字号·· | 护眼
海峡时报

特朗普密集任命法官的计划遭遇共和党人阻挠Trump's judge appointment blitz faces Republican resistance

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

华盛顿11月15日——美国总统唐纳德·特朗普在民主党即将控制美国参议院之前,试图尽可能多地安插法官的最后时刻努力,正遭遇一些同党共和党人的阻挠。

WASHINGTON, Nov 15 - A last-minute effort by US President Donald Trump to install as many judges as possible before Democrats take control of the US Senate is running into resistance from some fellow Republicans.

直到最近,参议院共和党人在特朗普的第二个任期内,一直例行批准他关于地区法院和上诉法院终身法官席位的提名人选,迄今已确认了57人,并帮助他巩固了将持续到其总统任期结束之后的保守派司法印记。

Until recently, Senate Republicans had routinely approved Trump's nominees for lifetime seats on district and appeals courts during his second term, confirming 57 so far and helping him cement a conservative imprint on the judiciary that will outlast his presidency.

但随着白宫和参议院共和党领袖在跛脚鸭国会会期期间继续推进司法提名人选,少数几名共和党人已经阻止或对为他们各自家乡州挑选的三名提名人选提出了质疑。

But as the White House and Senate Republican leaders press ahead with judicial nominees during the lame-duck session, a handful of Republicans have blocked or cast doubt on three nominees selected for their home states.

传统上,参议员协助挑选其所在州的法院空缺职位人选。初审法院提名人选尤其容易受到阻碍,因为按照参议院的惯例,家乡州的参议员可以通过扣下“蓝条”(即向参议院司法委员会表示支持的表格)来阻止他们。

Senators traditionally help choose judges for vacancies in their states. Trial court nominees are especially vulnerable because, under Senate custom, home-state senators can block them by withholding a “blue slip," a form indicating support to the Senate Judiciary Committee.

白宫在总体上尊重这一传统的同时,有时也会不顾共和党参议员的反对,挑选保守派填补司法空缺。

While generally honoring that tradition, the White House has sometimes picked conservatives to fill judicial vacancies over the objections of Republican senators.

俄克拉何马州共和党参议员阿兰·阿姆斯特朗表示:“我们提出了许多真正合格的候选人并将其送往白宫,而他们基本上对此置之不理,只是强行通过了他们自己的人选。”

"We put up a lot of really qualified candidates that we sent to the White House, and they basically ignored that and just put through their one," Senator Alan Armstrong, an Oklahoma Republican, said.

参议院司法委员会的两名离任共和党成员——来自北卡罗来纳州的汤姆·蒂利斯和来自得克萨斯州的约翰·科宁,可以剥夺此类提名人选推进所需的票数。“这里可不是这么运作的”白宫于周二采取了罕见的举措,撤回了美国地区法院法官李·鲁多夫斯基对常驻圣路易斯的美国第八巡回上诉法院法官的提名,并由阿肯色州最高法院大法官J·科迪·海兰取而代之,此前阿肯色州美国参议员约翰·博兹曼和汤姆·科顿反对鲁多夫斯基。

Two outgoing Republican members on the Senate Judiciary Committee, Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas, can deny such nominees the votes needed to advance. 'NOT THE WAY IT WORKS HERE' The White House on Tuesday took the rare step of withdrawing US District Judge Lee Rudofsky's nomination to the St. Louis-based 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals and replacing him with Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland after US Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton of Arkansas opposed Rudofsky.

即将离任的共和党参议员阿姆斯特朗和科宁拒绝公开支持其所在州的两名提名人,而蒂利斯则利用其在委员会的职位,帮助阻挠了同僚反对的候选人。

Outgoing Republican Senators Armstrong and Cornyn have withheld public support for two nominees in their states, while Tillis has used his position on the committee to help block candidates opposed by his colleagues.

蒂利斯与特朗普关系破裂,他在周四对记者表示,白宫有时实质上对参议员说:“这是我们的人,希望你们能支持。”

Tillis, who has a fractured relationship with Trump, told reporters on Thursday that the White House has at times essentially told senators, "This is our guy, I hope you'll get on board."

“这里不是这么运作的,”他说。“他们应该预料到会得到这种回应。”对白宫而言,未来几周反映了一个始于特朗普首个任期、旨在将联邦司法系统的意识形态平衡向右倾斜的项目的最后冲刺,该倡议的影响将在特朗普离任后持续数年。

"That's not how it works here," he said. "They should expect they're going to get this response." For the White House, the next few weeks reflect the last hurrah on a project that began during Trump's first administration to shift the federal judiciary's ideological balance to the right, an initiative whose effects will be felt for years after Trump leaves office.

“我们预计参议院待决的所有司法提名人今年都将获批准,”一名白宫官员在声明中说。

"We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year," a White House official said in a statement.

特朗普在2017年至2021年的首个任期内任命了234名法官,其中包括美国最高法院现有6比3保守派超级多数中的三名大法官。目前大约三分之一的在职法官是特朗普任命的。

Trump made 234 judicial appointments during his first term in office from 2017 to 2021, including three members of the US Supreme Court's current 6-3 conservative supermajority. Roughly one-third of active judges are now Trump appointees.

