
越来越多的学校正在提供一种让大学费用降低的新办法:把学制缩短一年。
A growing number of schools are offering a novel way to make college less expensive: Chop a year off.
随着学生债务不断攀升,美国家庭越来越质疑昂贵的四年制学位能带来什么回报,已有数十所院校提出或宣布三年制学士项目,包括纽约大学、俄克拉何马大学和萨福克大学。
As American families increasingly question the return on pricey four-year degrees amid mounting student debt, dozens of institutions have proposed or announced three-year bachelor’s programs, including New York University, the University of Oklahoma and Suffolk University.
这些项目并非只是把传统的120个学分塞进更少的学期:它们经过重新设计,通常围绕90个学分设置。学生通常支付相同的年度费用,但只读三年而不是四年。智库兰德公司高级政策研究员贾森·李表示,仅今年就宣布了约150个缩短版学士项目,而2024年只有5个。许多项目是在州监管机构的鼓励、甚至强制要求下推出的。
These programs don’t merely cram the traditional 120 credits into fewer semesters: They are redesigned, typically around 90 credits. Students usually pay the same annual cost, but for three years instead of four. Around 150 shortened bachelor’s programs have been announced this year alone, up from five in 2024, said Jason Lee, a senior policy researcher at the think tank Rand. Many came at the encouragement, or even mandate, of state governing bodies.
“120个学分时并不一定是什么神奇的数字,”弗吉尼亚州高等教育委员会执行主任斯科特·弗莱明说。该委员会正在研究一项相关计划。
“The 120 credit hours isn’t necessarily a magic number,” said Scott Fleming, executive director of the State Council of Higher Education for Virginia, which is exploring an initiative.
支持者表示,这些速成项目往往设在酒店管理或护理等职业方向上,有助于满足紧迫的劳动力需求。三年制学士学位在英国和欧洲大部分地区很常见。
Proponents say the expedited programs, often in career tracks such as hospitality or nursing, help meet pressing workforce needs. Three-year bachelor’s degrees are common in the U.K. and much of Europe.
马萨诸塞州伯灵顿的奎因·麦克唐纳看着自己的兄弟姐妹读完大学并开始偿还学生贷款。为了减轻这一经济负担,他选择了位于罗德岛州普罗维登斯的约翰逊与威尔士大学的三年制项目。“我意识到,省下一年对我有帮助,也不必让家里承担经济负担,”他说。
Quinn McDonald, of Burlington, Mass., watched his siblings finish college and start repaying student loans. Determined to lighten that financial load, he chose a three-year track at Johnson & Wales University in Providence, R.I. “I realized that saving a year would help me and not have to put a burden on my family with paying,” he said.
麦克唐纳是一名学习刑事司法的大二学生,每年学费约3万美元,将在21岁毕业,这是马萨诸塞州从事执法工作的最低年龄。“我能够让自己的人生抢先起步,”他说。
A sophomore studying criminal justice, McDonald pays about $30,000 a year and will graduate at 21, the minimum age to work in law enforcement in Massachusetts. “I’ll be able to get a jump-start on my life,” he said.
然而,批评者认为,这些速成学位削弱了长期以来的学术期望,为了速度而剥夺了大学的探索性质。他们担心这可能会使学士学位本身贬值。
Critics, however, say the expedited degrees erode longstanding academic expectations, stripping away the exploratory nature of college in favor of speed. They worry this could devalue the bachelor’s degree itself.
美国大学教授协会主席托德·沃尔夫森说:“我们不想从核心上掏空我们现有的高等教育体系。”该协会代表5万多名会员。他表示,三年制学位项目是对大学高昂学费的一种错误应对。
“We don’t want to hollow out the higher education system that we have from its core,” said Todd Wolfson, president of the American Association of University Professors, which represents more than 50,000 members. He said three-year degree programs are a misguided response to the high cost of college.
“人们在寻找一个简单的解决方案:‘我们为什么不干脆把它改成三年制?’”他说,并认为这些举措并没有解决负担能力问题的根源。“这似乎是一个走捷径的答案。”为了在不损害项目质量的前提下把学士学位缩短一年,学校正在采用一些策略,比如减少选修课要求、用更综合的模式取代实习,或者合并课程内容。
“People are looking for an easy solution: ‘Why don’t we just make it three years?’” he said, arguing that the initiatives don’t address root causes of affordability problems. “This seems like a shortcut answer.”To shave a year off a bachelor’s degree without shortchanging the program, schools are using strategies such as requiring fewer electives, replacing internships with more integrated models or combining course material.
在纽约大学,校长琳达·米尔斯最近提议为护理和酒店管理专业增设三年制学士学位。她说,纽约大学已有七分之一的学生在三年内毕业。米尔斯说,这表明学生看重更快的进度,希望更早赚钱,也希望少付学费。
At NYU, President Linda Mills recently proposed adding three-year bachelor’s degrees for nursing and hospitality. One in seven NYU students already graduates in three years, she said. That’s an indicator students value an expedited timeline, want to earn money sooner and want to pay less tuition, Mills said.
一个粗略的蓝图已经存在。纽约大学在2013年率先推出了三年制医学学位,该校还提供三年制舞蹈学位,因为该领域的职业窗口期较短。
A loose blueprint already exists. NYU pioneered a three-year medical degree in 2013, and the institution also offers three-year dance degrees because the field’s career windows are shorter.
