
中国专家警告称,潜在的“跛脚鸭”时期可能无法阻止美国总统唐纳德·特朗普在中期选举后推行更多“交易式”或“冒险式”外交政策举措,同时对强大“民主党浪潮”的预期表示怀疑。
A potential lame-duck phase may not deter US President Donald Trump from pursuing more “transactional” or “risky” foreign policy moves after the midterm elections, Chinese experts warn, while casting doubt on expectations of a powerful Democratic wave.
在一系列可能重塑全球政治格局的高风险角逐中,美国周二的投票格外引人注目。
Amid a season of high-stakes contests that could reshape global politics, the US vote on Tuesday stands out.
这场将决定谁控制美国国会的选举,可能导致特朗普及其共和党同僚在未来两年不再掌握所有权力杠杆。
The election, which will determine who takes control of the US Congress, could result in Trump and his fellow Republicans no longer holding all the levers of power over the next two years.
多个模型和评级预测,民主党有望翻转众议院,尽管预测对净增席位数存在分歧。
Multiple models and ratings project that Democrats are on track to flip the House of Representatives, although forecasts differ on what the net seat gain will be.
近几个月也出现迹象表明,民主党一度狭窄的横扫两院之路已有所拓宽,尽管大多数被视为摇摆不定的参议院席位位于传统红州,意味着民主党必须在共和党腹地取胜。
There have also been signs in recent months that the party’s once narrow path to sweeping both chambers has widened, even though most of the Senate seats regarded as toss-ups are in traditionally red states, meaning the Democrats must win in Republican territory.
中国观察人士一致认为,11月3日的美国中期选举极有可能迎来分裂政府。
Observers in China agree that the US midterms on November 3 are likely to usher in a divided government.
他们预期,这种变化可能使特朗普面临更多调查监督,增加众议院民主党主导弹劾的可能性,并导致国会僵局,阻碍其政府在余下第二任期内的立法、人事和预算议程。
They expect that such a shift could expose Trump to increased investigative oversight, raise the odds of impeachment led by House Democrats, and induce congressional gridlock for his administration’s legislative, personnel and budget priorities for the rest of his second term.
“未来两年可能是特朗普的‘跛脚鸭’[时期],”北京中国人民大学专攻美国政治的国际关系教授刁大明说。
“The next two years could be a lame-duck [period for Trump],” said Diao Daming, an international relations professor specialising in US politics at Renmin University in Beijing.
不过,刁大明表示,特朗普一直在持续扩大总统权力,并可能继续通过大量行政命令绕过国会推进政策,从而引发更多法律纠纷的前景。
Still, Diao said Trump had been consistently expanding presidential power and was likely to continue his approach of bypassing Congress through a barrage of executive orders to advance policies, leading to the prospect of more legal disputes.
据“美国总统项目”统计,截至10月22日,特朗普在其第二任期前半段已签署292项行政命令——超过了其整个第一任期签署的220项。
As of October 22, Trump had already signed 292 executive orders during the first half of his second term – outpacing the 220 signed during his entire first term – according to the American Presidency Project.
其中,他在重返白宫的前100天内签署了140多项行政命令,这一数字远超历任前任总统在同一时期签署的总数。
Of those, more than 140 were signed in his first 100 days back in the White House, dwarfing the total issued by any predecessor over the same time frame.
美国对俄罗斯、伊朗、欧洲和中国的政策可能在高压施压与部分讨价还价之间迅速摆动。赵志江 尽管特朗普在中期选举后可能在推进立法方面空间变小,但他仍可能在行政和外交政策行动上保持活跃,上海复旦大学社会科学研究员孟维瞻在上月底的一条社交媒体帖子中写道。“他仍然能决定很多事情,”孟维瞻写道。
US policy towards Russia, Iran, Europe and China could swing rapidly between heavy pressuring and partial bargaining. Zhao Zhijiang Although Trump might emerge from the midterm elections with less room to advance legislation, he could remain active on executive and foreign policy actions, Meng Weizhan, a social sciences researcher at Fudan University in Shanghai, wrote in a social media post late last month. “He can still decide a lot of things,” Meng wrote.
他指出,即使仅持续几个月,关税、企业许可证、制裁执行、军事部署或高级官员任命方面的单一决定,都可能产生现实后果。
Even if lasting only a few months, a single decision on tariffs, corporate licences, sanctions enforcement, military deployments or senior official appointments could have real-world consequences, he noted.
“他仍有能力改变政策方向,尽管某些政策将难以维持,”孟维瞻补充道。
“He still has the capacity to change policy direction, although some policies will be hard to sustain,” Meng added.
北京独立智库安邦智库的研究助理赵志江也预计,特朗普将在贸易、关税、制裁、移民执法、行政监管、外交和国家安全等领域保留相当大的自由裁量空间。
Zhao Zhijiang, a research assistant at Beijing-based independent think tank Anbound, also expected Trump to retain considerable latitude in areas such as trade, tariffs, sanctions, immigration enforcement, administrative regulation, diplomacy and national security.
