字号·· | 护眼
美国消费者新闻与商业频道

AI生成的“垃圾宣传”出现在政治广告中,引发互联网平台警惕AI-generated 'slopaganda' in political ads puts internet platforms on alert

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

周二的中期选举紧随创纪录的AI生成政治广告支出之后。目前没有联邦立法强制要求披露此类广告中AI的使用情况。

Tuesday's midterm elections follow record spending on AI-generated political ads. There's no federal legislation mandating disclosure of AI use in such ads.

本轮中期选举周期一直由“AI垃圾宣传”主导,即包含AI生成片段和图像的竞选广告,这给Instagram、YouTube和X在监管其平台方面带来了又一挑战。

The midterm election cycle has been dominated by "slopaganda," or campaign ads featuring AI-generated clips and images, creating another challenge for Instagram, YouTube and X as they attempt to monitor their platforms.

“AI垃圾宣传”一词可追溯至去年早些时候,当时一组AI专家在一篇论文中使用该词,以描述一种将生成式AI垃圾内容与宣传及误导信息相结合的新现象。

The term slopaganda dates back to early last year, when a group of AI experts used it in a paper to describe a new phenomenon combining generative AI slop with propaganda and misinformation.

没有全面的联邦法律管辖政治广告中AI的使用或披露。虽然有约30项州法律对AI使用和披露有不同要求,但候选人并不总是遵守这些规定。在Meta、谷歌、埃隆·马斯克旗下SpaceX运营的主要互联网网站上,用户会遇到AI生成的广告和政治家分享的AI生成帖子,它们与真实视频和片子混杂在一起。

There's no comprehensive federal law governing the use or disclosure of AI in political ads. And while there are some 30 state laws with different requirements about AI use and disclosure, candidates don't always abide by them. On the leading internet sites run by Meta Google Elon Musk's SpaceX users run into AI-generated ads and AI-generated posts shared by politicians, alongside authentic videos and clips.

根据韦斯利安媒体项目上周发布的一项分析,已有超过1.87亿美元用于近300条由AI生成或增强的广告。该组织表示,这几乎肯定是一个低估数字,因为许多广告不包含免责声明。报告发现,超过90%的支出来自共和党候选人、共和党党委会或倾向共和党的团体,且大多数不包含披露信息。

More than $187 million has been spent on nearly 300 ads generated or enhanced by AI, according to an analysis released last week by the Wesleyan Media Project That's almost certainly an undercount, the organization says, because so many ads don't contain disclaimers. Over 90% of the spending came from Republican candidates, a Republican party committee or a Republican-leaning group, the report found, and most don't include disclosures.

CNBC发现多条未带披露信息的AI生成广告在网上投放,其中包括一段纽约州民主党籍州长凯西·霍楚尔的伪造视频,由她的对手、共和党挑战者布鲁斯·布莱克曼发布。

CNBC found a number of AI-generated ads running online without disclosures, including a fake video of New York Democratic Governor Kathy Hochul that was posted by her opponent, Republican challenger Bruce Blakeman.

在得克萨斯州,共和党参议员候选人肯·帕克斯顿制作了一段AI生成视频,显示民主党对手詹姆斯·塔拉里科发表争议性言论,视频中间闪现了三秒钟的披露信息。该视频正由帕克斯顿的竞选团队作为原生内容在YouTube和X上分享。布莱克曼和帕克斯顿的竞选团队未立即回应置评请求。

In Texas, Republican senatorial candidate Ken Paxton created an AI-generated video showing Democratic opponent James Talarico making controversial statements, with a three-second disclosure flashing in the middle. It's being shared as organic content on YouTube and X by Paxton's campaign. The Blakeman and Paxton campaigns didn't immediately respond to requests for comment.

