字号·· | 护眼
美国有线电视新闻网

法官似乎对特朗普推翻封口费定罪的诉求持开放态度Judges appear open to Trump’s push to overturn hush money conviction

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

Justin Lane/Pool/Getty Images/资料图Justin Lane/Pool/Getty Images/FILE

特朗普连任总统已满两年,他仍在试图抹去2024年的重罪定罪记录。周四,纽约州上诉法院的一个合议庭审理了特朗普对其定罪提出的法律挑战,该定罪涉及伪造商业记录以掩盖封口费支付、从而影响2016年总统大选。

Two years into his second term, President Donald Trump is still trying to wipe his 2024 felony conviction from the books. A panel of New York appellate justices on Thursday heard Trump’s legal challenges to his conviction on falsifying business records to cover up hush money payments to influence the 2016 presidential election.

这五位大法官——均由民主党籍州长任命——有时似乎对特朗普的论点持开放态度,即联邦选举法和总统豁免权可能会影响该定罪。

The five justices – who were all appointed by Democratic governors – at times appeared open to Trump’s arguments that federal election law and presidential immunity could affect the conviction.

特朗普的律师辩称,与向斯托米·丹尼尔斯偿还封口费有关的定罪应被推翻,部分理由是联邦选举法优先于州法律。

His lawyers argued the conviction tied to the reimbursement of hush money payments to Stormy Daniels should be overturned based in part on the argument that federal election law preempts state law.

特朗普的法律团队还表示,审判法官违背了最高法院2024年关于总统豁免权的裁决,允许将白宫官员的证词和特朗普的推文——即官方行为——作为涉及非官方行为的刑事案件中的证据。

Trump’s legal team also says the trial judge ran afoul of the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision on presidential immunity by allowing testimony of White House officials and Trump’s tweets – official conduct – to be used as evidence in a criminal case involving unofficial acts.

特朗普因34项意图实施或隐瞒其他犯罪而伪造商业记录的罪名被定罪。

Trump was convicted on 34 counts of falsifying business records with the intent to commit or conceal another crime.

在审判中,曼哈顿地方检察官办公室的检察官称,该“其他犯罪”是指通过非法手段促成或阻止选举,这可能包括违反《联邦竞选法案》(FECA)、伪造银行记录或税务犯罪。

At trial, prosecutors with the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office said that crime was to promote or prevent an election through unlawful means, which could include violations of the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA), falsifying bank records, or tax crimes.

曼哈顿地检办上诉部门主管史蒂文·吴周四表示:“就底层选举法阴谋而言,关键在于(特朗普)及其共谋者对其所为的合法性其实是漠不关心的。他们想要隐瞒所做之事,并让这些封口费支付在无人知晓的情况下进行。”

“For purposes of the underlying election law conspiracy, the point is that (Trump) and his co-conspirators were really indifferent to the legality of what they were doing. They wanted to hide what they were doing, and to make these hush money payments without anybody finding out,” Steven Wu, Chief of Appeals for the DA’s office, said Thursday.

检察官在审判中表示,违反《联邦选举竞选法》(FECA)是定罪最明显的依据,但特朗普的律师罗伯特·吉乌夫拉告诉上诉小组,这实际上是“推翻原判最明显的依据”。

The FECA violations were the most obvious ground for conviction, prosecutors said at trial, but Trump’s attorney Robert Giuffra told the appellate panel it’s actually “the most obvious ground for reversal.”

“而且法律非常明确,”他说。“司法部和联邦选举委员会拥有监管和执行竞选捐款与支出违规行为的专属管辖权。” 一个由12名纽约人组成的陪审团裁定特朗普所有罪名成立,使他成为重罪犯。特朗普再次当选总统,在其就职典礼前几天,法官判处他无条件释放。

“And the law is quite clear,” he said. “The Department of Justice and the Federal Election Campaign Commission have exclusive jurisdiction to regulate and enforce contribution and expenditure violations.”A jury of 12 New Yorkers found Trump guilty on all counts, making him a felon. Trump was reelected president, and days before his inauguration the judge sentenced him to an unconditional release.

周四,上诉小组质问州政府律师,审判团队在多大程度上依赖 FECA 违规行为来证明特朗普伪造商业记录的 34 项罪名。

The panel Thursday challenged the state’s attorney on how heavily the trial team relied on the FECA violations to prove the 34 counts of falsifying business records against Trump.

