字号·· | 护眼
卫报

美国军队被指“武器化”索马里洪灾,将妇女儿童困在厄尔尼诺路径上US forces accused of ‘weaponising’ Somalia’s floods by trapping women and children in the path of El Niño

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

2023年,在摩加迪沙,一名美国特种作战上校(左)与一名由美军特种部队训练的索马里军队分支士兵。 摄影:Jonathan Torgovnik/盖蒂图片社A colonel from US special operations in Somalia with a soldier from a branch of the Somali army trained by US special forces, in Mogadishu in 2023. Photograph: Jonathan Torgovnik/Getty Images

水位正在迅速上涨,已淹至卡伊尼·阿里的腰部。她的家距离南索马里泛滥的朱巴河仅五米,根本无法幸免。无处可逃。这位六个孩子的母亲说,阿里所在的吉利卜市正遭受袭击,反复的空袭将居民钉在涨水的河边。

The water was rising rapidly. It had already reached Cayni Ali’s waist. Her home, five metres from the flooded River Juba in southern Somalia, never stood a chance. There was nowhere to go. Ali’s city of Jilib was under attack. Repeated airstrikes, said the mother of six, were pinning its population beside the rising river.

“无人机一直来,”这位27岁的妇女说,“我们一直能听到它们的声音。它们杀牲畜,杀平民。城镇很大,但到处都是破坏。”

“The drones come all the time,” said the 27-year-old. “We hear them constantly. They kill animals, civilians. The town is big but destruction is everywhere.”Cayni Ali with her child Mandeq at a health centre in Kismayo, Somalia.

来自吉利卜附近马伦达村的阿绍·奥马尔描述说,“持续不断”的空袭迫使人们向朱巴河岸边聚集。“到处都是空袭,难以移动。这么多人被杀害。”

Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham Asho Omar from Malenda, a village near Jilib, described “constant” airstrikes that had forced people towards the banks of the Juba. “The airstrikes are everywhere; it is difficult to move. So many people have been killed.”

他们的证词难得一窥“青年党”这一控制索马里30%领土的伊斯兰武装组织大本营内部的生活。由于与外界隔绝,居民描述了一座正在承受大量平民伤亡的城市。据称,尸体就躺在街道上。

Their testimony offers a rare glimpse of life inside the stronghold of al-Shabaab , the Islamist militants who control 30% of Somalia. Closed off from the outside world, residents describe a city dealing with significant civilian casualties. Bodies, some said, lay in the streets.

这场正在进行的冲突是一场法律地位模糊、隐蔽的战争,由美国在东非协调指挥,对索马里平民造成的伤害几乎没有任何问责。

The ongoing conflict is a legally ambiguous, shadowy war coordinated by the United States in east Africa, in which there is little accountability for harm to Somali civilians.

Cayni Ali 在索马里基斯马尤的一家卫生中心抱着她的孩子 Mandeq。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamCayni Ali with her child Mandeq at a health centre in Kismayo, Somalia. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

美国非洲司令部(非洲司令部)拒绝分享一场明显在加速的军事行动的“作战安全”细节,该行动也引发了关于潜在美国秘密空袭的质疑。但这场针对“青年党”事实上首都的攻势,或许还有更黑暗的一面。

The United States Africa Command (Africom) would not share “operational security” details of a seemingly accelerating campaign that has also raised questions over potential covert US strikes. But there is, perhaps, an even darker dimension to the offensive on al-Shabaab’s de facto capital .

消息人士称,军事战略似乎意在利用迅速增强的厄尔尼诺现象,“将其武器化”,淹没生活在“青年党”控制区的人们,预计厄尔尼诺现象将从本月开始加剧索马里的雨季。

Sources say the military strategy appears to be seeking to drown those living in al-Shabaab territory by “weaponising” a rapidly strengthening El Niño , forecast to intensify Somalia’s rainy season from this month.

航拍视角下的朱巴河,靠近基斯马尤镇。摄影:休·金塞拉·坎宁安“空袭迫使民众向河流靠拢。这是一场极具侵略性的攻势,利用厄尔尼诺现象作为战争武器,将民众推向易发洪水的区域,”一名监测索马里南部朱巴河泛滥平原的消息人士表示。

An aerial view of the Juba River, close to the town of Kismayo. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham “The airstrikes are forcing people to go close to the river. It’s an extremely aggressive offensive, exploiting El Niño as a weapon of war to push the population into flood-prone areas,” said a source monitoring the Juba floodplain in southern Somalia.

