字号·· | 护眼
经济学人

随着美国抛弃乌克兰,欧洲只能孤军奋战Until recently European leaders thought they had drawn Donald Trump away from do

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

但欧洲人无法完全取代美国的支持,他们在国内也面临麻烦 |4分钟阅读 克里尔·德米特里耶夫,俄罗斯在乌克兰战争中与美国的主要谈判代表,根据他在X上的帖子来判断,他享受了过去两周的时光。美国总统唐纳德·特朗普最近与乌克兰的冲突以及他对俄罗斯的拥抱——尤其是他对购买俄罗斯石油的国家免除制裁——是一个“真正具有历史意义的时刻”。

But Europeans cannot fully replace American support, and they face trouble at home |4 min read KIRILL DMITRIEV, Russia’s main negotiator with America over the war in Ukraine, has enjoyed the past fortnight, to judge by his posts on X. President Donald Trump’s latest bust-up with Ukraine and embrace of Russia—especially his waiver of sanctions against countries buying Russian oil—was a “truly historic moment”.

即将到来的经济协议,尤其是在北极地区的协议,证明了“冰已经破裂”。至于欧洲沮丧的领导人,他声称,本周巴黎和米兰街头的暴力表明欧洲公民正在转而反对“战争贩子”。10月16日,德米特里耶夫转发了一则关于新全球秩序的网络迷因:美国鹰和俄罗斯熊联手对抗英国狮子,以决定一个分裂的欧洲大陆的命运。

Forthcoming economic deals, not least in the Arctic, prove that “the ice has broken”. As for Europe’s dismayed leaders, he claimed, this week’s violence in the streets of Paris and Milan showed European citizens were turning against “warmongering”. On October 16th Mr Dmitriev reposted a meme about the new global order: the American eagle and the Russian bear together taking on the British lion over the fate of a fracturing European continent.

越来越多的,这就是乌克兰领导人弗拉基米尔·泽连斯基眼中的世界样子。“如果美国站在俄罗斯一边……当然我们不会获胜,”他在10月18日告诉NBC电视台。10月16日,泽连斯基在布鲁塞尔的峰会上曾赞扬欧洲人是“真正的领导人”。但他们也面临日益增长的压力:尽管在支持乌克兰方面基本保持团结,但他们对跨大西洋关系破裂的前景感到担忧,且无法取代美国军事和情报支持的损失。他们还面临着日益肆无忌惮的俄罗斯“灰色地带”破坏和威胁、国内财政压力的增加以及政治两极化的加剧。

Increasingly, that is how the world looks to the Ukrainian leader, Volodymyr Zelensky. “If the United States takes the side of Russia…of course we will not prevail,” he told NBC television on October 18th. At a summit in Brussels on October 16th, Mr Zelensky had hailed Europeans as “real leaders”. But they are under growing pressure, too: largely united in supporting Ukraine, yet alarmed by the prospect of a transatlantic breakdown and unable to replace the loss of American military and intelligence support. They also face ever more brazen Russian “grey-zone” sabotage and intimidation, growing fiscal pressures and more polarised politics at home.

10月17日,德国总理弗里德里希·默茨告诉他所属基督教民主联盟的青年翼:“我们不能让[乌克兰]及其人民自生自灭。”但民粹右翼选择党(AfD)的联合领导人爱丽丝·魏德尔——该党在民意调查中领先——坚持认为,“90%的德国人反对继续在乌克兰燃烧德国纳税人的钱”。她声称,恢复与俄罗斯的能源交易将降低能源成本并提振经济。

On October 17th Friedrich Merz, the German chancellor, told the youth wing of his Christian Democratic Union that “we must not leave [Ukraine] and its people to fend for themselves”. But Alice Weidel, co-leader of the populist-right Alternative for Germany, which leads in opinion polls, insists that “90% of Germans oppose the continued burning of German taxpayers’ money in Ukraine”. A return to energy deals with Russia, she claims, would lower energy costs and boost the economy.

直到最近,欧洲各国领导人还以为自己已成功说服特朗普打消以牺牲乌克兰利益为代价与俄罗斯达成交易的念头。今年6月,他们甚至促使特朗普签署了七国集团声明,承诺“强化各项制裁措施,包括针对石油和天然气行业的制裁”。然而,距离美国中期选举仅剩两周多时间,其所在的共和党又面临失去国会参众两院控制权的风险,特朗普的立场随即发生转变。

Until recently European leaders thought they had successfully drawn Mr Trump away from the notion of doing deals with Russia at Ukraine’s expense. In June they even got him to sign up to a G7 statement pledging to “strengthen our sanctions, including those on the oil and gas sectors”. But with America’s midterm elections slightly more than two weeks away, and his Republican Party at risk of losing control of one or both houses of Congress, Mr Trump has changed his tune.

10月9日,他宣布与弗拉基米尔·普京达成协议:暂时解除相关制裁,允许俄罗斯向美国及其他国家出口更多柴油。特朗普声称此举能降低燃油价格,但经济学家们认为效果微乎其微。随后他又宣称俄罗斯与乌克兰将停止对彼此的能源基础设施实施轰炸。然而俄罗斯完全无视这一所谓的“能源停火协议”,乌克兰也仅短暂遵守了几天。

On October 9th he announced a deal with Vladimir Putin to lift sanctions temporarily to allow Russia to sell more diesel to America and other countries. He promised the move would bring down fuel prices; economists think it will be ineffectual. Mr Trump then declared that Russia and Ukraine would stop bombing each other’s energy infrastructure. Russia disregarded that so-called energy ceasefire, and Ukraine observed it only briefly.

