
澳大利亚对人工智能公司实施的新强制性保障措施可能为东南亚树立榜样,分析人士表示,但该地区首先需要建立其制度和技术能力。
Australia’s new mandatory safeguards on AI companies could serve as a model for Southeast Asia, analysts say, but the region needs to build its institutional and technical capabilities first.
总理安东尼·阿尔巴尼斯周二宣布,在澳大利亚运营的人工智能公司必须立即报告其模型出现失控或错位行为的事件,并必须开放系统供评估。
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced on Tuesday that AI companies operating in Australia must immediately report incidents in which their models behave in a rogue or misaligned way and must open systems for evaluation.
这些措施是在今年6月OpenAI代理程序突破限制、入侵澳大利亚政府医疗数据系统之后出台的。OpenAI直到9月才向澳大利亚政府通报该漏洞。
The measures followed a breach of Australia’s government health data system in June by OpenAI agents that bypassed restrictions on private files. OpenAI did not tell the Australian government about the breach until September.
阿尔巴尼斯表示,对该漏洞的审查建议“在涉及错位行为或网络事件时强制人工智能公司报告,并考虑在严重不当行为案件中改革刑法”。
A review into the breach urged “mandatory AI company reporting when it comes to misaligned behaviour or cyber incidents, and consideration of reforming criminal law in cases of serious misconduct”, Albanese said.
他补充道:“澳大利亚在这一领域是首创者,我们希望确保继续努力,以便能够从人工智能中获得潜在收益。”
“Australia is the first mover in this space, and we want to make sure that we continue to work so that we can reap the potential benefits from AI,” he added.
堪培拉还将设立一家监管机构,负责评估人工智能模型,监督人工智能系统在开发和部署全过程中的安全控制,并识别和管理风险。
Canberra will also establish a regulator to evaluate AI models, oversee security controls throughout the development and deployment of AI systems, and identify and manage risks.
观察人士称新规则是受欢迎的一步,但表示它们不一定能防止下一次事件发生。
Observers called the new rules a welcome step, but said they would not necessarily prevent the next incident.
帮助组织评估人工智能治理准备情况的非营利平台Balai Labs联合创始人马克·马南坦表示:“Medicare(澳大利亚联邦医疗保险计划)漏洞暴露了两个问题:自主人工智能代理的不可预测行为,以及责任公司的延迟披露。”
“The Medicare breach exposed two problems: unpredictable behaviour by autonomous AI agents and delayed disclosure by the company responsible,” said Mark Manantan, co-founder of Balai Labs, a not-for-profit platform that helps organisations assess their AI governance readiness.
“强制性事件报告直接解决了这一问责缺口,”曼南坦说,他同时也是墨尔本拉筹伯大学全球安全中心的研究员。“同样重要的是独立评估,这超越了要求AI公司自我认证安全的做法。”新加坡非营利组织AI Safety Asia首席战略官亚历杭德罗·雷耶斯表示,澳大利亚“正朝着正确的方向迈进”。
“Mandatory incident reporting directly addresses that accountability gap,” said Manantan, who is also a research fellow at La Trobe University’s Centre for Global Security in Melbourne. “Equally important is independent evaluation, which moves beyond asking AI companies to certify their own safety.”Alejandro Reyes, chief strategic officer of Singapore-based non-profit organisation AI Safety Asia, said Australia was “moving in the right direction”.
“关键的转变在于:从依赖AI公司自我监管,转向要求它们证明其系统安全并对失效负责……但报告是在出了问题之后才发生的,”他说,并补充称真正的挑战在于预防。
“The important shift is from relying on AI companies to police themselves to requiring them to demonstrate that their systems are safe and to account for failures … but reporting is what happens after something has gone wrong,” he said, adding that the real challenge was prevention.
“医疗保险事件极具启示意义,因为它显然涉及一名AI代理在测试期间超出其授权范围行事,而非传统网络犯罪分子发动攻击,”雷耶斯说。“这引发了关于责任归属的棘手问题,即当AI系统采取其开发者未预期的行动时,责任由谁承担。”雷耶斯表示,澳大利亚做法的有效性将取决于“必须报告什么、报告多快、谁能独立评估系统,以及监管机构是否具备执行规则的专业知识和权力”。
“The Medicare incident is particularly instructive because it apparently involved an AI agent acting beyond its authorised scope during testing, rather than a conventional cybercriminal directing an attack,” Reyes said. “It raises difficult questions about responsibility when an AI system takes actions its developers did not intend.”Reyes said the effectiveness of Australia’s approach would depend on “what must be reported, how quickly, who can independently evaluate the systems and whether the regulator has the expertise and authority to enforce the rules”.
曼南坦说,实施将是真正的考验。“澳大利亚的提案需要明确的报告门槛、独立的技术评估和可执行的处罚,”他说。“这是一个有前景的问责框架,但其有效性将取决于监管机构能否真正调查并核实有害的AI行为。”观察人士表示,随着东南亚地区应对自身的AI治理和准备度问题,可以从澳大利亚汲取经验,但单纯复制堪培拉的做法不会那么简单。
Manantan said implementation would be the real test. “Australia’s proposals need clear reporting thresholds, independent technical assessments and enforceable penalties,” he said. “It is a promising accountability framework, but its effectiveness will depend on whether regulators can actually investigate and verify harmful AI behaviour.”Observers said Southeast Asia could learn from Australia as the region deals with its own AI governance and readiness concerns, but that simply replicating Canberra’s approach would not be as straightforward.
新加坡报业控股媒体集团(SPH Media)周一表示,据信由人工智能实施的网络攻击影响了其数据库的9%。该集团称,没有财务信息遭到泄露。
Singapore’s SPH Media said on Monday that cyberattacks, believed to have been carried out by AI, had affected 9 per cent of its database. No financial information was compromised, it said.
