
为何此事值得关注:沙特阿拉伯资助的LIV高尔夫联盟曾试图通过支付高额报酬来吸引球员脱离PGA巡回赛,但这一策略最终难以为继。今年9月,该联盟依据《美国破产法》第11章申请了破产保护。
Why it matters: The Saudi-backed league filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in September after its strategy of paying big money to lure players away from the PGA Tour proved unsustainable. The contracts include deals with prominent players like Bryson DeChambeau, Jon Rahm and Phil Mickelson.
这些合同涉及众多知名球员,包括布莱森·德尚博、琼·拉姆以及菲尔·米克尔森。
引人深思之处:破产法专家对LIV高尔夫试图将这些合同作为机密文件提交的做法提出质疑,指出必须有充分理由才能让此类文件避开法庭的公开审查。
The intrigue: Bankruptcy experts questioned whether LIV Golf's motion to file the contracts under seal is justified, saying there must be a compelling reason to shield them from the spotlight in court. "Yes, you can file stuff under seal.
“确实可以将某些文件列为机密,但那仅适用于涉及敏感信息的情形,比如可口可乐的配方之类的。”密歇根大学破产法教授约翰·波特对Axios说道,“我认为,破产法官很可能会对这种信息必须保密的必要性持强烈怀疑态度。”
It's for sensitive information. It's supposed to be the formula for Coke and stuff like that," University of Michigan bankruptcy law professor John Pottow tells Axios. He added: "I think that a bankruptcy judge is going to have serious skepticism about the need for this information to remain confidential."
当前状况:LIV高尔夫的律师在法庭文件中称,球员们签署的各项协议中包含大量“具有商业敏感性”的信息,必须对公众保密,其中包括“关于解约条款、薪酬数额以及后续商业合作安排的具体细节”。这些律师还写道:“此外,鉴于签约球员均为知名公众人物,若其个人信息遭到泄露,将极大增加他们的安全风险,甚至可能被用于对其进行伤害或骚扰。”
State of play: LIV Golf attorneys said in a court filing that its players' separate agreements contain "commercially sensitive" information that must be shielded from public view, including "specific and detailed terms regarding releases, payment amounts, and ongoing business arrangements." "In addition, given the high-profile celebrity nature of the Players, disclosure of the Personal Information, would create a real risk to the safety of the Players and could be used to harm or harass them," the LIV attorneys wrote.
现实情况:关于职业运动员薪酬的相关信息其实早已广泛公开,而球员们也时常因薪酬水平或赛场表现而受到褒贬不一的评价。
Reality check: Information about the compensation for professional athletes is widely available, and players are regularly subject to praise and scorn for a variety of reasons, including their pay and their play.
各方观点:“我认为保密条款应当作狭义解释;若对‘商业敏感信息’这类术语作宽泛解读,则可能损害破产救济制度所追求的透明度目标,”北卡罗来纳大学破产法教授梅丽莎·雅各比对Axios说道。“至于因自己收入过高而感到难为情——我觉得成年人就该为自己的契约行为负责,享受由此带来的好处,”波特沃说道,“不过我不确定这点是否足以成为申请保密的理由。”我们正密切关注:是否会有相关方对此提出异议。
What they're saying: "I do believe the sealing statute is meant to be narrowly construed and that broad interpretation of terms like 'commercially sensitive' risks undermining the objectives of transparency as part of the price of getting bankruptcy relief," University of North Carolina bankruptcy law professor Melissa Jacoby tells Axios in an "Just being embarrassed of how much money you're being paid — I think you're a big boy and you signed the contract and you're reaping the benefits," Pottow said. "I don't know if that's enough to get you under seal." What we're watching: It remains to be seen whether anyone will object.
通常情况下,隶属于特朗普政府司法部的美国破产受托人机构最有可能对此类大型破产案中的保密申请提出异议。但该机构至今尚未采取行动,且拒绝对此报道发表评论。
The U.S. Trustee — part of President Trump's Department of Justice — would typically be the most likely party to file an objection to a request like this in a major bankruptcy case. But it has not done so yet — and the office declined to comment for this story.
波特沃指出,如果本案各方均未提出异议,那么法官迈克尔·卡普兰要驳回保密申请就会面临更大难度。
Pottow said that it could be harder for Judge Michael Kaplan to justify rejecting a motion to seal if no parties in the case have cried foul.
宏观背景:本周三的听证会是本案的关键节点。此前沙特方面以投资战略调整为由撤资,LIV联盟正试图借此机会寻求转型之路。
Zoom out: Wednesday's hearing is a pivotal moment in the case as LIV tries to find a path to reinvention after the Saudis withdrew funding, citing a shift in investment strategy.
周一,LIV在法庭文件中披露:已从BC Partners处获得400万美元的破产期间运营资金。作为协议的一部分,若LIV能吸引足够多的球员加盟其第二季赛事,BC Partners承诺将提供最高3亿美元的资助。
LIV disclosed Monday in a court filing that it had obtained $4 million in debtor-in-possession bankruptcy financing from BC Partners as part of the investor's agreement to provide up to $300 million if it can lure a sufficient number of players to commit to the league's second iteration.
BC Partners设想让参与LIV 2.0的球员成为联盟的股权持有者,从而“让他们能直接参与联盟未来的建设”。该公司在声明中称:“我们认为这种独特机制有助于吸引并留住顶尖人才,强化各球队的凝聚力,同时实现球员、所有者与球迷长期利益的一致性。”
The investor envisions players participating in LIV 2.0 as equity holders, giving them "a direct voice in building its future" "BC Partners Credit believes this unique structure will attract and retain top talent, strengthen team identity, and align the long-term interests of players, owners, and fans," BC said in a statement.
总结:卡普兰法官有权决定外界能否获悉LIV与球员们所签署的协议细节。
The bottom line: Judge Kaplan controls whether the world will see the details of LIV's deals with its players.