将民众——其中包括大量妇女和儿童——钉在河流泛滥平原上,引发了对未来几个月可能发生大规模死亡的担忧。

Pinning the population – which includes large numbers of women and children – on the river’s floodplain has raised concerns of large-scale deaths in the months ahead.

“官方说法是他们针对的是军事阵地和‘青年党’,但由于‘青年党’嵌入在社区之中,很难避免附带损害,”该消息人士补充道。

“The official line is that they are targeting military positions and al-Shabaab, but because al-Shabaab is embedded within the community, it’s difficult to avoid collateral damage,” added the source.

朱巴河靠近基斯马尤镇一段的航拍图。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamAn aerial view of the Juba River, close to the town of Kismayo. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

上一次厄尔尼诺现象袭击索马里是在2023年,它导致该国百年来最严重的洪水,造成120多万人流离失所。分析人士质疑美军据称利用易发洪水区域的测绘数据——这些数据原本旨在减少平民伤亡——来造成伤害的伦理性。

When El Niño last struck Somalia in 2023, it caused the worst floods seen in the country for a century, displacing more than 1.2 million people . Analysts have questioned the ethics of the US military allegedly using mapping data from flood-prone areas – conceived to mitigate civilian casualties – to inflict harm.

丹麦国际研究所高级研究员杰思罗·诺曼表示:“将厄尔尼诺现象武器化是一个过程的逆转——利用人道主义遥感技术造成伤亡,而非减轻危害。你捕捉到了在厄尔尼诺洪水背景下持续空袭行动的累积影响。”

Jethro Norman, a senior researcher with the Danish Institute for International Studies , said: “A weaponisation of El Niño is a reversal of process – using humanitarian remote sensing to inflict casualties rather than to mitigate harm. You capture the cumulative impact of a sustained airstrikes campaign in an El Niño flooding context.”

2023年厄尔尼诺现象过后,朱巴兰的卢乌克区遭遇了该国有史以来最严重的洪水。

The aftermath of the 2023 El Niño in Luuq district, Jubaland, which caused the worst floods ever seen in the country.

美国官方否认利用气候因素。一名发言人表示:“非洲司令部不以平民为目标,不为驱逐平民而开展行动,也不将天气或洪水作为作战手段。非洲司令部针对合法军事目标,并采取可行措施减轻平民伤害。”

US officials deny exploiting climatic factors. A spokesperson said: “Africom does not target civilians, conduct operations for the purpose of displacing civilian populations or use weather or flooding as a method of warfare. Africom targets lawful military objectives and takes feasible measures to mitigate civilian harm.”

2023年厄尔尼诺现象在朱巴兰卢克区造成的灾后景象,引发了该国有史以来最严重的洪水。 摄影:Feisal Omar/路透社The aftermath of the 2023 El Niño in Luuq district, Jubaland, which caused the worst floods ever seen in the country. Photograph: Feisal Omar/Reuters

尽管如此,许多人仍在质疑,利用天气削弱“青年党”的机会是否过于诱人而无法忽视,从而导致一场归咎于超强厄尔尼诺现象的灾难性溺亡事件。

Nevertheless, many wonder if the opportunity to weaken al-Shabaab using the weather was too tempting to ignore, offering a catastrophic drowning event blamed on a supercharged El Niño .

与许多城市一样,在极端天气时代,吉利卜的地理位置被证明存在缺陷。这座城市位于低洼平原上,长期容易遭受洪水侵袭。2023年,大片农田被淹没。来自吉利卜以南卡姆苏马的哈利莫·阿卜迪卡迪尔描述了她家被毁的情况,她家距离河流6英里(10公里)。“夜里洪水来得很快——洪水退去后,到处都是泥浆。许多动物被淹死了。”

Like many cities, Jilib’s location has been found wanting in an era of extreme weather. On a low-lying plain, the city is chronically vulnerable to flooding. In 2023, vast swathes of farmland were submerged. Halimo Abdikadir from Kamsuuma, south of Jillib, described the destruction of her home, 6 miles (10km) from the river. “The waters came quickly at night – when they left, everything was mud. A lot of animals drowned.”

来自吉利卜郊外另一个村庄艾哈迈德亚雷的阿尔贝·法穆预计,这次厄尔尼诺现象将比2023年严重得多:她种植的玉米和高粱已被水淹没。“吉利卜已经发生了严重洪灾,”这位70岁的老人说。

Arbey Famu from Ahmed Yare, another village outside Jilib, expects this El Niño to be far worse than 2023 : her crops of maize and sorghum are underwater. “In Jilib, there is big flooding already,” said the 70-year-old.

