
苏黎世,11月9日——瑞士选民将在11月29日决定是否阻止一项放宽武器出口限制的法案,该公投引发了对瑞士不断演变的中立传统的质疑,并受到武器工业的强烈反对。
ZURICH, Nov 9 - Swiss voters will decide on November 29 whether to block a bill relaxing curbs on weapons exports, in a referendum that raises questions about Switzerland's evolving neutral tradition and is strongly opposed by the arms industry.
瑞士遵循1907年海牙公约的中立原则,该原则禁止瑞士参与武装冲突,除非受到直接威胁,或向任何交战方提供军事支持。
Switzerland follows the 1907 Hague Conventions on neutrality, which prevent it participating in armed conflicts unless directly threatened, or providing military support to any of the parties.
然而,自2022年俄罗斯对乌克兰发动全面侵略以来,瑞士在冷战期间基本保持的立场开始改变,促使其加深与欧洲伙伴及跨大西洋北约联盟的防务联系。
Yet a stance that largely held throughout the Cold War has begun to change since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 prompted Switzerland to deepen its defence ties with European partners and the transatlantic NATO alliance.
民调显示,由包括社会民主党、绿党等在内的左翼政党联盟提出的公投可能出现两种结果。
Polls suggest the referendum, proposed by a coalition of left-wing parties including Social Democrats, the Greens and others, could go either way.
一些右派也已脱离瑞士人民党(SVP),反对该修正案,而该修正案在公投举行前无法生效。中立国家能向交战国运送武器吗?
Some right-wingers have also split from the Swiss People's Party (SVP) to oppose the amendment, which cannot come into force until the referendum is held. CAN A NEUTRAL COUNTRY SEND WEAPONS TO A NATION AT WAR?
左翼社会民主党议员法比安·莫利纳(Fabian Molina)表示:“未来,瑞士的军火在某些情况下可能会被转交给交战国家,这将违反中立。”该修正案旨在允许向36个西方国家运送武器,即使这些国家正卷入活跃的武装冲突,但不用于这些冲突。乌克兰未被列入其中。该修正案还取消了购买国需签署不再转出口声明的要求。
"In future, Swiss war material could in certain cases be passed to belligerent states," said Fabian Molina, a lawmaker for the leftist Social Democrats. "That would violate neutrality." The amendment is intended to allow arms shipments to 36 Western countries, even if they are involved in active armed conflicts, albeit not for use in those conflicts. Ukraine is not included, however. It also scraps a requirement for countries to sign a non-re-export declaration upon purchase.
伯尔尼曾阻止数个国家将先前购买的瑞士制造弹药和作战车辆运往乌克兰,随后德国将瑞士企业排除在采购合同之外,丹麦和荷兰也暂停了订单。
Bern had blocked several countries from sending previously purchased Swiss-made ammunition and combat vehicles to Ukraine, and Germany subsequently excluded Swiss firms from procurement deals, while Denmark and the Netherlands halted orders.
然而,该修正案不适用于按此前条款购买的武器,或旨在立即转交第三方的武器——因此仍然排除乌克兰。
The amendment would, however, not apply to weaponry bought on the previous terms, or bought with the intention of immediately sending it to a third party - thus still excluding Ukraine.
中间党议员雷托·瑙泽表示,法律需要彻底改革,以反映更加危险的国际环境。
Centre Party lawmaker Reto Nause said the law needed to be overhauled to reflect a more dangerous international environment.
“我们面临的威胁程度是自第二次世界大战以来从未见过的,”他说。“拥有国内军工产业、拥有一定的生产能力,尤其是掌握关键技术的专业知识,是具备自卫能力的一部分。”瑙泽表示,不再出口声明会阻碍北约国家购买瑞士军火,因为它们希望在联盟遭受攻击时能够共享武器。
"We're facing a level of threat we haven't seen since the Second World War," he said. "Part of being able to defend yourself is having a domestic arms industry, having some production capacity and above all know-how in key technologies." The non-re-export declaration would deter NATO countries from buying Swiss armaments because they wanted to be able to share weapons if the alliance was attacked, Nause said.
受影响的制造商包括德国莱茵金属公司,该公司在瑞士生产反无人机防御系统;法国泰雷兹集团;轻武器制造商西格·绍尔公司;以及100多家其他公司。
The affected manufacturers include Germany's Rheinmetall, which builds anti-drone defence systems in Switzerland, French defence group Thales, small-arms maker SIG Sauer, and more than 100 other companies.
瑞士跻身全球前20大军火出口国 根据斯德哥尔摩国际和平研究所的数据,过去10年里,瑞士是全球第17大军火出口国。该行业雇佣了1.4万人,去年出口额约为11.5亿美元。
SWITZERLAND AMONG TOP 20 ARMS EXPORTERS Switzerland was the world's 17th-largest arms exporter over the past 10 years, according to data from the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute. The sector employs 14,000 people and last year, its exports were worth around $1.15 billion.
制造商担心如果法律不修改,前景堪忧,理由是国内市场太小;其支持者称,生产“两用”产品(可用于军事或民用)的企业还提供了另外15.4万个就业岗位。
Manufacturers fear for the future if the law is not amended, arguing that the domestic market is too small, and their supporters say there are another 154,000 jobs in companies making "dual use" products - for military or civilian purposes.
“这至关重要,真的是瑞士军工业未来的‘生’或‘死’,”瑞士航空、安全与国防协会秘书长马蒂亚斯·佐勒说,该协会代表该行业。
"This is decisive, it's really 'go' or 'no go' for the future of the Swiss arms industry," said Matthias Zoller, general secretary of the Swiss Aeronautics, Security and Defence Association, which represents the industry.
他说,瑞士拥有自己的军工产业至关重要,但如果出口受到过度限制,制造商可能直接迁往国外。
He said it was crucial for Switzerland to have its own armaments industry but, if exports were excessively restricted, manufacturers could simply move abroad.
他还说,如果瑞士无法再向国外出售武器,在向其他国家购买新系统甚至零部件时,恐怕只能排到队尾。
And if Switzerland could no longer sell arms abroad, it could expect to go to the back of the line for buying new systems or even components from other countries, he said.
绿党议员格哈德·安德烈表示,放弃对瑞士武器流向的控制“并非中立之举”,并指出尽管存在限制,但去年的出口额仅略低于历史纪录水平。
Green Party lawmaker Gerhard Andrey said ceding control of where Swiss arms go was "not a neutral choice", and noted that exports were just below record level last year, despite the restrictions.
社会民主党青年组负责人米里亚姆·霍斯特曼表示,放宽法律可能导致瑞士武器越来越多地被用于内战或流氓政府手中。
Mirjam Hostetmann, leader of the youth wing of the Social Democrats, said relaxing the law could lead to Swiss weapons increasingly being used in civil wars or by rogue governments.
她说:“认为更多武器能保证更多和平是一种幻觉。除了军火工业,没人能从这些变化中获益。” 路透社
"It's an illusion to believe that more weapons will guarantee more peace," she said. "Nobody benefits from these changes apart from the arms industry." REUTERS