在“帮助人们快速了解”平台上的对话。批评人士指出,其在部分帖子上提供的评论摘要与可靠科学相悖。
Facebook also has taken the step of adding titles or comment summaries to some posts. Generated by Meta’s AI tool, they are meant to “help people catch up” on conversations on the platform. The comment summaries it offered on some posts conflicted with good science, critics said.
例如,Meta 的 AI 给一篇帖子加上的标题是:“怀孕期和婴儿期推荐或跳过哪些疫苗?”它对评论的总结称:“乙肝疫苗和流感疫苗通常被建议跳过,而有些人建议延迟接种或挑选疫苗接种。”这与美国医生团体的建议相冲突,后者建议所有婴儿出生时普遍接种乙肝疫苗,以及六个月及以上儿童和流感季节的孕妇接种流感疫苗。
For example, Meta’s AI entitled one post: “What vaccines are recommended or skipped during pregnancy and infancy?”It summarized the comments by stating: “Hepatitis B and flu vaccines are commonly suggested to skip, while some recommend delaying or picking and choosing vaccines.”That conflicts with recommendations from doctors’ groups in the US, which recommend universal hepatitis B vaccination for all infants at birth, as well as flu vaccine for children six months and older and for pregnant women during influenza season.

2019 年 4 月 29 日,在犹他州普罗沃,一名护士正在为一名儿童准备接种麻疹、腮腺炎和风疹病毒疫苗。
A nurse prepares the arm of a child to receive a measles, mumps and rubella virus vaccine on 29 April 2019 in Provo, Utah.
在关于兰开斯特麻疹的帖子中,该帖询问如何从麻疹-腮腺炎-风疹(MMR)疫苗中“排毒”,Meta 的 AI 将讨论总结为:“无需排毒,部分评论者引用维生素 A 缺乏作为麻疹风险因素,而其他人则声称疫苗没有必要甚至有害。”迪雷斯塔表示,Meta 的 AI 系统可能正在为该帖子添加背景信息,以澄清疫苗排毒并非一个科学上有效的概念。
On the Lancaster measles post, which asked for ways to “detox” from the MMR vaccine, Meta’s AI summarized the discussion as: “No detox needed, some commenters cite vitamin A deficiency as a measles risk factor, while others claim the vaccine is unnecessary or even harmful.”Meta’s AI system could be adding context to that post to clarify that a vaccine detox is not a scientifically valid idea, DiResta said.
“AI 做到这一点非常容易,”她说,并指出 Meta 在 Threads 上使用 AI 生成部分备注。“但看来,他们再次选择不这样做。”Meta 在周三晚间告诉《卫报》,它已在 9 月移除了对讨论的 AI 摘要。但《卫报》在 10 月截取了 10 多条此类摘要的屏幕截图,其中一些可追溯至 2025 年 12 月。
“It’s very easy for an AI to do that,” she said, pointing out that Meta uses AI for some notes on Threads. “But it seems, again, that they’re choosing not to do that.”Meta told the Guardian on Wednesday evening it had gotten rid of AI summaries of discussions in September. But the Guardian took screen shots of more than 10 such summaries in October, some going back as far as December 2025.
对于《卫报》提出的关于 AI 生成内容实质问题的具体提问,Meta 未作回应。
Meta did not respond to specific questions on the issues the Guardian raised about the substance of the AI-generated content.
胡塞尔表示,他习惯关注网上流传的不良医疗信息,以免在工作中病人向他询问时感到意外。
Husser said he makes it a habit to pay attention to bad medical information circulating online so he won’t be surprised at work if patients ask him about it.
“[Facebook] 宽容得多,”胡塞尔说。“自 2025 年以来,它已成为一个完全不同的环境。”Crunchy Moms 的管理员鲁普表示,她也注意到了变化。过去,她记得因提及“疫苗”一词而收到 Facebook 的警告或遭到内容移除。“似乎我们不再像过去那样因许多事情惹上麻烦了,”鲁普说。
“[Facebook is] way more permissive,” Husser said. “Since 2025, it’s become a totally different environment.”Crunchy Moms’ administrator Rupe said she has noticed a change as well. In the past, she remembers getting Facebook strikes or removals for mentioning the word vaccines. “It seems like we’re not getting in trouble for a lot of things like we used to,” Rupe said.
过去,她回忆 Facebook 会在帖子获批前标记其认定为包含错误信息的帖子,她表示如果看到此类提示通常不会批准这些帖子。但她不记得今年收到过任何此类提示。鲁普说,Facebook 每月仅从 Crunchy Moms 移除约一条帖子。
In the past, she recalls that Facebook would flag posts it deemed as containing misinformation before they were approved, and said she usually would not approve them if she saw such a message. But she doesn’t remember getting any this year. Rupe said Facebook only takes down about one post per month from Crunchy Moms.
当有人在群组中使用脏话或其变体时,Meta 的 AI 会提醒她。但鲁普表示,对于一些人可能称为医疗错误信息的内容,AI 并不会给她任何警报。
Meta’s AI will alert her when someone uses a swear word, or a variation of one, in the group. But Rupe said it doesn’t give her any alerts about what some might call medical misinformation.
迪雷斯塔表示,Facebook 向人们推荐这个群组这一事实意义重大。
DiResta said the fact that Facebook is recommending this group to people is significant.
“Meta 未经请求就将这种内容推送到尤其是新手父母的信息流中,”迪雷斯塔说,“他们自然会对孩子的健康感到担忧和恐惧。他们想感觉到自己正在为孩子做最好的事。”
“Meta is pushing this thing unsolicited into the feeds of particularly new parents” who naturally have concerns and fears about their childrens’ health, DiResta said. “They want to feel that they’re doing the best for their kids.”