
企业使用 AI 的程度前所未有,但相关支出并未随之增加。Ramp 最新报告显示,尽管 Token 使用量上升,但 AI 支出在夏末趋于平稳,这表明价格竞争和更精明的客户可能正在限制 OpenAI 和 Anthropic 的收入增长。根据 Ramp 数据,8 月和 9 月的 Token 支出仅增长 1.5%。相比之下,7 月支出较上月增长了 42%。
Companies are using more AI than ever, but they’re not spending more on it. A new report from Ramp shows AI spending flatlined over late summer even as token volumes rose, a sign that price competition and savvier customers may be capping revenue for OpenAI and Anthropic. According to Ramp’s data, token spend only grew 1.5% across August and September. To compare, in July, it grew 42% from the previous month.
随着 Anthropic 筹备 IPO,这些数据暗示投资者若假设 AI 公司将继续保持爆发式增长,可能判断失误。
As Anthropic gears up for its IPO the data suggests investors might be wrong to assume AI companies will keep growing at breakneck speed.
Ramp 首席经济学家 Ara Kharazian 对 TechCrunch 表示:“几乎所有的 AI 支出来自风投支持的高增长科技公司。只要 AI 支出持续上升这没问题,但如果因市场因素或其他原因开始放缓,这些公司将同时放缓,并可能引发其他连锁效应。” Kharazian 称,他已看到证据表明,排名前 1% 的企业 —— 最“痴迷 AI” 的群体 —— 在 8 月和 9 月的支出略有停滞,略低于夏季高峰期的人均 1 万美元水平。他说,该群体的放缓“足以让整体收入放缓,尽管我们看到使用量在上升。”
“Almost the entire spend on AI is from venture-backed, high-growth tech companies,” Ramp’s lead economist Ara Kharazian told TechCrunch. “That’s fine as long as AI spend continues to rise, but if it starts to slow down because of something in the market or some other factor, they will all start to slow down simultaneously, and that could lead to other cascading effects.”Kharazian said he’s already seeing evidence that the top 1% of firms — the most “AI-pilled” — have stuttered slightly in their spend in August and September, coming up just below the $10,000 per-employee they were hitting at their summer peaks. A slowdown among that cohort is “sufficient to slow down revenue entirely, despite the fact that we’re seeing rising volumes,” he said.
Ramp 数据显示,中位数企业和前 10% 企业的支出虽有增长,但不足以弥补差距。中位数企业每员工每月支出 12 至 15 美元,前 10% 企业支出 600 至 1000 美元。
Ramp data shows growth in spending among median and top 10%, but it’s not enough to make up the difference. Median firms spend $12-$15 per employee per month, and the top 10% spend $600-$1,000.
Kharazian 表示:“看看当前的用例,不一定清楚它们能否达到前 1% 企业所处的人均每月 1 万美元的水平。虽然软件和金融等行业对 AI 编程代理需求旺盛,但‘不一定医生诊所或汽车经销商需要在 AI 上花那么多钱。’超高速增长时代可能已结束,现在我们知道从前 1% 身上榨取的‘汁水’可能没那么多了。”他继续说道。
“If you look at the use cases today, it’s not necessarily clear they will get up to that $10,000 per employee per month mark that the 1% is at,” Khazarian said. While there’s plenty of demand for AI coding agents in industries like software and finance, “it’s not necessarily true that a doctor’s office or a car dealership will need to spend that much on AI.” era of hypergrowth may be over, and now that we know there may not be as much juice to squeeze out of the top 1%,” he continued.
10月数据确实出现了再加速,令牌支出从9月23日到10月23日增长了8.9%,但Khazarian表示,支出增长面临的逆风很强。
October data did see a re-acceleration, with token spend up 8.9% from September 23 to October 23, but Khazarian said the headwinds on spend growth are strong.
Khazarian(曾发布一系列名为“AI论点的裂痕”的博客)表示,放缓并非源于需求问题。再次强调,AI使用量在上升。相反,他指出是市场的竞争性质导致的。
Khazarian (who has published a series of blogs called “Cracks in the AI Thesis”) said the slowdown isn’t due to a demand problem. Again, AI volumes are up. Instead he points to the competitive nature of the marketplace.
“OpenAI和Anthropic的降价……只是让使用AI变得更便宜,”他说。9月,OpenAI将GPT-6 Sol和GPT-6 Luna的API价格减半。作为对价格战的回应,Anthropic也大幅降低了Fable 5.1和Opus 5.5的定价——该公司在近期的一份文件中表示,这一决定使收入增长减少了约6亿美元。两家公司还一直在提供企业折扣,旨在锁定支出,但实际上却冲击了它们的收入目标。
“OpenAI and Anthropic price cuts have…just made it cheaper to use AI,” he said. In September, OpenAI cut API prices in half for GPT-6 Sol and GPT-6 Luna. Answering the price war, Anthropic has also made significant reductions to pricing for Fable 5.1 and Opus 5.5 — a decision that the company said in a recent filing slashed revenue growth by about $600 million. Both companies have also been offering enterprise discounts that are intended to lock-in spend, but in reality are hitting their revenue targets.
Khazarian表示,这种动态意味着这已非常明显地成为买方市场。
Khazarian said this dynamic means it has very much become a buyer’s market.
为了锁定客户而补贴昂贵技术的使用,一直是大型科技公司的惯用策略。回想一下,乘坐Uber或Lyft曾经多么便宜,而现在由于几乎没有其他网约车竞争者,从A地到B地的费用已大幅上涨。Khazarian表示,这种动态在AI领域行不通,因为竞争实在太激烈了。
Subsidizing use of expensive technology in order to lock in customers has always been a part of the Big Tech playbook. Just recall how cheap it used to be to take an Uber or Lyft ride, and now that there are few other ride-hail players, the cost of going from A to B has risen significantly. Khazarian says those dynamics don’t work in the AI world because there’s just too much competition.