YouTube 告诉 CNBC,该公司会对“逼真的 AI 内容”加贴“显著标签”。“对于 YouTube 上的自然内容,如果政治候选人的面部看起来经过了 AI 修改或生成,他们可以请求移除,”该公司表示。“对于广告主,我们要求在选举广告包含合成或经数字修改的人或事件时进行披露,以向观众提供透明度。”YouTube 母公司 Google 还要求政治广告完成其选举广告验证流程,并包含“由……付费”披露。

YouTube told CNBC that the company applies "prominent labels to realistic AI content." "For organic content on YouTube, political candidates can request removal where their face appears to be altered or generated by AI," the company said. "For advertisers, we require disclosure when an election ad contains synthetic or digitally altered people or events to provide viewers with transparency." YouTube parent Google also requires political ads to complete its election ads verification process and include "paid for by" disclosures.

X 表示,广告主必须遵守适用法律,将责任归于广告主而非平台。该公司未回应 CNBC 的置评请求。

X says advertisers must comply with applicable laws, putting the responsibility on the advertiser, not the platform. The company didn't respond to CNBC's request for comment.

Meta 援引其政治广告准则,其中包括在选举前一周限制此类广告的投放。该公司还强制要求“由……付费”标签,并维护一个政治广告库。6 月,该公司加大了标签力度,为 Meta 检测到由第三方 AI 工具创建的广告新增了“关于此广告”工具。

Meta referred to its guidelines on political ads, including restrictions on their use in the week prior to the election. The company also mandates "paid for by" labels and maintains an ad library of political ads. In June, the company ramped up its labeling, adding a new "about this ad" tool for ads that Meta detects have been created with third-party AI tools.

上个月,新墨西哥州一家法院下令 Meta 支付 250 亿美元罚款,这是源于近十年前剑桥分析公司丑闻的一起数据隐私案件的一部分。据称,这家政治咨询公司不当获取了 8700 万 Facebook 用户的信息。

Last month, Meta was ordered to pay $25 billion in penalties by a New Mexico court as part of a data privacy case that stemmed from the company's Cambridge Analytica scandal from nearly a decade ago. Cambridge Analytica, which was a political consulting firm, allegedly accessed the information of 87 million Facebook users in improper fashion.

生成式 AI 给科技平台带来的一大风险是被要求制作误导性图片和视频。布伦南司法中心测试了 ChatGPT、Gemini、Grok、Claude、Perplexity 和 DeepSeek 在助长欺骗性内容方面的意愿。8 月发布的研究发现,许多模型可能会避免生成围绕熟悉阴谋论的内容,但通常可以被操纵制作出误导性材料。

One risk the tech platforms face with generative AI is being asked to create misleading images and videos. The Brennan Center for Justice tested ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok, Claude, Perplexity and DeepSeek for their willingness to facilitate deceptive content. The study from August found that many models may avoid generating content around familiar conspiracies, but can generally be manipulated into creating misleading material.

10月对这些平台的再次测试发现,ChatGPT已取得进展。它开始将有害选举图像的提示词重定向为插画,使其看起来像漫画,或者干脆拒绝对这些提示词采取任何行动。一些国家级政客正试图解决这一问题。

retest of those platforms in October found that ChatGPT had made progress. It had started redirecting prompts for harmful election images into illustrations so they look like comics, or refusing to take action on them altogether. A number of national politicians are trying to address the issue.

由两党参议员支持的《保护选举免受欺骗性AI侵害法案》,将禁止明知故犯地传播关于联邦候选人的实质性欺骗性AI生成视频或音频。国会民主党人主导的其他法案,包括《AI广告法案》,旨在将现有的竞选虚假陈述禁令扩大至生成式AI内容。目前,尚无任何提议的法案走出委员会审议阶段。AI面临的挑战是市场上算力短缺

Protect Elections from Deceptive AI Act backed by senators from both parties, would prohibit knowingly distributing materially deceptive AI-generated video or audio about federal candidates. Other bills are being led by Democrats in Congress, including the AI Ads Act which is looking to expand current bans on campaign misrepresentation to include generative AI content. None of the proposed bills have advanced out of committee. AI challenge is lack of compute in the marketplace

阅读媒体原文 ↗