德州共和党给了马斯克 17 亿美元、保密特权和特殊通道。现在怎么办?
Texas Republicans Gave Elon Musk $1.7 Billion, Secrecy and Access. Now What?
SpaceX 和特斯拉在德州的根基比在加州时更深,马斯克 2020 年正是为逃避民主党政策才离开加州。
SpaceX and Tesla are more embedded across Texas than they ever were in California, which Mr. Musk left in 2020 to escape Democratic policies.
2024 年情人节,德州州长格雷格·阿博特打断了与妻子的私人晚餐,接听了埃隆·马斯克的电话。
On Valentine’s Day in 2024, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott interrupted a private dinner with his wife to take a call from Elon Musk.
马斯克刚刚遭到特拉华州一家法院的斥责,他的两家最大公司 SpaceX 和特斯拉都在该州注册。一名法官判决作废马斯克在特斯拉的薪酬方案,价值约 500 亿美元,称其为“难以想象的巨额”。马斯克多年来与这位共和党州长建立了紧密关系。如今在电话里,马斯克想知道如果他在德州而非特拉华州注册公司,阿博特是否会支持他的企业。
Mr. Musk had recently been rebuked by a court in Delaware, where his two largest companies, SpaceX and Tesla, were incorporated. A judge had voided Mr. Musk’s pay package at Tesla, valued at about $50 billion, calling it “an unfathomable sum.”Mr. Musk had spent years building a close relationship with the Republican governor. Now, on the call, Mr. Musk wanted to know if Mr. Abbott would support Mr. Musk’s businesses if he incorporated them in Texas, rather than Delaware.
“一百个百分点支持,”阿博特说,他在 2025 年德州大学法学院的一次演讲中复述了这个故事。
“One hundred percent,” Mr. Abbott said, recounting the story in a 2025 speech at the University of Texas School of Law.
马斯克兑现了承诺,进一步将其市值万亿美元的电动车制造商特斯拉和市值两万亿美元的火箭制造商 SpaceX 与德州捆绑在一起。自 2020 年搬到德州以来,马斯克一直在笼络德州的共和党领袖。一段时间里,这项策略回报丰厚。阿博特兑现了情人节的承诺,根据《纽约时报》的分析,在过去两年里给马斯克及其企业提供了至少 17 亿美元的拨款、减税和其他激励。
Mr. Musk followed through, further entwining his trillion-dollar electric vehicle maker, Tesla, and his two-trillion-dollar rocket maker, SpaceX, with the state. Mr. Musk had been cultivating Texas’s Republican leaders since he moved there in 2020. For a while, the strategy paid off handsomely. Mr. Abbott held up his end of the Valentine’s Day bargain, awarding Mr. Musk and his businesses at least $1.7 billion in grants, tax breaks and other incentives in the past two years, according to a New York Times analysis.
自本月大选以来,马斯克在德州的重注变得脆弱。德州选民投票淘汰了他的许多政治盟友,包括阿博特,尽管马斯克在全国范围内给共和党捐了近 5 亿美元。
Since this month’s election, Mr. Musk’s big bet on Texas has become vulnerable. Texans voted out many of his political allies, including Mr. Abbott, even after Mr. Musk gave Republicans nearly $500 million nationwide.
但与六年前与加州决裂不同,现年 55 岁的马斯克这次不易拔腿就走。他比在西海岸创业时更深地扎根于德州。
But unlike his breakup with California six years ago, Mr. Musk, 55, cannot easily pick up and leave this time. He is far more embedded in Texas than he ever was on the West Coast, where he started his business empire.
特斯拉和SpaceX在得克萨斯州控制着七大主要设施,占地至少20,000英亩(约809平方公里),其中包括一个航天发射场、一座锂精炼厂,以及一座正在建设中的1亿平方英尺(约929万平方米)半导体工厂。马斯克本人在该州还个人拥有1,000多英亩土地。据一项估算,他的公司在该州雇佣了20,000多人。马斯克在得州已成立90多家私营公司并购买多处房产。他甚至创建了自己的城市,名为“星港”。
Tesla and SpaceX control seven major facilities in Texas that span at least 20,000 acres, including a spaceport and a lithium refinery, as well as a 100-million-square-foot semiconductor facility that is under construction. Mr. Musk personally owns 1,000 more acres in the state. By one estimate, his companies employ more than 20,000 people in the state. And Mr. Musk has formed more than 90 private companies in Texas and bought multiple properties. He even started his own city, called Starbase.