“Meta和Nvidia也在推出企业级产品,提供价格相当低廉的模型或开源模型,”Khazarian说。他还指出,来自中国和美国的其他开源模型公司,以及一家名为Jev的新公司——一种用于在几个预设输出中选择的轻量级工具——正日益跻身Ramp的顶级表现者之列。
“Meta and Nvidia are also introducing enterprise offerings with pretty cheap models or open source models,” Khazarian said. He also pointed to the range of other open model companies from China and the United States, as well as a new company called Jev— a lightweight tool for choosing between a few predetermined outputs — that is increasingly among the top performers on Ramp.
“对于许多AI应用场景来说,你只需要一个简单的‘是/否’答案,”哈扎里安说。“所以你把你本来就便宜的模型迁移到Jev上,现在你本来就便宜的东西变得更便宜了。”能够以低得多的成本完成工作负载,是推动支出放缓的另一个因素。这在一定程度上归因于AI公司提供的折扣,但也因为企业在精打细算方面变得越来越擅长。
“For a lot of AI use cases, you just need a simple Yes/No,” Khazarian said. “So you take your already cheap models, you shift them over to Jev, and now your already cheap stuff gets even cheaper.”The ability to complete workloads at a much cheaper cost is another factor driving the spending slowdown. That’s partly due to the discounts from AI companies, but also because companies are just getting better at being thrifty.
“随着你在使用AI方面变得非常熟练,你也更善于弄清楚如何控制它,”哈扎里安说。“你更有可能采用默认设置,防止在长时间运行的任务中使用非常昂贵的模型。你更有可能对员工施加一些预算限制。你更有可能通过路由器将部分支出从标准和轻量模型转移到更便宜的轻量模型上。”
“As you get really advanced in using AI, you get better at figuring out how to control it,” Khazarian said. “You’re more likely to use defaults that prevent usage of very expensive models for long-running tasks. You’re more likely to impose some budgets on employees. You’re more likely to offload some of the spend from standard and light models to even cheaper light models via routers.”
Notion联合创始人阿克沙伊·科塔里最近发布了与Ramp的洞察相符的内部数据。他言简意赅地写道:“token哗哗地跑。成本嗷嗷地涨。”
Notion co-founder Akshay Kothari recently posted internal data that matched Ramp’s insights. As he succinctly put it: “tokens go brr. Costs go ahhh.”
“我们此前关于AI支出轨迹的许多假设正开始瓦解,”哈扎里安说。“你可以使用更多AI,但花得更少。这对客户来说很棒……但对模型公司来说未必是好事。而且这确实给它们的收入轨迹带来了新的问题。”彭博社周五报道称,Anthropic的潜在估值从10月初估计的2万亿美元跌至仅1.2万亿至1.3万亿美元。据报道,该公司预计还将从信用评级机构获得很高的“垃圾”评级。
tokens go brrr costs go ahhh October 22, 2026 lot of the assumptions that we had about the trajectory of AI spend are starting to break down,” Khazarian said. “You can use more AI, but use it for less. That’s great for the customers…but it’s not necessarily great for the model companies. And it does introduce new questions around their revenue trajectories.”Bloomberg reported Friday that Anthropic’s potential valuation sank from the $2 trillion estimated in early October to just $1.2 to $1.3 trillion. The company is also reportedly expected to receive a high “junk” rating from credit agencies.
OpenAI也将其提议估值从1.4万亿美元下调至1.25万亿美元,并将其最新融资目标削减了约100亿美元。
OpenAI also lowered its proposed valuation to $1.25 trillion from $1.4 trillion and slashed its latest fundraising goals by about $10 billion.
哈扎里安表示,Ramp的数据集很可能印证了许多投资者的担忧。不过,对于支出轨迹而言,还有一个潜在的亮点,尽管这只是推测。
Khazarian says Ramp’s dataset likely informs many investor concerns. There is, however, one potential brightside for spending trajectories, albeit a speculative one.
超高速增长支出的核心论点在于,人工智能无疑将引入新的应用场景,从而加速发展。AI编程在仅仅一年半前才崭露头角,成为最具商业可行性的产品,并使Anthropic和OpenAI跻身万亿美元市值公司行列。投资者寄希望于出现另一场革命,以推动进一步的支出增长。有人认为,个人智能体将成为继编程智能体之后的下一个爆发点。
Much of the thesis for hypergrowth spending is that AI will undoubtedly introduce new use cases that will accelerate things. AI coding emerged just a year and a half ago as the most commercially viable product that has led Anthropic and OpenAI to becoming trillion-dollar companies. The hope among investors is that there will be another revolution that will drive further spend. Some think personal agents will be the next coding agents.
OpenAI、SpaceX、Meta均已推出各自的个人智能体产品,初创公司Instinct也加入其中。不过,Khazarian持怀疑态度,他认为个人智能体“在经济生产力方面不如编程”,难以提供行业实现持续增长所需的动力。
OpenAI SpaceXAI Meta have all released their own personal agents, alongside startups like Instinct Khazarian is skeptical, though, that personal agents, which are “not as economically productive as coding,” will provide the boost the industry needs for nonstop growth.
Khazarian表示:“预测认为将会有新产品推出,从而推动进一步增长。但基于我们目前能观察到的情况、现有产品以及商业化程度来看,AI支出已经开始放缓。”
“The projection is that there will be new products being introduced that will drive further growth,” Khazarian said. “But based on what we can observe today and the products available and what is commercially advanced, AI spend has started to slow down.”