字号·· | 护眼
CNBC

专家:AI智能体可替你炒股——风险与收益并存AI agents can trade stocks for you—here are the risks and benefits, according to experts

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

美国股市:你很有可能在一定程度上接触到了人工智能。而且,根据你投资的方向,人工智能也可能在帮你管理投资组合。

U.S. stock market there's a good chance you have at least some exposure to artificial intelligence And depending on where you invest, AI could be helping you manage your portfolio, too.

在线券商正在推出代理式交易,即由人工智能代理执行投资组合管理的某些环节。这比机器人顾问更进一步,后者根据风险承受能力等偏好自动为投资者构建投资组合。人工智能代理可以帮你根据自然语言提示制定投资策略,并在市场形势变化之际代表你执行交易。

Online brokerages are rolling out agentic trading in which AI agents perform aspects of portfolio management. It goes a bit further than robo-advisors, which automatically build portfolios for investors based on preferences like risk tolerance. AI agents can help you build investment strategies from plain language prompts and execute trades on your behalf amid shifting market conditions.

Robinhood和Webull等在线交易平台的用户可以利用人工智能帮助监测市场走势、制定策略,并将某些经批准的任务自动化。

Users of online trading platforms like Robinhood and Webull can tap AI to help monitor market movement, build strategies and automate certain approved tasks.

如果这听起来就像告诉Claude或ChatGPT,让它们自行判断买卖股票来帮你赚钱,那并非如此。

If that sounds as simple as telling Claude or ChatGPT to go make you money by buying and selling stocks as they see fit, it's not.

“我不认为事情真的是那样运作的,”Robinhood经纪产品与客户服务副总裁阿布希谢克·法特赫普里亚说。该公司于2026年5月推出代理式交易,允许投资者将第三方大型语言模型关联到其Robinhood账户,基于互联网上公开可获取的信息以及用户的投资组合历史,执行投资组合再平衡和市场分析等操作。该公司于9月宣布在Robinhood应用内原生集成人工智能代理,但尚未向所有客户开放。

"I don't think that's really how it works," says Abhishek Fatehpuria, vice president of brokerage product and customer care at Robinhood. The company rolled out agentic trading in May 2026 allowing investors to link a third-party large language model to their Robinhood account to perform actions like portfolio rebalancing and market analysis based on a publicly available information across the internet and a user's portfolio history. It announced AI agents integrated natively on the Robinhood app in September but they are not available to all customers yet.

法特赫普里亚说,投资者仍然必须自己提出投资可能如何让自己受益的假设;代理不会替他们做这件事。不过他说,像Robinhood这样的代理式交易工具可以帮助个人梳理并检验自己的假设。

Investors still have to come up with their own hypothesis for how an investment could benefit them; an agent won't do that for them, Fatehpuria says. Agentic trading tools like Robinhood's, however, can help individuals think through and test their assumptions, he says.

“执行这项工作可能需要海量的工作量,甚至验证那个假设也可能需要海量的工作量,而这正是本产品的核心功能所在,”Fatehpuria 表示。“它并非旨在替代拥有假设这一环节。”执行,而非预测Shridhar Rathore 也认同,AI 智能体不会为你的投资组合创造奇迹。“这不是魔法。它不会为你凭空发明任何东西,”他说道。

"Executing that can require enormous work, or even vetting that hypothesis can require enormous work, and that's really what this product is built to do," Fatehpuria says. "It's not meant to be a substitute for having a hypothesis." Execution, not prediction Shridhar Rathore agrees that an AI agent is not going to do miracles for your portfolio.

这位来自北卡罗来纳州夏洛特市、现年 45 岁的 IT 专业人士于 2026 年 3 月开始尝试智能体交易。他是一位自学成才的投资者,活跃交易已有约 20 年,涉及股票、加密货币和期权策略。他表示,随着投资组合规模扩大,管理工作变得相当耗时。

"It's not magic. It's not going to invent anything for you," he says.

Rathore 于 2025 年 8 月起开始自动化部分投资任务。他编写了一个程序,用于追踪包含 40 至 50 只股票的自选清单,一旦某只股票触及他计划买入或卖出的价位,程序便会发送邮件提醒。随后,他会借助 AI 生成的围绕该股票的市场新闻摘要,辅助决定下一步操作,例如在其网上券商账户中设置限价单——即以特定价格买入或卖出证券的指令。

The 45-year-old IT professional from Charlotte, North Carolina, started experimenting with agentic trading in March 2026. He's a self-taught investor who's been actively trading for around 20 years, including stock, cryptocurrency and options strategies. As his portfolio grew, it became quite time-consuming to manage, he says.

如今,AI 智能体帮他简化了这一流程,提供期权交易分析,并协助他评估潜在风险,以便他自行复核并做出交易决策。

Rathore started automating some investment tasks in August 2025. He built a program that tracked his watchlist of 40 to 50 stocks and emailed him an alert whenever a stock hit a price at which he planned to buy or sell shares. He then used an AI-generated summary of the market news around that stock to help decide his next move, like setting up a limit order — an instruction to buy or sell a security at a certain price — in his online brokerage account, for example.

