字号·· | 护眼
纽约时报

意大利数百所学校因炸弹威胁疏散,欧洲多地接连受扰Hundreds of Schools in Italy Are Evacuated as More Bomb Threats Rattle Europe

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

意大利数百所学校因更多炸弹威胁疏散,欧洲各地的恐慌情绪加剧意大利官员表示,在欧洲上周有飞机和新闻机构成为威胁目标之后,并未发现爆炸物。这些虚假威胁加剧了人们对欧洲大陆遭受混合攻击的焦虑。

Hundreds of Schools in Italy Are Evacuated as More Bomb Threats Rattle Europe No explosives were found, Italian officials said, after planes and news outlets in Europe were targeted with threats last week. The hoaxes have added to anxiety over hybrid attacks on the continent.

官员表示,意大利及欧洲其他地区的数百所学校周三在收到通过电子邮件发出的炸弹威胁后被疏散,经查这些威胁均为虚假消息。此前,欧洲各地的航班和新闻机构上周也成为了类似威胁的目标,此次疏散进一步加剧了混乱。

Hundreds of schools in Italy and elsewhere in Europe were evacuated on Wednesday after receiving emailed bomb threats that were determined to be hoaxes, officials said, adding to disruptions after flights and news outlets across the continent were targeted with similar threats last week.

官员表示,最新的信息还发送给了爱尔兰、北爱尔兰和苏格兰的学校,这似乎是有计划在欧洲各地制造混乱的协调行动的一部分,不过他们表示目前尚不清楚幕后黑手是谁。

The latest messages, which were also sent to schools in Ireland, Northern Ireland and Scotland, appeared to be part of a coordinated campaign to sow confusion across Europe, officials said, even as they indicated that they did not know who was behind them.

意大利教育部表示,大约有6300所学校收到了这些匿名威胁。教育部长朱塞佩·瓦尔迪塔拉表示,意大利的情报机构正在进行调查,并暗示这可能与欧洲最近的其他混乱事件有关,包括针对超市制冷系统和血库的明显网络攻击。

Italy’s education ministry said that some 6,300 schools had received the anonymous threats. Education Minister Giuseppe Valditara said that Italy’s intelligence agencies were investigating and suggested a link to other recent disruptions in Europe, including apparent cyberattacks on supermarket refrigeration systems and blood banks.

瓦尔迪塔拉在意大利La7电视台的晨间访谈节目《l'Aria che Tira》上表示:“这不是第一次了。”他接着说:“我们显然需要保持警惕,但我们也必须意识到,在混合战日益被用作破坏国家和经济稳定工具的背景下,我们需要做好准备。”

“It’s not the first time,” Mr. Valditara told “l’Aria che Tira,” a morning talk show on the La7 channel in Italy. “We obviously need to be vigilant, but we must also be aware that in a context where hybrid warfare is increasingly being used as a tool to destabilize nations and economies, we need to prepare ourselves.”

意大利总理梅洛尼于周三召集了部长和网络安全官员会议,但她表示,“目前进行的调查尚未发现任何证据表明存在具体的危险。”

Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni of Italy called a meeting of ministers and cybersecurity officials on Wednesday but said that “at this time, the investigations conducted have not revealed any evidence to suggest that a concrete danger exists.”

她在社交媒体上的一份声明中补充说:“相反,这些似乎是一项旨在引起恐慌和担忧的战略的一部分。”苏格兰警方表示,周三上午,“许多学校收到了威胁信息”。警方在声明中表示:“这些信息已立即受到评估,并被当作恶作剧处理”,并补充说他们并未建议学校疏散。

“Rather,” she added in a statement on social media, “they appear to be part of a strategy aimed at causing alarm and concern.”The police in Scotland said that “threatening messages were sent to a number of schools” on Wednesday morning. “These messages were immediately assessed and are being treated as hoaxes,” the police said in a statement, adding that they were not advising schools to evacuate.

官员们表示,发送给爱尔兰和北爱尔兰学校的类似电子邮件也被当作恶作剧处理。北爱尔兰教育局在声明中表示:“我们强烈谴责这些恶意电子邮件,以及给学校社区造成的痛苦和混乱。”官员们强调,威胁的范围仍然有限。例如,上周受影响的航班数量只是欧洲每天运营的数万个航班中的一小部分。但在欧洲大陆,随着俄罗斯对乌克兰的战争波及边界,混合战攻击和恐吓战术在近几个月震动了航空旅行和其他行业,焦虑情绪高涨。上周发生了什么?

Similar emails sent to schools in Ireland and Northern Ireland were also being treated as a hoaxes, officials said. Northern Ireland’s Education Authority said in a statement, “We strongly condemn these malicious emails and the distress and disruption caused to school communities.”Officials have emphasized that the extent of the threats remains limited. The number of flights affected last week, for example, was a fraction of the tens of thousands that operate daily in Europe. But anxiety is running high on the continent, where hybrid warfare attacks and intimidation tactics have shaken air travel and other industries in recent months as Russia’s war against Ukraine spills over its borders. What happened last week?

