
美国政府曾要求马斯克及其SpaceX公司在包括乌克兰、伊朗、也门和黎巴嫩在内的多个国家开启或关闭Starlink,以支持外交政策和安全目标。
US administrations asked Musk and SpaceX to switch Starlink on or off in countries, including Ukraine, Iran, Yemen and Lebanon, to support foreign policy and security goals.
近期Starshield在乌克兰的减速令基辅和欧洲不满,泽连斯基表示这损害了无人机的使用,官员们警告称美国对SpaceX的依赖过度。
The recent Starshield slowdown in Ukraine has upset Kyiv and Europe, with Zelensky saying it hurt drone use and officials warning the US relies too much on SpaceX.
路透社称,拜登和特朗普团队曾利用Starlink阻止武装分子使用并援助盟友,显示马斯克的公司已成为美国政策中关键且有争议的一环。
Reuters says Biden and Trump teams used Starlink to block militant use and aid allies, showing Musk’s company has become a key, and controversial, part of US policy.
华盛顿——据六位熟悉此事的前美国高级官员透露,早在十月对乌克兰军方使用埃隆·马斯克卫星通信系统进行限速之前,拜登和特朗普政府就多次要求SpaceX在多个国家开启或关闭Starlink服务。
AI generated WASHINGTON – Well before the throttling in October of Ukraine’s military access to Elon Musk’s satellite communications system, the Biden and Trump administrations had several times asked SpaceX to turn its Starlink service on or off in various countries, according to six former senior US officials familiar with the matter.
四位前官员表示,在乔·拜登总统任期内,这些请求包括关闭服务,以防伊朗代理民兵在也门和黎巴嫩利用Starlink进行通信;以及开启服务,为伊朗境内以及乌克兰提供互联网接入,以支持其军队。
During the presidency of Joe Biden, the requests included switching off the service to prevent Iranian proxy militias in Yemen and Lebanon from using Starlink to communicate, and activating the service to provide internet access inside Iran and in Ukraine to support its military, said four of the former officials.
同样,前特朗普高级官员及知情人士向路透社透露,唐纳德·特朗普总统的政府曾要求马斯克——SpaceX首席执行官——在2025年和2026年美以发动空袭后,使该服务在伊朗可用,期望提升反政府抗议者的互联网接入和通信能力。
Similarly, President Donald Trump’s administration asked Musk, who is chief executive officer of SpaceX, to make the service available in Iran following US-Israeli strikes in 2025 and 2026, in hopes it would bolster internet access and communications for anti-government protesters, a former senior Trump official and a person familiar with the matter told Reuters.
所有受访者均要求匿名。此前关于美国请求Starlink访问的情况首次在此报道。
All the people spoke on condition of anonymity. The previous US requests about Starlink access are being reported here for the first time.
近期因限制乌克兰使用SpaceX卫星服务而引发的争议,使人们对美国政府与马斯克之间的关系产生疑问,后者的公司拥有对美国军方及其盟友至关重要的系统。
The recent blow-up over restrictions to Ukraine’s use of SpaceX satellite services has raised questions about the ties between the US government and Musk, whose company owns systems vital to the US military and to US allies.
拜登时期和特朗普时期对马斯克的请求显示出一种密切关系,即美国政府在前所未有的程度上依赖一家私营公司来帮助实施外交政策。
The Biden-era and Trump requests to Musk show a close relationship in which US administrations rely to an unprecedented degree on a private-sector company to help implement foreign policy.
尽管乌克兰是美国盟友,但最近对乌克兰的限制也让欧洲官员感到不安,其中一些人认为欧洲必须发展自己的军用卫星通信能力,因为目前没有可行的短期替代方案。
The recent limits on Ukraine, despite being a US ally, have also rattled officials in Europe, some of whom argue that Europe must develop its own military satellite communications capabilities because no viable short-term alternative currently exists.
星盾(Starshield)限制削弱了乌克兰军方的作战能力。乌克兰总统弗拉基米尔·泽连斯基上周表示,乌克兰获取星盾——星链系统的军用版——的渠道被有意限制,干扰了该国军用无人机的性能。
Starshield restrictions hobble Ukraine military Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said last week that his country’s access to Starshield, the military version of the Starlink system, had been intentionally limited, interfering with the performance of the country’s military drones.
他还说,乌克兰用于包括防御俄罗斯导弹袭击在内的部分军事活动的星链速度被降低。
He also said the speeds were reduced for Starlink, which Ukraine uses for some military activities including defence against Russian missile attacks.