他订阅了投资通讯 Arora Report,并利用其分析辅助决策。他表示,若没有 Arora Report 提供的信息以及他多年积累的投资经验,智能体交易恐怕对他用处不大,因为智能体更多是用于执行操作,而非预测资产表现。毕竟,再强大的 AI 智能体也无法预知未来。

Now, AI agents have helped streamline that process for him, delivering analyses for options trades and helping him determine his potential risk so he can review and make trading decisions himself.

AI 可能有助于你在短期内更快地行动,但如果你是着眼于长期策略进行投资,那些节省下来的分钟数不会产生太大影响,金融服务公司 Carson Group 投资组合管理总监 Blake Anderson 表示。

He pays for a subscription to Arora Report, an investment newsletter, and uses that analysis to help inform his decisions. Without the information from Arora Report and the investing savvy he's picked up over the years, agentic trading likely wouldn't be of much use to him, he says, because the agents are more for executing actions than predicting how assets will perform. Even the most powerful AI agent can't predict the future, after all.

“AI 很可能有助于降低交易延迟,但投资预期可能不会有太大差别,”他说。“作为一名基本面投资者,利用 AI 执行交易,不太可能改变所买入企业的长期盈利潜力。”

AI could help you move quicker in the short-term, but if you're investing with a long-term strategy in mind, those saved minutes won't make much of a difference, says Blake Anderson, director of portfolio management at Carson Group, a financial services firm.

代理式交易的风险持有股票、加密货币或其他可投资资产,通常意味着要承担一定程度的风险。Rathore 表示,让 AI 代理影响或替你做出投资决策,可能会招致更多风险,因为该技术可能出现故障,或做出与你的投资目标不一致的决策。

"AI may likely help reduce trading latency, but investing expectations may not differ much," he says. "As a fundamental investor, using AI to execute a trade likely won't change the long-term earnings potential of the business being bought." Risks with agentic trading You generally assume some level of risk by owning stocks, crypto or other investable assets. Letting an AI agent influence or make investing decisions for you can invite more risk, given the technology could malfunction or make a decision that isn't aligned with your investment goals, Rathore says.

Robinhood 设置了一些护栏来保护投资者,例如仅允许代理在一个单独的、专用的经纪账户中运行。在经纪商的默认设置下使用该应用代理的投资者,必须批准每一个交易决策。该功能可以关闭,尽管某些交易可能仍需要批准。

Robinhood has some guardrails in place to protect investors, like only allowing agents to operate in a separate, dedicated brokerage account. Investors using the app's agents on the brokerage's default settings have to approve every trade decision. That feature can be turned off, though some trades may still require approval.

尽管 Rathore 目前对代理式交易感到满意,但他不会让该技术自行为其投资做出最终交易决策。

Even though Rathore has been pleased with agentic trading thus far, he wouldn't let the tech make final trade decisions for his investments on its own.

代理“毫无疑问能让你的交易体验更轻松,”他说。“但让代理做出投资决策,如果不小心,人们就可能亏钱。它们必须提供一些基本事实依据,并必须确保在执行层面上,人类处于决策回路之中。”他补充道,如果没有扎实的投资经验就使用代理式交易,风险会很大,因为大语言模型(LLM)已知会产生“幻觉”——这是行业术语,指机器人编造信息或以其他方式误解用户指令。

Agents can "make your trading experience easier, there is no doubt about it," he says. "But [letting agents] make investment decisions, that's where people can lose money if they are not careful. They have to provide some ground truth, and they have to make sure that for the execution, the human is in the loop." Using agentic trading without solid investing experience can be risky, he adds, because of the way LLMs are known to hallucinate the industry term for when bots make up information or otherwise misinterpret the user's directions.

利用人工智能进行投资的一个潜在好处可能正是如此——即收集更多关于特定投资标的的信息,安德森表示。但要确保你的大语言模型是从可信来源获取这些信息,而不仅仅是证实你自己的偏见。

A potential benefit of using AI to invest could be just that — to gather more information about a given investment, Anderson says. But make sure your LLM is getting that information from trusted sources and not just confirming your own biases.

“如果投资者能利用人工智能以不同于主流叙事的方式理解一家企业,或拓宽他们的知识面,那么他们或许能对更多种类的股票进行批判性思考,并有可能发现被低估的机会,”他说。

"If investors can use AI to understand a business differently than the prevailing narrative or expand their knowledge, then they may be able to think critically about a wider variety of stocks and potentially find discounted opportunities " he says.

通过 CNBC Select 掌控您的财务 CNBC Select 编辑独立,并可能通过联盟合作伙伴链接获得佣金。

Take control of your money with CNBC Select CNBC Select is editorially independent and may earn a commission from affiliate partners on links.

2026 年最热门节日玩具的最佳信用卡 设立偿债基金可帮您避免节日负债。以下是最佳起步方式 1000 美元存入一年期定期存单 (CD) 能赚多少?

The best credit cards for the hottest holiday toys of 2026 A sinking fund can help you avoid holiday debt. Here are the best ways to start How much could $1,000 earn in a 1-year CD?

买方市场中谈判房屋好价的 4 种方法 旅行成本越来越高。以下是如何判断您是否拿到了最优酒店价格

4 ways to negotiate a good deal on a house in a buyer’s market Travel is getting more expensive. Here’s how to know if you’re getting the best hotel deal

阅读媒体原文 ↗