字号·· | 护眼
福克斯新闻网

专家警告影响深远:特朗普移民“橄榄枝”恐打开潘多拉魔盒Trump's immigration olive branch threatens to open Pandora's box as experts warn of far-reaching fallout

点「原文对照」整页切到原文,或双击某段只看那段的原文。

在中期选举后不久播出的《60分钟》专访中,总统唐纳德·特朗普表示愿意与民主党人“达成协议”,允许部分非法移民获得合法身份。随后,福克斯新闻网采访了多位移民专家,探讨此类协议可能产生的影响。

After President Donald Trump signaled in a "60 Minutes" interview that aired shortly after the midterm elections that he was willing to "work on a deal" with Democrats to allow some illegal immigrants to gain legal status, Fox News Digital spoke with several immigration experts about the potential ramifications of such an agreement.

该专访播出之际,距离共和党在中期选举中遭遇惨败仅过去几天,引发外界猜测特朗普是否会在移民问题上妥协。但总统随后排除了大赦的可能性,表示“不会有大赦”,同时坚称其移民政策没有改变。

The interview came just days after Republicans suffered crushing losses in the midterm elections, raising questions about whether Trump might be willing to compromise on immigration. But the president later ruled out amnesty, saying, "There won't be amnesty," while maintaining that his immigration policy had not changed.

尽管特朗普未提出具体方案,但其言论引发了关于潜在协议内容、以及给予部分非法移民合法身份可能如何影响法治、同化和财政政策的疑问。

While Trump has not outlined a specific proposal, his comments have raised questions about what a potential deal could look like and how granting legal status to some illegal immigrants could impact the rule of law, assimilation and fiscal policy.

福克斯新闻网采访了三位移民专家,探讨潜在协议对国家的意义,包括对法治、同化和纳税人的影响。

Fox News Digital spoke with three immigration experts about what a potential agreement could mean for the country, including its impact on the rule of law, assimilation and taxpayers.

“我认为首先必须考虑的一点是对法治的影响,以及是否会削弱法治。很难说服人认为,恢复法治和应对非法移民的最佳途径,是奖励某大部分违法者,”移民研究中心(CIS)研究主任史蒂文·卡马罗塔表示。

"I think one of the first things we have to always consider is the impact on the rule of law and does it undermine it. It's very hard to argue that the best way to restore the rule of law and deal with illegal immigration is to reward some large fraction of people who've broken the law," said Steven Camarota, the director of research at the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS).

美国总统唐纳德·特朗普于2025年9月19日签署了两项行政命令,设立“特朗普金卡”,并对H-1B签证征收10万美元费用。“特朗普金卡”是一项签证计划,允许外国公民通过100万美元投资获得美国永久居留权和入籍途径。President Donald Trump signed two executive orders on Sept. 19, 2025, establishing the "Trump Gold Card" and introducing a $100,000 fee for H-1B visas. The "Trump Gold Card" is a visa program that allows foreign nationals permanent residency and a pathway to U.S. citizenship for a $1 million investm

卡马罗塔认为,大赦引发了基本公平性问题,并影响那些合法入境美国的人如何看待移民制度。“在我看来,这似乎是在嘲笑他们,”他说。

Camarota believes that amnesty begs the question of basic fairness, and impacts how people who have come to the United States legally view the immigration system. "It seems like it mocks them," he said.

他以非法逾期居留签证者为例阐述观点,称此类人不应因逾期居留而获得公民身份作为奖励,尤其是当已有数百万人遵守法律、在签证到期后离境的情况下。

He used the example of a person who illegally overstays a visa to illustrate his point, saying that person shouldn't be rewarded with citizenship after overstaying a visa, especially when there are millions of people who have already followed the law and left the country when their visas expired.

乔治·W·布什总统中心移民政策主任劳拉·柯林斯承认了这些担忧,但认为该国的移民法律是问题的一部分。

Laura Collins, director of immigration policy at the George W. Bush Presidential Center, acknowledged those concerns but argued that the country's immigration laws are part of the problem.

“我理解人们对法治的担忧,”柯林斯说。“我也认为,现行的一套移民法律并未按预期发挥作用,之所以有这么多无证人员滞留此地,是因为我们的经济吸纳了大量劳动力,但移民制度却限制了这种劳动力流动。”她说,美国正处于十字路口:国家可以选择一种制度,让非法移民无法留下并纠正错误,同时也为经济做贡献;或者让他们留下,并给予一个补偿的机会。

"I understand people's concerns about the rule of law," said Collins. "I also think you have a set of immigration laws that are not working as intended, the reason we have so many people who are here undocumented is because we have an economy that pulls in a lot of people's work, but an immigration system that restricts that labor flow." She says the United States is at a crossroads: the country can choose a system where illegal immigrants cannot stay and fix their mistakes while also contributing to the economy, or they can stay and be offered a chance at restitution.