后来,由于美国莫名其妙地未向乌克兰预警即将发生的弹道导弹袭击,还禁止乌方高速无人机使用星链卫星网络,乌克兰便彻底不再有所顾忌。特朗普则坚称自己并未下达停止此类支援的命令。10月16日,他以“国家利益”为由,豁免了国会新规定中对购买俄罗斯石油和天然气国家的制裁措施。

It abandoned all restraint after America mysteriously failed to warn it of impending ballistic-missile attacks, and blocked its high-speed drones from using the Starlink internet-satellite system. Mr Trump claimed he had given no orders to halt such support. On October 16th he waived new congressionally-mandated sanctions against countries buying Russian oil and gas, citing “national interests”.

乌克兰仍能使用哪些美国卫星的细节仍然模糊不清,而泽连斯基现在表示,对星链的访问正在恢复。但如果限制技术支持和施加政治压力旨在阻止对俄罗斯炼油厂的袭击,那么它们显然已经失败。10月18日,乌克兰发动了迄今为止针对圣彼得堡最大规模的无人机袭击,点燃了该市的油库终端,并击中了其他目标。梅尔茨认为,远程打击是正当的。

The details of what access Ukraine still has to American satellites are still murky, and Mr Zelensky now says access to Starlink is being restored. But if restricting technical support and exerting political pressure were intended to halt attacks on Russian refineries, they have plainly failed. On October 18th Ukraine launched the biggest drone assault yet against St Petersburg, setting the city’s oil terminal alight and striking other targets. Mr Merz, for one, says long-range strikes are justified.

“这些打击是乌克兰唯一能让俄罗斯明白它已准备好认真捍卫自己的手段。”泽连斯基则认为,对俄罗斯的让步只会延长战争。但他的反击和对特朗普的公开批评可能正在加速与美国的永久疏离,并最终削弱乌克兰在战场上的地位。欧洲盟友和乌克兰的创新型国防工业目前尚无法替代美国的一些能力:弹道导弹发射的早期预警、用于拦截的爱国者导弹,以及星链在低地球轨道上的密集互联网卫星网络。

“These strikes are the only means Ukraine has to make Russia understand it is ready to seriously defend itself.”Mr Zelensky argues that concessions to Russia only lengthen the war. But his ripostes and open criticism of Mr Trump may be hastening a permanent estrangement with America, and ultimately weakening Ukraine’s position on the battlefield. Neither European allies nor Ukraine’s innovative defence industries can yet substitute for some of America’s capabilities: early warning of ballistic-missile launches, Patriot missiles to intercept them and Starlink’s dense network of internet satellites in low-Earth orbit.

4月,欧盟批准了价值900亿欧元(1010亿美元)的贷款,以帮助支付乌克兰今年及明年的需求。但10月16日,泽连斯基要求明年再提供700亿欧元,部分用于提升国内武器生产。他得到了同情的倾听,但没有得到承诺。许多欧洲政府的预算因沉重的债务、上升的债券收益率和高昂的能源价格而紧张。一些领导人再次主张动用欧洲冻结的价值超过2000亿欧元的俄罗斯资产来为乌克兰提供资金。比利时——这些资产大多存放在那里——到目前为止一直拒绝考虑这一想法,担心这会损害欧洲的财产权。

In April the European Union approved loans worth €90bn ($101bn) to help pay for Ukraine’s needs this year and next. But on October 16th Mr Zelensky asked for €70bn more next year, in part to boost domestic weapons production. He got a sympathetic hearing but no promises. Many European government budgets are strained by heavy debts, rising bond yields and high energy prices. Some leaders are again pushing to use more than €200bn-worth of frozen Russian assets in Europe to fund Ukraine. Belgium, where most of them are held, has so far refused to entertain the notion, fearing the damage to property rights in Europe.

据称,美国曾向欧洲施压,要求其解冻部分俄罗斯资产,其依据是一种站不住脚的理论——即这种绥靖政策会促使克里姆林宫参与和谈。默尔茨拒绝了这一观点,宣称:“这是我们的事,我们正在对此作出决定。” 欧洲人的唯一安慰在于,美国对特朗普的两党批评声音日益高涨。共和党在中期选举中的失利可能使乌克兰的支持者变得更加坚定。

America has reportedly entreated Europe to unfreeze some Russian assets, on the dubious theory that such appeasement would encourage the Kremlin to engage in peace talks. Mr Merz rejected that notion, declaring: “This is our business and we are deciding over it.”The only consolation for Europeans is that bipartisan criticism of Mr Trump has grown louder in America. Republican losses in the midterms might allow Ukraine’s supporters to become more assertive.

然而,这并无保证:如果特朗普在国内受到约束,他很可能会寻找替罪羊。这可能意味着他会对国外 perceived 的敌人进行更猛烈的攻击。■ 探索更多 预计法国将再次爆发激烈抗议 没有人在解决该国面临的核心问题 葡萄牙已限制移民,西班牙可能效仿 两国的移民潮在政治上看来不可持续

There’s no guarantee of that, however: If Mr Trump is chastened at home he is likely to seek someone to blame. That could mean lashing out even harder at his perceived foes abroad. ■ Explore more Expect violent protests to erupt in France again No one is addressing the core problems that the country faces Portugal has limited immigration, and Spain may follow The wave of immigrants in both countries looks politically unsustainable