字号·· | 护眼
纽约时报

特朗普政府高层女性官员离职人数增加The Trump Administration and the Shrinking Number of Women in Top Roles

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

特朗普政府消失的女性 在特朗普总统的第二个任期中,无论是自愿还是被迫离职的官员,都是女性。

The Disappearing Women of the Trump Administration In President Trump’s second term, those heading for the exits, voluntarily or involuntarily, are female officials.

《纽约时报》摄影师:Tierney L. Cross、Eric Lee、Kenny Holston 和 Haiyun Jiang。图片来源……支持本文的 特朗普总统第二个任期中,金伯利·吉尔福伊尔(Kimberly Guilfoyle)在本周之前一直担任美国驻希腊大使,她的被免职在细节上令人惊讶。这一消息是在现场电视直播中宣布的,正是新任白宫新闻秘书首次举行简报会的时候。

New York Times photographs by Tierney L. Cross, Eric Lee, Kenny Holston & Haiyun Jiang. Credit... Supported by The ouster of Kimberly Guilfoyle, who until this week was the U.S. ambassador to Greece, was surprising in its particulars. It was announced on live TV, during the first-ever briefing by the new White House press secretary.

但吉尔福伊尔女士被迫辞职也反映出特朗普总统第二个任期中的一个更大趋势:离开政府的显要人物,无论是自愿还是被迫离职,绝大多数都是女性。

But Ms. Guilfoyle’s forced resignation also was part of a larger pattern in President Trump’s second term: The prominent figures who have departed the administration, either voluntarily or involuntarily, overwhelmingly are women.

吉尔福伊尔女士是今年离职的最高级别女性官员之一。今年春天,特朗普总统的八名女性内阁级官员中,有四人在短短三个月内辞职或被解职:司法部长帕姆·邦迪(Pam Bondi);劳工部长洛里·查韦斯-德雷默(Lori Chavez-DeRemer);国土安全部长克里斯蒂·L·诺姆(Kristi L. Noem);以及国家情报总监图尔西·加巴德(Tulsi Gabbard)。她们的职位全部被男性接替。

Ms. Guilfoyle was the latest high-ranking woman to leave this year. In the spring, four of Mr. Trump’s eight female cabinet-level officials resigned or were fired in just three months: Attorney General Pam Bondi; Lori Chavez-DeRemer, the labor secretary; Homeland Security Secretary Kristi L. Noem; and Tulsi Gabbard, the director of national intelligence. All were replaced by men.

吉尔福伊尔女士被要求辞职,是因为《华尔街日报》报道称,她曾要求一名捐款人在她的确认投票之前帮她还清10万美元的美国运通账单。吉尔福伊尔女士否认了这一指控。但周二,特朗普总统表示,虽然吉尔福伊尔“工作做得不错”,但他“不喜欢我读到的内容”。

Ms. Guilfoyle was asked to resign after The Wall Street Journal reported that she had asked a donor to pay off her $100,000 American Express bill before her confirmation vote. Ms. Guilfoyle has denied the allegation. But on Tuesday, Mr. Trump said that while Ms. Guilfoyle “was doing a good job,” he “didn’t like what I read.”

他还淡化了自己与吉尔福伊尔之间的任何实质性联系的说法——吉尔福伊尔是特朗普总统最坚定的支持者之一,曾一度与特朗普总统的长子小唐纳德·特朗普(Donald Trump Jr.)订婚。他对记者说:“她不是我家庭的一员。”“我想,她很久以前曾和我的儿子约会过。”特朗普总统身边的女性并不比男性更容易卷入争议;他的男性任命官员反复受到审查和要求下台的呼声。

He also downplayed the idea that he had any substantial connection with Ms. Guilfoyle, who is one of the president’s staunchest defenders and was at one point engaged to Donald Trump Jr., the president’s eldest son. “She wasn’t a member of my family,” he told reporters. “She, I guess, dated my son a long time ago.”The women in Mr. Trump’s orbit do not seem any more inclined to controversy than the men; his male appointees have repeatedly drawn scrutiny and calls for their ouster.

联邦调查局局长卡什·帕特尔不得不面对诸多关于其不当行为的质疑,包括酗酒、指派特警队保护女友以及私自使用政府专机等指控。(他已否认这些指控。)在司法部公布的文件中,商务部长霍华德·卢特尼克也被列为性犯罪者杰弗里·爱泼斯坦所拥有的私人岛屿的到访者之一。国防部长皮特·赫格塞斯则在一次私人聊天软件对话中泄露了机密战争计划,而《大西洋月刊》主编杰弗里·戈德堡也意外加入了该对话。

Kash Patel, the F.B.I. director, has been forced to confront questions about his conduct, including allegations of excessive drinking, assigning a SWAT team to protect his girlfriend and using a government plane for his personal use. (He has denied the allegations.) Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick surfaced in files released by the Justice Department as one of the visitors to the private island owned by Jeffrey Epstein, the sexual predator. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth disclosed secret war plans in a conversation on a private messaging app that inadvertently included Jeffrey Goldberg, the editor of The Atlantic.