“几乎每一项在移民问题上有通过机会、且涉及合法化计划的立法,都包含补缴税款、接受背景审查、缴纳某种罚款或费用或补偿金等条款,以弥补这些人因逾期居留或偷越边境而做了违法之事这一事实,”她说。

"Almost every single piece of legislation that, has had a chance at passage on immigration that involves legalization program has had things like paying back taxes, going through a background check, paying some sort of fine or fee or restitution payment in order to make up for the fact that these people did something illegal by either overstaying a visa or crossing the border," she said.

2014年9月19日,在新泽西州泽西市自由州立公园举行的入籍宣誓仪式上,移民宣誓效忠美国。(John Moore/盖蒂图片社)Immigrants take the oath of citizenship to the United States during a naturalization ceremony at Liberty State Park on Sept. 19, 2014, in Jersey City, New Jersey. (John Moore/Getty Images)

但卡马罗塔质疑,未来的大赦协议是否真的会要求移民在获得公民身份前完成这些补偿支付。

But Camarota questioned whether a future amnesty agreement would actually require immigrants to complete those restitution payments before obtaining citizenship.

卡马罗塔还表示,限制移民的主要原因之一,是为了确保美国不会不堪重负。

Camarota also said that one of the main reasons for restricting immigration in the first place is to ensure that the United States isn't overwhelmed.

“我们不希望数量大到淹没同化进程,导致你去的学校全是同背景的人,或者你根本不必学英语,因为周围有足够多说你母语的人,”他说。

"We don't want the numbers to be so large that they overwhelm the assimilation process where you can go to a school where everyone's from your background or, you don't ever have to learn English because there's enough people around you who you don't [and] who you speak your native tongue So that's one reason to limit immigration," he said.

“实际上,大赦把这一点抛诸脑后,意思是,我们有这些限制,但我们不打算执行它们,”他接着说。

"In effect, an amnesty throws that out the window and says, well, we have these limits, but we're not going to enforce them," he continued.

2025年12月22日,美国总统唐纳德·特朗普在位于佛罗里达州棕榈滩的海湖庄园向媒体发表声明,宣布创建“特朗普级”战列舰并回答记者提问。特朗普宣布,这款新型舰艇将成为其“黄金舰队”计划的核心。U.S. President Donald Trump takes questions as he announced the creation of the "Trump-class" battleship during a statement to the media at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate on December 22, 2025 in Palm Beach, Florida. Trump announced the new class of ship will become the centerpiece of his "Golden Fleet" p

柯林斯援引2022年著作《黄金街道:美国移民成功的不为人知的故事》的研究结果指出,当今移民的同化速度与前几代移民相似。美国目前的外国出生人口比例已达到历史峰值,与19世纪末20世纪初的水平相当。目前约有15%的人口是外国出生的。

Drawing from the findings of a 2022 book called "Streets of Gold: America's Untold Story of Immigrant Success," Collins argued that today's immigrants are assimilating at a pace similar to that of immigrants of prior generations. America's current foreign born population has matched a historic peak similar to late 1800s and early 1900s levels. About 15% of the current population is foreign born.

她说,这本书将人们对祖辈、曾祖辈来美后同化情况的记忆进行了对比。“他们发现的实际上是,移民的融入速度大体相同,”她说。

The book, she said, compared people's memories of how their grandparents and great grandparents assimilated when they came to the United States. "And what they found was actually that immigrants are integrating it pretty much the same rates," she said.

她还表示,工作有助于人们更快同化,因此,如果非法移民获得合法工作机会,同化过程将更加顺畅。

She also said that work helps people to assimilate faster, and thus, if illegal immigrants were given the opportunity to work legally, assimilation would be a smoother process.

“我认为美国真正擅长的一件事就是接纳新来者并将他们变成美国人,所以我对此不太担忧,”她说。“但我理解为什么会出现让人们感到恐惧的情形。但数据不支持这种担忧。”

"I do think that one of the things America really is good at is us taking newcomers and turning them into Americans, and so I worry less about that" she said. "But I understand why there is a scenario where people could be afraid of that. But the data doesn't support it."

卡马罗塔估计,由非法移民主持的家庭每年获得约500亿美元的政府福利,通常是通过其美国出生的子女有资格申请的项目获得的。他以医疗补助、补充保障收入(SSI)、贫困家庭临时援助(TANF)和免费学校午餐为例,尽管非法移民本人通常被禁止领取许多联邦福利。

Camarota estimated that households headed by illegal immigrants receive approximately $50 billion annually in government benefits, often through programs for which their U.S.-born children are eligible. He cited Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and free school lunches as examples, although illegal immigrants themselves are generally barred from receiving many federal welfare benefits.

