欧洲军事专家正在密切关注一系列紧急的危险信号,这些迹象表明弗拉基米尔·普京可能正在准备对北约联盟进行直接升级行动。
European military experts are tracking urgent danger signs that suggest Vladimir Putin may be preparing for a direct escalation against the NATO alliance.
分析人士之间存在分歧的焦点在于,俄罗斯总统究竟是在权衡各种选项,还是已经下定决心要采取行动。
What analysts are split over is whether the Russian president is merely weighing his options or has already decided to pull the trigger.
伦敦军事智库皇家联合军种研究所的高级研究员贾斯汀·布隆克表示:“从……多个成员国的国家元首和国防部长公开的情报简报中可以清楚地看出,俄罗斯正在策划某种形式的侵略行为,可能采取多种潜在形式。”
"What's pretty clear from public intelligence briefings by … a number of heads of state and defence secretaries across different member states is that Russia is planning [some] sort of aggression, probably with multiple potential forms," said Justin Bronk, senior research fellow for airpower and technology at the Royal United Services Institute, a London-based military think-tank.
“这并不意味着他们已经决定这么做,但这确实表明该行动可能正处于积极规划阶段,因此其风险已显著上升。”波兰外交部长拉多斯瓦夫·西科尔斯基周五在纽约联合国大会期间的一场小组讨论中警告称,莫斯科“今年正在酝酿一件大事”,但他未作进一步说明。
"That doesn't mean they've decided to do it — but it does mean it's probably under active planning and therefore the risk of it has risen significantly." Moscow is "cooking up something big this year," warned Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski during a panel discussion as part of the United Nations General Assembly in New York on Friday, without elaborating.
丹麦政府本周发布的一份威胁评估报告加剧了这些担忧,该报告提出了俄罗斯可能对用于支持乌克兰的北约基础设施发动导弹袭击的可能性。报告称,此类袭击可能在数周内发生。
The concerns have been fuelled by a threat assessment from Denmark's government that this week raised the prospect of a Russian missile attack on NATO infrastructure used to support Ukraine. The report said such an attack could happen within weeks.
过去一个月来发生的一系列事件,已使各国政府和安全机构进入高度戒备状态。
A wave of incidents over the last month have put governments and security services on high alert.
德国政府直接指责普京策划了对莱比锡机场的无人机袭击企图,该袭击似乎旨在打击运载援助物资前往基辅的飞机。
Germany's government has directly blamed Putin for an attempted drone strike on Leipzig's airport that appeared to target aircraft carrying supplies to Kyiv.
随后,一架俄罗斯无人机在波兰边境袭击了一列乌克兰客运列车,当时列车正在卸载一车厢满载欧洲政要的乘客,其中包括英国前首相鲍里斯·约翰逊。俄罗斯确认了此次袭击,但否认其意图是暗杀欧洲外交官。
A Russian drone then attacked a Ukrainian passenger train on the border with Poland, a NATO ally, just as it unloaded a carriage full of European VIPs, including former British prime minister Boris Johnson. Russia confirmed the strike but denied it was trying to assassinate European diplomats.
与此同时,波兰当局表示,他们强烈怀疑克里姆林宫特工是本周早些时候一起纵火袭击事件的幕后黑手,该袭击目标是一个作为乌克兰武装部队关键链路的卫星通信地面站。展望未来,分析人士认为莫斯科的目标经过了精心算计。
Meanwhile, Polish authorities stated they strongly suspect Kremlin agents were behind an arson attack earlier this week on a satellite communications ground station serving as a critical link with Ukraine's armed forces. Going forward, analysts suggest Moscow's goals are highly calculated.
“俄罗斯人不会做他们认为会导致长期、艰难战争的事情。那不是他们的目标,”布朗克说。
"The Russians aren't going to do something that they think leads to a long, difficult war. That's not their objective," said Bronk.
“他们的目标是做一些规模足够小,但又能明确侵犯北约领土的事情,从而公开测试该联盟,同时又要将其控制在足够小的范围内,使得北约很难获得直接进行军事反击并将他们驱逐出去的政治意愿。”普京否认了所有关于侵略的指控,并一如他在过去27年身处俄罗斯权力金字塔顶端时所做的那样,将俄罗斯描绘成西方军事联盟好战行为的受害者。
"The objective would be to do something small enough that it still definitively violates NATO territory to test the alliance visibly, but keep it small enough that it becomes very difficult to get the political will to respond directly and militarily kick them out." Putin has denied all allegations of aggression and instead framed Russia as the victim of warmongering by the Western military alliance as he has for much of 27 years at the top of Russia's power pyramid.