休斯顿莱斯大学政治学教授马克·琼斯表示,马斯克已在该州变得“无处不在”。
Mr. Musk has become “omnipresent” across the state, said Mark Jones, a political science professor at Rice University in Houston.
这意味着在可预见的未来,马斯克可能不得不与得州民主党人合作,而其中许多人是在竞选途中抨击他的言论中当选的。当选民主党参议员詹姆斯·塔拉里科便在大选后表示,他无意听命于马斯克。
That means that for the foreseeable future, Mr. Musk may have to work with Texas Democrats, many of whom were elected after excoriating him on the campaign trail. James Talarico, the Democratic senator-elect, for one, said after the election that he did not intend to do Mr. Musk’s bidding.
当选州长吉娜·伊诺霍萨同样将矛头指向马斯克。在她作为当选州长的首场新闻发布会上,她宣布马斯克试图购买南得州一处州立公园部分土地——该公园靠近他的火箭发射场,也是她的家乡——的计划已被叫停。在接受《纽约时报》采访时,她采取了更为缓和的姿态,表示欢迎马斯克,“但这必须关乎这种关系能为得州带来什么。”
Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa also took aim at Mr. Musk. In her first news conference as governor-elect, she announced that Mr. Musk’s attempts to buy a portion of a state park in South Texas near his rocket launch site — and her hometown — had been paused. In an interview with The Times, she took a more conciliatory approach, saying she welcomes Mr. Musk “but it needs to be about what a relationship can provide for Texas.”
马斯克及其公司未回应置评请求。大选后,SpaceX和特斯拉的股价下跌。马斯克本月初在X平台上表示,这两家公司“在得州蓬勃发展,因为我们没有时刻在一个压迫性和榨取性的州政府手下运营。”“我们热爱得州”马斯克于20世纪90年代末搬到加利福尼亚州,此前他在离开祖国南非约十年后。21世纪初,他在洛杉矶创办SpaceX并接管特斯拉,在弗里蒙特开设工厂。
Mr. Musk and his companies did not respond to requests for comment. SpaceX’s and Tesla’s shares fell after the election. Mr. Musk said earlier this month on X that those two companies “have prospered in Texas, because we were not constantly operating under an oppressive and extractive state government." ‘We Love Texas’Mr. Musk moved to California in the late 1990s, about a decade after leaving his home country, South Africa. In the early 2000s, he started SpaceX in Los Angeles and took over Tesla, opening a factory in Fremont.
但2020年疫情限制引发了与当地官员的冲突后,马斯克当年12月告诉《华尔街日报》,该州在商业竞争方面已变得自满,硅谷正在扼杀初创企业的创建,因此他要搬到得克萨斯州。
But after pandemic restrictions in 2020 led to a fight with local officials, Mr. Musk told The Wall Street Journal that December that the state had become complacent with business competition and that Silicon Valley was stifling start-up creation, so he was leaving for Texas.
马斯克及其在SpaceX和特斯拉的顾问立即开始与该州的共和党立法者建立关系。
Mr. Musk and his advisers at SpaceX and Tesla immediately began building relationships with the state’s Republican lawmakers.
SpaceX聘请了杰夫·米勒,这位曾与前共和党众议长凯文·麦卡锡合作的策略师,协助马斯克在全州拓展人脉。根据游说记录,自2020年以来,SpaceX已向米勒的公司Miller Strategies支付了100多万美元。根据今年披露的州游说者登记,特斯拉和SpaceX共同聘用了另外10名个人游说者。
SpaceX hired Jeff Miller, a strategist who worked with former Republican Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy, to help Mr. Musk make inroads across the state. Since 2020, SpaceX has paid Mr. Miller’s firm, Miller Strategies, more than $1 million, according to lobbying records. Tesla and SpaceX together use 10 more individual lobbyists in Texas, according to state lobbyist registrations disclosed this year.
马斯克还与阿博特建立了融洽关系,后者自2015年起领导该州。2021年,阿博特在CNBC采访中表示,他经常与这位亿万富翁交谈。
Mr. Musk also developed a rapport with Mr. Abbott, who has led the state since 2015. In 2021, Mr. Abbott said in a CNBC interview that he spoke with the billionaire frequently.
“马斯克一贯告诉我,他喜欢得克萨斯州的社会政策,”阿博特说。
“Elon consistently tells me that he likes the social policies in the State of Texas,” Mr. Abbott said.
