
数学界围绕 AI 的戏剧性事件正在变得真实起来。周五,Anthropic 的数学家 Levent Alpöge 称他利用 AI 解决了该领域最著名的未解难题,仅几小时后,另一位数学家突然现身,宣称自己也解决了该问题。只是这位数学家表示,他是在不使用 AI 的情况下完成的。
The drama over AI in the math community is getting real. Hours after Levent Alpöge, a mathematician at Anthropic, said he solved the most famous open problem in the field using AI on Friday, another mathematician came out of the woodwork to announce he'd also solved the problem. Only this mathematician said he did it without using AI.
斯坦福大学博士后研究员 Alessandro Masullo 称,他已钻研该问题 12 年,原本还差约一年才会发布成果,却被 Alpöge 的报告打了个措手不及。他在网上发布的一篇论文中写道:“鉴于当前的氛围,我被建议按现状发布当前版本”,并补充说,由于赶工,其中可能存在错误。他在对 Alpöge 进行了一番隐晦的讽刺时表示,人类数学家在 AI 时代依然有其位置。
Alessandro Masullo, a postdoctoral researcher at Stanford, said he's been working on the problem for 12 years and was about a year away from releasing his results when he was blindsided by Alpöge's report. "In light of the current climate I am being advised to release the current version as it is," he said in a paper posted online, adding that there may be errors in it because it was rushed. And in a thinly veiled slight against Alpöge, who described working with Claude for weeks to reach his solution, Masullo said that human mathematicians still have a place in the age of AI.
Alpöge 此前描述称,他与 Claude 合作了数周才得出解决方案。Masullo 说:“如果这项工作要向因当前节奏和基调而感到沮丧的数学家传递任何信息,那就是:我们依然在这里。我们非常活跃。我们不会离开。”
"If any message at all this work is meant to send to the mathematician who feels discouraged by the pace and tone of the current climate, it is this: we are still here," he said. "We are very much alive.
Masullo 的解决方案比 Alpöge 的短得多,立即在数学界引发了进一步的轩然大波,该群体此前已因 Anthropic 这篇前所未有的论文,以及 AI 公司数月来接连宣布攻克长期悬而未决的数学难题而陷入震动。“剧情愈发扑朔迷离!”康奈尔大学数学教授 Steven Strogatz 周五在 X 平台上写道。“现在变得更复杂了,”加州理工学院数学教授 Sergei Gukov 对《商业内幕》表示。
We are not going anywhere." Masullo's solution, which is far shorter than Alpöge's, immediately sparked a further firestorm in a math community already reeling from the unprecedented Anthropic paper and months of AI companies announcing high-profile solutions to long-standing math problems. "The plot thickens!" Steven Strogatz, a math professor at Cornell, said on X on Friday. "Now it's getting more complicated," Sergei Gukov, a math professor at Caltech, told Business Insider.
数学家们正争分夺秒地动用自己的大脑和 AI 来审查这两个解决方案。截至周五下午,两者均未被正式证明。赌注关乎人类数学家在 AI 时代的信誉,而谁的解决方案是正确的,将对数学的未来产生严重影响。
Mathematicians are now racing to scrutinize both solutions with their own brains and with AI. Neither had, by Friday afternoon, been formally proven. At stake is nothing less than the credibility of human mathematicians in the age of AI, and who's solution is right will have grave implications for the future of mathematics.
马斯洛、他在斯坦福大学的合作伙伴布莱恩·康拉德以及阿尔普盖周五未回应置评请求。有关的问题是黎曼假设,斯特罗加茨向《商业内幕》将其描述为数学界的“白鲸”。它提出了素数与其他数字一起出现频率的预测分布。证明该假设的任务是一项千禧年大奖难题,意味着解决它可为数学家赢得100万美元奖金。纳维-斯托克斯方程也属于千禧年大奖难题类别,OpenAI曾声称已解出该方程。
Masullo, his partner at Stanford, Brian Conrad, and Alpöge did not respond to requests for comment on Friday. The problem in question is the Riemann Hypothesis, which Strogatz described to Business Insider as the "White Whale" of mathematics. It proposes a predicted distribution for how often prime numbers appear alongside other numbers. The task of proving the hypothesis is a Millennium Prize Problem, meaning that solving it earns a mathematician $1 million. The Navier-Stokes equations, which OpenAI has said it solved, are also in the Millennium Prize category.
加州理工学院数学教授古科夫称这一宣称是“重大事件”。“黎曼假设曾是数学界最大的难题,”他说,使用了过去时。
Gukov, the math professor at Caltech, called the claim that it was solved a "HUGE deal." "RH was the biggest problem in math," he said, using the past tense.