“北约正在膨胀和扩张,”他在9月18日的一次克里姆林宫会议上说道,并声称欧洲领导人“只是试图通过指责俄罗斯的侵略行为来挽救他们下滑的支持率,并掩盖错误”。
"NATO is swelling up and expanding," he told a Kremlin meeting on Sept. 18, claiming European leaders are "simply trying to salvage their sagging ratings, and cover up mistakes" with accusations of Russian aggression.
普京一再将他2022年2月对乌克兰的入侵辩解为自卫,并虚假地声称北约当时正在那里集结军队和武器,准备入侵俄罗斯。“墙角的困兽”如今,在经历了四年半的全面战争后,据信俄罗斯已有高达140万人伤亡,其经济也承受着巨大的压力。
Putin has repeatedly justified his February 2022 invasion of Ukraine as self-defence, falsely claiming that NATO was building up troops and weapons there in preparation for invading Russia. 'Rat in the corner' Now, after four and half years of full-scale war, Russia is believed to have suffered as many as 1.4 million people killed or wounded and its economy is under severe strain.
一位爱沙尼亚高级指挥官周五将普京比作“墙角的困兽”,暗示由于战争进展不顺,他可能将针对乌克兰欧洲盟友的侵略视为打破西方支持的最佳手段。
One senior Estonian commander on Friday likened Putin to a "rat in the corner," suggesting that because the war is going badly he may see aggression against Ukraine's European allies as a the best means to break Western support.
挪威首相称俄罗斯入侵的威胁是“真实的” 9月21日 时长 周五,俄罗斯官方媒体俄新社(RIA Novosti)发布了一篇题为《俄罗斯正面临另一场短暂的特别军事行动》的报道,为这一理论增加了可信度。俄罗斯至今仍将其对乌克兰的战争称为“特别军事行动”。
Threat of Russian invasion is 'real,' says Norway's prime minister September 21 Duration On Friday, the Russian state media outlet RIA Novosti gave the theory added credibility with a story headlined: "Russia is facing another short SVO" or special military operation as Russia continues to call its war against Ukraine.
报道称“它将是短暂的”,并提出了对北约成员国立陶宛发动导弹袭击的可能性。
"It will be short," it said, and raised the possibility of missile strikes against Lithuania, another NATO member.
这篇文章在发布后不久就被撤下,文中还暗示不排除使用核武器的可能性。俄罗斯前总统兼前总理德米特里·梅德韦杰夫(Dimitri Medvedev)曾多次对北约发出类似威胁,分析人士普遍认为这是一种恐吓手段。
The article — which was taken down a short time after it was posted — also suggested that using nuclear weapons was not out of the question. Dimitri Medvedev, a former Russian president and prime minister, has frequently made similar threats against NATO which are widely viewed by analysts as a scare tactic.
俄新社随后进行了一种“更正”,声称撤下该文章是因为“它不符合编辑团队的观点”或“俄罗斯联邦的国家政策”。令人不安的相似之处 这种情况与普京入侵乌克兰前的几周有着令人不安的相似之处。
RIA Novosti later added a sort of correction claiming the article was removed because "it did not align with the editorial team's views," or the "state policy of the Russian federation." Eerie similarities The situation shares eerie similarities with the weeks leading up to Putin's invasion of Ukraine.
当时,普京和其他克里姆林宫官员极力否认有任何入侵意图,并将局势升级归咎于北约,尽管当时俄罗斯在乌克兰边境的军队不断增加,旨在平息危机的外交努力也在持续进行。
Back then, Putin and other Kremlin officials vigorously denied any intent to invade and blamed NATO for escalation, even as Russian troops on the border with Ukraine swelled and diplomacy to try to calm the crisis continued.
后来研究普京战争之路的西方和俄罗斯作者得出结论:普京与一小群强硬派安全顾问在对西方不满情绪的驱使下,排挤了克里姆林宫更广泛的建制派,做出了让国家陷入战争的决定性决策。
Western and Russian authors who later studied Putin's road to war concluded he and a tiny circle of hard-line security advisers, fuelled by grievances against the West, froze out the broader Kremlin establishment and made the fateful decision to plunge the country into war.
他们认为乌克兰会迅速投降,这被证明是现代政治史上最大的失误之一。但实地情况的其他事实与2022年大不相同。
Their belief that Ukraine would quickly capitulate turned out to be one of greatest blunders in modern political history. But other facts on the ground look vastly different than in 2022.