炸弹威胁针对多家欧洲航空公司,打乱了数十个航班的秩序,并迫使一些航班紧急降落,部分降落伴随着军机的伴飞。据官员称,所有航班上均未发现爆炸物。

Bomb threats targeted several European airlines, disrupting dozens of flights and forcing emergency landings, some accompanied by military jets. No explosives were found on any of the flights, according to officials.

周五,捷克警方表示,布拉格主要机场收到威胁,称有爆炸物被放置在抵达和起飞的航班上。匈牙利国防部长罗穆卢斯·鲁津-森迪表示,匈牙利战斗机曾临时护航其中一架航班。

On Friday, Czech police said that Prague’s main airport had received threats of explosives placed aboard arriving and departing flights. The Hungarian defense minister, Romulusz Ruszin-Szendi, said that Hungarian fighter jets had temporarily escorted one of the flights.

哥本哈根机场官员也表示,丹麦警方已针对航班威胁做出反应,但未透露细节。

Officials at Copenhagen’s airport also said that Danish police had responded to threats to flights, without giving details.

前一天,官员称,受威胁的航班包括一架从都柏林飞往罗马的爱尔兰航空客机,该航班被改道至法国一空军基地;四架飞往布拉格的航班;两架波兰LOT航空飞往巴黎和布鲁塞尔的航班;以及两架爱琴海航空航班,分别从塞萨洛尼基飞往米兰、从雅典飞往维也纳。11月3日发生的一系列类似威胁曾扰乱波兰、西班牙、保加利亚和意大利的航班。

A day earlier, officials said that targeted flights included an Aer Lingus plane flying to Rome from Dublin that was diverted to an air base in France; four planes heading to Prague; two LOT Polish Airlines flights, bound for Paris and Brussels; and two Aegean Airlines flights, from Thessaloniki to Milan and from Athens to Vienna. A series of similar threats on Nov. 3 disrupted flights in Poland, Spain, Bulgaria and Italy.

周五,在爱尔兰和其他欧洲国家多家新闻媒体办公室因炸弹威胁被疏散(后证实为恶作剧)后,紧张情绪进一步加剧。保加利亚新闻媒体机构Nova报告称,其收到一封炸弹威胁邮件,发件人还声称对针对飞机的威胁负责。官员们怎么说?

Nerves were further rattled on Friday after the offices of several news media outlets in Ireland and other European countries were evacuated following bomb threats that turned out to be hoaxes. Nova, a Bulgarian news media organization, reported that it had received a bomb threat by email that also claimed responsibility for the threats against planes. What are officials saying?

周五,在针对媒体公司的威胁发生后,爱尔兰政府在一份声明中说:“这似乎很可能是一场有组织的破坏行动。”英国运输大臣海迪·亚历山大上周四对英国新闻媒体表示,政府高度重视这些“恶意恶作剧威胁”,但不认为这些威胁可信。

On Friday, after the threats to media companies, the Irish government said in a statement: “It seems likely that this is a coordinated campaign of disruption.”Heidi Alexander, Britain’s transport secretary, told British news media last Thursday that the government was taking the “malicious hoax threats” seriously, but that they were not believed to be credible.

管理罗马两大商业机场的罗马机场公司官员表示,周四上午收到一封用意大利语撰写、主题为“威胁通知”的威胁邮件。该机场运营商的一名发言人称,该邮件由“男性国家的战士”发送,他们声称要让天空因爆炸而“变红”。

Officials at Aeroporti di Roma, which manages Rome’s two commercial airports, said that one threat arrived Thursday morning in an email written in Italian with the subject line “threat notification.”A spokesman for the airport operator said that the email had been sent from “fighters of the male state” who said they wanted to “turn the skies red” with explosions.

苏格兰警方指出,周三的信息“广泛发送给英国和北爱尔兰各地的分发名单,我们的评估依然是,它们不构成可信的威胁。”该机构的网络与欺诈部门正在进行调查。欧洲还有什么事让人感到紧张?

Police Scotland noted that the messages on Wednesday were “sent widely to distribution lists across the U.K. and Northern Ireland and our assessment remains that they do not represent a credible threat.”The agency’s Cyber and Fraud Unit was investigating, it said. What else has Europe on edge?

多个欧洲国家的超市制冷系统受到了疑似网络攻击的影响,其中包括10月的法国,以及本月的爱尔兰、瑞典、比利时和卢森堡。

A number of European countries have been affected by suspected cyberattacks on supermarket refrigeration systems, including France in October and Ireland, Sweden, Belgium and Luxembourg this month.