特朗普确实惩处了与该聊天记录相关的一名男性官员:国家安全顾问迈克·沃尔茨,正是他将该记者拉入了群聊。不过沃尔茨的结局还算“体面”——他被任命为驻联合国大使,这个职位原本是特朗普承诺给他在国会中的女性盟友伊莉丝·斯特凡尼克的。

Mr. Trump did punish one male appointee related to that text chain: Mike Waltz, the national security adviser, who had added the journalist to the chat. But Mr. Waltz had a soft landing. He was appointed to serve as the ambassador to the United Nations, a position that Mr. Trump had promised to his longtime female ally in Congress, Elise Stefanik.

自称“极端MAGA支持者”的斯特凡尼克最终在政治上陷入孤立无援的境地,最终选择退出国会。

Ms. Stefanik, a self-proclaimed “ultra MAGA” warrior, ended up politically adrift and ultimately quit Congress.

研究总统任命制度的专家们指出,这种仅由单一性别成员集体离职的现象极为罕见。

Experts on presidential appointments said the single-gender exodus was highly unusual.

“我从未见过这样的情况:首批离职的内阁成员全为女性,”自里根时代起便持续追踪历届总统政府人员构成多样性的布鲁金斯学会客座研究员凯瑟琳·邓恩·滕帕斯说道。

“I’ve never seen a situation where all of the first set of cabinet departures have been of one gender — all women,” said Kathryn Dunn Tenpas, a nonresident fellow at the Brookings Institution who has tracked diversity in presidential administrations since the Reagan era.

高层中的女性力量:2024年大选获胜后,特朗普在组建核心团队时也启用了多名女性。他任命苏西·怀尔斯为白宫幕僚长,这是首位担任这一内阁级要职的女性。卡罗琳·莱维特曾是担任白宫新闻秘书一职最年轻的人选,今年8月她为照顾两个年幼的孩子而离职,接替她的是另一位女性凯蒂·扎卡里亚。

Women in the Top Ranks As Mr. Trump assembled his top brass shortly after clinching the 2024 election, several women were among the ranks. He appointed Susie Wiles as chief of staff, the first woman to hold the powerful, cabinet-level position. Karoline Leavitt was the youngest person to serve as White House press secretary before she left her job in August to raise her two young children. She was replaced by another woman, Katie Zacharia.

在一份针对本报道的声明中,白宫发言人表示:“特朗普总统组建了历史上最伟大的政府,他根据一个标准挑选了他令人难以置信的团队成员:他们为美国人民服务的能力。”发言人泰勒·罗杰斯补充道:“与沉迷于身份政治的民主党人不同,总统根据才能和资历来评判个人,而不是根据不可改变的特征。”

In a statement for this story, a White House spokeswoman said that “President Trump has assembled the greatest administration in history, selecting each member of his incredible team based on one criterion: their ability to deliver for the American people.”“Unlike the identity politics-obsessed Democrats, the president judges individuals on merit and qualifications, not immutable characteristics,” added the spokeswoman, Taylor Rogers.

去年在妇女历史月庆祝活动上,特朗普先生宣称他“很高兴地说,我们内阁中的女性人数超过美国历史上任何一位共和党总统。”如今情况已不再如此。目前内阁级职位中仅剩四名女性。

At a Women’s History Month celebration last year, Mr. Trump declared that he was “thrilled to say that we have more women in our cabinet than any Republican president in the history of our country.”That is no longer the case. There are now four women remaining in cabinet-level positions.

在许多情况下,离职的女性官员似乎未能通过某种对特朗普先生的忠诚测试。

In many instances, the female officials who departed appeared to have failed some kind of loyalty test to Mr. Trump.

邦迪女士因处理爱泼斯坦文件公开的方式而受到批评,并且未能满足特朗普先生对其敌人进行报复的要求。特朗普先生还对她在国会听证会和电视节目中的表现表示不满。

Ms. Bondi came under fire for her handling of the release of the Epstein files, and for falling short of Mr. Trump’s demands for retribution against his enemies. Mr. Trump was also dissatisfied with her performance in congressional hearings and on television.

国会听证会上的证词也似乎成为诺姆女士被解雇的导火索,特别是她表示特朗普先生批准了数千万美元的政府广告,而她在这些广告中被突出展示。特朗普先生否认了这一说法。

Testimony before Congress also appeared to be a catalyst for Ms. Noem’s firing, particularly her statement that Mr. Trump had approved of tens of millions of dollars of government ads in which she was prominently featured. Mr. Trump denied that account.