美国国防部官员将会了解厄尔尼诺现象对青年党腹地影响的早期迹象。联合国机构表示,朱巴河流域“尤其令人担忧”。与此同时,红十字国际委员会(ICRC)预计将出现“严重洪灾”。

US defence officials will know the early indicators of El Niño’s impact in al-Shabaab’s heartland. UN agencies say the Juba River basin is of “particular concern”. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) , meanwhile, foresees “severe flooding”.

阿尔贝·阿卜迪·法穆,基斯马尤达尔希斯卡流离失所者营地的居民。摄影:休·金塞拉·坎宁安使用地面部队进攻吉利卜风险很大。空袭可以取得诸如10月1日一名青年党高级指挥官被击毙这样的胜利,但无法攻占一座拥有10万人口的城市。

Arbey Abdi Famu, a resident of the Dalhiska displacement camp in Kismayo. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham Attacking Jilib using ground forces carries much risk. Airstrikes can yield triumphs such as the death of a senior al-Shabaab commander on 1 October, but are unable to overrun a city of 100,000.

朱巴兰州流离失所者事务专员阿里·阿丹·阿里感到担忧。在他的基斯马尤办公室里,阿里确定了327个易受洪水影响的地区。截至10月,厄尔尼诺预警只发布给了其中一半地区。

Ali Adan Ali, the commissioner for displaced people in Jubaland , is worried. In his Kismayo office, Ali identified 327 regions prone to flooding. By October, El Niño warnings had only been issued to half.

Arbey Abdi Famu,索马里基斯马尤达利斯卡流离失所者营地的居民。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamArbey Abdi Famu, a resident of the Dalhiska displacement camp in Kismayo. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

他最担心的是缺少船只。他说,没有船只,青年党控制区内数千人可能被困在河东岸,无法到达朱巴河河口的基斯马尤寻求帮助。

His chief concern is the lack of boats. Without them, he says, thousands in al-Shabaab territory risk being trapped on the east side of the river, unable to reach help in Kismayo, at the mouth of the Juba.

基斯马尤街头的人们,长期干旱和美国国际开发署的削减给他们带来了苦难。摄影:休·金塞拉·坎宁安阿里说,三年前上一次厄尔尼诺现象期间,1.9万人被困了一周,没有食物。“我们的时间不多了,”他说。

People on the streets of Kismayo, where long-term drought and USAID cuts have brought misery. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham Three years ago, during the last El Niño, Ali says, 19,000 people were stranded for a week without food. “We are running out of time,” he says.

船只的缺席概括了索马里的资金困境。2023年,该国的援助预算为22亿美元。如今仅剩约30万美元。防洪投资已大幅缩水。

The absence of boats sums up Somalia’s funding woes. In 2023, the country’s aid budget was $2.2bn. Now it stands at about $300,000. Flood protection investment has dwindled.

索马里基斯马尤街头的民众,长期干旱和美国国际开发署(USAID)削减援助给当地带来了苦难。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamPeople on the streets of Kismayo, where long-term drought and USAID cuts have brought misery. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

令担忧加剧的是,青年党在其控制区内缺乏应急准备。阿里尚未收到武装分子关于厄尔尼诺备灾的回复。凯尼·阿里表示,吉利卜目前尚未部署任何沙袋或防洪设施。沿河修建了土墙,但已被证明不够用。

Compounding concerns is al-Shabaab’s lack of preparedness in the area it controls. Ali has not received a response from the militants regarding El Niño readiness. Cayni Ali said there are no sandbags or flood defences deployed yet in Jilib. Earth walls were erected along the river but have proved insufficient.

“它们不够大,”她说。朱巴河最新的洪水预警敦促社区“加固”薄弱的河岸。

“They are not big enough,” she said. The latest flood advisory for the River Juba urges communities to “reinforce” weak riverbanks.

相互印证的证词描述了针对青年党的长期——且似乎不分青红皂白的——空袭行动,似乎已造成大量平民死亡。美国不愿分享潜在平民死亡人数的细节,理由是“保护美国和伙伴部队并维护行动安全”。

Corroborating testimonies describe a prolonged – and seemingly indiscriminate – campaign of airstrikes against al-Shabaab that appears to have killed many civilians. The US would not share details of potential civilian fatalities “to protect US and partner forces and preserve operational security”.

法尔汉·艾哈迈德一直住在吉利卜,直到上个月逃离,他描述了持续的恐惧。“每天都有空袭,一直都有。”一次空袭夷平了他所在街区的五栋房屋。35岁的艾哈迈德描述说,城市街道上遍布尸体。

Farhan Ahmed, who lived in Jilib until fleeing last month, described constant terror. “There were airstrikes every day, all the time.”One strike flattened five homes in his neighbourhood. Ahmed, 35, described bodies littering the city streets.