虽然特朗普本人在中期选举后将进入总统任期的后期阶段,但“特朗普主义不一定会同步衰退”,赵志江表示,年轻的共和党人正在接管这一运动的政治路线。
While Trump himself would enter the later stage of his presidency after the midterms, “Trumpism will not necessarily decline in tandem”, Zhao said, adding that younger Republicans were taking up the movement’s political line.
“所谓的‘跛脚鸭’问题更多关乎特朗普的个人任期。特朗普主义能否长期延续,才是判断美国政治未来走向的更重要变量,”他说。
“The so-called lame duck problem is more about Trump’s personal term in office. Whether Trumpism can endure over the long run is the more important variable for gauging the future shape of American politics,” he said.
共和党以在众参两院均占据微弱多数的姿态进入中期选举竞争,此时多项民调显示特朗普的国内支持率处于历史低位。
Republicans are heading into the midterm race with slim majorities in both the House and Senate, at a time when several polls show Trump’s domestic approval ratings at record lows.
周二的投票被广泛视为对美国总统的一次公投,尽管这位被视为善变的领导人——他颠覆了美国协助建立的二战后秩序——并不在选票上。
The vote on Tuesday has been widely framed as a referendum on the US president, even though the man – who has been perceived as a mercurial leader upending the post-World War II order that the US helped build – is not on the ballot.
他的首个任期见证了共和党失去约40个席位,在2018年中期选举中丧失众议院多数党地位,尽管他们在参议院以净增两席的优势扩大了多数优势。随之而来的是两年的调查、传票和弹劾。
His first presidency saw Republicans yield about 40 seats, losing their House majority in the 2018 midterms, although they expanded their Senate majority with a two-seat net gain. What followed were two years of investigations, subpoenas and impeachment.
全球目光聚焦于选举能否激发民主党重演此类局面,以制衡特朗普。
The global spotlight is fixed on whether the elections can galvanise Democrats to repeat such a scenario to keep Trump in check.
所有435个众议院席位、100个参议院席位中的35个,以及50个州州长职位中的36个,将在中期选举中决出。
All 435 House seats, 35 of the 100 Senate seats and 36 of the 50 state governorships will be decided in the midterm elections.
刁大明表示,民主党夺回众议院“几乎是一个高概率事件”,并补充说参议院结果较难预测,但共和党失去控制权的可能性“持续上升”。
A Democratic takeover of the House is “almost a high-probability event”, said Diao, adding that the outcome in the Senate remained harder to call but the likelihood of Republicans losing their grip there was “continuing to rise”.
不过,他预计赢得一个议院,甚至两个,未必能让民主党获得主导议程的权力。
However, he expected that winning one chamber, or even both, would not necessarily secure Democrats the power to dominate the agenda.
刁大明说:“即使民主党卷土重来,也可能感觉像是一个脆弱的、甚至微弱的、甚至无效的多数派。”
“Even if the Democrats come back, it may feel like a fragile, even narrow, even ineffective majority,” Diao said.
刁大明表示,如果民主党仅以微弱优势控制众议院,可能不得不调整一些政策,以容纳党内崛起的民主社会主义派系,他们的观点往往与党内建制派背道而驰。
If Democrats get a thin House majority, they might have to adjust some policies to accommodate the party’s rising democratic socialist wing, whose views often diverge from those of the party establishment, Diao said.
即使民主党翻转参议院,他们也可能仅拥有极其微弱的多数优势,这将不足以终结阻挠议事,或者难以维持团结,因为宾夕法尼亚州民主党参议员约翰·费特曼可能在许多问题上与共和党站在一起。其他中国分析人士也表达了类似评估。
Even if Democrats flipped the Senate, they would probably hold only a razor-thin majority, which would be either insufficient to end a filibuster or difficult to hold together, given that Pennsylvania’s Democratic Senator John Fetterman could align with Republicans on many issues. The assessment was echoed by other Chinese analysts.
孟彦在其报告中写道:“即使民主党控制两院,他们仍将难以绕过总统否决权,自行推行一整套新政策。”
“Even if Democrats controlled both chambers, they would still find it difficult to get around the presidential veto to enact a full slate of new policies on their own,” Meng wrote in his note.
他指出,共和党可能以微弱优势保住参议院控制权,而民主党有望夺得众议院控制权。
He noted that Republicans might narrowly hold the Senate while Democrats could take the House.
他还指出,自去年以来,多个州重新划分了国会选区地图,这可能使民主党在众议院获胜的规模存疑;同时,由于竞选开支、选民投票率和当地基础等因素,一些共和党候选人可能在部分胶着选区的表现优于民调预测。
He also noted that several states’ redrawing of congressional maps since last year could leave the scale of any Democratic House win in question, while some Republican candidates could outperform the polls in some tight districts due to campaign spending, voter turnout and local footprint.