针对西科尔斯基关于即将发生“大事”的警告,爱沙尼亚的一位高级军事人物声称,他的国家没有看到任何俄罗斯军队在北约东翼集结的证据。
Countering Sikorski's warnings of "something big" on the horizon, one of Estonia's top military figures claimed his country is seeing no evidence of Russian troops massing along NATO's eastern flank.
“我们没有迹象表明俄罗斯目前打算军事攻击任何北约盟友,”爱沙尼亚内政部最高官员塔尔莫·米利茨写道。
"We have no signs indicating that Russia currently intends to militarily attack any NATO ally," wrote Tarmo Miilits, the top official at Estonia's Interior Ministry.
英国《泰晤士报》援引其他欧洲高级安全官员的话称,“没有新情报表明俄罗斯即将发动攻击。”芬兰总统亚历山大·斯图布本周在纽约联合国访问期间,敦促领导人和分析师停止使用“危言耸听的语言”,声称关于战争扩大的猜测正是克里姆林宫宣传专家想要的。
And Britain's The Times newspaper quoted other top European security officials saying that there is "no new intelligence to suggest a Russian attack is coming." During his visit to the UN in New York this week, Finland's President Alexander Stubb urged leaders and analysts to stop using "alarmist language," claiming the speculation about an expanded war is exactly what the Kremlin spin doctors want.
任何北约成员国都可以援引第5条——该联盟的基石原则,即对一国的攻击被视为对所有成员国的攻击——但这引出了一个关键问题:什么构成“攻击”?联盟能否指望做出回应?
Any NATO member can invoke Article 5 — the alliance's foundational principle that an attack against one member is considered an attack against all — but this raises the crucial question of what constitutes "an attack"? And can the alliance be counted on to respond?
拉脱维亚总统本周告诉英国第四台,他绝对相信如果俄罗斯对其采取行动,美国和其他30个成员国会伸出援手,但他承认对于这可能如何定义存在分歧。
Latvia's president told Britain's Channel 4 this week that he absolutely believed the U.S. and the other 30 member states would come to his country's aid if Russia moves against it, but he acknowledged there is disagreement over how that might be defined.
“真正的麻烦始于你必须界定第5条在这种情况下何时生效时,”埃德加斯·林克维奇说。
"The real trouble starts when you have to define when Article 5 starts in this situation," said Edgars Rinkēvičs.
“混合攻击可能触发第5条,但这正是我们需要共同努力的地方。”在联盟77年的历史中,第5条仅被援引过一次——由美国在9·11袭击后援引。分析 俄罗斯让北约神经紧绷,但莫斯科将走多远?
"Hybrid attacks could result in Article 5 but this is where we need to work together." Article 5 has been invoked only once in the alliance's 77-year history — by the U.S. in the wake of the 9/11 attack. Analysis Russia is rattling NATO’s nerves, but how far will Moscow go?
涉嫌间谍北约的加拿大人被拒保释。接下来会发生什么 北约将分担北极责任,丹麦称随着格陵兰与美国安全协议推进 英国选择不这样做,即使在俄罗斯2018年公然刺杀前间谍谢尔盖·斯克里帕尔及其女儿尤利娅之后,那次事件在索尔兹伯里镇留下了致命军用级神经毒剂的痕迹。
The Canadian suspected of spying on NATO was denied bail. Here's what comes next NATO will share Arctic responsibility as Greenland security deal with U.S. moves forward, Denmark says The U.K. chose not to, even after Russia's blatant 2018 assassination attempt on former spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia, which left traces of a deadly military-grade nerve agent around the town of Salisbury.
叙利亚内战期间,土耳其曾多次濒临边缘,因其边境社区遭炮弹袭击,但紧急磋商最终避免了启动联盟的集体军事机制。
Turkey came close on several occasions during the Syrian civil war after its border communities were struck by artillery shells, but emergency consultations ultimately avoided testing the alliance's collective military mechanism.
美国总统唐纳德·特朗普对该联盟的长期承诺依然存疑,而右翼民粹主义政党正在整个欧洲考验大陆团结,这引发了一种可能性:如果援引第五条而成员国未能响应,北约的威慑力可能遭受致命打击,联盟将形同虚设。在这种环境下,普京可能会判断时机成熟,再次孤注一掷。
U.S. President Donald Trump's long-term commitment to the alliance remains a source of contention and right-wing populist parties are testing continental solidarity across Europe, raising the possibility that NATO's deterrence could be fatally undermined and the alliance neutered if Article 5 is invoked and member states fail to respond. In this environment, Putin may decide the occasion is ripe to gamble once again.