阿博特批准了一系列针对马斯克企业的激励措施。去年,阿博特向SpaceX拨付1730万美元补助金,用于扩建其位于奥斯汀郊外巴斯特罗普县的星链卫星互联网服务设施。马斯克在该县还有其他业务,包括他的隧道企业Boring Company、一座名为Snailbrook的公司城镇,以及两打多英亩他计划用于创办学校系统的土地。
Mr. Abbott approved a slew of incentives for Mr. Musk’s businesses. Last year, Mr. Abbott awarded SpaceX a $17.3 million grant for the expansion of its Starlink satellite-internet service facility in Bastrop County, just outside Austin. Mr. Musk has other operations in the county, including for his tunneling venture, the Boring Company, a company town called Snailbrook, and more than two dozen acres where he had planned to start a school system.
“我们热爱得克萨斯州,”SpaceX总裁格温·肖特韦尔当时在声明中说。
“We love Texas,” Gwynne Shotwell, SpaceX’s president, said in a statement at the time.
阿博特在批准马斯克位于格赖姆斯县的巨型半导体工厂“Terafab”的激励措施方面也发挥了关键作用。州长办公室于8月宣布为该项目提供3000万美元补助金,并批准了估计超过16亿美元的税收减免。
Mr. Abbott was also instrumental in greenlighting incentives for Mr. Musk’s mammoth semiconductor factory, known as Terafab, in Grimes County. The governor’s office announced a $30 million grant for the project in August, and has approved tax breaks estimated at more than $1.6 billion.
“得克萨斯州的经济发展激励措施要经过严格的法定程序,其中内置了审查和问责机制,”阿博特的一名发言人说。“同情待遇”近年来,在共和党同时控制得州立法机构两院的情况下,马斯克及其公司在得州立法机构取得了一连串胜利,但这一连胜纪录现在存疑。
“Economic development incentives in Texas go through a rigorous statutory process with built-in review and accountability,” a spokesman for Mr. Abbott said. ‘Sympathetic treatment’Mr. Musk and his companies enjoyed a string of wins in the Texas legislature in recent years when Republicans led both legislative chambers, a streak that is now in doubt.
在SpaceX的游说下,得州议员去年投票通过法案,将星舰基地等航天发射场纳入该州“关键基础设施”设施名单,星舰基地是该公司位于南得州的火箭发射场。另一项法案规定,在星舰基地及类似场所上空飞行无人机属于违法。
After lobbying by SpaceX, Texas lawmakers voted last year to add spaceports like Starbase, the company’s rocket launch site in South Texas, to the state’s “critical infrastructure” facilities. A separate bill made it illegal to fly drones over Starbase and other sites like it.
尽管得州宪法保护公众使用公共海滩的权利,SpaceX还赢得了在火箭发射期间关闭星舰基地附近的博卡奇卡海滩的更大控制权。在一起涉及该海滩、并上诉至州最高法院的相关诉讼中,即将卸任的共和党总检察长、马斯克的盟友肯·帕克森介入诉讼支持SpaceX,随后为判决结果欢呼。
SpaceX also won greater control over closing Boca Chica Beach near Starbase for rocket launches, despite the fact that the Texas Constitution protects access to public beaches. In a related lawsuit that went to the state Supreme Court involving the beach, Ken Paxton, the outgoing Republican attorney general and an ally of Mr. Musk’s, intervened in the court case to support SpaceX, and later cheered the ruling.
帕克森在X上发帖称,这“正是确保SpaceX拥有安全且可运营的发射场所必需的”。马斯克花费超过2亿美元试图让帕克森当选联邦参议员,但帕克森败给了塔拉里科。帕克森的办公室未回复置评请求。
It’s “exactly what’s needed to ensure SpaceX has a safe and operational launch site,” Mr. Paxton posted on X. Mr. Musk spent more than $200 million trying to get Mr. Paxton elected to the U.S. Senate. He lost to Mr. Talarico. Mr. Paxton’s office didn’t return a request for comment.
虽然共和党仍控制得州参议院,但民主党在中期选举中赢得了得州众议院的控制权。政治学教授琼斯表示,至少这将为马斯克及其公司试图推动的任何措施制造僵局。琼斯说:“他不能指望从州政府获得同样的优待、同情待遇。”“亲密且尴尬”马斯克试图将其在得州扩张的许多细节保密,得州对商业友好的记录法以及负责执行这些法律的帕克森为此提供了帮助。
While Republicans still control the State Senate, Democrats won control of the Texas House in the midterms. At minimum, that will create gridlock for any measure that Mr. Musk and his companies try to pass, said Mr. Jones, the political science professor. “He can’t expect the same preferential, sympathetic treatment from state government,” Mr. Jones said. ‘Intimate and embarrassing’Mr. Musk has tried to keep many details of his expansion across Texas a secret, aided by the state’s business-friendly records laws and Mr. Paxton, who enforces them.
