字号·· | 护眼
NBC新闻

星链降速如何影响乌克兰前线抵御俄军的士兵How Starlink slowdown hit Ukraine’s front line soldiers pushing Russia back

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

乌克兰士兵于10月16日在顿涅茨克地区的一个战斗阵地架设星链卫星通信终端。 Dmytro Smolienko / NurPhoto via GettyUkrainian soldiers set up a Starlink satellite communication terminal at a combat position in the Donetsk region Oct. 16. Dmytro Smolienko / NurPhoto via Getty

他领导的无人机部队一直在乌克兰东南部前线帮助击退俄军。然而,上周二晚些时候,一架飞向俄军的无人机突然失去了连接。这位47岁的指挥官说:“当时它正在加速,与无人机的联系瞬间中断了。”由于所执行任务的敏感性,他只希望以呼号“燧石”示人。他驻扎在东部顿涅茨克和南部扎波罗热地区的交界地带。“燧石”在WhatsApp上的一系列消息中说,无人机坠地,任务中止。

The drone unit he leads has been helping push back Russian troops on the front lines in southeastern Ukraine. Then, late last Tuesday, a drone launched toward Russian troops suddenly lost connection. “As it was picking up speed, contact with the drone was lost in an instant,” according to the commander, 47, who is serving on the border between the eastern Donetsk and southern Zaporizhzhia regions, and only wanted to be identified by his call sign Flint due to the sensitivity of his service. The drone fell to the ground, aborting the mission, Flint said in a series of messages on WhatsApp.

他担心无人机内的技术“可能已落入敌手”。他还说:“只有在分析飞行情况后,才明确问题具体与星链的速度限制有关。”乌克兰上周表示,其使用“星盾”被在没有警告的情况下施加了限制,影响了依赖它的战场任务。“星盾”是埃隆·马斯克的SpaceX运营的星链互联网服务的军用版本。美国总统唐纳德·特朗普周四表示,马斯克已恢复在乌克兰的服务,但基辅周五表示,并未看到限制有任何解除。

He fears the technology inside “may have fallen into enemy hands.”“Only after analyzing the flight, it became clear that the issue was specifically related to the Starlink speed limit,” he added. Ukraine said last week that limits were imposed without warning on its use of Starshield, the military variant of the Starlink internet service run by Elon Musk’s SpaceX, affecting battlefield missions reliant on it. President Donald Trump said Thursday that Musk had restored the service in Ukraine, but Kyiv said Friday that it was not seeing any lifting of restrictions.

特朗普没有说明为何实施这些限制,不过马斯克此前曾表示,“对速度或使用量的任何限制都由美国军方决定,并最终由美国总统决定”。乌克兰还曾警告美国情报共享存在缺口,白宫对此予以否认。第二位无人机飞行员在东部哈尔科夫地区服役,他说,乌克兰没有能像星链那样有效用于飞行无人机的替代方案,但这也会影响部队的移动——并最终影响战场上的生存机会。

Trump did not say why the limits were in place, though Musk had previously said that “any limits on speed or usage are decided by the U.S. military and ultimately POTUS.”Ukraine had also warned of gaps in intelligence sharing from the U.S., something the White House has denied. A second drone pilot, serving in the eastern Kharkiv region, said that Ukraine does not have an alternative that’s as effective as Starlink for flying drones, but it also affects the unit’s movements — and ultimately survival chances out in the field.

9月,乌克兰士兵在前线城镇德鲁日基夫卡(顿涅茨克地区)。 Iryna Rybakova / Ukraine's 93rd Mechanized Brigade via APUkrainian soldiers in the front line town of Druzhkivka, Donetsk region, in September. Iryna Rybakova / Ukraine's 93rd Mechanized Brigade via AP

这名飞行员也只希望以呼号“多夫布什”示人,他说:“当我们开车进入阵地时,车上安装了一台星链Mini,我们总是尽量尽快赶到那里,因为如果我们开得慢,敌人就会发现我们,无人机就会追上我们。”

“When we drive into a position, we have a Starlink Mini mounted on the vehicle, and we always try to get there as fast as possible, because if we drive slowly, the enemy will spot us and a drone will catch up with us,” said the pilot, who also only wanted to be identified by his call sign, Dovbush.

