新证据显示,学校手机禁令正逐步提升考试成绩 此前结果不一,但首个追踪个别学生成长的全国性研究表明,禁令可能有助于扭转下滑趋势。
School Phone Bans Are Gradually Improving Test Scores, New Evidence Shows Previous results were mixed, but the first national study to track individual students’ growth shows bans may help reverse declines.
根据首个大规模全国性分析,该分析对比了学生在禁令实施前后的考试成绩,学校手机禁令开始适度提升学生的学业表现。
School cellphone bans are beginning to modestly improve students’ academic performance, according to the first large national analysis that compared students’ test scores before and after the bans.
研究发现,实行严格禁令的学校——要求学生全天将手机锁在袋中——其数学和阅读成绩的提升幅度,相当于学生每年多上了一到两周的课。该研究于周二由哈佛大学教育政策研究中心发布。
Schools with strict bans — requiring students to lock their phones in pouches all school day — saw math and reading scores improve as if students had an additional week or two of school a year, the study found. It was published Tuesday by the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard.
美国学生的考试成绩十多年前开始下滑。这一下滑与智能手机的普及同期发生,引发了关于智能手机在下滑中所扮演角色的疑问。目前关于手机禁令学业影响的证据好坏参半。但新研究表明,禁令开始产生影响。
U.S. students’ test scores began falling over a decade ago. The drop coincided with the rise of smartphones, raising questions about their role in the decline. The evidence so far on the academic effects of phone bans has been mixed. But the new study indicates they are starting to have an influence.
“早期关于手机禁令的研究因暗示影响微小而被忽视,校内手机使用也被排除在成绩下滑的主要因素之外,”哈佛大学教育研究生院教授、该研究作者之一托马斯·凯恩说。“但我们认为那是错误的。” 该研究考察了2021年至2026年间的330万名学生。他们就读于4600所美国学校,年级跨度为三年级至十年级。研究利用MAP测试成绩——该测试追踪从秋季到春季的学业成就——对比了实行严格手机禁令的学校与未实行此类禁令的相似学校学生的表现。
“The earlier studies on cellphone bans have been dismissed as implying small impacts, and in-school cellphone use has been ruled out as playing a big role in the decline,” said Thomas Kane, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and an author of the study. “But we think that’s mistaken.”The study looked at 3.3 million students between 2021 and 2026. They were in third through 10th grade, attending 4,600 U.S. schools. Using scores on MAP tests, which track achievement from fall to spring, it compared the performance of students at schools that put in strict phone bans with those at similar schools that did not have such bans.
年度增幅逆转了平均学生在疫情前几年经历的年度损失约一半。(学生在疫情期间的停课中失去了更多进步。)两项早期研究得出的结论不一。一项针对佛罗里达州单个学区2025年的研究发现,到禁令实施的第二年,考试成绩有小幅上升。另一项利用全国各地学校在多种标准化考试中的平均成绩进行的研究发现,成绩没有统计学意义上的显著增长。
The annual gains reversed about half the annual loss that an average student experienced in the years leading up to the pandemic. (Students lost even more ground during pandemic closures.) Two earlier studies reached mixed conclusions. One, of a single district in Florida in 2025, found small increases in test scores by the second year of the ban. Another, using schools’ average scores on a variety of standardized tests nationwide, found no statistically significant increase in scores.
这项新研究之所以不同,是因为它评估的是个别学生在同一考试中的成绩,考察的是整个学年的成长情况,覆盖全国范围,并延伸至2025-26学年。
The new study is different because it assesses individual students’ scores on the same test, looking at growth over the school year, across the country and through 2025-26.
三项研究的研究人员均表示,这些发现并不一定与早期研究相矛盾。它们都发现至少部分考试成绩有小幅增长——有些增长更显著——且有证据表明增长随时间增加。他们说,这讲得通,因为正如下降是逐年累积的,改善也可能是渐进的。
The findings don’t necessarily contradict earlier ones, researchers on all three studies said. They all found small growth in at least some test scores — some more significant than others — and evidence that growth increases with time. That makes sense, they said, because just as declines added up gradually each year, improvement could also be gradual.
密歇根大学教授、早期全国手机禁令研究作者之一Brian A. Jacob表示,新研究显示的效果与其研究团队发现的“相当相似”。在他的研究中,积极效果太小,不具统计学显著性,但在新研究中则具备了显著性。
Brian A. Jacob, a professor at the University of Michigan and an author of the previous national phone ban study, said the new study showed effects “quite similar” to what his research team found. In his study, the positive effects were too small to be statistically significant, but in the new study, they weren’t.
他警告不要对适度的成绩提升过于乐观,但补充道:“如果这些提升年复一年地累积起来,那可能真正重要且意义深远。”美国考试成绩自1990年以来一直在上升,但在2010年代中期开始急剧下降。
He cautioned against being too optimistic about modest achievement gains, but added that “if they accumulate over time, year after year, that could be really important and really meaningful.”Test scores in the United States, which had been increasing since 1990, began a sharp decline in the mid-2010s.
研究人员表示,原因可能有几个,包括联邦学校问责法《不让一个孩子掉队》的终结,随后是疫情停课和缺勤率上升。手机的大规模普及是另一个原因——到2018年,几乎所有青少年都有手机,大多数表示他们在学校每天都使用手机。
Researchers say there are probably several reasons, including the end of the federal school accountability law called No Child Left Behind, followed by pandemic school closures and an increase in absenteeism. The mass introduction of phones is another — by 2018, nearly all teenagers had one, and most said they used them daily at school.
