中国的科技巨头在试图跟上美国竞争对手在人工智能尖端领域的步伐时,本已举步维艰。在英伟达丑闻爆发后出台的新美国规则,将使它们放缓得更厉害。
China’s tech champions were already limping as they tried to keep pace with American competitors at the cutting edge of artificial intelligence. New U.S. rules issued in the aftermath of the scandal at Nvidia are set to slow them down even more.
美国商务部本周表示,正在堵住漏洞,这些漏洞曾允许中国公司通过远程访问中国境外(尤其是东南亚)的数据中心,绕过对英伟达最强大AI芯片的出口限制。
The Commerce Department this week said it was closing loopholes that allowed Chinese companies to bypass export restrictions on Nvidia’s most powerful AI chips by remotely accessing them through data centers outside China, especially in Southeast Asia.
据知情人士透露,新规针对的是像Megaspeed这样的公司,后者在该地区建设数据中心,并安排将价值数十亿美元的顶级英伟达芯片运往中国。英伟达创始人黄仁勋与Megaspeed前高管Alice Huang的婚外情曝光,毁了这位创始人的职业生涯,并招致了美国证券交易委员会的调查。
The rule targets companies like Megaspeed, which built data centers in the region and arranged for billions of dollars’ worth of top-of-the-line Nvidia chips to be shipped to China, according to people familiar with the situation. The revelation of an affair between Jensen Huang and former Megaspeed executive Alice Huang has blown up the Nvidia founder’s career and invited an investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
新规已经产生影响。据知情人士透露,银行家们正在重新评估为新加坡公司Aolani Cloud采购英伟达芯片提供融资的计划,以向中国科技巨头字节跳动提供算力。
The new rules are already having an impact. Bankers are reassessing plans to finance the purchase of Nvidia chips by Singapore-based Aolani Cloud to provide computing power to Chinese tech giant ByteDance, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Aolani发言人表示,公司正在努力确保自身保持合规。中国商务部抨击新规是滥用出口管制。
An Aolani spokesman said the company was working to ensure it remains compliant. China’s Ministry of Commerce slammed the new rules as an abuse of export controls.
切断中国获取美国高端算力的举措,给北京的AI前景带来沉重打击,尤其是在短期内。中国在推动AI进步的许多因素上与美国持平或领先,例如工程人才和能源获取。但在制造最好芯片方面,中国至少落后美国10年。
The move to cut off China from high-end American computing power delivers a heavy blow to Beijing’s AI prospects, particularly in the near term. China matches or beats the U.S. in many of the factors that drive progress in AI, such as engineering talent and access to energy. But it is at least 10 years behind the U.S. in making the best chips.
尽管中国政府大力推广国产芯片,但该国顶尖AI实验室仍继续依赖英伟达硬件来构建其旗舰模型,尤其是在密集的早期训练阶段。美国美国限制英伟达最先进芯片对华出口,导致许多实验室通过在马来西亚和印度尼西亚等地数据中心获取这些芯片来训练模型。这种变通做法可能不再行得通。对中国人工智能行业来说,这一时机也很糟糕,该行业一直在艰难地创造利润。
Despite a push by China’s government to promote the country’s domestic chips, the country’s top AI labs have continued to rely on Nvidia hardware to build their flagship models, especially during intensive early-stage training. U.S. restrictions on exports of Nvidia’s most advanced chips to China led many labs to access them through data centers in places like Malaysia and Indonesia to train their models. That workaround may no longer work. It also comes at a bad time for the Chinese AI industry, which has been struggling to generate profits.“The new regulations will close the door to most Chinese lab remote access,” said Daniel Nishball, director of research at SemiAnalysis, an AI-infrastructure data and consulting firm.
AI基础设施数据与咨询公司SemiAnalysis的研究总监丹尼尔·尼什鲍尔表示:“新规将关上大多数中国实验室远程访问的大门。”据业内人士称,中国人工智能公司已经在探索通过与中国没有明显关联的当地实体,访问美国和欧洲的数据中心。但业内人士表示,这类安排将存在风险,而且找到足够大的算力集群来训练新模型会很困难。
Chinese AI companies are already exploring ways to access data centers in the U.S. and Europe through local entities without obvious ties to China, according to industry insiders. But such arrangements will be risky, and finding clusters of computing power big enough to train new models will be difficult, the insiders say.
中国已利用走私硬件(包括英伟达的Blackwell芯片)建成了几个大型国内算力集群。不过,业内人士表示,这些还远远不能满足AI训练需求。填补算力缺口的任务将最沉重地落在华为技术有限公司肩上。华为是中国科技设备巨头,也是中国国内最强大AI芯片的生产商。该公司利用其电信业务积累的网络技术专长,将数十万颗AI芯片捆绑成集群,并称这些集群的性能接近美国最先进的芯片。
China has managed to build several large domestic computing clusters using smuggled hardware, including Nvidia’s Blackwell chips. Still, the insiders say those are far from enough to meet AI training demand. The task of filling the void in computing power will fall heaviest on Huawei Technologies, the Chinese tech-equipment giant and producer of the country’s most powerful domestic AI chips. The company has used networking expertise from its telecommunications business to bundle together hundreds of thousands of AI chips into clusters that it says approach the performance of cutting-edge American silicon.
知情人士称,中国AI初创公司DeepSeek一直在用华为的升腾芯片训练其下一代旗舰模型V5。他们表示,如果新模型主要使用华为硬件成功训练完成,那将表明中国国产芯片有能力进行大规模前沿AI训练。DeepSeek计划依靠华为硬件训练V5一事最早由The Information报道。华为9月表示,计划明年推出两款新的AI芯片,并计划在2028年和2029年进一步发布新品。
Chinese AI startup DeepSeek has been training its next flagship model, V5, on Huawei’s Ascend chips, people familiar with the matter said. If the new model is successfully trained mainly using Huawei’s hardware, that would indicate Chinese domestic chips are capable of large-scale frontier AI training, they said. DeepSeek’s plan to rely on Huawei hardware to train V5 was first reported in the Information. Huawei said in September that it plans to introduce two new AI chips next year, with further releases planned for 2028 and 2029.