法杜莫·阿卜迪声称空袭基本上未能击中武装分子。“袭击主要杀害的是平民。有些人被埋葬了,但有些人没有,”她说。

Fadumo Abdi claimed the airstrikes were largely failing to target militants. “The attacks are mostly killing civilians. Some were buried, but some were not,” she said.

来自卡姆苏马的阿卜迪卡迪尔补充说:“对吉利卜的无人机袭击太多了。太多人死去。”

Abdikadir, from Kamsuuma, added: “The drone attacks on Jilib are too much. So many people die.”

27岁的优素福·西迪来自贾马梅附近、青年党控制区内阿拉雷,他目睹了三名青少年在一次空袭中丧生。玛丽安·萨拉赫当时在贾马梅附近的家中,一架无人机将一块20厘米长的燃烧金属碎片送入她的后院,落在她两岁女儿旁边。“太近了。我非常愤怒。我与冲突无关。”

Yusuf Siidi, 27, from Araare near Jamame in al-Shabaab territory, witnessed three teenagers killed in one strike. Maryan Salah was at home near Jamame when a drone sent a shard of burning metal 20cm long into her back yard, landing next to her two-year-old daughter. “ It was so close. I am very angry. I’m not part of the conflict.”

萨拉赫的险情发生在当前攻势之前。她只记得那发生在“3月中旬”。美国承认3月19日在贾马梅附近进行了一次无人机空袭,但未提供其他数据。

Salah’s near miss predates the current offensive. She can recall only that it happened in “mid-March”. The US admits a drone strike near Jamame on 19 March, but no other data is provided.

一位母亲带着她的婴儿来到基斯马尤的索马里红新月会健康中心检查营养不良症状。摄影:休·金塞拉·坎宁安尽管目击者的描述详述了吉利卜发生了数量异常之多的空袭,但美国官方记录仅确认8月份在吉利卜进行了一次空袭。上个月发生了六次。从8月初至今,美国表示总共仅实施了11次空袭。

A mother takes her baby to a Somalia Red Crescent Society health centre in Kismayo to check for symptoms of malnutrition. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham Although eyewitness accounts detail an extraordinary number of strikes in Jilib, official US records confirm only one airstrike in Jilib during August. Six took place last month. Between the start of August and now, the US says it conducted a total of just 11 strikes.

一名母亲带着婴儿前往基斯马尤的索马里红新月会卫生中心,检查营养不良症状。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamA mother takes her baby to a Somalia Red Crescent Society health centre in Kismayo to check for symptoms of malnutrition. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

含糊其辞的指控日益成为美国在索马里行动的特征。这种不透明的做法引发了人们对非洲司令部是否授权在该地区进行秘密空袭的质疑。

Allegations of ambiguity increasingly characterise US operations in Somalia. It is an opaque approach that raises questions over whether Africom has authorised covert airstrikes in the region.

最近医院的记录显示存在密集空袭或战斗。今年,红十字国际委员会在基斯马尤治疗了205名“与武器相关”伤害的患者,比去年增加了43%。

Records from the nearest hospital indicate intensive airstrikes or fighting. The ICRC has treated 205 patients with “weapon-related” injuries in Kismayo this year, a 43% increase on last year.

新美国智库分析师戴维·斯特曼表示:“当出现归属不明的空袭时,我们看到美国秘密空袭的可能性始终挥之不去。”

David Sterman, analyst at the New America thinktank, said: “The possibility that we are seeing covert US strikes always looms large when there are strikes without clear attribution.”

9月,基斯马尤医院重症监护病房里一名营养不良的三个月大婴儿。摄影:休·金塞拉·坎宁安然而,美国表示已公布“其在索马里授权下进行的所有空袭。我们不保留未披露或未宣布的空袭计数。”

A malnourished three-month-old baby in Kismayo hospital’s intensive-care ward in September. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham The US, however, said it publicised “all airstrikes conducted under its authority in Somalia. We do not maintain an undisclosed or unannounced strike count.”

9月,基斯马尤医院重症监护病房内一名营养不良的三个月大婴儿。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamA malnourished three-month-old baby in Kismayo hospital’s intensive-care ward in September. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

土耳其也使用无人机在索马里打击青年党。土耳其与非洲司令部协同行动,但很少透露其在索马里空袭或军事行动的任何细节。

Turkey has also used drones to target al-Shabaab in Somalia. Operating alongside Africom, Turkey rarely divulges any details of its strikes or military operations in Somalia.

