字号·· | 护眼
路透社

香港火灾暴露楼宇维修行业根深蒂固的三合会网络Hong Kong fire exposes entrenched triad networks in building renovation industry

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

香港一个屋苑发生的致命火灾暴露出,与犯罪团伙有关联的围标网络如何利用香港利润丰厚的楼宇维修行业中的漏洞,影响价值数亿港元的合同。

A deadly fire at a Hong Kong housing estate has exposed how bid-rigging networks linked to criminal gangs exploited weaknesses in the city's lucrative building renovation industry to influence contracts worth hundreds of millions of dollars.

在关于政府资助的大埔宏福苑大火的报告中,“三合会”等有组织犯罪团伙被提及超过40次。这场火灾造成168人死亡,数千名居民流离失所。

Organised crime groups known as triads were mentioned more than 40 times in the report on the government-subsidised Wang Fuk Court inferno, which killed 168 people and displaced thousands of residents. In response to the report’s findings, the government proposed to make bid-rigging in building renovation a criminal offence, punishable by up to 10 years in prison and a HK$10 million ($1.3 million) fine.

针对报告中的调查结果,政府提出将楼宇维修中的围标行为列为刑事罪行,最高可判处10年监禁及1000万港元(约合130万美元)罚款。打击三合会的相关法律也将收紧。

Laws against triads will also be tightened. "After all these years, the syndicates are so sophisticated that they make use of all the legal loopholes," said Chiu Yan Loy, founder and spokesperson of the All-Hong Kong Owners' Anti-Corruption and Anti-Bid-Rigging Alliance.

全港业主反贪腐反围标大联盟创始人兼发言人赵恩来表示:“这么多年过去,这些集团已经非常老练,他们会利用一切法律漏洞。”

Some networks delay distributing profits for months and use channels including cryptocurrencies, making money flows difficult to trace, he added.

他补充说,一些网络会推迟数月才分配利润,并利用加密货币等渠道,使资金流向难以追踪。

Lawyers and law enforcement officers say the new offence will only work if it helps investigators gather hard evidence.

律师和执法人员表示,新罪行只有在能帮助调查人员收集确凿证据的情况下才会有效。

"We're talking about offences that exist in a kind of twilight world.

“我们说的是存在于某种灰色地带中的罪行。罪犯之间并不总是有交易、贿赂或书面记录来证明串通行为或卡特尔的存在,”一名因问题敏感而要求匿名的执法人员说。

There aren't always transactions between offenders, bribery or a paper trail to prove collusive behaviour or a cartel," said one law enforcement officer, who declined to be identified due to the sensitivity of the issue.

三合会团伙——成员宣誓以鲜血效忠并保守秘密的兄弟会组织——数十年来一直与勒索、卖淫、贩毒和放高利贷有关联。

Triad gangs — fraternal brotherhoods whose members swear blood oaths of loyalty and secrecy — have for decades been linked to extortion, prostitution, drug trafficking and loan-sharking.

警方和学者表示,他们虽不如20世纪80年代和90年代那样显眼,但仍然活跃,并从事更复杂的白领诈骗活动。

Less prominent than in the 1980s and 1990s, they remain active and operate more complex white-collar scams, police and academics say.

报告解释说,围绕承包商审查和聘用方面的监管松散、执法不严,使他们得以进入建筑生态系统。

The report explained that loose regulation and lax enforcement around vetting and hiring contractors let them enter the construction ecosystem.

行业专家表示,2012年政府推出数亿港元补贴,并配套实施要求业主维修楼龄超过30年建筑的计划后,围标问题进一步恶化,为承建商创造了一个利润丰厚的市场。

Industry experts say bid rigging worsened when the government introduced hundreds of millions in subsidies in 2012 alongside a scheme requiring owners to repair buildings more than 30 years old, creating a lucrative market for contractors.

维克森林大学副教授汤米·梁表示,他的研究显示,该计划推出后,翻新价格上涨了约40%。

Tommy Leung, an associate professor at Wake Forest University, said his research showed renovation prices rose about 40% after the scheme began.

宏福苑的翻新工程费用从最初估计的1.52亿港元升至超过3.3亿港元,这为外界了解涉嫌操纵项目的手法提供了一个窗口。

The Wang Fuk Court renovation, whose cost rose from an initial HK$152 million estimate to more than HK$330 million, provides a window into alleged methods used to manipulate projects.

据报道,涉嫌手法首先是从取得对顾问的影响力开始的,该顾问协助业主挑选承建商。

According to the report, the alleged scheme began with gaining influence over the consultant who helps owners select contractors.

威尔·鲍尔建筑师事务所以22万港元(2.8万美元)的报价拿下该角色,远低于约50万港元的市场估价,随后发出误导性的招标评估,包括给总承建商普雷斯提治建筑在安全合规方面打满分,尽管该公司此前已有定罪记录。

Will Power Architects secured that role with a HK$220,000 ($28,000) bid, well below an estimated HK$500,000 market rate, then issued misleading tender assessments, including giving main contractor Prestige Construction full marks for safety compliance despite previous convictions.

当局已就宏福苑相关事宜提出至少25项刑事指控,涉及普雷斯提治、威尔·鲍尔及七名个人。宏福苑共有八座31层高的大厦,居住着5000多人。报道未说明这些公司是否与三合会有联系。记者未能联系到普雷斯提治和威尔·鲍尔置评。

Authorities have brought at least 25 criminal charges related to Wang Fuk Court, which housed more than 5,000 people in eight 31-storey towers, against Prestige, Will Power and seven individuals. The report did not say whether the firms had triad links. Prestige and Will Power could not be reached for comment. Security Secretary Chris Tang, the former police chief, said on Friday the government would "dismantle the criminal networks behind such activities."

保安局局长、前警务处处长邓炳强周五表示,政府将“瓦解此类活动背后的犯罪网络”。香港现计划赋予执法部门更大的调查权力,成立由警方、廉政公署和竞争事务委员会组成的联合专责小组,并设立一个新局负责监管翻新工程。一些宏福苑前居民并不信服。

Hong Kong now plans to give law enforcement greater investigative powers, create a joint task force involving police, the Independent Commission Against Corruption and Competition Commission, and a new bureau overseeing renovation work. Some former Wang Fuk Court residents were unconvinced. "It's just a slogan.

“这只是口号。他们会说‘我们将打击围标’,但最终什么都不会做,”不愿透露全名的贝蒂说。

They'll say, 'we'll crack down on bid-rigging,' but ultimately, nothing gets done," said Betty, who declined to give her full name.

阅读媒体原文 ↗