卡马罗塔说,非法移民使用福利并非因为懒惰,而是因为他们大多受教育程度不超过11年级。

Illegal immigrants use welfare not because they're lazy, but because most of them do not have educations higher than 11th grade levels, Camarota said.

“合法化并不能改变非法移民群体绝大多数受教育程度较低这一事实,受教育程度较低的人根本无法缴纳足够的税款来覆盖其对公共服务的消耗,尤其是考虑到他们获得的所有经济状况调查类项目时,”他说。他指出,低收入人群根本缴纳的税款不多。

"Legalizing folks doesn't change the fact that the illegal population is overwhelmingly less educated, and less educated people just don't pay enough in taxes to cover their consumption of public services, especially when you consider all the means-tested programs they get," he said. Low income people, he noted, simply don't pay much in taxes.

2026年1月28日,美国移民与海关执法局(ICE)特工在明尼阿波利斯开展移民执法行动。(Madison Thorn/Anadolu via Getty Images)Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents conduct immigration enforcement operations in Minneapolis on Jan. 28, 2026. (Madison Thorn/Anadolu via Getty Images)

“记住,所有工人中有一半不缴纳联邦所得税,”他说。“所以,是的,非法移民确实缴纳税款,实际上我们认为超过一半已经在正规账面上工作,所以对纳税人来说无论如何都没有什么大的好处。但现在,他们自己将有资格获得福利项目。”

"Remember, half of all workers pay no federal income tax," he said. "So, yes, illegal immigrants do pay taxes, and actually we think more than half already work on the books, so there's no big boon to taxpayers anyway. But now, they themselves will become eligible for welfare programs."

柯林斯承认,虽然许多移民受教育程度较低,但她说这并不意味着他们都在从事与其受教育技能相匹配的工作。她引用了国会预算办公室(CBO)2013年对“八人小组”移民法案S. 744的分析,该分析估计该立法将在10年内增加联邦税收收入并减少联邦赤字约1580亿美元,尽管政府福利支出会增加。

Collins conceded that while many immigrants have low education levels, but said that that doesn't mean all of them are working jobs that meet their education skills. She pointed to a 2013 Congressional Budget Office (CBO) analysis of the Gang of Eight's immigration bill, S. 744, which estimated that the legislation would increase federal tax revenues and reduce federal deficits by approximately $158 billion over 10 years, despite increased spending on government benefits.

“你会获得一点更多的税收收入,”她说。“他们有可能获得更高的工资,因为他们拥有合法工作授权,能够为不同的工作和不同的工资进行谈判,”柯林斯说。

"You get a little bit more tax revenue," she said. "They are potentially making higher wages, they're able to negotiate for different jobs and different wages because they have that legal work authorization," Collins said.

她辩称,有了合法工作授权,一些非法移民将能够在更高层次的工作中充分发挥潜力。

She argued that with legal work authorization, some illegal immigrants would be able to fulfill their full potential in higher-level jobs.

马克·克里科良经营CIS。他说,虽然权衡大赦的利弊可能是一个有用的思想实验,但这一点恐怕毫无意义。

Mark Krikorian runs CIS. He said that while thinking through the pros and cons of amnesty might be a useful thought exercise, the point is probably moot.

资料照片——人们在美籍移民局办公室内等候。特朗普政府发布新规,允许美籍移民局在不先进行庇护实质面谈的情况下,将特定庇护申请直接移交移民法官。(John Moore/盖蒂图片社)FILE - People wait inside a U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services office. The Trump administration issued a new rule allowing USCIS to refer certain asylum applications directly to immigration judges without first conducting an affirmative asylum interview. (John Moore/Getty Images)

“首先,这不会发生,”他说到大赦协议时表示。“任何事情发生的可能性,当然在民主党人上台之前、下一届国会上台之前,甚至到那时,依然是,依我之见,接近于零。”克里科良认为,共和党没有筹码达成协议,主要有两个原因。

"Well, to begin with, it's not going to happen," he said of an amnesty deal. The likelihood of anything happening, certainly until the Democrats come in, until the next Congress comes in, and even then, it is, in my opinion, close to zero." For two reasons, Krikorian doesn't think Republicans have leverage to make a deal.

他说,民主党人不愿在移民问题上做出任何让步,从而让共和党没有动力为非法移民达成大赦协议。

He says Democrats won't be willing to concede any restrictions on immigration, thus leaving Republicans with no incentive to make an amnesty deal for illegal immigrants.

他以DACA为例。近日,国土安全部部长马克韦恩·穆林提及可能就DACA受益人达成妥协——这些人童年时来到美国,并获得临时驱逐保护——该妥协可能会给予他们永久合法身份。

He used DACA as an example. Recently, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin floated the possibility of a compromise involving DACA recipients — people who came to the United States as children and received temporary protections from deportation — that could give them permanent legal status. "A DACA amnesty?