在得克萨斯州,企业可以介入公共记录纠纷,并请求州检察长将相关信息保密。现在,帕克斯顿将由民主党州参议员内森·约翰逊取代,后者誓言要调查SpaceX是否不当获得了州政府拨款。
In Texas, a business can weigh in on public records disputes and ask the attorney general to keep the information from the public. Now Mr. Paxton is being replaced by Nathan Johnson, a Democratic state senator who has vowed to investigate whether SpaceX has improperly received grants from the state.
去年,得克萨斯新闻室——一个公共广播电台合作组织——请求获取马斯克及其企业与阿博特办公室工作人员之间的通信记录,以了解他们的关系。据《纽约时报》审阅的请求回复显示,阿博特办公室辩称不应公开这些记录,因为这会暴露政策决策,包括州政府吸引企业投资的具体细节。
Last year, The Texas Newsroom, a collaboration of public radio stations, requested communications between Mr. Musk and his businesses and anyone working for Mr. Abbott in an effort to understand their relationship. Mr. Abbott’s office argued the records should not be released because they would reveal policy decisions, including details of how the state entices companies to invest, according to responses to the requests reviewed by The Times.
该办公室指出,记录可能包含关于阿博特、马斯克及其公司的“私密且尴尬”细节。SpaceX的律师请求帕克斯顿保留这些通信;其办公室裁定许多文件可以不予公开。
The office noted the records could include “intimate and embarrassing” details about Mr. Abbott and Mr. Musk and his companies. SpaceX’s lawyer asked Mr. Paxton to withhold the communications; his office ruled that many of the documents could be withheld.
阿博特最终公开了约1400页记录。除约200页外,其余均经过涂黑处理。
Mr. Abbott eventually released about 1,400 pages of records. All but about 200 were redacted.
上月,伊诺霍萨在特拉维斯县地方法院起诉阿博特,要求获取这些电子邮件,指控他违反了一项允许立法代表查阅机密记录的州法律。她详述了这两名男子关系的亲密程度,包括马斯克在情人节的通话,该通话最早由《得克萨斯论坛报》报道。
Last month, Ms. Hinojosa sued Mr. Abbott in Travis County District Court for access to the emails, accusing him of breaking a state law that allows legislative representatives to view confidential records. She detailed the closeness of the two men, including Mr. Musk’s Valentine’s Day call, first reported by The Texas Tribune.
得克萨斯州法院支持了她的主张,并下令公开记录。阿博特将该法律行动称为“虚假诉讼”,并对该判决提出上诉,这一举措暂时阻止了伊诺霍萨获取记录。
The Texas court agreed with her and ordered the records be released. Mr. Abbott, who has called the legal action “a sham lawsuit,” appealed the decision, a move that temporarily blocked Ms. Hinojosa’s access to the records.
在她准备就职之际,马斯克仍在等待至少两个主要项目的未公开金额激励措施获批:一个是在其星舰基地总部附近规划的数据中心,另一个是特斯拉在福特本德县建设的太阳能电池制造厂,称为“水晶阳光项目”。
As she prepares to take office, Mr. Musk is still awaiting approval for an undisclosed amount of incentives on at least two major projects: a planned data center near its Starbase headquarters and a solar cell manufacturing plant that Tesla is building in Fort Bend County known as Project Crystal Sun.
今年夏天,代表特斯拉的官员向该州申请房产税减免。他们暗示了面对民主党更强烈的抵制时自己可能采取的应对方式:根据州政府文件,他们表示,如果没有这些激励措施,“特斯拉将被迫进一步评估在得克萨斯州以外进行这项潜在投资的可能性”。
Over the summer, officials representing Tesla asked the state for property tax breaks. They offered a hint at how they might respond to stronger resistance from Democrats: Without those incentives, “Tesla would be forced to further evaluate this potential investment outside of the state of Texas,” they said, according to state documents.
劳伦·麦高希是《纽约时报》驻得克萨斯州政治记者,报道这个美国第二大州的政策制定者如何改变本州民众的生活,以及如何影响美国政治。
Lauren McGaughy is the Texas politics correspondent for The New York Times, writing about the ways that policymakers in the second largest state are changing lives for their citizens and influencing American politics.