除了空袭和洪水之外,索马里人最关心的是饥饿。逃离朱巴河谷的人——地方当局正在向逃出的人提供人道主义援助——表示没有足够的食物维持生计。

Beyond airstrikes and floods, the primary concern for Somalis is hunger . Those fleeing the Juba valley – local authorities are offering humanitarian help to those who escape – say there is insufficient food to sustain them.

奥马尔一家13口每天靠一条鱼生存。鱼有多大?奥马尔双手比出的距离不到30厘米。

Omar’s family of 13 survives on one fish a day. How big is the fish? Omar held her hands less than 30cm apart.

来自贾马梅的55岁哈比巴·阿里说,她的家庭——和许多家庭一样——每天共享一顿玉米饭。其余时间则用来躲避冲突。“当战斗停止时,我们等待它再次开始。”在基斯马尤,长期干旱和美国国际开发署的削减同样带来了苦难。

Habiba Ali, 55, from Jamame, said her family – like many – shares one daily meal of maize. Time in between is spent hiding from conflict. “When the fighting stops, we wait for it start again.”In Kismayo, too, long-term drought and USAID cuts have brought misery.

32岁的舒克里·艾哈迈德是加尔贝德难民营的负责人,他估计,自特朗普政府去年突然关闭美国国际开发署以来,基斯马尤各个流离失所者安置点网络中可能已有6000人死亡。一夜之间,有两名儿童在临时搭建的棚屋里因腹泻死亡。

Shukri Ahmed, 32, the president of Galbeed refugee camp, estimates that 6,000 might have died in Kismayo’s network of displacement sites since the Trump administration abruptly shut USAID last year. Overnight, two children had died in makeshift shelters from diarrhoea.

联合国支持、负责认定饥荒的机构警告说,厄尔尼诺现象将“加深(索马里)的饥饿程度”。

El Niño will “deepen [Somalia’s] hunger levels”, warns the UN-backed body responsible for identifying famine.

扎卡里亚·穆罕默德在基斯马尤一家由红十字国际委员会支持的医院担任护士长已有五年,他说,每天都有来自青年党控制区的儿童被送到这里,他们严重营养不良或极度虚弱,已无法挽救。今年儿童营养不良率上升了40%。

Zakaria Mohammed, head nurse at Kismayo’s ICRC-supported hospital for five years, says children from al-Shabaab territory arrive every day so severely malnourished or weak they cannot be saved. Cases of child malnutrition rates have risen 40% this year.

哈沃·纳克多尔及时赶到了。青年党曾阻止她离开贾马梅去为她的孩子接受治疗。但她14个月大的女儿法杜莫奄奄一息,于是纳克多尔在夜里逃了出来。

Xaawo Nacdoor made it just in time. Al-Shabaab had blocked her leaving Jamame to receive treatment for her baby. But her 14-month-old daughter Faadumo was dying, so Nacdoor fled at night.

Fadumo Abdi 在基斯马尤医院婴儿重症监护室陪伴着她14个月大的女儿 Maryan。 摄影:Hugh Kinsella CunninghamFadumo Abdi with her 14-month-old baby, Maryan, in the infant intensive-care unit in Kismayo hospital. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham

法杜莫·阿卜迪和她14个月大的孩子玛丽安在基斯马尤医院的婴儿重症监护室。摄影:休·金塞拉·坎宁安纳克多尔背着女儿,只带了一瓶水,走了三天。第二天,这个幼儿失去了意识。

Fadumo Abdi with her 14-month-old baby, Maryan, in the infant intensive-care unit in Kismayo hospital. Photograph: Hugh Kinsella Cunningham For three days, with just a bottle of water, Nacdoor walked with her daughter strapped to her back. On the second day, the toddler lost consciousness.

“她严重脱水,但我一直往前走。”到达医院时,法杜莫体重4.1公斤。三天后:4.4公斤。她活了下来。

“She was severely dehydrated, but I kept going.”Arriving at the hospital, Faadumo weighed 4.1kg. Three days later: 4.4kg. She survived.

这里的多数病人发誓绝不回家,他们说,在青年党统治下的生活意味着没有学校、没有教育、没有医疗保健,也没有食物。对于朱巴河两岸的数千个家庭——往往是最贫困的家庭——来说,情况即将变得更糟得多。

Most patients here vow never to return home, saying life under al-Shabaab meant no school, education, healthcare or food. For the thousands of families straddling the Juba River – often the poorest – things are about to get much worse.

阅读媒体原文 ↗