“DACA大赦?坦率地说,DACA受益人已经拥有大赦了。这只是把他们从‘轻量版大赦’升级为‘高级版大赦’,”他说。

Frankly, the DACAs already have amnesty. It's upgrading them from amnesty light to amnesty premium," he said.

他说,特朗普第一任政府曾试图利用DACA受益人作为筹码,换取更严格的移民措施。

He said the first Trump administration tried making an a deal for tighter immigration measures using DACA recipients as a bargaining chip.

2022年11月17日,支持“童年入境暂缓遣返行动”(DACA)的抗议者在美国国会大厦外举行游行,呼吁提供入籍途径。(Nathan Posner/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)Pro-DACA protestors hold a march outside of the U.S. Capitol Building calling for a pathway to citizenship on November 17th, 2022 in Washington, D.C. (Nathan Posner/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

“这个想法有价值,可能会产生成效,但没有可能,把已经拥有社会安全号码和工作许可的DACA受益人升级为普通绿卡身份,是民主党会用任何东西来交换的,”他说。

"That idea is valuable and could be productive, but there's no way that upgrading the DACA who already have Social Security numbers and work permits to regular green card status is something that the Democrats would give anything in exchange for," he said.

但克里科里安警告称,给予DACA受益人绿卡,最终可能允许他们担保更多亲属,包括在他们成为美国公民后担保父母,尽管现有的移民限制可能会阻止一些亲属获得合法身份。

But Krikorian warned that giving green cards to DACA recipients could eventually allow them to sponsor additional relatives, including their parents once they become U.S. citizens, although existing immigration restrictions could prevent some relatives from obtaining legal status.

“而且这会产生一些影响,因为一旦你拥有绿卡,就可以为某些亲属提出申请,五年入籍时钟开始计时,”他说。“当你成为公民后,就可以为父母提出申请。这方面没有数量限制。”特朗普在《60分钟》节目中讨论,可能达成一项协议,允许一些在酒店业和园林绿化等行业工作的非法移民留在美国。

"And that would have some effects, because once you have a green card, you can petition for certain relatives, and the five year clock for citizenship starts," he said. "And when you become a citizen, you could then petition for your parents. There's no numerical caps for that." Trump discussed on "60 Minutes" potentially working out a deal that would allow some illegal immigrants working in industries like hospitality and landscaping to remain in the country.

纽约,纽约——2025年7月8日:联邦特工在雅各布·K·贾维茨联邦大楼的移民法庭大厅巡逻。多名市议员和一名州参议员旁听了移民听证会,并观察移民与海关执法局继续执行任务。NEW YORK, NEW YORK - JULY 08: Federal agents patrol the halls of immigration court at the Jacob K. Javitz Federal Building on July 08, 2025 in New York City. Various council members and a state senator attended immigration hearings and observed Immigration and Customs Enforcement as they continued t

“当你走进一家酒店,看到一名女性在那里当女佣、清洁工、这个那个,当服务员,做着很多好事、好工作,突然之间她们被驱逐出境,这很难受。这是一件难受的事,”特朗普在《60分钟》节目中表示。他补充说,他所描述的“极右翼”人士希望驱逐非法移民,无论该非法移民是否在工作。

"When you go into a hotel and you have a woman that's working there as a maid, as a cleaner as a this as a that, as a waitress, a lot of good things, great jobs, and all of a sudden they're being taken out of the country, it's tough. It's a tough thing," Trump said on "60 Minutes." He added that people whom he described as "far-right" want deportations regardless of whether the illegal immigrant is working.

与此同时,白宫表示,特朗普的“强硬移民政策保持不变”,白宫发言人劳伦·比斯塔(Lauren Bis)对福克斯新闻数字版(Fox News Digital)表示,民主党应与总统合作,保障边境安全,将危险的犯罪非法移民驱逐出境,并制止贩毒。

The White House, meanwhile, says Trump's "strong immigration policy remains unchanged," and White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis told Fox News Digital that Democrats should work with the president to keep the border secure, remove dangerous criminal illegal immigrants from the country and stop drug trafficking.

她说,总统的“常识移民议程”已带来“历史上最安全的边境”。“如果民主党选择推行激进左翼的开放边境和大赦政策,那就是选择与美国人民的利益背道而驰,”她说。国土安全部未回应置评请求。

She said the president's "commonsense immigration agenda" has resulted in the "most secure border in history." "If Democrats choose to pursue radical left open border and mass amnesty policies, they are choosing to work against the interests of the American people," she said. The Department of Homeland Security did not return a request for comment.

阅读媒体原文 ↗