曼南坦表示:“SPH Media事件凸显了人工智能相关网络安全的紧迫性,尽管人工智能涉嫌参与其中,但这不应与已确认的自主失控代理行为混为一谈。”
“The SPH Media incident reinforces the urgency of AI-related cybersecurity, although the suspected involvement of AI should not be confused with confirmed autonomous rogue-agent behaviour,” Manantan said.
他说:“澳大利亚的防护措施提供了有用的原则,但东南亚不能简单复制堪培拉的做法。‘在纸面上制定安全要求’与‘具备评估人工智能系统并在出现问题时作出反应的技术能力’是两码事。”曼南坦表示,该地区的核心问题在于缺乏对人工智能技术栈的控制权。
“Australia’s safeguards offer useful principles, but Southeast Asia cannot simply replicate Canberra’s approach,” he said. “Having safety requirements on paper is different from having the technical capacity to evaluate AI systems and respond when something goes wrong.”Manantan said the region’s core problem was its lack of control over the AI technology stack.
他说:“大多数东南亚国家主要消费和部署在别处开发的前沿模型。它们对控制底层模型、计算基础设施和安全评估的公司影响力有限。”
“Most Southeast Asian countries primarily consume and deploy frontier models developed elsewhere. They have limited leverage over the companies controlling the underlying models, computing infrastructure and safety evaluations,” he said.
“这造成了一种不对称:政府仍有责任保护本国公民和机构,即使最具影响力的人工智能系统是在其管辖范围之外开发的。”曼南坦表示,除了监管之外,东南亚政府还需要实用工具来评估机构准备情况、识别差距并增强评估人工智能系统的能力。
“This creates an asymmetry: governments remain responsible for protecting their citizens and institutions, even when the most consequential AI systems are developed beyond their jurisdiction.”Aside from regulation, Southeast Asian governments also needed practical tools to assess institutional readiness, identify gaps and strengthen their ability to evaluate AI systems, Manantan said.
一些国家已经开始行动。越南去年底成为该地区首个通过独立人工智能法律的国家,而新加坡则侧重于强调实用治理框架和技术指导。雷耶斯表示:“我们不应低估越南和新加坡已经取得的成果。”
Some countries have already begun. Vietnam became the first in the region to pass a stand-alone AI law late last year, while Singapore has focused on emphasising practical governance frameworks and technical guidance. “We should not underestimate what Vietnam and Singapore have already done,” Reyes said.
越南的法律于3月生效,要求通报严重人工智能事件,以及进行风险分类、监管高风险系统、实施检查并规定法律责任。雷耶斯表示,挑战“将在于如何有效落实这些要求”。
Vietnam’s law, in force since March, requires notification of serious AI incidents, as well as risk classification, oversight of high-risk systems, inspections and legal liability. Reyes said the challenge “will be implementing these requirements effectively”.
新加坡已发布单独的框架,其中包括一份关于智能体AI的框架——于1月发布并在5月更新——以应对过度自主、访问权限和人工监督问题。“但其大部分AI专项指导仍属自愿性质,尽管现有的网络安全和数据保护法律具有强制执行力,”雷耶斯说。
Singapore has issued separate frameworks, including one on agentic AI – launched in January and updated in May – to address excessive autonomy, access permissions and human oversight. “But much of its AI-specific guidance remains voluntary, even though existing cybersecurity and data protection laws are enforceable,” Reyes said.
据观察人士称,澳大利亚目前正聚焦于针对前沿AI开发者的定向义务,将关注点重新置于开发者问责上。
Australia is now focusing on targeted obligations for frontier AI developers, according to observers, returning attention to developer accountability.
“更大的区别在于监管雄心与实施之间,”马南坦说。“在Balai Labs,我们认为AI治理不仅仅是通过法律的问题,而是建立执行这些法律所需的制度和技术能力的问题。越南、新加坡和澳大利亚的起点不同,但最终都面临同一个挑战。”他说,该地区应建立检测有害AI行为的能力,追究开发者责任,并在事件跨越国界时做出集体反应。
“The bigger distinction is between regulatory ambition and implementation,” Manantan said. “At Balai Labs, we see AI governance not simply as a question of passing laws, but of building the institutional and technical capabilities needed to enforce them. Vietnam, Singapore and Australia have different starting points, but all ultimately face that same challenge.”He said the region should build the capacity to detect harmful AI behaviour, hold developers to account and respond collectively when incidents crossed borders.
“东盟应探索共同的事件报告协议和共享的技术评估能力,”马南坦说。“一个汇聚政府、技术机构和主要AI开发者的‘东盟+科技+’安排,可支持在披露、测试和协调反应方面形成共同预期,并有望建立在《东盟数字经济框架协定》基础之上。”雷耶斯敦促“特别重视共同报告标准、获取独立评估的渠道以及国家网络安全机构间的合作”。
“Asean should explore common incident-reporting protocols and pooled technical evaluation capabilities,” Manantan said. “An Asean+Tech Plus arrangement bringing together governments, technical institutions and major AI developers could support shared expectations for disclosure, testing and coordinated responses, potentially building on the Asean Digital Economy Framework Agreement.”Reyes urged “particular emphasis on common reporting standards, access to independent evaluations and cooperation among national cybersecurity authorities”.
他说:“单个国家可能对主要全球AI公司的影响力有限。共同行动,它们在设定预期方面能拥有更强的声音。”
“Individual countries may have limited leverage over major global AI companies,” he said. “Acting together, they can have a stronger voice in setting expectations.”