防御低成本无人机、导弹和滑翔炸弹的饱和攻击是可能的——但代价高昂。2026年2月28日针对伊朗的“史诗之怒”行动开始后的头100个小时里,美国发射了价值约17亿美元的拦截弹。但用每枚500万美元的“爱国者”拦截导弹击落每一架造价5万美元的“沙赫德”无人机,在经济上不可持续。与此同时,在乌克兰,这类拦截弹供不应求,该国正抵御俄罗斯的空中打击。
Defending against a barrage of low-cost drones, missiles and glide bombs is possible—but it costs a fortune. In the first 100 hours after Operation Epic Fury began against Iran on February 28th 2026, America fired interceptors worth an estimated $1.7bn. But shooting down every $50,000 Shahed drone with a $5m Patriot interceptor missile is not economically sustainable. In Ukraine, meanwhile, such interceptors are in short supply as the country fends off Russian aerial attacks.
但到2027年,防空的经济账将不再那么沉重。更廉价的系统将投产或服役。其他系统将扩大产量,从而降低成本。
But in 2027 the economics of air defence will become less grievous. Cheaper systems will enter production or service. Others will be made in greater numbers, bringing down costs.
加快测试与重新设计的循环是省钱的一种办法。拉脱维亚允许爱沙尼亚拦截弹初创公司弗兰肯堡技术公司在其阿达日军事靶场每年进行约100次试射。该公司老板库斯蒂·萨尔姆表示,这帮助弗兰肯堡在短短13个月内让其Mark 1反无人机导弹“从PPT走到了制导灾难性命中演示”。在欧洲其他靶场,每年进行一两次测试可能是常态。产量增加应会使Mark 1的价格在2027年底前降至3万美元以下。同类拦截弹的价格可能高达25万美元,战时还要翻倍。
Accelerating test-and-redesign cycles is one way to save money. Latvia has let Frankenburg Technologies, an Estonian interceptor startup, conduct around 100 test launches a year at its Adazi military range. That helped Frankenburg get its Mark 1 counter-drone missile “from PowerPoint to the demonstration of a guided catastrophic hit” in just 13 months, says Kusti Salm, the firm’s boss. At ranges elsewhere in Europe, one or two tests a year can be the norm. Increased production should bring the Mark 1’s price below $30,000 by the end of 2027. Comparable interceptors can cost $250,000, or double that in wartime.
乌克兰把快速迭代推得更远,利用来自前线的反馈。以2025年推出的四旋翼拦截无人机“毒刺”为例。其制造商野蜂公司的一名高管表示,“毒刺”每月摧毁约2500架“沙赫德”和“格兰”无人机,成功率超过90%。“毒刺”售价约2000美元,某些配置的价格只有一半。许多部件自产有所帮助,规模效应同样如此:每月产量超过1万架。更快的改型“毒刺2”将于2027年量产。
Ukraine has taken rapid iteration even further, using feedback from the front. Take the Sting, a quadcopter interceptor introduced in 2025. It has been destroying roughly 2,500 Shahed and Geran drones a month, with a success rate higher than 90%, says an executive at Wild Hornets, its manufacturer. The Sting sells for about $2,000, with some configurations costing half that. In-house production of many parts helps, as does scale: more than 10,000 are built a month. A faster variant, the Sting 2, will be in mass production by 2027.
更便宜的动力系统也在出现。英国初创公司 Greenjets 推出的新型拦截机“Kestrel”(红隼)不使用燃气涡轮,而是采用管道电风扇,运动部件更少。该机型旨在拦截俄罗斯速度最快的“Geran”(格拉尼)无人机,速度可超过 600 公里/小时。公司负责人 Anmol Manohar 称其为“以电力成本实现喷气式性能”。一架 Kestrel 成本不足 5 万美元,而美国 RTX 公司生产的同级喷气动力拦截机 Coyote Block 2C 成本为 12.5 万美元。
Then there is cheaper propulsion. Instead of a gas turbine, the Kestrel, a new interceptor from Greenjets, a British startup, uses ducted electric fans with fewer moving parts. Built to kill Russia’s fastest Geran drones, it can exceed 600kph. Anmol Manohar, the firm’s boss, calls it “jet performance at electric costs”. A Kestrel costs less than $50,000, compared with $125,000 for a similarly capable Coyote Block 2C, a jet-powered interceptor made by America’s RTX.
Greenjets 目前月产 1500 架 Kestrel,Manohar 预计到 2027 年初产量将翻四番,成本再降三分之一。
Greenjets has been turning out 1,500 Kestrels a month. Mr Manohar expects to quadruple output by early 2027, knocking a third off the cost.
枪炮射击成本更低,且因机器人技术进步而愈发可行。7 月,总部位于奥斯汀的初创公司 Allen Control Systems 开始交付“Bullfrog”(牛蛙)机枪机器人炮塔,它利用摄像头和激光测距仪瞄准无人机,成本仅为雷达的十分之一。该公司预计 2027 年交付超过 2000 套,其中包括交付乌克兰的订单。
Cheaper still is gunfire, made increasingly viable by advances in robotics. In July, Allen Control Systems, an Austin-based startup, began shipping Bullfrog, a robotic machinegun mount that uses cameras and a laser rangefinder—at a tenth of the cost of radar—to aim at drones. The firm expects to ship more than 2,000 units in 2027, including to Ukraine.
发射能量脉冲而非弹丸的武器也在变得实用,至少对付无人机是如此。2027 年,英国海军一艘驱逐舰将装备“DragonFire”(龙火)激光武器。每次发射成本约 13 美元。但它对巡航导弹和弹道导弹无效,拦截这类目标仍需“爱国者”这类系统。
Weapons that fire bursts of energy, not bullets, are also becoming practical, at least against drones. In 2027 a British navy destroyer will get DragonFire, a laser gun. Each shot costs about $13. But it is no use against cruise and ballistic missiles, where something like a Patriot is still needed.
“爱国者”系统制造商洛克希德·马丁正在开发更廉价的拦截弹,目标是以一半价格实现 90% 的性能。乌克兰初创公司 Fire Point 正在研发更便宜的方案,单枚成本低于 120 万美元,计划于 2027 年中进行试射。■
Lockheed Martin, maker of the Patriot system, is developing a cheaper form of its interceptor. The aim is to deliver 90% of the capability at half the price. Fire Point, a Ukrainian startup, is working on an even cheaper option, at less than $1.2m apiece. It aims to test-fire it in mid-2027. ■