“所以我们尽量开快,但一开快,连接就断了。”31岁的多夫布什说,这让他们只能依靠无线电作为唯一的通信替代手段。他还表示,缺乏可靠的连接已经影响到用于识别目标的侦察无人机。“这是在背后捅刀子,”无人机部队指挥官弗林特在谈到美国似乎撤回支持时说。他表示,他的部队依靠“星盾”来操控攻击和侦察无人机,打击对象从俄罗斯军队到指挥所再到坦克不等。

“So we try to drive fast, but when we drive fast, the connection drops.”That leaves them with a radio as the only alternative for communication, Dovbush, 31, said, while a lack of reliable connection has impacted reconnaissance drones used to identify targets, he added. “It’s a knife in the back,” Flint, the drone unit commander, said of the apparent withdrawal of U.S. support. He said his unit relies on Starshield to fly attack and reconnaissance drones at anything from Russian troops to command posts to tanks.

“它的主要作用是保持与无人机的连接,所以这对我们来说是非常重大的损失,”他补充说。他说,如果“星盾”的限制持续下去,他们很大一部分无人机将根本无法起飞,而其他无人机则将非常脆弱,只能以较低速度飞行。“它们几乎可以用一根棍子从天上拍下来,”他说。“而最可怕的是,这一切都发生在前线许多地区——包括我们所在的地区——正在进行进攻行动的背景下,”他补充说。

“Its primary role is maintaining the connection with the drone, so this is a very significant loss for us,” he added. Should Starshield restrictions continue, a large portion of their drones will never even get off the ground, he said, while others will be highly vulnerable, flying at lower speeds. “They could practically be swatted out of the sky with a stick,” he said. “And the scariest part is that all this is happening against the backdrop of offensive operations on many areas of the front line, including ours,” he added.

乌克兰总统泽连斯基周五表示,“星链”的限制仍然存在,但美国国务卿卢比奥告诉他,大约48到72小时内将全面恢复。在与华盛顿的关系最近一次破裂之前,乌克兰军队一直在逐步蚕食俄罗斯在顿涅茨克东部地区夺取的土地,该地区是克里姆林宫一直难以攻占的顿巴斯腹地的一部分。乌克兰官员表示,在一次重大行动中,已收复超过100平方英里的领土和16个定居点,并将此归功于使用轰炸无人机将机器人车辆送入敌后等战术。这次攻势——被称为“维瓦尔第行动”——在美国态度急剧转变的数周前被公开。

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Friday that restrictions on Starlink were still in place, but that U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio had told him it would be fully back in about 48 to 72 hours. Before the latest collapse in relations with Washington, Ukraine’s military had been chipping away at land seized by Russia in the eastern Donetsk region, part of the Donbas heartland that the Kremlin has been struggling to capture. In one major operation, more than 100 square miles of territory and 16 settlements have been reclaimed, Ukrainian officials have said, crediting methods like using bomber drones to fly robot vehicles behind enemy lines. The offensive — dubbed Operation Vivaldi — was made public several weeks before the drastic turn from the United States.

特朗普已同意与俄罗斯达成一项柴油协议,放弃大规模新制裁,其和平特使还称赞俄罗斯总统弗拉基米尔·普京是“人道主义者”。乌克兰指责美国曾短暂扣留有关俄罗斯袭击的情报预警,并表示“星链”降速已影响战场任务。美国坚决否认将乌克兰排除在外,但这一连串戏剧性事态让乌克兰士兵士气低落。NBC新闻采访了五名士兵,其中多为无人机操作员,他们表示自己感到被美国、尤其是特朗普背叛。

Trump has agreed to a diesel deal with Russia, waived sweeping new sanctions and seen his peace envoy laud Russian President Vladimir Putin as a “humanitarian.”Ukraine accused the U.S. of briefly withholding intelligence warnings about Russian attacks, and has said the Starlink slowdown has affected battlefield missions. The U.S. has vehemently denied freezing Ukraine out, but the slew of dramatic developments have left Ukrainian troops disheartened. NBC News spoke with five soldiers, mostly drone operators, who said they felt betrayed by the U.S., and Trump in particular.