路透社报道,限制星盾的指令来自白宫内部。特朗普政府已承认速度放慢,但未说明是否下达了该指令。
Reuters has reported that the order to throttle Starshield came from inside the White House. The Trump administration has acknowledged the slowdown but has not said whether it gave the order.
白宫在接受置评请求时,将路透社指向特朗普于10月23日的言论,当时他表示并未就乌克兰星链接入问题与马斯克交谈,并称“如果出现问题,我会解决”。
The White House, contacted for comment, referred Reuters to Trump’s remarks on Oct 23, when he said he had not spoken with Musk about Starlink access issues for Ukraine and that “if there is a problem, I’ll get it straightened out”.
乌克兰驻华盛顿大使馆发言人哈琳娜·尤西普克表示,乌克兰的首要任务是“尽快恢复服务至正常速度,因为我们的人民生命依赖于此”。
Halyna Yusypiuk, a spokesperson for the Ukrainian embassy in Washington, said Ukraine’s priority is “to have the service restored to normal speed as soon as possible, as the lives of our people depend on it”.
SpaceX未对置评请求作出回应,尽管马斯克本周早些时候在社交媒体上写道:“星盾系统归美国政府所有并受其控制。任何速度或使用限制均由美国军方决定,最终由美国总统决定。”民主党众议员杰森·克罗于10月23日呼吁澄清乌克兰卫星服务的最新变化,称美国对SpaceX的依赖存在风险。
SpaceX did not respond to requests for comment, although Musk said in a social media post earlier this week: “Starshield systems are owned and controlled by the US government. Any limits on speed or usage are decided by the US military and ultimately (by the president of the United States).”Democratic US Representative Jason Crow called on Oct 23 for clarity about the recent changes to Ukraine’s satellite service, saying there are risks to the US dependence on SpaceX.
“未经选举的亿万富翁和私营企业不应决定什么符合美国国家安全的最大利益,”克劳说。
“Unelected billionaires and private corporations should not decide what is in the best interest of America's national security,” Crow said.
对乌克兰而言,星链互联网服务已成为前线部队之间通信的命脉,前线人员表示,目前没有任何竞争对手能与SpaceX产品的能力相抗衡。
For Ukraine, the Starlink internet service has become the lifeblood of frontline communication between units, who say there is currently no rival to the capabilities of SpaceX’s products.
“星盾”接收设备极难受到无线电干扰,被用作机载制导系统,并为乌克兰无人机提供与远程飞行员的通信链路,包括在乌克兰境内俄罗斯防线深处。
Starshield receivers, largely impervious to radio jamming, are used as onboard guidance systems and to provide links to a remote pilot for Ukrainian drones, including deep behind Russian lines inside Ukraine.
马斯克的影响力引发不确定性 马斯克作为一家对美国国家安全拥有巨大影响力公司的强势首席执行官,其角色有时引发了关于谁在决定SpaceX卫星服务事务的质疑。
Musk’s influence raises uncertainty Musk’s role as the strong-willed CEO of a company with outsized influence over US national security has at times raised questions over who is making decisions about SpaceX’s satellite services.
卫星行业咨询公司Summit Ridge Group总裁阿曼德·缪塞说:“他本应是一名拥有政府合同的企业高管,但他实际上正在做出重大的外交政策决策。”
The SpaceX CEO is “supposed to be a business executive, with government contracts, and he's essentially making huge foreign policy decisions”, said Armand Musey, president of Summit Ridge Group, a satellite industry consultancy.
缪塞说:“他是一个含糊不清到足以让人无法判断的人,你不知道他的决定是出于个人怪癖,还是因为其他地方的影响力在作用于他。”
“He’s sufficiently ambiguous of a person that you don’t know if his decisions are sort of his personal quirks, or it’s because there’s an influence elsewhere that’s impacting him,” Musey said.
据路透社报道,在过去几年里,马斯克曾采取行动限制乌克兰使用星链。2022年,马斯克下令SpaceX人员切断乌克兰试图收复地区的星链覆盖,此举令白宫官员感到意外。
In previous years, Musk has moved to limit Ukraine’s access to Starlink. In 2022, according to Reuters reporting, Musk ordered SpaceX personnel to cut Starlink coverage in areas Ukraine was trying to retake, a move that surprised White House officials.
马斯克曾公开表示,他拒绝了乌克兰2022年要求在克里米亚港口城市塞瓦斯托波尔激活其卫星网络以协助攻击俄罗斯舰队的请求,理由是他担心会卷入一场重大战争行为。五名前官员表示,拜登政府有时依赖马斯克协助执行政策。
Musk has said publicly that he refused a 2022 Ukrainian request to activate his satellite network in Crimea’s port city of Sevastopol to aid an attack on Russia’s fleet there, saying he feared complicity in a major act of war. The Biden administration at times relied on Musk to help implement policy, five of the former officials said.