安邦智库的赵某表示,共和党近期为巩固竞选动员和防线所作的努力,加上部分候选人在具体议题上与特朗普保持距离,使得早先预测中民主党大获全胜的局面变得更加不确定。
Zhao from Anbound said that recent Republican efforts to shore up campaign mobilisation and defences, together with some candidates distancing themselves from Trump on specific issues, had made a Democratic landslide in earlier projections more uncertain.
他引用民调显示,美国民众对两党解决国家问题的能力均缺乏信心。“目前的局势看起来更像是对执政的[共和]党的惩罚,而非对民主党的强力支持,”他说。
He cited surveys showing that Americans lacked confidence in either party’s ability to solve the country’s problems. “The current situation looks more like a punishment of the [Republican] party in power than strong support for the Democrats,” he said.
刁某也表示,除了批评共和党,民主党并未提供明确的解决方案;通胀、中东冲突推高油价以及与加拿大贸易战的后果,加剧了公众对特朗普政府的不满。
Diao also said Democrats had offered no clear solutions beyond criticising Republicans, when inflation, higher oil prices driven by the conflict in the Middle East and the fallout from the trade war with Canada had fuelled public frustration with the Trump administration.
“即使民主党赢得两院控制权,那算所谓的‘蓝色浪潮’吗?你们没有政治纲领……那浪潮由什么构成?”刁某说。“这就是为什么有人说这不是蓝色浪潮,而是红色暗流。”随着华盛顿权力新平衡逼近,中国社交媒体上出现了关于特朗普余下任期是否将进入“垃圾时间”的讨论。
“Even if the Democrats win both chambers, is that a so-called blue wave? You don’t have a political platform … so what would the wave be made of?”Diao said. “That’s why some people say it’s not a blue wave but a red undertow.”As a new balance of power looms over Washington, there has been discussion on Chinese social media over whether Trump will enter “garbage time” for the remainder of his presidency.
专家表示,这种表述偏离了重点。这个广泛使用的体育术语指比赛末段一方领先优势大到无法逆转、胜负已定、球员往往变得消极的阶段。该词近期在中国社交媒体上染上了更浓的政治色彩。赵某表示,特朗普任内最后两年“不会是政策停滞期”。
Experts said the characterisation missed the mark. The widely used sports term refers to the closing stretch of a game when one side has such an insurmountable lead that the outcome is not in doubt and players tend to become passive. The term has recently taken on a more political hue on Chinese social media. Zhao said Trump’s final two years in office “would not be a period of policy stagnation”.
他预计美国总统将在移民问题上保持强硬立场,同时推进能源生产、放松监管、制造业投资和贸易谈判等议题。
He expected the US president to maintain a hard line on immigration while pressing ahead with issues such as energy production, deregulation, manufacturing investment and trade talks.
“外交可能变得更加交易化。美国对俄罗斯、伊朗、欧洲和中国的政策可能在重压施加与部分讨价还价之间快速摇摆,”他说。
“Diplomacy may become even more transactional. US policy towards Russia, Iran, Europe and China could swing rapidly between heavy pressuring and partial bargaining,” he said.
孟预计特朗普在未来两年将维持其狂热的执政风格,尽管宣布的措施与最终落实之间的差距可能扩大,并补充称,可负担性、边境政策和人工智能也将位列其优先事项之中。“外交政策才是真正值得更密切关注的,”他写道。
Meng also expected Trump to keep up his frenetic governing style over the next two years, although the gap between announced measures and eventual delivery could widen, adding that affordability, border policy and AI would also be among his priorities. “Foreign policy is what is really worth watching more closely,” he wrote.
他指出,特朗普似乎最近与乌克兰总统泽连斯基交恶,尽管孟认为,这位美国领导人过去两年一直试图与莫斯科和基辅保持“等距离”。
He noted that Trump appeared to have fallen out with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky recently, although Meng considered that the US leader had spent the last two years trying to maintain an “equal” distance from both Moscow and Kyiv.
“美欧关系的裂痕可能会加深,”他写道。“这可能不受国会影响。”孟补充称,伊朗和古巴问题存在“高度不可预测性”。
“The split in US-Europe ties is likely to deepen,” he wrote. “This is something that may not be influenced by Congress.”Meng added there was a “high degree of unpredictability” over Iran and Cuba.
刁预计特朗普在外交事务上将更加“以政治遗产为导向”,并寻求在该领域有更多作为。
Diao expected Trump to become more “legacy-driven” in foreign affairs and seek to do more in this field.
“另一方面,在他认为自己能够控制或能快速取得成果的领域,他也可能采取一些冒险行动,”他说。
“On the other hand, [in areas] he believes he can control or achieve results quickly, he may also take some risky actions,” he said.