加巴德女士辞职是为了照顾生病的丈夫。但她的宣布恰逢她与白宫关系紧张之际,且发生在她拒绝向国会作证称伊朗构成迫在眉睫的威胁之后——正如特朗普先生曾断言的那样,以此为由证明他对该国发动战争的正当性。特朗普先生表示,她在这件事上的立场“比他更软”。

Ms. Gabbard resigned to care for her ill husband. But her announcement came amid a strained relationship with the White House, and after she refused to testify to Congress that Iran had posed an imminent threat, as Mr. Trump had asserted to justify his war against the country. Mr. Trump said she was “softer on that” issue than he was.

查韦斯-德雷默女士在陷入丑闻后辞职,当时有指控称她所在的机构充斥着毒性和功能失调,并且她通过与一名工作人员维持不当关系以及将公共资金用于私人用途,严重滥用了职权。

Ms. Chavez-DeRemer resigned after becoming embroiled in scandal amid allegations that her agency was rife with toxicity and dysfunction, and that she had grossly abused her power by having an inappropriate relationship with a staffer and by using public funding for private purposes.

但即使是特朗普最激烈的批评者之一,他们很高兴看到女性内阁成员离职,也指出他们所看到的明显双重标准。

But even some of Mr. Trump’s fiercest critics, who were glad to see the female cabinet members go, called out what they saw as a glaring double standard.

“他是否已经没有女性了?”纽约州民主党众议员亚历山德拉·奥卡西奥-科尔特斯在邦迪和诺姆离职后,当被记者问及总统应该解雇谁时说。“特朗普似乎只有解雇女性部长的能力。”

“Is he out of women?”Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Democrat of New York, said after the departures of Ms. Bondi and Ms. Noem, when asked by a reporter whom the president should fire next. “Trump only seems to have the capability to fire female secretaries.”

得克萨斯州民主党众议员贾斯敏·克罗克特是总统嘲弄的常见目标,她在社交媒体帖子中写道,赫格塞思应该是下一个被解雇的人。“我看到一种主题,”她写道,指特朗普。“他会比无能的男性更快地把无能的女性踢出局。”四月份,宾夕法尼亚州民主党众议员玛德琳·迪恩在一次国会听证会上质疑卢特尼克关于双重标准的问题,指出他与性侵犯杰弗里·爱泼斯坦的关系被曝光。“总统是否担心您与爱泼斯坦先生继续保持的关系?”她问道。“我不会讨论我与总统的对话,”卢特尼克回应。

Representative Jasmine Crockett, a Texas Democrat who is a frequent target of the president’s mockery, wrote in a social media post that Mr. Hegseth should be the next to go. “I see a theme,” she wrote of Mr. Trump. “He will throw the incompetent women under the bus a lot faster than the incompetent men.”In April, Representative Madeleine Dean, Democrat of Pennsylvania, grilled Mr. Lutnick about the double standard during a congressional hearing, pointing to revelations about his connection to the sexual predator Jeffrey Epstein. “Is the president concerned about your continued relationship that you had with Mr. Epstein?” she asked. “I am not going to discuss conversations I have with the president,” Mr. Lutnick replied.

“特朗普总统刚刚解雇了三名内阁部长——三名女性,”迪恩回应道。“如果特朗普总统甚至对杰弗里·爱泼斯坦的帮凶承担责任有一点点担忧,他也会解雇你。”独立女性法律中心主任、曾在特朗普两届政府中担任高级白宫官员的梅尔·邮件曼表示,有许多有能力的女性正在关键岗位上任职。

“President Trump has just fired three cabinet secretaries — three women,” Ms. Dean responded. “If President Trump has even a shred of concern about accountability for Jeffrey Epstein’s enablers, he would fire you too.”May Mailman, director of the Independent Women’s Law Center and a former senior White House official in both of Mr. Trump’s administrations, said that there were plenty of powerful women serving in key roles.

她指出,除了威尔斯之外,最近被确认领导疾病控制与预防中心的埃里卡·施瓦茨,以及领导司法部民权司的哈米特·迪隆,都是被任命的女性官员。

She pointed to Ms. Wiles as well as to appointees like Erica Schwartz, who was recently confirmed to lead the Centers for Disease Control, and Harmeet Dhillon, who leads the civil rights division at the Department of Justice.

“特朗普政府中不存在女保守主义者的孤独感,”梅尔曼女士说。“只有赋权。你因你本人而成为团队中不可或缺的一员,而不是因为你的性别。”

“There’s no loneliness of the female conservative in the Trump administration,” Ms. Mailman said. “There’s only empowerment. You’re a necessary member of the team for who you are, not your sex.”