他们表示,拜登官员曾与SpaceX协调,通过切断服务来挫败美国对手,并通过扩大星链的可用性来援助盟友。
Biden officials coordinated with SpaceX to thwart US adversaries by cutting the service, and to help allies by expanding Starlink’s availability, they said.
他们补充说,政府与SpaceX之间的讨论通常有五角大楼和白宫官员参与,往往集中在防止也门的伊朗关联组织胡塞武装和黎巴嫩真主党等团体使用“星链”终端。
They added that discussions between the government and SpaceX, which usually included Pentagon and White House officials, often focused on preventing groups such as the Iranian-linked Houthis in Yemen and Hezbollah in Lebanon from using Starlink terminals.
拜登政府官员曾多次与SpaceX分享情报,显示胡塞武装和真主党正在使用被转移的“星链”终端——这些硬件通过中间商流向了武装分子。
Biden officials several times shared intelligence with SpaceX that indicated that the Houthis and Hezbollah were using diverted Starlink terminals – hardware that made its way to the militants through intermediaries.
2023年10月,在以色列与黎巴嫩南部真主党武装分子交战期间,情报官员告知白宫,与真主党有关联的个人可能已获得“星链”终端的使用权。
In October 2023, during fighting between Israel and Hezbollah militants in southern Lebanon, intelligence officials told the White House that individuals linked to Hezbollah could have gained access to Starlink terminals.
五名官员表示,2024年美国对也门伊朗关联组织胡塞武装发动空中打击期间,官员们对胡塞武装也有类似担忧。
Officials had similar concerns about the Houthis in Yemen in 2024 during a US air campaign against the Iran-linked group, five of the officials said.
在这两种情况下,政府都联系了SpaceX,要求其识别这些终端并将其关闭。两名官员表示,至少部分终端已被停用。
In both cases, the administration contacted SpaceX and asked it to identify the terminals and shut them off. At least some of the terminals were deactivated, said two of the officials.
SpaceX在2024年向美国商务部工业与安全局提交的文件中表示,该公司与美国政府机构密切合作,在需要时争取出口授权,并保护技术以支持美国国家安全目标和外交政策目标。
In a 2024 submission to the US Commerce Department’s Bureau of Industry and Security, SpaceX said it works closely with US government agencies to secure export authorisations where required and to safeguard technology in support of US national security objectives and foreign policy goals.
2022年俄罗斯全面入侵乌克兰后不久,拜登政府官员推动SpaceX扩大“星链”供乌克兰军方使用,两名前官员透露了这一情况。
Soon after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Biden officials pushed SpaceX to expand Starlink use for the Ukrainian military, said two of the former officials.
在另一起事件中,据一名前官员透露,拜登政府曾要求SpaceX在伊朗开通“星链”服务,当时正值2022年9月因伊朗女子玛莎·阿米尼因未正确佩戴头巾被捕后死亡而引发的抗议运动。
In a separate instance, the Biden administration asked SpaceX to turn on Starlink in Iran during a protest movement launched in September 2022 after the death of Mahsa Amini, an Iranian arrested for not wearing her hijab properly, according to one of the former officials.
这名官员表示,在政府帮助下,“星链”终端被运入该国,但该官员拒绝透露转移了多少终端。
Starlink terminals were moved into the country with the help of the administration, said the official, who declined to say how many were transferred.
特朗普政府在2026年早些时候采取了类似步骤,并与马斯克和SpaceX讨论将星链终端送入伊朗,并在2025年6月美以空袭伊朗后以及2026年2月再次空袭后激活这些终端,一名前特朗普政府高级官员和一位知情人士告诉路透社。
The Trump administration took a similar step earlier in 2026 and discussed with Musk and SpaceX getting Starlink terminals into Iran and activated following US-Israeli strikes in the country in June 2025 and again in February 2026, a former senior Trump official and a person familiar with the matter told Reuters.
特朗普政府和SpaceX均未公开证实这些终端已被开启。《华尔街日报》2月报道称,美国政府已向伊朗运送了数千个星链终端。伊朗驻联合国代表团未回应置评请求。
Neither the Trump administration nor SpaceX has publicly confirmed that those terminals were turned on. The Wall Street Journal reported in February that the US government had sent thousands of Starlink terminals into Iran. Iran’s delegation to the UN did not respond to a request for comment.