周一,法国官员指责伊朗策划了10月的攻击,并对三名“隶属于伊斯兰革命卫队电子与网络中心”的伊朗人发出了国际逮捕令。11月4日,法国表示,有一起网络攻击通过提高储存冰箱的温度,将血库作为了攻击目标。目前尚不清楚这些网络攻击是否与炸弹威胁有关。目标是什么?

On Monday, French officials accused Iran of orchestrating the October attack and issued international arrest warrants for three Iranians “affiliated with the Electronic and Cyber Center of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps.”And on Nov. 4 France said that a cyberattack had targeted blood banks by raising the temperatures in storage refrigerators. It is not clear whether the cyberattacks are linked to the bomb threats. What is the goal?

发出威胁者的身份和动机目前均不清楚。但一些官员和专家一直在试图找出目标背后的逻辑。例如,爱尔兰的媒体公司和爱尔兰国家航空公司(Aer Lingus)都收到了威胁,该国本周正在举办欧洲和全球领导人峰会。

Neither the identities of those making the threats nor their motives are clear. But some officials and experts have sought to find a logic behind the targets. For example, Ireland — where media companies and the national air carrier, Aer Lingus, received threats — is hosting summits of European and global leaders this week.

伦敦国王学院安全研究教授彼得·纽曼表示,他看到了混合攻击的特征:目标分散,其目的似乎是制造破坏。“混合战役的目的是制造混乱、不确定性和威胁感,”他说。

Peter Neumann, a professor of security studies at King’s College London, said he saw hallmarks of a hybrid attack: The targets were diffuse, and the goal seemed to be disruption. “The aim of a hybrid campaign is to create chaos, uncertainty and a sense of threat,” he said.

但分析人士一致认为,要极其有把握地将这类威胁归咎于某个具体的主体或团伙,是非常困难的。爱尔兰政府的声明称,目前尚不清楚这些威胁来自“个人还是集中或有组织的行动”。航空风险咨询公司奥斯佩(Osprey)的安全分析师里斯·琼斯(Rhys Jones)表示:“炸弹威胁的成本极低,而且从很容易掩盖的意义上讲,它们的风险也很小。”这意味着形形色色的人都有能力实施此类威胁,包括青少年或恶作剧者。为什么这些诈唬会造成如此大的干扰?

But analysts agreed that it can be extremely difficult to attribute these kind of threats to any one actor or group with confidence. The Irish government’s statement said it was unclear whether the threats were from “individuals or a centralized or coordinated effort.”“Bomb threats are incredibly cheap, and they are low-risk in the sense that they’re pretty easy to obscure,” said Rhys Jones, a security analyst at Osprey, an aviation risk consultancy, meaning a variety of people are capable of performing them, including teenagers or pranksters. Why are the hoaxes so disruptive?

伦敦金斯顿大学航空运营讲师马尔科·陈(Marco Chan)表示,即使一项炸弹威胁被评估为可能是诈唬,当局也很难在不进行彻底搜查的情况下百分之百地确定这一点。

Marco Chan, a lecturer in aviation operations at Kingston University in London, said that even if a bomb threat is assessed as a probable hoax, it is difficult for the authorities to determine that for certain without carrying out a thorough search.

因此他表示,如果航班在空中时收到威胁,当局别无选择,只能让飞机降落进行紧急检查。

As a result, he said, if a threat is received while a flight is in the air, the authorities have little choice but to ground the aircraft for emergency inspections.

陈先生说:“如果对是否存在炸弹威胁哪怕存有一丝疑虑,也必须始终将其视作真的。”

“If there is a shred of concern as to whether there is a bomb threat, they should always treat it as genuine,” Mr. Chan said.

本文的早期版本错误表述了一架飞往罗马的爱尔兰航空航班的出发地。出发地是都柏林,而不是迪拜。

An earlier version of this article misstated where an Aer Lingus flight to Rome had originated. It was Dublin, not Dubai.

我们对报道中的失误致以更正。如果您发现错误,请通过 corrections@nytimes.com 与我们联系。了解更多信息。

We acknowledge mistakes in our reporting with corrections. If you spot an error, please let us know at corrections@nytimes.com. Learn more.

乔纳森·沃尔夫(Jonathan Wolfe)是《纽约时报》驻伦敦记者,负责突发新闻报道。

Jonathan Wolfe is a Times reporter based in London, covering breaking news.

伊丽莎白·波沃莱多(Elisabetta Povoledo)是《纽约时报》驻罗马记者,负责意大利、梵蒂冈及该地区的文化报道。她从事新闻工作已有35年。

Elisabetta Povoledo is a Times reporter based in Rome, covering Italy, the Vatican and the culture of the region. She has been a journalist for 35 years.

阿里·沃特金斯(Ali Watkins)为《纽约时报》报道国际新闻,常驻贝尔法斯特。

Ali Watkins covers international news for The Times and is based in Belfast.

阅读媒体原文 ↗