苏恩将司法提名确认为优先事项 参议院多数党领袖约翰·苏恩周一表示,在共和党保持对参议院控制权期间,司法提名确认是首要任务。

THUNE PRIORITIZING JUDICIAL NOMINATIONS Senate Majority Leader John Thune said Monday that judicial confirmations were a top priority while Republicans retain control of the chamber.

参议院周四确认了跛脚鸭会期的首位司法提名人。仍有23名提名人待决,其中包括科罗拉多州联邦地区法官丹尼尔·多梅尼科,他被提名为设在丹佛的第10巡回上诉法院法官,定于周一进行表决。

The Senate confirmed its first judicial nominee of the lame-duck session on Thursday. Twenty-three nominees remain pending, including Colorado-based US District Judge Daniel Domenico, whose nomination to the Denver-based 10th US Circuit Court of Appeals is set for a Monday vote.

但即将退休的蒂利斯、以及在初选中败给特朗普支持的挑战者的科宁,如今已处于任期最后阶段,并已表示愿意阻挠参议院司法委员会面前的一些待决提名人,他们二人均为该委员会成员。

But Tillis, who is retiring, and Cornyn, who lost a primary to a Trump-backed challenger, are now in their final days in office and have indicated a willingness to block some nominees pending before the Senate Judiciary Committee, of which they are both members.

乔治·梅森大学法学教授罗布·路瑟表示,目前处于“借来的时间”里的参议员们,阻碍了“运动保守派”被任命为法官。路瑟曾在特朗普第一任期内的白宫法律顾问办公室负责司法提名工作。

Rob Luther, a George Mason University law professor who worked on judicial nominations in the White House Counsel's Office during Trump's first term, said senators who are now on "borrowed time" stand in the way of "movement conservatives" being appointed to the bench.

蒂利斯承认,他曾支持阿肯色州参议员阻止鲁多夫斯的努力。鲁多夫斯基是特朗普的第一任期任命官员,以一项削弱一项重大选举权法案执行力度的裁决而闻名。

Tillis acknowledged he had supported efforts by Arkansas' senators to block Rudofsky, a first-term Trump appointee known for a ruling that weakened enforcement of a major voting rights law.

领导反对行动的博兹曼则支持海兰。海兰在8月份表示,他曾获提供一个审判法院提名,但他拒绝了。参议员理应获得“尊重”蒂利斯表示,在为其所在州选择法官时,参议员理应获得白宫更多的“尊重”。

Boozman, who led the opposition, instead favored Hiland, who said in August that he had been offered a trial court nomination, which he declined. SENATORS DESERVE 'RESPECT' Tillis said senators deserved more "respect" from the White House in selecting judges for their states.

科宁则分别拒绝承诺支持蒂·埃利奥特·盖泽。盖泽是特朗普提名的达拉斯联邦法官人选。盖泽来自俄亥俄州,他的入选没有经过得克萨斯州通常由参议员主导的筛选程序。

Cornyn has separately declined to commit to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Gaiser, who hails from Ohio, was selected without going through the usual senator-driven screening process in Texas.

盖泽目前领导着司法部法律顾问办公室,该办公室曾发表意见,支持特朗普议程中最具争议的一些内容。如果没有科宁的蓝条支持,盖泽将无法出席周三举行的司法委员会听证会。

Gaiser now leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, which has issued opinions endorsing some of the most controversial elements of Trump's agenda. Without a blue slip from Cornyn, Gaiser cannot appear at a Judiciary Committee hearing on Wednesday.

蒂利斯同样支持阿姆斯特朗反对扎克·韦斯特。韦斯特是俄克拉何马州总检察长办公室的一名律师,因捍卫堕胎限制以及支持宗教学校参与俄克拉何马州特许学校项目而赢得了保守派法律活动人士的赞誉。

Tillis is likewise backing Armstrong's opposition to Zach West, a lawyer in the Oklahoma attorney general's office who has drawn praise from conservative legal activists for defending abortion restrictions and supporting the participation of religious schools in Oklahoma's charter school program.

阿姆斯特朗最初对韦斯特交出了赞成的蓝条,但后来撤回了支持。蒂利斯的支持意味着,当该委员会下次决定推进哪些人选时,韦斯特将没有足够的票数通过委员会。

Armstrong initially returned a favorable blue slip for West but later withdrew his support. Tillis' backing leaves West without enough votes to clear the committee when it next decides whom to advance on Tuesday.

使局势复杂化的是,阿姆斯特朗将于11月30日离开参议院,并由候任参议员凯文·赫恩接替。赫恩是一名共和党人,可能会对韦斯特采取不同的立场。蒂利斯表示,目前他将继续阻止该提名人。

Complicating matters, Armstrong will leave the Senate on November 30 and be replaced by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, a Republican who could take a different position on West. Tillis said that, for now, he will continue blocking the nominee.

“当该州的两名共和党人都让我推进此事时,我就会推进,”蒂利斯说。“如果有一名或多名共和党人要求我不要推进,那我就不推进。” 路透社

"When I've got two Republicans from the state telling me to move on it, I move on it," Tillis said. "If I have one or more asking me not to, then I'm not." REUTERS

阅读媒体原文 ↗