9月,一辆覆盖着反无人机网的卡车行驶在前线城镇德鲁日基夫卡(顿涅茨克地区)的街道上。 Iryna Rybakova / Ukraine's 93rd Mechanized Brigade via APA truck covered with an anti-drone net rides along the street in the front-line town of Druzhkivka, Donetsk region, in September. Iryna Rybakova / Ukraine's 93rd Mechanized Brigade via AP

乌克兰官员称,此次攻势打乱了俄罗斯对斯拉维扬斯克和克拉马托尔斯克的进攻,这两座城市是乌克兰在顿巴斯地区的重要据点。“我们阻止了敌人包抄斯拉维扬斯克-克拉马托尔斯克城市群,并将其陷入钳形攻势,”领导此次行动的第三军团指挥官安德里·比列茨基准将说。比列茨基表示,此次攻势中约有8000名俄罗斯士兵被打死;他还补充说,乌克兰使用轰炸无人机将机器人车辆投送到敌后深处,并将苏联时代的装甲运兵车改装成爆炸装置,以“炸毁敌人防御最坚固的阵地”。

Ukrainian officials say that the offensive has disrupted Russia’s assault on Sloviansk and Kramatorsk, key Ukrainian strongholds in the Donbas region. “We prevented the enemy from flanking the Sloviansk-Kramatorsk agglomeration and trapping it in a pincer movement,” said Brig. Gen. Andrii Biletskyi, commander of the Third Army Corps, which led the operation. The offensive, in which Biletskyi said some 8.000 Russian troops were killed, saw Ukraine use bomber drones to deliver robot vehicles deep behind enemy lines and convert Soviet-era armored personnel carriers into exploding units to “blow up the enemy’s most heavily fortified positions,” he added.

“那是我们干的,”一名乌克兰无人机操作员对NBC新闻说,同时表示他的部队正在调往其他地方。“我们的侦察无人机阵地每三周向前推进一次,”这名24岁的士兵在WhatsApp上的一系列语音消息中说。由于所执行任务的敏感性,他只希望以呼号“幸运”示人。普京上周在与军队高层会面时表示,俄军正在整条前线发动进攻。“推进速度已显著加快,”他补充说。

“That was us,” a Ukrainian drone pilot told NBC News as he said his unit was redeploying elsewhere. “Our reconnaissance drone positions moved forward every three weeks,” the soldier, 24, who only wanted to be identified by his call sign Lucky because of the sensitive nature of his service, said in a series of audio messages on WhatsApp. During a meeting with his army chiefs last week, Putin said Russian forces were on the offensive along the entire front line. “The pace of advancement has increased significantly,” he added.

总部位于华盛顿的战争研究所高级俄罗斯分析师乔治·巴罗斯表示,该机构每天都在分析乌克兰的战场局势,他们评估认为,自今年初以来,俄罗斯在整个乌克兰仅净占领了约40平方英里的领土。“这意味着俄罗斯的日均推进速度远低于每天0.4平方英里。这简直是以步速推进,”他说。“在9月,我们观察到的证据表明,乌克兰实际上收复和夺回的领土比俄罗斯多。”

But George Barros, a senior Russia analyst with the Washington-based Institute for the Study of War, which has provided daily analysis of the battlefield situation in Ukraine, said they assess that Russia has seized a net of only about 40 square miles across all of Ukraine since the beginning of the year. “That means that the daily average Russian rate of advance is far below 0.4 square miles per day. This is a literal foot-pace advance,” he said. “In the month of September, we observed evidence to assess that the Ukrainians actually liberated and took back more territory than the Russians did.”

