字号·· | 护眼
彭博社

地方检察官:曼吉奥内在美国的认罪不应阻止州审判Mangione’s US Guilty Plea Should Not Bar State Trial, DA Says

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

路易吉·曼吉奥内于8月11日在纽约州最高法院出席审前听证会。摄影师:David Dee Delgado/路透社/彭博社Luigi Mangione during a pretrial hearing at New York State Supreme Court in New York on Aug. 11. Photographer: David Dee Delgado/Reuters/Bloomberg

曼哈顿检察官周五表示,尽管路易吉·曼吉奥内已就联邦指控认罪,这些指控涉及联合健康集团高管布莱恩·汤普森遭枪杀身亡一案,但他仍应面临纽约州的谋杀审判。

Mangione should still face a New York state murder trial even after he pleaded guilty to federal charges related to the fatal shooting of UnitedHealth Group Inc. executive Brian Thompson, Manhattan prosecutors said Friday.

检察官称,曼吉奥内于8月认罪的联邦跟踪指控,与他在州法院面临的谋杀案“毫无关系”。此文件是针对曼吉奥内律师的主张作出的回应,后者称根据“双重危险”法律原则,州政府的案件应被驳回。

Prosecutors said that the federal stalking charges, which Mangione pleaded guilty to in August, have “nothing to do” with the murder case he faces in state court. The filing is in response to Mangione’s lawyers’ claims that the state case should be dismissed because of the legal concept known as double jeopardy.

曼哈顿州检察官乔尔·赛德曼周五对一名纽约州法官表示,这些是“不同的损害、不同的罪恶、不同的目的、不同的罪行”,并补充称纽约州法律“允许继续起诉被告的州级谋杀指控”。现年28岁的曼吉奥内于8月在联邦法院就两项跟踪罪名认罪,承认他于2024年在曼哈顿中城一家酒店的投资者会议外枪杀了汤普森。在认罪当天,他的律师在州法院提交动议,辩称美国宪法和纽约州法律禁止因同一行为对某人进行两次起诉,即双重危险。

They are “different harms, different evils, different purposes, different crimes,” Manhattan state prosecutor Joel Seidemann told a New York state judge Friday, adding that New York state law “permits the continued prosecution of defendant’s state murder charge.”Mangione, 28, pleaded guilty in federal court in August to two counts of stalking, admitting that he shot Thompson outside an investor conference at a midtown Manhattan hotel in 2024. On the day of his plea, his lawyers filed a motion in state court, arguing the US Constitution and New York state law prohibit prosecuting someone twice for the same act, or double jeopardy.

曼吉奥内法律团队的一位发言人引用了其辩护律师此前提出的论点。

A spokeswoman for Mangione’s legal team cited prior arguments his defense lawyers made.

“从2024年12月9日被捕之日起,路易吉·曼吉奥内就成了纽约县地方检察官办公室和美国司法部发起的平行起诉中的一枚棋子,”他的律师在8月14日驳回州案件的动议中写道。“我们不知晓在该国起诉历史上,还有其他具有这种情况组合的案件。” 汤普森遇害引发了联邦和纽约市当局的大规模调查,导致管辖权之争,并对曼吉奥内提起了两起独立的刑事案件。

“From the day of his arrest on December 9, 2024, Luigi Mangione has been a pawn in parallel prosecutions pursued by the New York County District Attorney’s Office and the United States Department of Justice,” his lawyers said in their Aug. 14 motion to dismiss the state case. “We are unaware of a single other case with this combination of circumstances in the history of prosecutions in this country.”Thompson’s slaying triggered a massive investigation by both federal and New York City authorities, leading to a turf battle and two separate criminal cases against Mangione.

在州级案件中,曼吉奥内面临25年至终身监禁,这可能是在联邦地区法官玛格丽特·加内特于12月判处的任何刑罚之外追加的。曼哈顿联邦检察官杰米·麦克唐纳表示,美国将寻求判处终身监禁。

In the state case, Mangione faces 25 years to life in prison, which may be in addition to whatever sentence which is imposed by US District Judge Margaret Garnett in December. Manhattan US Attorney Jamie McDonald has said the US would seek a life sentence.