护理学院院长安吉拉·弗雷德里克·阿马尔说,对于这项旨在应对护理人员短缺的拟议本科项目,一门必修的化学课程可以用一门科学基础课程来替代,后者教授生物化学、有机化学、遗传学和营养学的关键内容。
For the proposed undergrad program, meant to address the nursing shortage, a required chemistry course can be replaced with a scientific foundations course that teaches crucial aspects of biochemistry, organic chemistry, genetics and nutrition, said nursing school Dean Angela Frederick Amar.
“我们提议的做法在某种程度上并没有真正从任何一方拿走什么,而是在思考如何更好地整合内容,”阿马尔说。
“What we’re proposing is sort of not really taking away anything from either, but thinking about how we may better integrate the content,” Amar said.

尽管如此,压缩大学教育仍需做出妥协。波士顿萨福克大学将于明年秋季开设医疗管理与创新专业的三年制学位,学生将面临双主修、辅修和出国留学的限制。
Still, compressing a college education comes with compromises. At Suffolk University in Boston, which will offer a three-year degree in healthcare administration and innovation next fall, students face limits on double-majoring, minors and studying abroad.
“进入这个项目的学生将无法三次更改专业,”校长玛丽莎·凯利说。“他们失去的部分就是灵活性。”不过,他们可以转到四年制学位。
“Students who come into this program are not going to be able to change their major three times,” said President Marisa Kelly. “Part of what they’re losing is flexibility.”They can, however, switch to a four-year degree.
新英格兰高等教育委员会主席劳伦斯·肖尔表示,约翰逊与威尔士大学的认证机构要求每个快速项目在试行期间都必须设有四年制版本。这让学生可以选择转过去,以防雇主或研究生项目不认可较短的学位。
Johnson & Wales’s accreditor mandates a four-year version of every expedited program during its trial period, said New England Commission of Higher Education President Lawrence Schall. That gives students the option to switch in case employers or graduate programs don’t recognize the shorter degrees.
到目前为止,需求正在增长。约翰逊与威尔士大学是最早从去年开始提供三年制学位的学校之一,其普罗维登斯校区这些项目的申请量今年跃升了27%。校长米姆·鲁尼说,三年制学生的留存率也略高一些。
So far, demand is growing. Johnson & Wales, among the first to offer three-year degrees starting last year, saw applications to those programs on its Providence campus jump 27% this year. And retention is slightly higher among the three-year students, said Chancellor Mim Runey.
教务长理查德·威斯科特认为,该校最终可能有高达70%的专业提供三年制版本。他把这些批评比作早期对在线大学的怀疑,而这种怀疑后来已经消退。“我真的相信,在三年制学位领域也会发生同样的情况,”他说。
Provost Richard Wiscott thinks up to 70% of the school’s majors could eventually come in three-year versions. He likened the criticism to early skepticism of online colleges, which has since faded. “I really do believe that will happen in the three-year degree space as well,” he said.

对许多大学领导者来说,三年制学位是吸引那些对是否上大学犹豫不决的学生的一种方式。俄克拉荷马大学校长乔·哈罗兹表示,学生不选择攻读学位,可能是因为四年太长了。该校正在努力增设一个社会工作三年制项目,这是该州急需人才的领域。
For many college leaders, the three-year degree is a way to draw in students on the fence about attending. University of Oklahoma President Joe Harroz, whose school is working to add a three-year program in social work, a high-need field for the state, said students might not be choosing to pursue the degree because four years is too long.
“有多少学生因为120个[学分]学时实在无法完成而被落下?”他说。
“How many students are being left behind because 120 [credit] hours is just insurmountable?” he said.
一些提供这类学位的院校仍在谨慎推进。位于圣乔治的犹他理工大学今年秋季推出了三年制项目,这对已经工作的成年学习者尤其有吸引力。但该校高级副教务长克里斯·盖蒙说,学校不鼓励传统本科生加入。
Some institutions offering the degrees are still proceeding cautiously. Utah Tech University in St. George deployed its three-year programs this fall, an option particularly attractive for adult learners who are already working. But the school discourages traditional undergraduates from joining, said senior associate provost Chris Guymon.
盖蒙表示:“给学生时间去消化和思考他们想成为什么样的人是有好处的,但同时也要尽可能沉浸在一所大学的氛围中。”对于入读的学生,学校要求获得教师推荐,以确保学生对所选领域充满热情。
“There’s a benefit to giving students time to process and think about what they want to be, but also be as immersed as possible in what a university is,” said Guymon. For those who enroll, the school requires a faculty recommendation to ensure the student is passionate about the field they choose.
特朗普政府将三年制学位的推广宣传为劳动力发展和大学可负担性方面的一项成果。一些保守派还认为,这些项目将遏制他们眼中的大学“意识形态扩张”和不必要开支。
The Trump administration has touted the expansion of three-year degrees as a win for workforce development and college affordability. Some conservatives also argue the programs will corral what they consider “ideological sprawl” and unnecessary spending at universities.
在弗吉尼亚州,弗莱明的团队正在研究如何平衡职业准备与“为教育而教育”。雇主希望应聘者具备一定的成熟度——弗莱明称之为“学会做成年人”——而在大学的时间缩短可能会妨碍这一点。他说:“任何举措都并非没有一些取舍。”
In Virginia, Fleming’s team is examining how to balance professional preparation with “education for the sake of education.”Employers want candidates with a certain maturity—“learning how to adult,” as Fleming calls it—and less time in college could hinder that. “Any initiative is not without some trade-offs,” he said.