2026年10月16日,乌克兰扎波罗热地区国家警察独立步兵营的士兵在顿涅茨克地区乌克兰境内将一架GARA无人机搬运至掩体内。来自扎波罗热地区国家警察独立步兵营的一名炮兵组士兵Soldiers from a separate task force rifle battalion of the National Police of Ukraine in the Zaporizhzhia region carry a GARA UAV to a shelter in the Donetsk region, Ukraine, October 16, 2026. An artillery crew soldier from the Separate Rifle Battalion of the National Police in the Zaporizhzhia regi

普京的军队首脑、瓦列里·格拉西莫夫大将告诉俄罗斯领导人,乌克兰的进攻是一系列“公关噱头”,一无所获,并让乌克兰损失了3500名阵亡或受伤的士兵。但巴罗斯说,这次进攻让乌克兰得以在无人机主导的战场上推进坦克和装甲运兵车,化解俄罗斯的无人机防御,并找到方法推进部队、取得进展。军事专家表示,至关重要的是,它阻止了顿涅茨克坚固城市的北部包围,给普京今年完成攻占顿巴斯的计划拧了一把扳手。

Putin’s army chief, Gen. Valery Gerasimov, told the Russian leader that the Ukrainian offensive was a series of “PR stunts” that achieved nothing and cost Ukraine 3,500 troops who had been either killed or wounded. But Barros said the offensive allowed Ukraine to push forward with tanks and armored personnel carriers into the drone-dominated battlefield, negate Russian drone defenses and find ways to push its forces forward and make gains. Critically, it stopped the northern encirclement of the stronghold cities in Donetsk, putting a wrench in Putin’s plans to complete the capture of Donbas this year, military experts said.

“乌克兰的‘维瓦尔第行动’毫无疑问是一次重大成功,”哥伦比亚大学萨尔兹曼战争与和平研究所高级研究学者拉詹·梅农说。但梅农表示,“星盾”限制是“乌克兰的严重问题”,“却是普京的天赐良机”。巴罗斯说,如果限制持续到中长期,俄罗斯部队将能够恢复其在靠近前线的受控地区的后勤,而乌克兰今年一直在用中程打击猛击这些地区。他补充说,结果是俄罗斯可能重获资源,以更大的作战节奏推进,增加了突破的可能性。

“Ukraine’s Operation Vivaldi was unquestionably a major success,” said Rajan Menon, senior research scholar at Columbia University’s Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies. But the Starshield slowdown is a “severe problem for Ukraine,” Menon said, “and a godsend for Putin.”If the restrictions continue for the medium- to long-term, Russian forces will be able to restore their logistics in the regions close to the front line that they control and that Ukraine has been pummeling with middle-range strikes this year, Barros said. As a result, Russia could regain resources to push forward with greater operational tempo, he added, increasing the likelihood of a breakthrough.

9月,一面乌克兰国旗系在前线城镇德鲁日基夫卡(顿涅茨克地区,乌克兰)中心一座恋人雕塑上。 Iryna Rybakova / Ukraine's 93rd Mechanized Brigade via APA Ukrainian flag tied to a sculpture of lovers in the center of the frontline town of Druzhkivka, Donetsk region, Ukraine, in September. Iryna Rybakova / Ukraine's 93rd Mechanized Brigade via AP

但接受NBC新闻采访的士兵中,至少有两人表示,星链并非在整条前线都普遍降速。一名在顿涅茨克服役的无人机技术员同样因服役敏感性要求不具名,他表示其所在单位未见性能出现任何大幅下降。“考虑到最近的天气,速度下降和服务情况似乎都正常,”这名31岁的士兵说,并补充称他知道其他单位正遭遇困难。针对士兵们的批评,五角大楼回应NBC新闻的置评请求时,援引了国防部长皮特·赫格塞斯周三的讲话,他在讲话中重申美国在任何方面都未改变对乌克兰的立场,称其对抗俄罗斯是“英勇的努力”。

But at least two of the soldiers interviewed told NBC News that Starlink was not slowed down universally across the front lines. A drone technician serving in Donetsk, who also asked not to be named due to the sensitive nature of his service, said his unit hasn’t seen any major drops in performance. “Given the recent weather, the speed dips and service seemed normal,” the soldier, 31, said, adding that he was aware that other units were experiencing difficulties. The Pentagon responded to NBC News’ request for comment on the soldiers’ criticisms by referring to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s remarks Wednesday in which he reiterated that the U.S. has not changed its posture toward Ukraine in any way, calling its fight against Russia “a heroic effort.”

阅读媒体原文 ↗