根据两家公司公布的规格,这些芯片所能提供的算力仍将落后于英伟达最好的芯片。即便合作被证明成功、新芯片如期面世,华为还面临另一个问题。美国对芯片制造设备的出口管制意味着中国难以大量生产高质量的人工智能芯片。华为被美国列入黑名单,在获取芯片制造工具方面面临更严格的限制。华为最新芯片的计划产量——今年约75万颗——远远无法满足需求。
The computing power that these chips can deliver will still trail the best Nvidia chips, according to specifications released by the two companies. Even if the collaboration proves successful and the new chips arrive on time, Huawei faces another problem.U.S. export controls on chip-making equipment mean China struggles to produce high-quality AI chips in large quantities. Huawei was blacklisted by the U.S. and faces even stricter limits on access to chip-making tools. Huawei’s planned production of its latest chip—around 750,000 this year—falls far short of demand.
华为已将这些芯片中的许多安装在内蒙古和林格尔县的一座大型设施内。这是中国最大的数据中心之一,但据总部位于美国的研究公司Epoch AI近期的分析,它提供的算力仍仅相当于美国最大数据中心——位于田纳西州的SpaceX“巨像2号”——的约7%。算力短缺在中国已经显现。自11月中旬以来,DeepSeek对其聊天机器人施加了限制,包括限制其可读取文档的长度。
Huawei has installed many of those chips inside a sprawling facility in Inner Mongolia’s Horinger County. It is one of the largest data centers in China, but it still only offers around 7% of the computing power of the largest data center in the U.S., SpaceX’s Colossus 2 in Tennessee, according to recent analysis by Epoch AI, a U.S.-based research firm. Computing shortages are already apparent in China. Since mid-November, DeepSeek has imposed restrictions on its chatbot, including limits on the length of documents it would read.
据知情人士称,该公司正在重新调配算力资源,以优先保障训练任务。Moonshot在7月发布其旗舰模型Kimi K3后不久便暂停了新订阅。随后在10月,该公司在发布该模型的更新版本Kimi K3.1 Pro后,为限制使用而致歉。
The company was reallocating its computing resources to give priority to training workloads, according to people familiar with the matter. Moonshot suspended new subscriptions shortly after it released its flagship Kimi K3 model in July. Then in October, the company apologized for limiting usage after releasing an update to the model, Kimi K3.1 Pro.
为DeepSeek、Moonshot AI和阿里巴巴工作的工程师表示,过去一年研究进度,尤其是推出新模型的进度,已多次放缓,部分原因是算力容量短缺。DeepSeek和Moonshot AI未回应置评请求。阿里巴巴拒绝置评。中国获取美国芯片的渠道可能会变得更加紧张。
Engineers working for DeepSeek, Moonshot AI and Alibaba said the pace of research, especially in rolling out new models, has repeatedly slowed down in the past year, partly due to computing capacity shortages. DeepSeek and Moonshot AI didn’t respond to requests for comment. Alibaba declined to comment. Chinese access to U.S. chips could get even tighter.
美国议员正在考虑对芯片技术和芯片制造设备实施新的出口管制,包括赋予国会阻止特定出口许可证的权力。周三,美国国会的美中经济与安全审查委员会建议制定新规,阻止任何会导致芯片制造或人工智能产能从美国转移到中国的对华芯片出口。包括英伟达的黄仁勋在内的批评者认为,中国应继续依赖美国技术,而不是在美国控制之外发展自己的芯片。
American lawmakers are considering new export controls on chip technology and chip-making equipment, including giving Congress the authority to block specific export licenses. On Wednesday, the congressional U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission recommended new rules blocking any export of chips to China that would divert chip manufacturing or AI capacity from the U.S.Critics, including Nvidia’s Huang, have argued that China should remain reliant on American technology rather than developing its own chips outside U.S. control.
支持管制的人士则表示,中国领导人习近平已将发展国内芯片供应作为国家安全事项列为优先任务。“中国人已经决定了行动方向,那就是他们打算要么窃取技术,要么自建技术,或者两者兼而有之,”美中经济与安全审查委员会副主席迈克·奎肯说。“在他们看来,他们不能依赖民主世界的技术。”总部位于美国的研究公司Tech Buzz China创始人马睿表示,收紧获取美国技术的渠道,可能会促使中国国内科技公司更加认真地投入芯片研发,从而加快中国的时间表。
Proponents of controls say Chinese leader Xi Jinping has prioritized developing domestic chip supplies as a matter of national security.“The Chinese have decided the course of action here, which is they intend to either steal the technology or build the technology, or both,” said Mike Kuiken, vice chair of the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission. “They cannot, in their view, be dependent on the democratic world’s technologies.”Tightening access to American technology could accelerate China’s timeline by encouraging domestic tech companies to devote more serious attention to developing chips, said Rui Ma, founder of Tech Buzz China, a U.S.-based research firm.
但鉴于中国在芯片技术上仍远远落后于美国,因失去美国算力而感受到的任何压力都不太可能带来立竿见影的进展。“这需要一段时间,”马睿说。联系本文作者Josh Chin,邮箱:Josh.Chin@wsj.com
But given how far China remains behind the U.S. in chip technology, any pressure the country feels from losing access to American computing power isn’t likely to produce immediate progress.“It is going to take a while,” said Ma. Write to Josh Chin at Josh. Chin@wsj.com