目前已有46个州实施了学校手机禁令或限制措施。各州的规定各不相同,学校的执行方式也不同,这使得评估其效果变得困难。一些学校要求学生将手机锁起来,另一些学校允许学生随身携带手机,还有一些学校允许学生在午餐时间和课间使用手机。
Forty-six states now have school cellphone bans or restrictions. The rules are different among states, and schools also enforce them differently, which makes it hard to assess the effects. While some schools require students to lock away their phones, others let them keep phones with them, and some allow students to use them during lunch and between classes.
研究表明,严格禁令——即物理上限制学生接触手机——对学业成长的影响最大。
The study indicated that strict bans — physically restricting students from accessing their phones — had the largest effects on academic growth.
各成绩水平的学生在数学和阅读方面均有提升。这让研究人员感到意外,他们原本预期成绩较差的学生受益最大,因为这部分学生的成绩下降幅度最大。
The gains were in both math and reading, for students at all levels of achievement. This surprised the researchers, who expected low performers to benefit most because achievement losses were largest among them.
雅各布教授说:“我认为,了解到没有差异这一点非常有趣且有用。”
“I think it’s really interesting and useful to know there’s no difference,” Professor Jacob said.
在阅读方面,禁令还减少了倒退现象——全年成绩下降的学生变少了。研究人员表示,阅读似乎更容易受到屏幕使用的影响,因为阅读需要持续的专注力,而屏幕往往会挤占阅读时间。
In reading, the bans also cut down on sliding backward — fewer students had their scores decrease over the year. Researchers say that reading seems to be more affected by screen use because it requires sustained focus, and because screens often displace time spent reading.
该研究还考察了不那么严格的政策,例如依靠学生自觉在课堂上不使用手机。研究发现,这些政策也带来了学业提升,但研究人员表示,由于实施和未实施这些禁令的学校在其他方面存在差异,他们对这些结果的信心较低。
The study also looked at less rigid policies, like relying on students not to use phones during class. It found that these also led to academic gains, but the researchers said they were less confident in the results because the schools with and without these bans were different in other ways.
仅靠禁用手机可能不足以扭转考试成绩。研究表明,成功的学校会同时采取多项干预措施,且执行情况至关重要。尽管如此,即使学业影响不大,禁令也是一种低成本的解决方案。
Banning phones probably won’t be enough on its own to turn around test scores. Research shows that successful schools do many interventions at once, and that execution matters. Still, even if the academic effects are modest, bans are an inexpensive solution.
屏幕在课堂内外的普及可能会削弱手机禁令的效果。去年接受采访的几位教师表示,学生们转而使用学校发放的笔记本电脑在课堂上互发信息或上网。研究人员推测,校外使用电子设备的时间也可能影响学生的学业表现。
The ubiquity of screens both in and out of classrooms could dilute the effect of phone bans. In interviews last year, several teachers said students had turned to their school-issued laptops to message one another or use the internet in class. Time spent on devices outside school could also be affecting student achievement, researchers hypothesized.
罗切斯特大学教授、佛罗里达州研究报告作者之一大卫·菲利奥表示,手机的“主要影响几乎可以肯定源于校外使用——睡眠质量下降、心理健康状况变化、分心,以及挤占了本可用于做作业的时间”。
A major impact of phones “is almost certainly due to out-of-school use — the reduction in sleep quality, changes in mental health, distraction, displacement of time that might have been spent on homework,” said David Figlio, a professor at the University of Rochester and an author of the Florida study.
教师和研究人员表示,考试成绩只是手机禁令的一个潜在益处。禁令还可能改善学生的身心健康,例如减少网络霸凌、提升社交技能,或鼓励学生参与课堂讨论。
Teachers and researchers said test scores were only one potential benefit of cellphone bans. They could also improve student well-being, such as by decreasing cyberbullying, boosting social skills or encouraging engagement in class discussions.
加利福尼亚州公共政策研究所K-12教育研究员莎拉·诺维科夫表示,理论认为手机禁令不仅“关乎教学时间,更关乎自尊、心理健康以及与同龄人的联结”。“我认为这些问题在现有文献中尚无定论,但它们与考试成绩同等重要。”
ory is that phone bans are not only “about instructional time, but about self-esteem and mental health and connectiveness to your peers,” said Sarah Novicoff, a research fellow on K-12 education at the Public Policy Institute of California. “Those are the questions I don’t think we know the answer to yet in the literature, and are important alongside test scores.”
在纽约州威斯特切斯特县吉尔·安德森所在的学校禁用电子设备前,她的三年级学生会在上课时给父母发短信,或者手机会在她讲课时响起。禁令实施后,她注意到除学业之外的益处:“孩子们身上没有电子设备时,会花更多时间社交、聊天、玩耍。”
Before Jill Anderson’s school banned devices, her third-grade students in Westchester County, N.Y., would text their parents during class, or phones would ring while she was teaching. Without them, she noticed benefits that went beyond academics: “When kids don’t have devices on them, they spend more time socializing, chatting, playing.”Claire Cain Miller is a Times reporter covering gender, families and education.