“只是部分依赖,”吴(Wu)表示,并补充说,特朗普违反 FECA 的证据是供陪审团考量的事实,而非被指控罪行的构成要件。

“Only partially,” Wu said, adding that evidence of Trump’s FECA violations were facts for jurors to consider rather than elements of the charged crimes.

“联邦法律优先原则的作用是阻止州政府直接执行联邦法规。但这并非本案检方所为,”吴说。

“What preemption does is prevent the state from directly enforcing a federal statute. That’s not what the prosecution was doing here,” Wu said.

大法官巴哈蒂·皮特-伯克进一步追问吴,指出本案涉及竞选捐款。“这显然属于 FECA 管辖范围。你们凭什么绕过这一点?”

Associate Justice Bahaati Pitt-Burke pressed Wu further, noting the case dealt with campaign contributions. “That’s clearly within FECA purview. What are you using to get around that?”

吴说:“FECA 仅限于对捐款和支出的直接限制。这源于判例法,也源于法规。但这起起诉以及被告被定罪所依据的法规,根本不涉及支出或捐款。”“如果你思考一下这起起诉的焦点——一家纽约企业账簿中发生的欺诈行为。那完全不是 FECA 所监管的内容,”这位法官补充道。

Wu said, “FECA is limited to direct limitations on contributions and expenditures. That comes from the cases, that comes from the regulation. But this prosecution and the statutes under which defendant were convicted are not about expenditures or contributions at all.”“If you think about the focus of this prosecution – the fraud that was committed in the records of a New York enterprise. That is not what FECA regulates at all,” the judge added.

吉乌夫拉大量依赖联邦法律优先论点,但仍表示,上诉法院对最高法院 2024 年豁免权裁决的解读可能会开创先例。

Giuffra leaned heavily on the federal preemption argument, but still said the appellate interpretation of the SCOTUS 2024 immunity decision could be precedent-setting.

“未来可能会有其他总统,”朱弗拉说。“这不仅关乎特朗普总统——更关乎未来的总统。”吴辩称,与白宫工作人员的谈话以及特朗普的推文都涉及非官方行为,因此不受豁免权保护;他补充说,即使法官错误地采纳了这些证据,仍有大量其他证据足以定特朗普的罪。

“It could be some other president down the road,” Giuffra said. “It’s not just about President Trump – it’s about future presidents.”Conversations with White House staffers and Trump’s tweets were both about unofficial acts and so not covered by immunity, Wu argued adding that even if the judge erroneously allowed the evidence there was plenty more to convict Trump.

吴辩称,这些证据在证明特朗普有罪的证据中只是“九牛一毛”,因此鉴于压倒性的有罪证据,任何推定的错误都属于无害错误。

They were a “drop in the bucket” in terms of evidence of Trump’s guilt, Wu argued, so any presumed error would be harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence of Trump’s guilt.

“关于总统豁免权,会存在无害错误这种情况吗?”大法官施洛莫·哈格勒发问。

“Can there be such a thing as harmless error with regard to presidential immunity?”Justice Shlomo Hagler challenged.

朱弗拉说,最高法院的豁免权裁决认定总统推文可以是官方行为,因为那是他与美国民众沟通的方式。

The Supreme Court’s immunity ruling determined presidential tweets can be official actions because that’s how he communicates with the American people, Giuffra said.

大法官特洛伊·韦伯宣读了最高法院判决书,并问朱弗拉,特朗普与前白宫通讯主任霍普·希克斯讨论如何回应媒体关于封口费支付的询问,这如何有助于丰富美国人的生活。

Justice Troy Webber read from the Supreme Court decision and asked Guiffra how Trump’s discussions with former White House communications director Hope Hicks to respond to media inquiries about the payment go toward enriching Americans’ lives.

朱弗拉说,这些推文关乎特朗普的任职资格。特朗普的律师补充说,其他总统在任内也曾不得不通过公开声明为自己针对指控进行辩护。

Giuifrra said the tweets relate to Trump’s fitness for office. Other presidents have had to similarly defend themselves against allegations in public statements while in office, Trump’s lawyer added.

特朗普的长期顾问鲍里斯·埃普施泰恩旁听了庭审。法警因他三次使用手机而予以训诫,并威胁要将他带离法庭。

Longtime Trump adviser Boris Epshteyn attended the proceedings. Court officers admonished him three times for using his cell phone and threatened to remove him.

阅读媒体原文 ↗